Thank you, Mr. Chair.
Honourable committee members, my name is Richard Robertson. I am B'nai Brith Canada's director of research and advocacy.
Established in 1875, B'nai Brith Canada is this country's longest-serving human rights organization. As part of its study on the effectiveness of international institutions and how Canada is meeting its foreign policy priority of strengthening these institutions, it is imperative that the committee examine Canada's present support for the United Nations Relief and Works Agency for Palestine Refugees in the Near East, UNRWA.
Canada is one of the largest contributors to UNRWA, having donated over $25 million U.S. In 2025 alone, as part of an over $100-million multi-year funding commitment. Following the October 7 Hamas-led terrorist attacks in Israel, evidence emerged of the links between UNRWA, listed terrorist organizations and the October 7 attacks themselves. As a UN agency, UNRWA has a fundamental obligation to maintain neutrality, to ensure both the integrity of the agency and the success of its operations.
The allegations against UNRWA prompted the UN Secretary-General to commission an independent review of UNRWA in 2024. The review focused on UNRWA's adherence to the international humanitarian principle of neutrality. From January to March 2024, Canada paused its funding to UNRWA while the review took place.
The resulting report, the Colonna report, found that although UNRWA had developed a significant number of mechanisms and procedures to ensure adherence with the principle of humanitarian neutrality, violations of the principle continued to persist. Violations recorded in the report include instances of staff publicly expressing political views, host country textbooks with problematic content being used in UNRWA schools, and politicized staff unions making threats against UNRWA management and causing operational disruptions. The report made 50 recommendations to strengthen UNRWA's neutrality, accountability, oversight and institutional integrity in eight critical areas requiring immediate improvement.
When Canada announced it was resuming funding to UNRWA on March 8, 2024, Global Affairs Canada stated that it was committed to ensuring full accountability, decisive action and the implementation of the necessary reforms within UNRWA. GAC further stated that Canada would work with stakeholders to ensure that the recommendations stemming from the report were fully implemented. GAC affirmed that Canada expects UNRWA to meet its obligation and uphold the UN value of neutrality, an essential component of UNRWA's mandate.
Canada further pledged additional funding to aid UNRWA in the implementation of the Colonna report recommendations. In May 2024, GAC doubled down on its expectations. GAC reaffirmed that Canada expects all the recommendations to be fully and swiftly implemented and that Canada will be monitoring progress closely. It has now been over 30 months since the Colonna report was published, yet publicly available evidence suggests that UNRWA has failed to implement its recommendations.
In July 2026, the Institute for Monitoring Peace and Cultural Tolerance in School Education, IMPACT-se, published an analysis of UNRWA's response to the Colonna report. IMPACT-se found that in the two years since the Colonna report was published, there had been limited publicly available evidence of meaningful structural change.
The IMPACT-se report noted that UNRWA's implementation reporting contained significant inconsistencies and has increasingly become difficult to assess. This includes evidence that recommendations previously classified by UNRWA as complete now appear to remain incomplete, and UNRWA's repeated requests for additional funding to facilitate the implementation of recommendations that it had already reported as complete.
The IMPACT-se report highlights that despite commitments to review educational materials and remove problematic content, there is limited evidence that such reforms have been undertaken. As an example, IMPACT-se referenced the continued use of educational materials containing anti-Semitic narratives, glorification of violence and encouragement of jihad.
UN Watch, an independent human rights organization accredited with special consultative status to the UN Economic and Social Council, raised similar concerns about UNRWA's implementation of the Colonna report's recommendations.
In September 2026, UN Watch found that UNRWA frequently measured administrative activity instead of meaningful reform and that, at most, 13 of the Colonna report's 50 recommendations had been completed as prescribed. They note that its employees continue to be exposed as members and supporters of terrorist organizations, that hateful educational content persists and that Hamas-dominated unions continue to obstruct neutrality.
Despite evidence from leading think tanks and human rights organizations that UNRWA has failed to implement the recommendations found in the Colonna report, the implementation of which the federal government acknowledged as essential and specifically committed funding towards, Canada continues to fund UNRWA.
If Canada wishes to ensure the effectiveness of international institutions and demonstrate its leadership in this sphere, it must demand an independent review of UNRWA's implementation of the Colonna report recommendations and cease sending Canadian funds to UNRWA until it has been demonstrated that it has successfully undertaken the required reforms.
If it proves incapable of reform, Canada must reconsider its continued support for UNRWA. Continuing to fund UNRWA as it currently exists is both a disservice to Canadian taxpayers and antithetical to Canada's attempts to ensure the effectiveness of international institutions.
