Evidence of meeting #53 for Environment and Sustainable Development in the 45th Parliament, 1st session. (The original version is on Parliament’s site, as are the minutes.)

A recording is available from Parliament.

On the agenda

Members speaking

Before the committee

Keith  Professor, Geophysical Sciences, University of Chicago, As an Individual
Zitner  General Manager, Carbon to Sea Canada
Jarvis  Vice-President, External Affairs, pHathom Technologies Inc.
Lawton  Emeritus Professor, Carbon Management Canada
Kravtsov  Chief Executive Officer, CarbonCure Technologies Inc.
Philip  Vice-President, Community and Government Relations, Planetary Technologies

The Chair Liberal Shannon Miedema

I call the meeting to order. Good afternoon, everybody.

Welcome to the 53rd meeting of the Standing Committee on Environment and Sustainable Development.

To our witnesses who are appearing in person, please remember to follow the health and safety guidelines, as per the cards on the table, to prevent audio and feedback incidents for our translators.

Today we're focused on our study of carbon capture, utilization and storage technologies. We have a series of witnesses for both hours.

We're going to begin with David Keith, professor of geophysical sciences from the University of Chicago, who is with us online. Welcome.

We have Miriam Zitner here in person. She's the general manager, Canada, in the Carbon to Sea Initiative.

We also have Alastair Jarvis, vice-president, external affairs, with pHathom Technologies Inc.

You're each going to have five minutes to provide some opening remarks, and then we'll move to questions by committee members. If it's helpful, I do have time cards. I will show you the card that shows when you have one minute remaining and then show you when the time is up. When you see the card, you don't have to instantly stop, but try to wrap up and conclude. I'll use these throughout the questioning as well.

We will begin online with David Keith for five minutes.

The floor is yours. Thank you.

David Keith Professor, Geophysical Sciences, University of Chicago, As an Individual

Thank you very much.

I'm David Keith. I'm a Canadian based in Canmore, Alberta, but I'm speaking to you today from the University of Chicago, where I lead the climate systems engineering initiative, which is perhaps the most ambitious effort at a big research university to build climate engineering as a field. That includes open-system carbon removal.

I've worked in climate more or less full time since 1990. In the early 2000s, I was one of the first people to realize that combining biomass energy with carbon capture and storage would produce something radically new—a power plant that could remove carbon dioxide from the atmosphere and move the carbon to long-term storage. I and others helped to push these ideas and other methods into the climate policy system through the IPCC, and they were adopted into models of energy decarbonization.

In 2009, still as a professor at University of Calgary, I founded Carbon Engineering, which became one of the major companies working on direct air capture. The plant using that technology would capture half a million tonnes a year from the air and is now commissioning in west Texas. That company was sold, and I'm no longer involved in it.

About a decade ago, climate modelers tasked with assessing how the world might meet the newly signed Paris commitment to a goal of 1.5°C relied on models that had the biomass energy with CCS. This is technology that I and others had worked on. Because those models showed a huge reliance on these, this catapulted carbon removal into the mainstream, and it became a hot topic among businessmen and politicians concerned with climate change.

An academic idea, if you like, had gone from obscurity to, I think, some overhype within about a decade. The overhype brought sensible criticism that carbon removal served industry and the status quo by holding out the promise that climate commitments could be met by substituting vague promises of future removals for emissions cuts today.

Now, as the carbon removal bubble is somewhat deflating, it's easy to dismiss the technology. My view is that this dismissal would be a mistake, because carbon removal is a unique tool in the climate solutions tool box. It's the only way that we can move the atmosphere back towards its pre-industrial state, making the atmosphere more like that in which humans and every species now alive evolved. I see it, then, as an essential part of the climate tool box if we wish to help to restore the natural world back from these impacts.

What should Canada do to advance carbon removal? I just got invited to do this on the last day. My understanding is that the topic here is carbon removal, but it sounds like maybe it's more about carbon capture and storage, which I have also worked on, but it is not what I'm addressing most now.

My view is that large-scale deployment of carbon removal makes little sense until the latter half of this century, when emissions have been substantially reduced. In the near term, our focus should overwhelmingly be on cutting emissions, and the goal for the next few decades for carbon removal should be not to deploy the technology at scale but to figure out which carbon removal technologies could be scaled up to this gigatonne-a-year scale with acceptably low cost and low environmental impacts while we maintain the focus on cutting emissions.

Much of the current policy framework supporting carbon removal aims to help various small companies grow gradually into larger markets, and this is complemented with funding for academic research. I'm somewhat skeptical of this framework. The niches, which make sense for small companies to develop under these current voluntary and other carbon markets—however well intentioned, however hard people work at them—may not do that much to advance the learning needed to enable large-scale, environmentally sound CDR later in the century. Academic research is often far too dominated by theory and is insufficiently grounded in practical engineering.

I suggest that Canadian policy-makers who want to advance these technologies rethink this strategy and think hard about how to develop publicly funded efforts towards technology development within environmental constraints. That might look quite different from the current policy environment.

I look forward to answering questions. Thank you.

The Chair Liberal Shannon Miedema

Thank you for that, Mr. Keith.

We will now turn to Ms. Zitner for five minutes.

The floor is yours.

Miriam Zitner General Manager, Carbon to Sea Canada

Thank you, Madam Chair, for the opportunity provided to offer testimony today.

My name is Miriam Zitner. I'm the general manager of Carbon to Sea Canada. I've spent the last 30 years working with large technology companies, start-ups and governments to bring forward new technologies, most of which have centred around the same questions this committee has about safety, efficacy and the role of government in providing guardrails and support.

By way of background, Carbon to Sea is a non-profit funded by philanthropy. We've granted more than $50 million in the last four years to answer questions about whether the ocean can help address climate crisis through marine carbon dioxide removal.

Whereas carbon capture and storage stops carbon dioxide from reaching the atmosphere, carbon removal takes out what is already there, and ocean alkalinity enhancement—the form of marine carbon dioxide removal we focus on—usually involves adding alkaline minerals to seawater. This mimics the ocean's natural ongoing process of drawing down carbon dioxide from the air and storing it in the ocean for tens of thousands of years.

To be clear, neither carbon capture and storage nor carbon removal are more important than cutting emissions, but the IPCC has been clear that large-scale removal will be required to stabilize the climate.

Today I'd like to share the work that is happening in Halifax, Nova Scotia, to advance OAE—ocean alkalinity enhancement—R and D, which I believe is a model worth replicating across the country.

Carbon to Sea has invested more than a third of our grant funding—roughly $20 million—in R and D initiatives in Halifax. We partner with researchers at Dalhousie University and with ocean innovation institutions like COVE, the Ocean Frontier Institute and MEOPAR. We collaborate closely with our private sector partners, all of whom have strong working relationships, as well as with indigenous communities and our fishing industry.

The results over just a few years have been promising. The research happening in Halifax has shown that rigorous environmental monitoring is possible and that marine carbon dioxide removal can be measured. It's being funded by philanthropy and builds on decades of public investment in ocean research, and private sector buyers have committed $80 million to Nova Scotian start-ups in the field.

In my experience, this kind of collaboration is unprecedented. Together, we're maximizing the impact of existing resources while demonstrating how collaboration for innovation can work: responsibly paced, well governed, transparent and built in Canada.

The scientific community agrees that a portfolio approach to carbon removal will be required to meet our climate goals and protect people, and OAE is regarded as a high-potential approach worth evaluating. As this committee designs policy that will shape carbon management in Canada, we ask that you prioritize partnerships and include marine carbon removal.

I have three recommendations for your consideration.

The first is to include marine carbon removal in your thinking about Canada's carbon management strategy. Where incentives exist for carbon capture and storage, ocean-based storage should also qualify on the same terms, based on outcomes.

Second, seize the opportunity to integrate marine carbon removal with existing investments. This includes the defence industrial strategy's evolution of the ITB framework and the Prime Minister's $82-million OceanEye commitment. Ocean sensors and uncrewed vehicles are already helping to measure carbon removal. There are systems in place that can support the R and D.

Lastly, I would ask the committee to consider the role of provinces in governing local marine carbon removal initiatives. The work in Halifax demonstrates the power of leveraging existing resources. As Environment and Climate Change Canada develops its view on OAE and other approaches, we ask you to consider provincial leadership in advancing federal guidelines and to consider a consolidated access point to permitting and enforcement.

I appreciate the opportunity to provide testimony today. I'm happy to answer any questions you might have.

Thank you.

The Chair Liberal Shannon Miedema

Thank you very much, Ms. Zitner.

We will now turn to Mr. Jarvis for five minutes, please.

Alastair Jarvis Vice-President, External Affairs, pHathom Technologies Inc.

Madam Chair and members of the committee, thank you for the invitation to appear.

My name is Alastair Jarvis. I'm vice-president of external affairs at pHathom Technologies in Nova Scotia. We capture CO2 from biomass flue gas, react it with limestone and seawater in a closed engineered system to form dissolved bicarbonate and store that bicarbonate in the ocean, where it stays for thousands of years. Think of it as carbon capture and storage where the storage is marine rather than geological.

We're at demonstration scale, and our pilot stores CO2 in tanks today. Our first marine storage is planned in Nova Scotia for late 2027.

Here's why this matters to your study.

Canada's CCUS policy was built around geology and pipelines. Much of our coastal industry has neither. What it has is tidewater. Marine storage gives those facilities a local carbon capture and storage option where today they have none.

Canada has already taken the first step. This month, the Government of Canada selected pHathom for a standing offer for BECCS removals with marine storage under the Isometric standard. As far as we know, it's the first time any government has selected BECCS with marine storage for procurement.

Next comes the path to scale. Solar and batteries became cheap because buyers stuck with them while they were expensive. Carbon removal needs to follow that same curve, and it has 24 years to reach the scale that our climate goals need. We'd like to ask the committee to recommend three more steps to get there.

Ms. Zitner made the general case. Here's what it looks like for one pathway.

First is capital. The CCUS investment tax credit supports carbon stored underground or in concrete. This past spring, the Department of Finance proposed extending it, and budget 2026 lands on November 5. We're asking for a third eligible use: dedicated marine storage, defined by a qualified process, with independent verification, the way concrete is today. The act already designates jurisdictions for geological storage, and the same test could apply to marine storage. Marine storage fits the existing credit, with no new program.

Second is a permitting pathway. ECCC has advised that our process appears to fall outside the London protocol definition of marine geoengineering, and it treats our return water as an industrial effluent under section 36 of the Fisheries Act. Today, there's no permit we can apply for. The onus is on us to show that the discharge isn't harmful. What's missing is a way to review a discharge like ours before it starts.

We'd ask that ECCC and DFO work with interested provinces to build one, with the federal regulator deciding what's safe and a province permitting against those thresholds before a project operates, with monitoring and reporting that show that the carbon stays stored. That's the kind of framework that the minister looks for to designate a province for the credit.

Third is accounting. The IPCC's inventory guidelines, written back in 2006, have methods only for geological storage. The IPCC is writing new guidance on carbon removal now for adoption at the end of 2027. We're asking Canada to make sure the BECCS chapter doesn't foreclose on non-geological storage that is measured and verified under a robust protocol. We aren't asking the IPCC to endorse marine carbon removal. We're asking only to keep the BECCS chapter open to this kind of storage. Canada's own protocols should follow the same principle.

Members, the proposed national electricity strategy sets out to double Canada's electricity supply by 2050, and clean, firm power is the hardest part to build. On our coasts, the biomass plants that can provide it sit in communities that have watched the pulp and paper economy contract around them. Carbon removal is the mechanism that makes firm biomass power economically and environmentally viable. It's also a new export, bringing money from buyers around the world into rural Canada. Canada has said that it intends to be an energy superpower in both clean and conventional energy. This is the clean part. Canada does have what the world wants, and carbon removal can be part of it.

With these three changes, the first plant in Nova Scotia becomes the first of many.

Thank you. I look forward to your questions.

The Chair Liberal Shannon Miedema

Thank you very much, Mr. Jarvis, and thank you to all our witnesses for their testimony.

We'll now turn to questions.

We'll begin with six minutes from the Conservative Party and Mr. Leslie.

3:45 p.m.

Conservative

Branden Leslie Conservative Portage—Lisgar, MB

Thank you, Madam Chair, and thank you to our witnesses.

I'll start with you, Mr. Keith.

In July, the Liberal government agreed to give taxpayer support for the ongoing costs of the Oil Sands Alliance Pathways carbon capture project, on top of the existing tax credits to help build it. In your view, at what point do we draw the line on taxpayer subsidies?

October 29th, 2026 / 3:45 p.m.

Professor, Geophysical Sciences, University of Chicago, As an Individual

David Keith

I don't see a convincing case for taxpayer subsidies or funding for that project, because it's very unlikely that this technology would be successfully exported outside of Canada and build added value to Canada. It's also not a very cost-effective way to cut CO2 emissions.

I understand that in the high politics of the oil sands, this has become an enormously important thing. I should say that I served on one of the original federal committees that led to some of these things a decade and a half ago. However, I see this as a profound political dead end. We will end up spending public money for little long-term gain in Canadian competitiveness.

3:50 p.m.

Conservative

Branden Leslie Conservative Portage—Lisgar, MB

Thank you.

Back in 2010, you warned a parliamentary committee that different government financial incentives made it difficult to determine which technologies reduced emissions at the lowest cost. Today, the government offers a 60% tax credit for direct air capture but only 50% for other carbon capture. As we've heard, it offers even less on the marine front.

What evidence is there that these different rates deliver the greatest emissions reductions for taxpayers, rather than simply allowing government to pick winners and losers?

3:50 p.m.

Professor, Geophysical Sciences, University of Chicago, As an Individual

David Keith

For carbon removal in Canada, I don't think there would be meaningful evidence to say that those were cost-effective.

3:50 p.m.

Conservative

Branden Leslie Conservative Portage—Lisgar, MB

I'll continue on that.

You share the view that taxpayers should be entitled to see exactly how many dollars of government support are being spent for each tonne of emissions reduced.

3:50 p.m.

Professor, Geophysical Sciences, University of Chicago, As an Individual

David Keith

For technologies that are being deployed at scale, meaning for solar, wind and nuclear power, for energy efficiency, we need effective ways to show what the marginal cost is. We're actually doing large-scale reductions, so we need to understand costs.

As for carbon removal, I don't think we're doing carbon removal in practice on a large scale. I think the goal is more to do future cost discovery and also discovery of future environmental impacts so that we can make decisions about how to direct public resources towards this long-term potential of doing large-scale carbon removal.

3:50 p.m.

Conservative

Branden Leslie Conservative Portage—Lisgar, MB

With regard to your earlier point on the deployment versus the research side, I guess you would agree that we need to figure out what the lowest cost is, particularly on the public funding side, for each tonne removed, regardless of the process.

3:50 p.m.

Professor, Geophysical Sciences, University of Chicago, As an Individual

David Keith

No. That's because it's a trade-off. There are several dimensions that matter.

I've been mostly focusing on cost and environmental impacts. Those trade-offs are real. There are ways that are of relatively low cost but that have high environmental impacts, and vice versa. I think both of those factors matter. It's not only dollars per tonne; it's dollars per tonne within the other environment and social constraints we face.

3:50 p.m.

Conservative

Branden Leslie Conservative Portage—Lisgar, MB

Under the carbon tax credit as it exists, a company could promise to capture, say, a million tonnes of CO2 per year. It could receive substantial taxpayer support to build the facility but ultimately may end up capturing only half of the amount that it claimed. However, it wouldn't automatically have to repay any of the credits that enabled the construction of the facility.

Shouldn't taxpayers have some sort of guarantee that they're paying for reduced emissions rather than simply for the cost of building the equipment?

3:50 p.m.

Professor, Geophysical Sciences, University of Chicago, As an Individual

David Keith

I don't know enough about the specifics of that policy now in Canada to comment. I'm sorry.

3:50 p.m.

Conservative

Branden Leslie Conservative Portage—Lisgar, MB

I have one more for you, and then I'm going to throw it over to our other colleagues here.

Let's say the government wants to forge ahead now rather than, as you said, wait and focus on emissions reductions in the meantime. If you had a limited amount of federal funding now, what would you invest in first to achieve the greatest verified emissions reductions?

3:50 p.m.

Professor, Geophysical Sciences, University of Chicago, As an Individual

David Keith

I would respectfully reject the question, or I wouldn't take the job. That is, I don't think it makes sense now to be spending money focused on getting verified reductions under these quite questionable verification protocols. I think it makes sense to be focused on building practical technology pathways within environmental constraints, and I have a bunch of ideas about how to do that.

3:50 p.m.

Conservative

Branden Leslie Conservative Portage—Lisgar, MB

I'll pivot to somebody who I think might take the job.

You mentioned measurable outcomes in your opening. How do we do a better job of measuring actual carbon removed rather than building a process for what we hope will be carbon removed?

3:50 p.m.

General Manager, Carbon to Sea Canada

Miriam Zitner

There are verification processes already under way. I'm happy to share, at a later time, the Isometric verification protocol.

There are rigorous ways to measure what has happened. Our colleagues from Planetary, who are testifying later, will be able to tell you more about that. I think we would all agree that we're asking for the Canadian government to pay more attention.

If you have questions about measurement and verification reporting, we, from Carbon to Sea, would certainly invite them. Our goal in philanthropy, as philanthropists, is to fund the research required to answer the questions you have.

This is not to send this back your way, but we agree that it is at an early stage. We're looking to try to understand if, and under what conditions, you can scale. To do that, we need to understand what the government thinks about, what it's concerned about and what it would like us to fund with respect to R and D to be able to ask and answer the very questions you have.

The Chair Liberal Shannon Miedema

Thank you very much, Ms. Zitner.

Thank you, Mr. Leslie.

Mr. Watchorn, you have the floor for six minutes.

Tim Watchorn Liberal Les Pays-d'en-Haut, QC

Thank you, Madam Chair.

Thank you to the witnesses for joining us.

Mr. Keith, what you said is interesting. At the beginning of your presentation, you said carbon capture and removal were part of the tool box the government or industries should use to improve the state of our climate.

I would like you to explain how biomass systems, systems that produce energy using biomass, can use carbon capture to improve their environmental footprint.

3:55 p.m.

Professor, Geophysical Sciences, University of Chicago, As an Individual

David Keith

That is a profoundly hard question. One of the deep challenges is that....

Sustainably harvested biomass can produce energy. When you burn a fuel, you produce CO2, just as if you had burned a fossil fuel, but that CO2 is recaptured when the biomass regrows. Biomass combined with carbon capture and storage captures that CO2 and puts it underground. There's a net transfer from the active biosphere, from fresh CO2 in the atmosphere, to the deep underground.

The challenge is the environmental footprint of biomass extraction, because the climate is just one environmental problem that people face. Another problem is the human appropriation of photosynthesis on the land surface.

Forgive the professor in me, but historically, the environmental impacts from excessive use of biomass have been huge. In the United Kingdom, where the Industrial Revolution started, it transitioned from being dominantly biomass-powered to fossil fuel-powered around the end of the 1700s. That was because they'd essentially cut down a significant fraction of all the standing biomass they had access to.

A real challenge is that while biomass absolutely can work, it inevitably involves trade-offs with other environmental things we might care about. There are other environmental reasons we might like to leave natural systems as undisturbed as possible.

I think we should, most of all, be focusing on energy systems that have a small land footprint. Solar power and nuclear power, for example, have a relatively small land footprint compared to biomass per unit of energy. I'm not saying we should ignore biomass—Canada has a big biomass potential—but we have to think hard about the trade-off between the benefits of reducing net carbon emissions, which is what this committee cares about and what matters for the climate, and other environmental concerns, for which increased biomass use will have other negative environmental impacts.

4 p.m.

Liberal

Tim Watchorn Liberal Les Pays-d'en-Haut, QC

Thank you very much, Mr. Keith.

I'm going to continue on the same topic with Mr. Jarvis.

Mr. Jarvis, you said that your technology uses an inshore biomass system and reinjects the carbon captured into the ocean.

First, I would like you to explain how this technology works.

Second, I would like to understand an aspect related to the pH of water. I know the ocean and the dilution factors are quite significant.

Isn't there a risk of altering the marine or river environment to the point where it is harming the species living there?

How do you deal with those two aspects, one on the technology of transferring biomass to the ocean and the other on the protection of species?