Evidence of meeting #49 for Environment and Sustainable Development in the 45th Parliament, 1st session. (The original version is on Parliament’s site, as are the minutes.) The winning word was building.

A recording is available from Parliament.

On the agenda

Members speaking

Before the committee

Mari  Managing Principal, Aryze Developments
Burns  Interim Chief Operating Officer, EfficiencyOne
Kabbara  Chief Executive Officer, The Transition Accelerator
Hunter  Scientist, As an Individual
Larmer  Senior Director, Policy, Government Relations & Communications, Canadian Gas Association
Finet  Analyst, Regroupement des organismes environnementaux en énergie

The Chair Liberal Shannon Miedema

Good afternoon. This is meeting number 49 of the Standing Committee on Environment and Sustainable Development.

For those here in person, please remember to follow the health and safety guidelines, as per the cards on your table, to prevent any audio or feedback incidents for our interpreters.

Today, we're continuing our study of retrofits for home energy efficiency. We have two hours of witness testimony today.

For our first hour, we have three witnesses in person.

Welcome to Luke Mari, the managing principal of Aryze Developments; Robert Burns, interim chief operating officer for EfficiencyOne; and Moe Kabbara, chief executive officer for The Transition Accelerator. You'll each have five minutes to give opening remarks, and then we'll proceed to questions from the committee.

Just before we begin, I want to give a brief update. We were at the Liaison Committee’s subcommittee on Wednesday and got approval for our budget to attend COP31 in Turkey. That doesn't necessarily mean we're going yet, but we did get through the budget approval process. We'll keep everybody posted as that follows through in its process.

We will begin with Mr. Mari.

You have five minutes. The floor is yours.

Luke Mari Managing Principal, Aryze Developments

Thank you, Chair and committee members.

My name is Luke Mari. I’m a professional planner and land economist, and the managing principal of Aryze Developments in Victoria. We are a real estate developer and builder of market-rate and affordable housing, and about 50% of our projects are non-profit or first nation collaborations.

To be clear, I am not an energy engineer. My perspective is from the point where good policy has to intersect with the economics of financing, building and operating housing. Done well, retrofits are not simply climate policy. They're housing policy, affordability policy, resiliency policy and economic development policy at the same time.

I think it's helpful to begin with a simple principle: Technology either helps us use less energy or helps us produce more energy. We should be clear about which problem we're trying to solve and choose a solution accordingly.

For existing buildings, the first opportunity is often to reduce the amount of energy the building needs. Better windows, improved envelopes, heat pumps and ventilation can all lower energy use and emissions, but they also improve the everyday quality of life for residents, including indoor temperatures, air quality, moisture and mould, and resiliency during extreme heat and cold events. The challenge is that there is a large gap between a retrofit that makes technical sense and one that will actually happen, and that barrier is often capital.

Financing has to match the housing. That is especially true for non-profits and co-operative housing. Many organizations own aging buildings occupied by people paying deeply affordable rents. Those rents simply do not generate enough cash flow to support the debt required for major capital improvements. A loan alone does not solve that problem. Programs that combine low-cost financing with meaningful forgivable contributions can. We have seen federal programs provide forgivable funding of up to $85,000 per unit for deep retrofits, and that funding has been fully subscribed. To me, that's an argument for continuing and expanding the model, not walking away from it.

Private rental housing has a different version of the same problem. The landlord pays for windows, insulation or mechanical systems, while the tenant often receives the benefit through lower utility costs and a better home. In a regulated rental market, the owner may have limited ability to recover that investment. This is what we typically refer to as a split incentive problem.

Financing programs should reward measurable energy improvements, but they also need to be stable. Owners cannot plan five- and 10-year capital programs in the future around incentives that constantly change names, rules or eligibility.

There's another issue we need to talk about, and that's embodied carbon.

We built one of Victoria, B.C.'s first passive homes, and one of the products we used was called XPS insulation. After the project was built, we came to understand that the greenhouse gas emissions associated with manufacturing that product were so high that the home's operational carbon savings were estimated to take roughly 300 years to offset that product alone.

We're good builders, but that building will not last 300 years. That illustrates an important blind spot. If we measure only the energy a product saves after installation but ignore the carbon emitted to manufacture it, we can make decisions that look green on an energy model but are not green on a whole-life carbon basis.

That also creates a great opportunity for Canada. We are one of the world's great forested nations. We produce an enormous amount of quality wood fibre and sawmill residue, much of which goes to relatively low-value uses, or we just burn it. Canada could move that material up the value chain by becoming a leader in high-performance wood-fibre insulation and other low-carbon building products. These products are common in Europe but very expensive and emissions-intensive to import to Canada.

Wood-fibre insulation can reduce operating energy while storing biogenic carbon in buildings for decades. That is climate policy and industrial policy at the same time: Canadian forestry, Canadian manufacturing, Canadian jobs and lower-carbon buildings.

We also need to remove surprisingly mundane regulatory barriers. Adding exterior insulation to an existing building makes an existing wall thicker. In some municipalities, that thickness can trigger a setback variance or reduce the allowable floor area in a building, triggering expensive planning processes. It should not take months or years of approvals simply to make an existing building more energy-efficient.

Finally, while the study is focused on retrofits, we cannot lose sight of new construction. Retrofits are important, but a new building is one of the longest environmental commitments that we can make. Every new building is tomorrow's existing building. The envelope, mechanical systems and materials we choose today may remain in service for 60, 80 or 100 years. While we improve the buildings we already have, we should put equal effort into making sure the buildings we add today are designed to perform for the long term. The cheapest retrofit is the one we never have to undertake because we built it properly in the first place.

My recommendations are simple. Make retrofit programs stable. Use grants where financing tools alone cannot work. Measure whole-life carbon. Remove unnecessary regulatory barriers. Use federal policy to help Canada become a manufacturing leader in the low-carbon building materials market, which we need here and around the world.

I have lots more to say, but I'll reserve it for Q and A.

Thank you.

The Chair Liberal Shannon Miedema

Thank you very much, Mr. Mari.

We will now turn to Mr. Burns for five minutes.

Robert Burns Interim Chief Operating Officer, EfficiencyOne

Thank you, Chair.

Thank you to the members of the committee for inviting me here today.

My name is Robert Burns. I'm the interim chief operating officer at EfficiencyOne.

EfficiencyOne is an independent, not-for-profit organization based in Nova Scotia. We work with homeowners, renters, businesses and industry to achieve their energy goals, save money, increase productivity, conserve resources, improve well-being and combat climate change.

We are Canada's first energy efficiency public utility. We offer one-window access to advice, technical assistance and financial incentives that reduce energy costs and offset greenhouse gas emissions in homes, businesses, municipalities and industrial facilities. Our work is about making energy work better for Nova Scotians in their homes, businesses and communities.

In Nova Scotia, we have seen first-hand what sustained investment in energy efficiency can accomplish. Since 2011, our programs have helped hundreds of thousands of Nova Scotians make lasting improvements to their homes and businesses, generating $6.4 billion in lifetime energy bill savings, including more than $849 million for low-income households. The opportunity for energy efficiency goes well beyond Nova Scotia.

Across Canada, we are facing several interconnected challenges: the affordability of everyday life, the cost and availability of housing, growing electricity demand and the need to reduce greenhouse gas emissions. Energy efficiency can help address all of them.

When we improve insulation and air sealing, install higher-efficiency heating systems such as heat pumps and make other improvements to our buildings, we permanently reduce the amount of energy required to keep those buildings comfortable. For Canadians, that means lower monthly energy bills, and homes are more comfortable and resilient. For electricity systems, it means reducing demand and making better use of the infrastructure that we already have. For Canada, it means reducing emissions while creating economic activity in communities from coast to coast.

Energy efficiency also plays a critical role in strengthening the electricity grid by reducing overall demand, particularly during periods of peak consumption. By lowering the amount of electricity needed to power homes and businesses, efficiency helps reduce strain on existing infrastructure, improve grid reliability and defer or avoid costly investments in new generation, transmission and distribution capacity.

We have seen the impact that well-designed federal energy efficiency programs can have. The Canada greener homes initiative significantly accelerated the adoption of energy efficiency technologies in homes. Since 2020, federal support has contributed to the installation of more than 229,000 heat pumps across Canada, including more than 17,000 in Nova Scotia. We have seen significant success through the oil to heat pump affordability program. As of February 2026, almost 30,000 heat pumps had been installed nationally through that program, with participating households saving an average of approximately $1,300 each per year in energy costs.

Nova Scotia's experience in this program is particularly noteworthy. More than 14,000 oil to heat pump affordability grants have been issued in the province to date. Programs like these demonstrate what is possible when the federal government works with provinces and experienced local delivery organizations to make efficiency upgrades accessible.

There's another piece of this conversation that is equally important, and that's workforce development. We can set ambitious targets for retrofitting Canada's homes, but ultimately, people have to do the work. We need energy advisers, contractors and skilled tradespeople with the capacity and expertise to install heat pumps, improve building envelopes and undertake increasingly complex retrofits.

Long-term and predictable investment in energy efficiency gives businesses the confidence to hire, train and invest in their people. That same principle has been a consistent theme in our experience in Nova Scotia. Stable program funding supports stable program delivery and provides confidence to the broader energy efficiency industry.

As Canada considers the future of home energy retrofits, I would encourage the committee to think about energy efficiency as more than just a climate program. It's an affordability strategy. It's an energy system strategy, and it's a housing strategy. It is also an economic and workforce development strategy.

The successes we have seen show that Canadians are willing to make these investments when programs are accessible, affordable and easy to navigate. The opportunity now is to build on the progress with long-term, predictable approaches that give households confidence to invest, give industry confidence to build capacity and ensure that Canadians of all income levels can benefit from more efficient homes.

Thank you.

The Chair Liberal Shannon Miedema

Thank you very much, Mr. Burns.

We will now turn to Mr. Kabbara for five minutes.

Moe Kabbara Chief Executive Officer, The Transition Accelerator

Thank you, Chair and members of the committee.

Thank you for inviting me.

My name is Moe Kabbara. I'm president and CEO of The Transition Accelerator. We also run something called the Building Decarbonization Alliance, representing over 300 partners across the country.

Our mission is simple, and I think non-controversial. It is to position Canada to win economically and geopolitically in a changing world.

In the focus of energy, the words “retrofits” and “home retrofits” have often been associated with windows and insulation. We've also been stuck in this debate over whether we make homes more efficient or switch their fuel to electricity. I'm going to argue today that this is a false choice, because a heat pump is an efficiency upgrade. It heats your home with a fraction of the energy used by a furnace, and the savings show up on the bills for a lot of Canadians in many regions.

Obviously, things like insulation and air sealing of windows are still important, but every year about a million homes have their heating systems replaced, and most of those replacements happen after something breaks down. If people miss that window, they are then locked in for another 20 years with a less efficient energy system.

Buildings account for 60% of the end use of electricity. We want to build the grid to grow the use of electricity by Canadians, and obviously we need to incorporate the way that we heat our buildings as well.

Our analysis shows that electrification, both transport and heating, can save Canadians up to $15 billion in energy costs. This means that about seven in 10 households could pay less by 2050 if this is done right. The question is, how do we do it right?

Currently, about 8% of homes are heating with heat pumps, yet we have good economics for about three million homes with oil, propane and electric baseboard heating.

We're very honest about where things work and where they don't, and I don't think it's good to paint a broad brush across the whole country to say that it's good for everybody. What that means, though, is three million homes. That's enough to keep us busy for a while, in my view, and those are real savings that are going to be felt by Canadians as their disposable income is unlocked.

I'm lucky that I'm speaking to you today, after the announcement this morning, which actually had a focus on retrofits and heat pumps. A lot of the previous testimonies were calling for things that actually were announced today, so given what happened this morning, I think it's more useful for this committee to focus on what can be done moving forward.

There are a few points about what happened this morning. The design is better. We were stuck with these very painful energy audits just to install a heat pump. Now we're saying approval within 24 hours, and I will trust and verify that. Going from six months to 24 hours is ambitious, but we'll see.

For a household below the median income, $10,000 is great. It unlocks moderate-income and lower-income households to participate in this. Landlords will be allowed to access this, which will help renters, and there's recapitalization of the deep retrofit accelerator initiative. That's where we are.

What do we need to do moving forward? The $10,000 rebate is far more attractive than the $2,000 rebate. If there's a higher uptake on that, we're not going to hit the number that is in the target, so we have to think about recapitalization much sooner. The last program ran through its budget and closed suddenly, so we have to think about the boom and bust of these programs. I think it's avoidable. It's not a fatalistic thing that we're going to have a boom and bust with every program.

The time to plan what comes next is now, not in two years. In what comes next, how do we move from grants to financing? We can't just continue giving people money forever. The whole point of market transformation is that you can grease the market and grease the wheel and get to a point where you have a self-sustaining model for market adoption. The greener homes loan program had a $2.9 billion uptake across 120,000 loans at 0%, but it crowded out private lenders. How do we move from that to bring in financial institutions to create a more sustainable model so that we have a predictable ramp-down from the grants and an uptake from the financing?

The second thing is to include electrification at the core of this renewed deep retrofit accelerator. The mandate for it didn't include electrification, which I think is a big part of efficiency, as I mentioned in my opening remarks.

The last thing is thinking about air conditioners. From a standards perspective for energy efficiency, an air conditioner and a heat pump are the same thing, except that one goes in both directions. Ultimately, it's a consumer protection policy to think about: Do we want to sell products to consumers that are not going to be doing the job that heat pumps could do with the same infrastructure and the same parts? A lot of jurisdictions have moved to basically ban one-way air conditioners.

I think that with this program there's an opportunity to leverage the $2,000 incentive to push for more air conditioners next summer, then move towards something like a standard that the industry has told us they can move on within 16 months, to just install heat pumps instead of ACs. There are 200,000 ACs that go into people's homes every year in Canada. If all those are heat pumps, then you get cheaper heat in the fall and the spring while still having your gas furnace. It will start to socialize the concept that we can use this thing to heat our homes.

To close, I think this is a good start. The last program we had ended in a boom and bust. This one doesn't have to. There are a million air conditioners that we're going to be installing over the next five years. Let's make sure they're heat pumps.

I'm happy to answer any questions.

4 p.m.

Liberal

The Chair Liberal Shannon Miedema

Wonderful. Thank you.

We'll now turn to questions from members, beginning with Mr. Ross for six minutes.

4 p.m.

Conservative

Ellis Ross Conservative Skeena—Bulkley Valley, BC

Thank you, Madam Chair.

Thank you to the witnesses for your testimony.

Mr. Mari, you brought me back to a past life. I was a labourer building houses in my village, and my brother was a Red Seal carpenter. The problem was that my council didn't enforce any building codes. In this respect we're actually talking about both instances. We're talking about new home builds that don't have a building code, especially when it comes to insulation, and we're talking about the older homes that had nothing, including my own father's house.

You made a comment early in your testimony about, basically, the supply chain, the total carbon footprint and how a certain insulation didn't live up to that in terms of the offset, which would take 300 years. Could you expand on it a bit? What did you mean?

4 p.m.

Managing Principal, Aryze Developments

Luke Mari

The product itself has a lot of different product lines, but essentially it's a poly-based material that is formed into styrofoam, which we use as exterior insulation. That process is very greenhouse gas intensive, and the building.... Full disclosure: a passive house in Victoria is a bit like a fish out of water. We have a very temperate climate, so it doesn't have the same advantages that you'd have in other jurisdictions. With the whole carbon analysis of that building, it's not that you shouldn't do a passive house. It's that if you're just looking at single measurable outcomes of how efficient that building produces on an energy model, it's just....

There are kind of three prongs to how a passive house gets heated. The appliances heat 33% of the home, the human occupants heat 33% of the home and then you have supplemental heat, which could be just a small electric heater, which is dramatically different from a big oil-based furnace in Prince George that is going to run you $800 a month in the winter. It's a very airtight building envelope, where you can have very low inputs to heat it, and that sounds great.

In British Columbia, power is seven cents per kilowatt hour for your heater, so it's a very cheap, highly efficient building However, the greenhouse gas emissions that went into the construction of that would take 300 years to pay back. There's no environmental sense in that structure anymore. There's no relevance to that building when you factor in the embodied carbon of the products that went into it.

4 p.m.

Conservative

Ellis Ross Conservative Skeena—Bulkley Valley, BC

Polyethylene came up in a previous testimony as well, but really we were talking about composite materials, not really insulation. Does that scenario play out in terms of composite materials being used as well, the polyethylene being used? I imagine it's a much lower scale than what you're talking about in terms of insulation or a much lower impact.

4 p.m.

Managing Principal, Aryze Developments

Luke Mari

Forgive me. I don't understand the question.

4 p.m.

Conservative

Ellis Ross Conservative Skeena—Bulkley Valley, BC

We were told that polyethylene could be used for composite materials for retrofits as well, which could add to lower emissions and greater savings. When you're talking about the offset, I'm assuming that would take a lower time period to be offset.

4 p.m.

Managing Principal, Aryze Developments

Luke Mari

Yes, there are certainly more products. Even that company with the XPS insulation line, has many different products now that are not as bad as the one we used, because that was 15 years ago or so now.

In British Columbia, we have a tremendous amount of sawmill waste. We use it for burning in pellet-based heaters, or for horses and pigs to sleep on at night. Instead, you could just mix it with some glue, and now you have a carbon sequestration product that you can insulate your homes with and that's very efficient and environmentally friendly. It's super common in Europe. We just don't do it here because we just don't have the manufacturing chain. Is there an opportunity for the federal government to start to sponsor some of these manufacturing processes that are proven? They exist, and we have the waste to do this.

4:05 p.m.

Conservative

Ellis Ross Conservative Skeena—Bulkley Valley, BC

That actually gets into the province and how they manage their non-saw log product. That creates a disadvantage for the forest companies. That's why they're going after the raw export logs and trying to manage their losses of the non-saw log. I don't know how the feds get involved with something like that, apart from incentivizing the provinces. Right now, B.C. is kind of a mess in terms of the forest industry overall. It's going to take a lot of reworking to imagine that.

I've asked this question before, but there's not much data on it. How much of this technology can come from first nations reserves? They need this, in terms of affordability and home heating efficiency. Do we have enough data to answer that question?

4:05 p.m.

Managing Principal, Aryze Developments

Luke Mari

In our work doing construction on reserves in the coastal communities, the building envelope is king. You need to build a house like you would build a boat. Certainly, the building code is different on reserve from what it is off reserve. The implementation of life and safety measures and building performance is not following a linear path, and it's different in every community.

There is definitely an opportunity for technological solutions of airtightness on reserve during procurement processes and the awarding of, whether through BC Housing or CMHC, to ensure proper airtightness on new construction on reserve.

The Chair Liberal Shannon Miedema

Thank you very much.

We will now turn to Mr. Greaves for six minutes, please.

Will Greaves Liberal Victoria, BC

Thank you, Madam Chair.

Good afternoon, colleagues.

Thank you to our witnesses for being here. In particular, Mr. Mari, it's great to see you here in person from Victoria. I really appreciate the effort you've made to join us today.

Given your expertise as a home developer in our community, I'd like to acknowledge the role your business has played in building new and cutting-edge homes in a community that desperately needs them. Also, I really appreciate the comments you've offered today on the opportunity before us to link together a number of different challenges currently being faced by the forestry sector and in terms of expanding manufacturing, with meeting the needs of communities and homeowners for these more sustainable and lower-energy homes.

In that vein, I'm going to invite you to elaborate, from your perspective, on the barriers facing small and medium-sized businesses like your own that actually do the work of building and retrofitting homes in communities like Victoria. Can you elaborate on what those barriers are and how you think the federal government can best help to address them?

October 8th, 2026 / 4:05 p.m.

Managing Principal, Aryze Developments

Luke Mari

Certainly.

I have three kids, so I have a lot of notes because my brain has limited capacity. I apologize for that.

Through the chair, if it's possible, I would also invite Moe Kabbara....

You had some really interesting points around moving from grant- to loan-based systems. I would love to hear more about that someday.

On the policy side, our concern is around instability and complexity. The industry gets a program, they learn it, consultants develop a little microindustry and knowledge base around it, and they develop internal expertise. Then the eligibility changes, funding is exhausted, the program closes, and a new program with a new name replaces it. That's very difficult for small businesses to plan around.

I'm sure you've heard the term “inelasticity of supply”. That's especially true in labour and material markets like home construction, where the federal government will come up with a new program and an entire microeconomy will spool up to meet the demand, which takes time, especially when we are probably a net importer of a lot of these technologies. Then the program will change. That whole small business community is just not designed to pivot quickly. Now they have to relearn the new thing.

I think stability of these programs is key.

The other part is from British Columbia and is especially relevant. We have a very robust seismic code. I know that's not the topic of today, but oftentimes when we're dealing with retrofits on existing multi-family structures—and even single-family homes, to a degree—we plan a lot of our renovations around earthquake safety. If the programs are aligned properly, when you're starting to change the structure of your building through adding shear walls, that's also a good time to introduce new mechanical penetrations for building envelope systems, heat pumps and things like that.

I think very localized solutions around the key challenges of regions are also key to these programs lining up.

Will Greaves Liberal Victoria, BC

Thank you for that.

I would like to pick up on the item of multi-unit dwellings and, in particular, rentals. You mentioned in your opening statement that one of the challenges with, specifically, affordable rental buildings is that there isn't necessarily a large enough revenue stream coming in to the owner of those properties to finance the necessary retrofits. You referred to the need, therefore, for both grants and financing tools.

Could you elaborate on the types of financing tools that would help fill that gap?

4:10 p.m.

Managing Principal, Aryze Developments

Luke Mari

We made a bit of a mark in Victoria because we did a massive tenant relocation plan. We took down five existing affordable buildings and built one new building that had affordability. We moved all the tenants from each building into that one and moved them down this chain. It took us eight years to do that, because we wanted no displacement.

The reason we did that is.... We looked at older buildings. In Victoria, 88% of all rental buildings were built in the 1960s and 1970s and are coming to their end of life. If you do any upgrades to the building envelope—high-performance insulation, windows or anything to do with the seismic code—you're evicting everybody. It's not financially possible to keep people in a building while you do these massive life and safety upgrades.

It shouldn't be a binary choice like that: life and safety upgrades or keeping old buildings going when they shouldn't really be kept going. I think one of the greatest opportunities at the federal level is the rental protection fund. How do we bolt on environmental and seismic upgrades to associate them with eligibility for that fund?

Will Greaves Liberal Victoria, BC

Thank you very much.

I am going to stick with you. I think it's the hometown advantage here. I'm confident that my colleagues will ask excellent questions of our other witnesses, and I appreciate all of your time here today.

Can you expand on your comments about the need to make good choices that actually produce long-term carbon reduction, not just the perception of reduction at the cost of a 300-year timeline?

I don't think it would be typical to have that length of time before carbon savings would materialize. Can you give us a sense of a more typical return on investment, from a carbon and energy perspective, for the kinds of projects your company undertakes?

4:10 p.m.

Managing Principal, Aryze Developments

Luke Mari

I'll try to do this thought process journey in 30 seconds or less.

Part of the thing in new construction is under-densifying a parcel of land. Let's say the regulatory environment allows you to build only four storeys and you build with wood frame construction, which is great: It supports B.C. forestry and it's environmentally friendly. However, if you under-densify that and in 30 years that building loses its economic life and is torn down and replaced with a bigger building.... The trees it took to build that building take 60 to 80 years to grow. If that building doesn't last 60 to 80 years, it's not environmentally friendly, because we're tearing it down early and the carbon sequestration through the wood frame construction isn't repaid.

I know that's very ethereal, but that's the way we have to think about these things from an environmental standpoint. How long is the life cycle for that particular investment to be repaid to taxpayers? As our other colleagues have highlighted, it means considering product selection, market uptake and the technological solution that is relevant to the area. A heat pump in Winnipeg is not the same as a heat pump in Victoria.

The Chair Liberal Shannon Miedema

Thank you very much for your time. We appreciate it.

Mr. Bonin, you have the floor for six minutes.

Patrick Bonin Bloc Repentigny, QC

Thank you, Madam Chair.

Thank you to the witnesses for being here.

Mr. Mari, did you use what was called the federal government's retrofit accelerator initiative? The program has ended and seems to require new funding. Would you like the program to be renewed?

4:10 p.m.

Managing Principal, Aryze Developments

Luke Mari

I'm not familiar with the vernacular use of that particular program. Does it have another name, or might I just be unfamiliar with it?