Good afternoon, members of the committee. Thank you for your invitation.
Greetings to my colleagues in the room.
My comments will be based on some 30 years of experience. I spent the first part of my career working for several international organizations, and now I study the governance of international organizations.
My argument is simple and echoes that of my colleague. To be effective, international organizations need trust, trust from governments like Canada's that fund them, trust from the partners that implement their programs and trust from the populations they serve. This trust is obviously based on results, and it is always by these results that effectiveness is measured. However, as Professor Pouliot said, it depends mainly on the decisions made by the member states. When states and populations trust international organizations, co‑operation becomes easier. This has been well demonstrated. This co‑operation enables international organizations to achieve better results, which in turn strengthens the trust they inspire.
As I often tell my students, to a large extent, we get the international organizations we deserve. Countries like Canada define their mandates, powers and budgets, but if their mandates are vague or contradictory, if their powers are discredited, or if their budgets are cut, it should come as no surprise that the results are different or even very negative.
However, as we know, organizations must answer to multiple governments. Consequently, priorities can often conflict. So, as Professor Pouliot said, any assessment of the situation must distinguish between management issues and the political or budgetary obstacles that may be imposed by certain members. The United States' disengagement in recent years from certain international organizations illustrates this distinction precisely. When a country as significant as the United States reduces its support and calls certain institutions into question, it undermines both their capacity to act and their credibility. Not all of the resulting difficulties can be attributed to administration or bureaucracy.
In my view, five priorities emerge from this context. The first is that Canada continues to demonstrate the usefulness of international organizations. Trust in them requires citizens to understand what international co‑operation is going to bring to them. The Government of Canada must explain why it supports an organization and what results it expects from that support. It must demonstrate how international organizations contribute, for example, to detecting epidemics, as we are currently seeing with Ebola in Africa, preventing conflict or coordinating disaster responses. Their effectiveness directly contributes to the collective security of Canadians. This is often very poorly understood.
The second priority is to continue funding what we're asking for. It sounds simple, but it doesn't happen often. When resources dwindle, programs are scaled back, and expertise is lost. It's the same for any federal government department. This decline in capacity can then be presented as evidence of inefficiency, justifying further cuts. It's a kind of vicious cycle. Canada must break this vicious cycle and ensure that the mandates it supports are aligned with the resources it is prepared to provide or mobilize from other partners in the international community to meet those needs.
The third priority is to deliver on our commitments and ensure continuity during a crisis. I think it's fair to say that we're in a crisis right now. We need predictable funding. This must allow for the maintenance of teams, information networks and staff safety features. Effectiveness depends on that continuity. Organizations, whether federal or international, must be able to plan their responses, retain staff and work sustainably with partners.
The fourth priority is to apply the same rules to everyone and protect safety through law. Trust also depends on a sense of fairness. Conversely, trust is weakened when the rules seem to vary depending on alliances or the short-term interests of powerful states, as was mentioned earlier. Canada must therefore support the consistent application of international law, even if that sometimes means criticizing one or more partners.
The fifth priority is to co‑operate where we can actually act. In Davos, the Prime Minister called on middle powers to work together on specific issues. That's exactly what an international organization is all about. Canada could give concrete expression to this call by, for example, bringing together partners to maintain essential services that are at risk of being eliminated because of budget cuts.
For example, in my field of humanitarian studies, I think that humanitarian monitoring and early warnings for epidemics, as we're seeing in Africa, are a good example of what Canada could do. When we lose our ability to document needs and identify worsening conditions, we intervene too late, and the human and financial consequences are much greater.
I'll end there. The five priorities I just mentioned were also included in a somewhat more comprehensive brief containing recommendations. They are based on shared responsibility. International organizations must improve their practices, but countries like Canada must give them realistic mandates. We must honour our own commitment. For Canada, this means supporting their effectiveness so that they can fully exercise their role as members, donors and partners. Trust is built through this commitment and the resources we provide them.
Thank you very much.
