I will start over.
Again, thank you for the opportunity to speak with the committee. It is an honour to contribute to this critical element of our liberal democracy. My comments will begin with the historical context and conclude with a policy recommendation.
The end of the Second World War launched a series of international organizations and institutions that have persisted to this day. The intent at the time was twofold. The international security institutions, headlined by the United Nations Security Council, were meant to prevent a third world war. The international economic institutions—the International Monetary Fund or IMF, the World Bank, and the General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade, or GATT, which later became the World Trade Organization—were all designed to encourage liberalized trade within a rules-based system, supervised for all intents and purposes by leading western liberal democracies.
This system of global governance was utterly consistent with Canadian national interests. Not only did we help design these institutions; three of our closest allies had vetoes on the Security Council. Canada and other wealthy countries had disproportionate voting power at the IMF and World Bank. The GATT promoted free trade within a rules-based liberal order, two ideas of critical importance to a trade-dependent middle-sized power like Canada.
To summarize the history, the system of global governance that emerged after the Second World War was built deliberately and intentionally by Canada and its western allies for their mutual benefit. The post-Second World War system never functioned exactly as envisioned. Its effectiveness waxed and mostly waned, based largely on the interests of the great powers—notably, the United States, Russia and China—in making them work.
Today, as the United States turns inward, Russia inexcusably violates the sovereignty of Ukraine on a daily basis, and China regularly exercises economic coercion to get its way in the world, much of that system of global governance is in disarray. The United Nations has been marginalized by the great power veto. The World Trade Organization's appellate body cannot function, because Democratic and Republican administrations have prevented the appointment of a quorum of judges.
In this context, Canada is left with three options. What Prime Minister Mark Carney calls “variable geometry” is an approach that suggests that since the system is broken, Canada should work around it. Ottawa should pursue “different coalitions for different issues, based on common values and interests”. It should develop a web of limited economic and security alliances and institutions to make up for the failures of the universal ones.
It's a practical, pragmatic approach, but in withdrawing its attention from the United Nations system, Ottawa makes it easier for Beijing to increase its influence and ultimately rebuild that system, stripped of its liberal democratic inclinations.
An alternative is for Ottawa to take a leadership role in advancing institutional reform. Since Canada benefits disproportionately from a universal system that privileges liberal democratic ideals, an aggressive commitment to reform would be understandable, but Ottawa is not nearly powerful enough to overcome the current institutional dysfunction alone, and any resources it dedicates to reform cannot be invested in building national resilience.
There is, I think, a middle way. Canada must build new relationships and alliances to make up for the failure of the old ones. It cannot count on the United Nations to maintain its security or the World Trade Organization to protect its economic interests, but it must also remain engaged in the traditional international system, no matter how flawed or dysfunctional. History suggests that the chaos of today will eventually at least somewhat subside. When it does, we must ensure that the system of global governance to which we return has not been infiltrated and compromised by the Chinese.
In sum, international institutions today are not at their best. Canada has no choice but to seek alternatives, but it must also defend the broken institutions from a hostile takeover.
Thank you.
