Good afternoon, Mr. Chair and members of the committee. It's a pleasure to be with you today.
My name is Meredith Lilly, and I am a professor of international trade at Carleton University.
A lot has changed since my last appearance at this committee, and Canadians across the country are closely following developments in Canada's trade dispute with the United States.
I'd like to use my time to encourage members to look past whether Canada returns to the negotiating table and instead focus on how we prepare to re-engage, because the details of an eventual agreement deserve our attention. I'm concerned about the perception that negotiations with the U.S. are frozen indefinitely. I don't believe this is accurate, and I anticipate that negotiations will resume in the coming months.
For example, if Mexico and the U.S. reach a bilateral agreement on tariff relief this fall, Canada would be urgently pushed back to the table. The Prime Minister has expressed a willingness to resume negotiations when a mutually beneficial agreement can be reached, and President Trump has suggested that talks could resume within weeks. Therefore, it is necessary to prepare for what a new bilateral agreement could look like.
In mid-August, both sides believed they had reached agreement on a set of terms before talks broke down. It is reasonable to expect those terms to now form the basis of the next round of negotiations, yet I expect even those elements Canada was prepared to accept in August to become more difficult to achieve now. The political context has shifted even further since the talks collapsed, and there is little appetite on the part of the general public to reach a deal.
Nevertheless, as Canada weighs the political downsides of re-engaging the U.S., our government must also calculate the cost of ongoing uncertainty for the Canadian businesses and workers most negatively impacted by tariffs. For example, we have witnessed several high-profile layoffs in Canadian manufacturing since the Trump administration announced tariffs on Canadian steel and vehicles: at Stellantis in Brampton, at Algoma Steel in Sault Ste. Marie and just last week at Stelco in Hamilton.
We know from decades of research that workers who lose their jobs in these circumstances often struggle to find new employment. This is especially difficult for workers who are older, who have less education or who live in smaller communities with few alternative sources of employment. Statistics Canada studies tell us that even those who find new jobs are likely to earn lower wages in their new roles.
Meanwhile, goods tariffed at 50% under the U.S.'s section 338 tariffs are effectively priced out of the U.S. market, and some Canadian products are now banned outright. The full impact of this most recent U.S. action and Canada's retaliation will only emerge in the coming weeks and months.
In addition, because of the deals other countries have reached with the U.S. to achieve their own tariff relief, those like the U.K., the EU, Japan and Korea enjoy simpler and often better tariff treatment for finished vehicles in the U.S. than Canada and Mexico do, further reducing our competitiveness.
While all of these challenges are very real, we cannot lose sight of the fact that CUSMA remains in place and that upwards of 80% of all Canadian goods continue to enter the U.S. tariff-free, provided that they are CUSMA-compliant. While I do not expect the U.S. president to withdraw from CUSMA, we must not underestimate the vital economic importance of this stable market access for the vast majority of our exporters to the U.S. That stability is what Canada must protect in any new agreement.
As the government considers the right conditions to resume negotiations, I urge it to set aside the impossible challenge of achieving trust with the Trump administration—the signature-in-pencil problem described by the Prime Minister in August. Instead, we must focus on the details of an agreement that Canada can live with whether it's in place for three months or three years. To me, there are two much more difficult scenarios facing Canada than the Trump administration reneging on the agreement.
The first would be reaching no tariff relief deal at all and the potentially devastating consequences for the most impacted Canadian sectors. The second would be reaching a really bad deal that cripples the long-term viability of Canada's manufacturing sector and potentially having to live with the agreement for several years after Trump leaves office. I believe our negotiators are acutely aware of the challenges presented by both scenarios and will work to achieve the right deal for Canada in these conditions.
To that end, I would encourage members of this committee to engage closely on the details of a potential deal, because that's what can best inform whether an agreement is in the interest of Canadians.
Thank you, Mr. Chair.
I'd be pleased to answer questions at the appropriate time.
