Hello. Good morning.
It's an honour to be with you and the committee this morning to contribute to your deliberations, which, as I understand it, are about the effectiveness of international institutions.
I want to start by reminding us all of what international institutions are. They are most simply arrangements that structure co-operation among sovereign states by establishing rules, procedures and expectations for how states interact. These arrangements vary in the degree of formality, ranging from informal understandings and norms, such as the institution of diplomatic immunity, to the formal international organizations, such as the UN, with established rules, administrative bodies and decision-making.
International institutions do not necessarily replace state sovereignty or operate independently of state interests. They create structured settings within which states pursue their goals and manage their interactions, even across time when governments change.
Why do these institutions matter for Canada? Professor Chapnick referred to this argument. Because our prosperity and security depend fundamentally on the broader global and institutional context, we've had a particular interest in building and sustaining an institutional architecture globally that will secure both our security and our economic objectives. The consequence of those realities is that we have relied upon international co-operation.
I want to stress to the committee that this has not been a naive or starry-eyed pursuit. It's been crucial to our success as a country. Given that Canada is not a major power, it has a continued interest in ensuring that any rules guiding these forms of international co-operation reflect the concerns of the many rather than the powerful few, minimize the capacity of the strong to coerce the weak, and have fair, transparent, rules-based mechanisms for resolving disputes.
Today, we face a fracturing multilateral system due to major powers' conflicting interests, lack of leadership from key players both regionally and globally, particular weaknesses in institutional enforcement and design, and continued under-representation of key states and non-state actors.
The past decade has brought to the surface the uncomfortable truth that core elements of the world's multilateral system are creaking and, in some cases, at risk of becoming obsolete. Added to this sentiment are questions about the legitimacy of a post-1945 architecture that does not adequately reflect the growing power and influence of non-western states, as well as simmering resentment about the alleged selectivity with which western states apply the core norms associated with that architecture.
One possible response to the fracturing multilateral system is for Canada to adopt a more transaction-based approach to international relations. We see some signs of this with the current government's approach to international trade in particular. As I suggested earlier, two Canadian realities—our relative power position and our globally facing economy and society—require ongoing commitment to multilateralism.
Then the key strategic question for Canada is whether it wishes to be a system maintainer or a system innovator. The latter calls for more proactive efforts to ensure that multilateralism better reflects changing power dynamics and emerging global challenges, including through the creation of new structures and processes, if necessary outside of well-established institutional frameworks. In short, it's still “a” rules-based order, not necessarily “the” rules-based order that we have all gotten used to.
However, there are two cautions.
First, variable geometry must be more than a slogan. It needs to be based on careful consideration of where and how coalitions can come together effectively in ways that complement and improve rather than undermine what I would call our legacy architecture.
Secondly, we need to be careful about how and with what criteria we evaluate the effectiveness of international institutions. The scapegoating of international institutions has become a well-trodden path for populist politicians around the world who want to deflect responsibility. Let's blame the WHO for all the problems of COVID. Let's blame the WTO for the loss of jobs in the heartland in the United States. Remember that international institutions are created by states. They do not sit above them or outside them and therefore reflect state interests and political dynamics. International institutions cannot eliminate those dynamics.
In my submission to you, I've left you some thoughts on questions to ask about the effectiveness of international institutions as you go through your deliberations. I will not summarize those now—I'd go over my five minutes—but I would say, most simply, ask whether a given institution makes a meaningful difference to international co-operation and helps address the problems it was created to solve. Simply establishing an institution, adopting rules or obtaining state compliance doesn't necessarily mean it's effective. We need to examine both institutional performance and an institution's actual contribution to important outcomes today.
Thank you for your attention. I look forward to your questions.
