Members of the committee, thank you for the invitation. It's always an honour to have the opportunity to speak with you and address you.
Today, I would like to present three observations on the effectiveness of international institutions, followed by a recommendation on the role Canada could play in redefining international institutions.
The first observation is that international institutions are undergoing a profound crisis. Violations and blockages are nothing new, of course, but their increasing frequency and intensity at this time are certainly undermining these institutions.
The second observation is that, despite this crisis, institutions continue, on the whole, to perform essential functions and produce results. The WTO, the World Trade Organization, is an excellent example. Despite the paralysis of its appellate body since 2019, its members continue to bring cases before the dispute settlement body. Above all, despite the trade war launched by the Trump administration, more than 70% of international trade continues to take place under the most favoured nation principle. I think that's a very telling example.
The third observation is that maintaining this effectiveness also depends on the adaptability and resilience of states. To return to the example of the WTO, faced with the blockage in the appellate body—driven by Canada and the European Union—several members established a provisional appellate arbitration mechanism. As a result, they used the possibilities offered by existing law to preserve a function that was at risk.
It could also be said that WTO members are currently negotiating a possible reform of the organization. Just a few days ago, on October 23, they were working on substantial proposals. Consequently, these efforts show resilience but, above all, signal a redefinition of our international institutions, the outcome of which remains uncertain for the time being.
This is where my recommendation comes in, dear members of the committee: If this transformation gains momentum and accelerates, Canada needs to be ready, and it needs to be prepared to help lead. It can play a role in setting the standard.
We know that, in the past, Canada has often played a significant role in bringing about major transformations, but it must be said that Canada has taken a back seat in recent decades. The ambition expressed in Davos by Prime Minister Carney, the ambition for concerted action by middle powers, now calls for a sustained investment in our capabilities. I think the impetus is there for us to move forward.
I therefore propose a four-part strategy for establishing a global presence and providing international legal expertise.
First, we should anticipate upcoming vacancies and support Canadian candidates with a dedicated team, a budget and diplomatic engagement. In other words, we need to increase the presence of Canadians in key positions. We need to recognize this. Our presence in international institutions remains sporadic and insufficient. No Canadian has ever been nominated as a judge to the International Tribunal for the Law of the Sea, even though we have the world's longest coastline. We haven't had a judge on the International Court of Justice since Justice Read, whose term ended in 1958. Furthermore, since 2016, we have had no Canadians serving on the International Law Commission, the body of the United Nations General Assembly that works to codify and advance international law.
Let's face it: Other medium-sized countries, such as Romania and Tunisia, have fared much better than we have in recent years. They have succeeded in having their judges—their own nationals—elected to major bodies. This did not happen by accident, but as a result of a strategy. In 2024, Global Affairs Canada was considering structured support for candidacies. Where do we stand today?
Second, I think we need to involve university professors more closely in the teams that advise and represent Canada before international bodies, obviously, to complement the expertise of public servants. We should take a cue from countries that systematically include university professors, such as France and Belgium, and that succeed in promoting and gaining acceptance for new ideas.
Third, as a university professor, I cannot overlook the need to develop the next generation of talent. We need secondments, litigation experience and mentorship opportunities, all developed in partnership with universities.
Fourth, this strategy must explicitly include francophone legal professionals and capitalize on Canada's bilingualism. French and English are the official languages or working languages of all the international courts and tribunals and of most international institutions. Canada therefore possesses a tangible advantage and must make the most of it.
In closing, Mr. Chair, we're at a pivotal moment. Institutions are under strain, and a period of redefinition lies ahead. Canada must therefore prepare to help shape that redefinition and seize the current momentum to become one of its leading architects. To that end, it must adopt a strategy aimed, among other things, at securing key positions for Canadians.
Thank you.
