Thank you very much for this invitation.
My focus is going to be narrower than that of all the speakers you've heard so far. I'm going to talk about the World Trade Organization and why strengthening it contributes to Canada's foreign policy priority of building a stable and prosperous world order.
We all know President Trump loves tariffs and does not love trade agreements. Last year, two European leaders called the WTO defunct and said it “hasn't worked for years”. In that famous Davos speech, Mark Carney said that the WTO was “greatly diminished”.
These perceptions are misleading. The WTO is the foundation of the trading system. Its fate matters enormously, not least for a small country like Canada. Countries do not automatically comply with any international obligation, and yet most WTO members do so much of the time. Observers have a natural tendency to look at breaches of the rules and ignore underlying compliance. The WTO secretariat estimates that 72% of all merchandise trade still takes place under the basic principle of countries treating their trading partners equally. This is known as the most favoured nation, or MFN, principle.
The purpose of the WTO is to reduce uncertainty and trade costs for importers and exporters. The WTO is not to blame for massive uncertainty in world trade. That's due to the geopolitical situation.
Reforms the WTO might need depend on its effectiveness in fulfilling three core functions.
First, it monitors the implementation of commitments and improves transparency on national trade policies. All of that is working well. WTO agreements are like the operating system for world trade. Its committees provide a forum for discussion of all the agreements, and those discussions are often based on notifications of new or changed trade measures. Thousands are submitted and published every year.
Second, it has a forum for settling legal disputes when they arise. This part of the system does need reform, but it's far from moribund. When countries cannot resolve conflict over the interpretation of the rules, they launch disputes. Rumours to the contrary notwithstanding, first-stage dispute panels still work. The problem is with appeals. The appellate body exists but is effectively defunct because of U.S. concerns. Some members appeal results anyway, which means rulings do not have to be implemented. Others use the interim mechanism of appealing by arbitration, which Canada helped create.
The third function is negotiating new agreements. WTO rules have not kept up with technological change and the evolution of complex global value chains. Observers will say that the WTO is ineffective because new negotiations involving the whole membership now seem impossible. Some say that 166 members cannot make decisions by consensus, but there will never be consensus to relax consensus. That's why members have tried to advance negotiations among smaller groups of countries in so-called plurilaterals. The results of some of these negotiations need consensus to be brought under the WTO umbrella. India, in particular, has created roadblocks to that consensus.
These institutional impediments to reform obscure the bigger problem. Capitals are distracted by events elsewhere. Bilateral negotiations and new strategic partnerships proliferate, but there's no alternative to the foundational role of the WTO in the trading system. If the WTO is allowed to fade away and world trade fragments into multiple small agreements, uncertainty and costs will rise for everyone. It won't be as instantaneous as closing the Strait of Hormuz, but it may be worse.
At the UN, in September, Canada co-sponsored the new Partners for Multilateralism coalition. This affirmed the need to uphold and enforce the rules essential to international order while renewing the multilateral system. One place to start is the WTO. We and other middle powers depend on the stability and predictability of the rules it provides. Dozens of reform proposals are on the table, but they are wish lists. Delegates are keeping the discussion alive, or treading water, until the politics allow genuine movement. Canada can help to ensure that the WTO does not sink while waiting.
Canada will likely make its own proposals. Officials in Geneva participate in country groups that meet informally on areas of possible agreement on institutional reform. Canada also supports informal dialogues on things like industrial policy and the environment. The Prime Minister and ministers are actively talking to their counterparts about trade. They should bring up the WTO. Canada can encourage other capitals to engage. For example, leaders could encourage India to be more accommodating of bringing plurilaterals under the WTO umbrella.
Thank you. I look forward to your questions.
