House of Commons photo

Crucial Fact

  • His favourite word was conservatives.

Last in Parliament April 2025, as NDP MP for New Westminster—Burnaby (B.C.)

Lost his last election, in 2025, with 32% of the vote.

Statements in the House

Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act February 25th, 2005

Mr. Speaker, I applaud the member for Halifax for her bill. During the federal election I knocked on over 6,000 doors in my community. One of the things I heard most regularly about was the number of young people who cannot go on to post-secondary education because of the post-secondary crisis that we are living through.

As she pointed out at the beginning of her remarkable presentation, the budget that was tabled this week does not deal with this post-secondary crisis. We have the Liberal government and the Conservative opposition both supporting a budget that does not deal with this fundamental crisis that is not only hurting younger generations of Canadians but is also going to hurt our economy as fewer and fewer Canadians go on to post-secondary education and to obtain the skills that are vital for tomorrow's economy.

Financial Administration Act February 25th, 2005

Mr. Speaker, I thank the hon. member for his question. As he noticed during my presentation, I am concerned by the general lack of consistency in this government when it comes to our public service, while its employees make such a big contribution to Canadian life, and work hard to represent their country. They also improve the outreach of federal services.

The concerns raised during second reading, which were clearly identified, still remain. General concerns have to do with the government ignoring linguistic duality. We saw this many times in many different areas. French does not receive the respect it deserves. It is widely used across the country. As the fourth largest francophone province in the country after Quebec, Ontario and New Brunswick, British Columbia now has 65,000 francophones. British Columbia is fourth in the pack in terms of the strength of its francophone community.

It must be said that in British Columbia there is a lack of services in French; still, at the same time, immersion schools are overflowing in that province. In fact, the immersion schools in British Columbia are the leaders in the country when it comes to people, parents and children, participating and wanting to learn French. In British Columbia, there always are obstacles to getting into the public service. It is always a problem. British Columbia is under-represented in the public service, while we are busy, in our immersion schools, teaching more and more bilingual young children who would like to contribute to their country by providing service in both official languages.

The entire issue of linguistic duality is and always has been a concern of the NDP. I was just talking to the hon. member for Halifax. Even when she was NDP leader in Nova Scotia, she fought to ensure that the Acadian community was well represented and respected in Nova Scotia. We could also talk about other governments, for instance, New Democratic governments, which have advanced francophone rights. We could mention the members of legislatures all over the country who have advanced francophone rights.

Everywhere in Canada, the NDP message is the same, whether in British Columbia, Newfoundland and Labrador, Nova Scotia, New Brunswick, with the hon. member for Acadie—Bathurst, Elizabeth Weir in Alberta and Léo Piquette. The governments of Saskatchewan and Manitoba have done the most to advance francophone rights. In fact, the New Democratic government in British Columbia set up the first francophone school boards. All over the country, we have the same message about linguistic duality and we always take the same care. That is a fundamental aspect of the NDP's existence and the reason why it must continue to speak on behalf of people all over the country.

Financial Administration Act February 25th, 2005

Mr. Speaker, I am somewhat stymied by this third reading of Bill C-8.

During the debates held in the House at second reading, we discussed Bill C-8 extensively. At the time, we raised a number of questions that have yet to be answered by the government, but that are very valid questions regarding the purpose of this legislation and the objectives of the government. Since the bill is now at third reading, we can assume that, indeed, these considerations and questions have been left unanswered.

Bill C-8 illustrates once again the scenario that we had with other bills proposed in this House. Indeed, with Bill C-31 and Bill C-32, we saw that the government had implemented administrative changes without consulting those who are most affected by these changes, and without putting in place a plan to develop those administrative changes.

As regards Bill C-31 and Bill C-32, since there were no plan or justification with respect to these changes, the House rejected these motions. In the case of Bill C-8, even though we said at second reading that we had some concerns and fundamental questions regarding this legislation, we still reviewed, in the hope, of course, that these questions would be answered, and that some objectives as well as a plan would be defined.

Unfortunately, as I said, our questions were not answered. I should point out that this is an issue of particular interest to the NDP. Indeed, we have always believed it is important that the government maintain good relations with public servants. Unfortunately, over the past several years, we have seen that those who spend their lives in the service of their country, Canada, to ensure that we have an effective public service and to maintain and even increase services provided to the public, we have seen that all these public servants who do so much to support programs, services and Canadians, were not consulted when the government decided to make the latest changes. Here, one week. There, the next.

We saw this recently during the surprise announcement of the single window for government services. So documents and information were leaked. We learned a few days ago that the government was planning to make some major changes, once again without consulting the public and the workers, the people devoting their lives to maintain and increase services for Canadians. There are no consultations. An announcement is made. We know that major changes are coming, once again, in the form of a single window, in the absence of planning and the implementation of all administrative procedures.

Unfortunately, I suspect that, once again, the Liberal government is deciding to make all kinds of promises of job offers here and there, without any plan to ensure the provision of services throughout the country. British Columbia, where I come from, is under-represented in the public service.

It is extremely important to people in British Columbia to be able to say that access to the public service corresponds to our demographic weight in Canada.

However, putting something like that in place requires a plan. There really have to be consultations with Canadians and public servants so we can a plan in place that will work. We know that this government has a tendency to make plans similar to those of the official opposition—sketched on table napkins—plans strung together with bailing wire that are not properly or sufficiently thought out, and ultimately, we end up with something that does not work.

We saw this with the Kyoto protocol; the government had in fact promised to reduce greenhouse gas emissions. It was supposed to reduce them by 20% by 2010. It is now 2005 and in actual fact greenhouse gases have gone up, not down, by 20%.

We have also seen other plans, including an anti-poverty plan. The NDP member for Ottawa Centre introduced a motion in the House in 1989. With the agreement of all members of this House, we adopted a plan whereby child poverty would be reduced by the year 2000 with a view to its total elimination.

Now here we are in 2005, and, tragically, there has been an increase in the number of children living in poverty in this country. They now number over one million. Among aboriginal children, 40% are poor or living in poor families, and liable to end up homeless. We know that 30% of families with disabled children are in the same situation.

This 12 year Liberal idea of a plan has once again resulted in failure. There has been a failure as far as the environment is concerned. A failure as far as housing for the homeless is concerned. The surprise announcement of a few days ago leaves us once again with a plan that has been cobbled together without consultation, without any clear objectives. This one will have a considerable effect on the Canadian public service, and that is most regrettable.

Now, if we look at Bill C-8, we see once again that it dates back to a year ago, after the decisions had been reached, without any connection between the two or any consideration of the impacts.

It must be pointed out that the hon. member for Ottawa Centre works tirelessly both in this House and outside to protect the public service and to ensure that its members are taken into consideration when the government plans to do something. I would like to congratulate him on the work he does. He is a new member like myself, but one with a long history in this place. He is new only in that his riding, Ottawa Centre, is a new one for him, but he is already hard at work, not only representing that riding, but also defending the interests of those who make such a great contribution to the running of our Canadian governmental services and the federal government's outreach in this country. The member for Ottawa Centre is making a remarkable contribution.

Let me point out the problem. We have Bill C-8. We have had questions raised in the House. Those questions have stayed there without a definitive response from the government. We know that morale is very low in the public service. We know of the surprise plan that was thrown out there, a one stop shop thrown out on the backs of the public servants who have contributed so much to this country.

Again we see a government proceeding without a plan, going from photo op to photo op, without considering the implications of each decision that is made. We saw with Bill C-31 and Bill C-32 how little forethought had actually been given to these decisions that the government was throwing forth to the House. At second reading we asked those questions and did not get the answers we wanted to hear.

We see very clearly that there has not been a consultation process with the people who are most concerned about this: the public sector workers who have contributed so much and yet receive so little consideration from the government. Last summer, after a real decrease in public sector wages of 10% and a salary gap in many sectors of 20%, as we saw with table 2, we saw the government, rather than engaging in meaningful negotiations, basically push through a settlement that of course public sector workers had to ratify after that.

What we see is a lack of respect for the public service. We do not see a change in attitude toward public sector workers. We do not see a change in responsibility. We do not see this government working with public sector workers and trying to engage in meaningful consultation, not relying on the strength of public sector workers who contribute in every community of this country, small or large, giving their hearts and souls, giving their efforts and their labour to make sure that we have the best possible services at all levels.

The responsibility for any concerns people have about public service and the state of public service in this country remains with the government, this government that does not consult, that refuses to recognize public sector workers as the assets they are for our country, that shows the same lack of respect for public sector workers we have seen it show to students with this recent budget. Students are not taken into consideration, nor are farmers. We see the same lack of consideration for people with disabilities and for poor Canadians. As well, in my area of greater Vancouver we have seen a threefold increase in the number of homeless. This is due to a lack of a housing strategy or policy.

We have seen, as I mentioned, an increase in greenhouse gas emissions. We have seen an increase in smog and toxic pollutants across this country, yet we saw the government last week actually vote against the NDP motion that would have set mandatory emission standards in this country and thus actually address the issue of increasing smog and pollution and the deaths caused by that.

We saw the Liberal government and the Conservative Party voting against that simple measure. Now we see the Liberal government and the Conservative Party voting for a budget that does not address housing and homelessness issues. It does not address the issues around the poor.

It does not address the crisis that we are facing in post-secondary education. As my colleague, the hon. member for Halifax, has said so often and so effectively, we need to address the crisis in post-secondary education. There is nothing in the budget for students.

There is also nothing in the budget for people with disabilities, even though we know that four million Canadians live in the poorest conditions and with perhaps the lowest quality of life of all Canadians.

There is nothing in the budget to address aboriginal issues.

There is nothing in this budget that addresses those important issues, except the lack of respect for Canadians generally. The Liberal government and the Conservative Party in opposition are still going to support this budget, so who does get the respect if public sector workers do not get it, if students do not get it, if seniors do not get it with that tiny buck a day increase?

We know who gets the respect. It is the big corporations, with a $4.6 billion tax break. It is the wealthiest of Canadians, who actually see the cap on RRSP contributions lifted for those who earn more than $100,000 a year. They get respect. It is wealthy people, big corporations and the banks. We heard them lobbying to have the foreign content limit, that cap of 30%, lifted. That lobbying paid off for them.

Banks, big corporations and the wealthy are the ones that get respect from this government, not public servants. That is why I again raise concerns about Bill C-8 and the fact that the government is not showing proper respect for public sector workers. The government has shown this pattern consistently over the months that I have been in Parliament and certainly in the years before I came to Parliament. We have seen a consistent pattern of a lack of respect and a lack of consultation.

I appreciate the opportunity to speak on the bill. The concerns remain.

Supply February 22nd, 2005

Mr. Speaker, the member for Churchill made a very impassioned and eloquent intervention. She mentioned the aboriginal healing fund and that $43 million was expended in administration charges, much more than 15%. Given the fact that there is great need in the member's riding and across the country, it is quite appalling that so much would be spent on administration rather than dealing effectively with the issues at hand and the great need that is out there.

What does the member think is motivating the government in this respect? Why does the government seem to be refusing to acknowledge the importance of having an appropriate auditing function in place through the Auditor General who, as she mentioned, very clearly has credibility across the country and the confidence of Canadians? Why is the government resisting bringing in the Auditor General to verify the $9 billion that the federal government has put into the foundations?

Supply February 22nd, 2005

Mr. Speaker, we see the old Liberal arrogance coming back. It is as if the government did not understand the message of June 28, 2004. What we saw that with the introduction of Bill C-31 and Bill C-32. There was no plan or consultation.

The Auditor General has clearly indicated that we need to have this oversight provision to ensure we see value for money, for Canadian public funds, on foundations. However, the government simply seems to refuse to allow that to happen. To compound the refusal, a few months ago the government withheld funding for the Office of the Auditor General. It took intervention from the other three corners of the House, led by the New Democratic Party caucus I should add, to push the Liberal government back and to ensure the Auditor General's Office was adequately funded.

We again see the old Liberal arrogance creeping up. I believe it will be up to the other three corners of the House to ensure that we put the government on the right road, which includes no more hide-and-go-seek with public funds, no more refusal to have adequate vetting of public expenditures and no more secret buddy-buddy agreements with Liberal appointees. We saw a repetition of the sort of serial nature of these agreements where Liberal appointees would have bottomless expenditure accounts that supposedly met Treasury Board guidelines. We saw that with Canada Post and the privacy commissioner, high-flying Liberal nominees and appointees not subject to prudent and appropriate use of public funds.

Unless we in the three corners push the Liberals in the right direction, we will see what we have seen over the last 10 years, which is the quality of life of most Canadians going down while the Liberals seem to be engaged in a feeding frenzy to ensure their friends get public funds, and that would be a shame.

Supply February 22nd, 2005

Mr. Speaker, the member for Ottawa Centre has been extremely impassioned to ensure that the public service does not become another victim of the old Liberal arrogance coming back.

In this corner of the House we are appalled by the fact that there has been no consultation for this plan, a plan that was thrown out or leaked a few days ago, and apparently may be in the budget tomorrow. Again, there has been no consultation with the public service or with people, who have in mind the best interests of the country, to ensure we provide adequate services. It is the same situation we saw with Bill C-31 and Bill C-32. Things were tossed into the middle of this Parliament without appropriate consultation or without appropriate development of a plan.

If it comes out tomorrow in the budget, we will oppose that portion of the budget in the same way we will fight for the interests of Canadians to ensure the budget is a budget for Main Street and not another budget for Bay Street.

Supply February 22nd, 2005

Mr. Speaker, I will be sharing my speaking time with the hon. member for Churchill, who, as we know very well, has battled for years in this House to ensure that proper use is made of public funds.

It is my pleasure to rise today to speak in support of this official opposition motion. It reads as follows:

That the House call on the government to implement the measures recommended in the latest Auditor General's report to improve the framework for the accountability of foundations, in particular, to ensure that foundations are subject to performance audits that are reported to Parliament and that the Auditor General be appointed as the external auditor of foundations.

I am speaking in favour of this motion for a number of reasons, one of which is that it is based on my own private member's motion, Motion No. 181. It is one of the first I submitted in this House as a new member of Parliament, on November 1, 2004, and that motion reads:

That, in the opinion of the House, the government should appoint the Auditor General as the external auditor of foundations...and ensure that adequate mechanisms are in place for a broad scope audit of all delegated arrangements.

We are in favour of this motion because of what we have seen with the refusal of the government to take into consideration and to follow up on what is very clear from the Auditor General, that is, to follow the direction that she has indicated she needs to take to make sure we are having the appropriate use of public funds. She needs to be able to audit these delegated arrangements, these foundations.

In a sense what we have seen from the government is the old Liberal arrogance making its reappearance with this refusal to in any way accept the auditing of foundations when it is very clear that there is a problem, when it is very clear that the Auditor General is not aware if we are having a satisfactory use of public funds, and when it is very clear that the Auditor General has raised concerns.

As I mentioned earlier and will mention in the course of my presentation today, most of the foundations do not have in place the type of contract that really makes it clear to Canadian taxpayers across the country that the funds are being used and verified in an appropriate way.

Since we are seeing this reaction from the government, it is very important that in all corners of the House we consider this motion today. I certainly hope that the motion will be adopted with support from all four corners of the House, but if the government refuses to support it, it is very clear that in this minority Parliament three corners of the House will be sufficient to adopt the motion, which would be in Canadians' interests.

The facts are very clear. Nine billion dollars in grants have been provided to these foundations since fiscal year 1996-97. In fact, in the last four years the amount of money in these foundations has almost doubled. To this day we now have $7.6 billion in Canadian public funds that has been sent to these foundations without the appropriate oversight. That is unfortunate.

The Auditor General has called for a broader scope of responsibility. She has been very clear that she needs to be able to monitor and audit those funds. How does the government reply? It has said it will not allow that appropriate type of auditing.

We saw last fall as well that the government was very reluctant to allow the Auditor General to play the important role that she does. We saw the Liberal government actually withholding funds, believe it or not, from the Auditor General's department and pushing her to the point where she would have had to lay off 85 staff members. In other words, she would not be able to do the good and effective job that she does on behalf of Canadians. It was only with pressure from this and two other corners of this House that we were able to push the Liberal government back and finally have acceptance of funding for the Auditor General. The staff was not laid off and the Auditor General could continue to do the good work she does in monitoring federal departments.

Now we are going beyond that. We need to stop this game of hide and go seek. We need to be able to monitor effectively the funds that are going into these foundations. We have enough cause for concern with the sponsorship scandal, the boondoggle around employment and the employment insurance fund, and the huge missteps around budgeting with the fact that when small budget surpluses are forecast we actually see large budget surpluses coming out.

We have some real concerns about this government's ability to sit down and monitor finances in an honest and prudent way and in a way that benefits all Canadians. It is not as if the need is not out there. We have seen a tripling of homelessness in my area in greater Vancouver. We have seen a health care crisis that led to closure of hospitals. We have a child care crisis. We have increasing child poverty. There are needs across this country that are not being met and we have the Liberals playing games with appropriate monitoring of public funds.

The Auditor General was very clear in her report about her concerns around foundations. I will give a brief resumé of some of the recommendations that she put forth and what the status is in terms of how the government has reacted since this issue was raised by her a few years ago.

She recommended that, in new or amended funding agreements, sponsoring departments should seek to ensure that evaluations commissioned by foundations meet recognized evaluation standards. I raised that question with her when we had the opportunity to discuss her report. She said that five foundations have completed those independent evaluations that meet recognized evaluation standards. Most of the foundations are not doing that, despite the fact that it was very clear in the Auditor General's report that this recommendation needed to be followed.

She also said in her report that eight funding agreements gave sponsoring ministers the authority to undertake compliance audits but none were planned or under way at the time of her audit. The ability existed, but the government did not follow up. There were no compliance audits even though the opportunity exists in many of the funding agreements to make sure Canadians are getting good value for money.

The Auditor General also talked about adjustment mechanisms. When a foundation is clearly not meeting its purpose, or when circumstances have changed, a mechanism needs to be put into place to ensure that value for money is met. She recommended that the adjustment mechanism should not rely on the allocation of additional funding and revisions to the funding agreement. Right now the mechanism available is to put more money into the foundations and that is how we negotiate an adjustment mechanism. The Auditor General raised the alarm around funding agreements in regard to making sure that the government has the authority to terminate the agreement if defaults are not remedied.

As I mentioned earlier, in most cases there are no provisions under funding agreements to ensure that the government has the opportunity to terminate the agreement if a foundation is in default. In most cases, Canadians' interests are not being looked after by this government.

Finally, the Auditor General also was very clear that funding agreements need to give the minister the right to recover unspent public funds upon the winding up of the foundation. Many of the funding agreements do not have this provision. We are now facing a circumstance where the Auditor General does not have the power to intervene. When defaults are found, how they are recovered is a matter of some speculation because the Auditor General cannot do that work, and in most cases the funding agreements do not allow the termination of the agreement. In many cases, ministers representing this Parliament do not even have the right to recover unspent funds upon the winding up of a foundation.

Right now we are basically operating on faith. As I mentioned earlier, given the spending scandals of this government, my faith in its ability to handle the financial management of this country responsibly is, to say the least, in question. The challenges are enormous. As we see increasing poverty and a decrease in the quality of life for most Canadians, this government continues to play hide and seek with public funds. That is a shame. That is why we in this corner of the House will be supporting the motion.

Supply February 22nd, 2005

Mr. Speaker, the President of the Treasury Board cited the Auditor General a number of times and seemed to indicate that there was an ideological difference between the Auditor General and the government on this question of auditing foundations. I certainly disagree because the Auditor General has been very clear that she does not feel there is satisfactory knowledge about how the funds are being used within the foundations given that we do not audit them.

He also mentioned the issue of independent evaluations. I asked the Auditor General about the number of foundations that had completed independent evaluations. Her office said that it had found five foundations which had completed independent evaluations but that most had not.

I asked a second question on the number of funding agreements that give the government authority to terminate the agreement if defaults are not remedied. The Auditor General found only five funding agreements that had this provision. Most did not.

Then I asked how many funding agreements contained a right for the minister to recover unspent funds on winding up. Her office found only seven funding agreements that had this provision to actually recover unspent funds upon winding up. In most cases we do not even have the right to terminate the agreement if defaults are not remedied.

On the issue of the 11 recommendations, 7 recommendations were rejected or not implemented by the government, which is a failure rate of two-thirds. Is the new Liberal standard of satisfactory performance when something fails two-thirds of the time?

Supply February 17th, 2005

Mr. Speaker, it is fair to say that we have nothing to learn from a government that has not even put an auto policy in place. We have nothing to learn from a government that on its watch has led Canada to the second highest per capita emission of greenhouse gases in the world, with emissions growing at 1.5% every year, We have nothing to learn from a government that has a 90% failure rate when it comes to voluntary greenhouse gas reduction efforts, a 99% failure rate when it comes to energy efficient housing and a planned 20% reduction that has developed into a 20% increase.

We have nothing to learn from the Liberal government.

Supply February 17th, 2005

Mr. Speaker, I find it interesting that, once again, an hon. member from the Liberal Party should be criticizing, when his party is in power in Canada and in Ontario, a government that made possible enormous progress in a period of extreme economic difficulty, from 1990 to 1995. We know very well that Ontario inherited a debt of over $2 billion from the Liberal Party.

Of course, after all the tricks by the Liberal Party in Ontario—which we continue to see here, at the federal level—we notice that the hon. members of the Liberal Party are still trying to shift their responsibilities onto someone else.

The members and hon. members of the Liberal Party are responsible for a 20% increase in greenhouse gas emissions. They could have changed something, they could have acted. But no, instead of acting, they do nothing, they try to blame others. That is no longer good enough. I think that Canadians showed very clearly at the end of June they are no longer satisfied with the Liberal Party's casting blame on anyone and everyone across the country.