We would support their suggestion that there does have to be a balance, because the reality is that consumers aren't interested in another piece of paper or even business transactions. They like to do things very quickly, so if they needed to get another separate consent for a similar type of re-advance on their mortgage, they would see the process as being more bureaucratic than helpful if they weren't able to give a continuing consent for all the advances on a mortgage at the time the mortgage was originally entered into.
The test really should be whether it's informed consent from a public policy perspective, I would suggest, because if the individual knows what he or she is consenting to, then it isn't the form of the consent that matters so much, but the substance, so if there's informed consent and the blanket consent provides for the necessary information, then it is still in the best interest of the consumer.
