Thank you, Chair.
I would just like to clarify a couple of things. Mr. Van Kesteren mentioned that I had in a previous meeting talked about needing to improve access to information. We should be focused on that. I also mentioned, though, that this case is really important to help us with advising the government on how they can do that. But I also have to underline the promise—and I remember Mr. Tilson was the chair of the committee when we had the Bill C-2 deliberations, for the Accountability Act—from the government that they'd bring forward ATI reforms. That's just to clarify the record.
Now, on the issue of witnesses, I'm hoping that the list of witnesses we have—and I'm not clear on this—will satisfy the request that I think we all have, which is to have the person who's the originator of the document in front of us. I'm not sure if that's the case. I'm hoping that's what Ms. Gwen Kutz is going to be able to do. If it's not, then I guess the deputy minister is the person to answer that.
In other words, this whole case is about who was aware of the document, to start with, because we heard different versions. We heard initially that the document didn't exist because of nomenclature--that we don't produce human rights assessments, etc. And then there was follow-up, and then eventually we got to the point of “Well, yes, we do, but it's not called that”.
What we need to know is that the witnesses that we're going to have will be able to answer the question of who the originator of the document itself was. I'm concerned, when I look at the process of how security classification is assigned, according to Treasury Board, that if we don't have the right person here, we won't be able to find out who originally developed this document and therefore find out or follow the track, if you will, of how this document was classified, and then ask questions about redaction or blacking out that follow from that.
We have a list of witnesses here we can all agree to, and I think Tuesday makes sense, if everyone's agreed. I'm agreed to that. Notwithstanding that, are we also assured—and I guess I'm looking to perhaps the clerks on this—that the person who is the originator of the document itself will be known or that the deputy minister, I guess, or Ms. Kutz, will be able to satisfy us with that? In other words, will they be able to say “Yes, here's the person who originally did the document”? If we don't have that, then we'll have a nice discussion, but we won't be able to source the originator of the document and then find out how it was classified.
Chair, one of the issues here is not only the redaction issue and what's been blacked out. It's how these documents are classified at source. That's critical. And if they were improperly classified, we need to know that.
Thank you.
