Evidence of meeting #47 for Foreign Affairs and International Development in the 45th Parliament, 1st session. (The original version is on Parliament’s site, as are the minutes.) The winning word was institutions.

A recording is available from Parliament.

On the agenda

Members speaking

Before the committee

Steil  Director General, Strategy, Department of Foreign Affairs, Trade and Development
MacKenzie  Director General, International Organizations and Human Rights Bureau, Department of Foreign Affairs, Trade and Development
Larose  Director General, International Security Policy and Strategic Affairs Bureau, Department of Foreign Affairs, Trade and Development
Dufour  Full Professor and Research Chair on Sustainable, Responsible, and Inclusive Trade Law, Faculty of Law, University of Ottawa, As an Individual
Slaughter  Incoming Dean, School of Public Policy, London School of Economics, As an Individual
Robertson  Director, Research and Advocacy, B'nai Brith Canada

Alexis Brunelle-Duceppe Bloc Lac-Saint-Jean, QC

Thank you, Mr. Chair.

Professor Dufour, it is genuinely a pleasure to hear from you. Thank you for being with us today.

I'd also like to thank all the other witnesses.

Professor Dufour, you have spoken extensively about the redefinition of institutions and international organizations. However, in a situation where a number of authoritarian regimes are themselves seeking to reshape those organizations and perhaps gain greater influence within them, what do you see as the principal vulnerabilities of the current system in the face of efforts to redefine it by actors who may be less committed to things like the rule of law, democracy and respect for human rights?

6:10 p.m.

Full Professor and Research Chair on Sustainable, Responsible, and Inclusive Trade Law, Faculty of Law, University of Ottawa, As an Individual

Geneviève Dufour

At the moment, at the World Trade Organization, the country that's constantly reminding everyone of the need to uphold the rule of law is China. That's quite striking, because we have long argued that China has violated the principles of international trade law, and it's not always the country that's most closely aligned with our values, whether in terms of human rights or environmental protection.

That's the danger we face right now. The risk is that influence gradually shifts to countries that don't share our values. That's one reason why the Canada-European Union Summit being held in Montreal over the next two days is so important. The objective is to build coalitions that may help compensate for the absence of a country that's not playing the game at the moment. The United States has stepped back from the system. When I say that, it's both true and not entirely true, because the United States remains at the negotiating table and continues to participate in the United Nations, the World Trade Organization, the World Health Organization and the International Labour Organization. It's still working with those organizations and has paid its assessed contributions. While the United States is no longer playing the role it did for decades, we shouldn't throw up our hands. Middle powers must come together and do so in an inclusive way, precisely to prevent the system from going off the rails.

Alexis Brunelle-Duceppe Bloc Lac-Saint-Jean, QC

Yes.

6:10 p.m.

Full Professor and Research Chair on Sustainable, Responsible, and Inclusive Trade Law, Faculty of Law, University of Ottawa, As an Individual

Geneviève Dufour

I would just add that we need to be careful about the partnerships we're pursuing right now. Canada is very active internationally at the moment and is entering into agreements with a number of countries that don't necessarily share its values.

Alexis Brunelle-Duceppe Bloc Lac-Saint-Jean, QC

That's exactly the point I wanted to raise. Let me come back to it, because you mentioned the Davos speech, in which there was discussion of working more closely with middle powers. It would be hard for anyone to oppose such a statement. I myself congratulated the Prime Minister for making it.

However, two days earlier, Mr. Carney was in Beijing shaking hands with Xi Jinping in connection with an agreement. More recently, Canada signed agreements with Turkey, accompanied by what I would describe as an almost Orwellian joint declaration stating that Canada and Turkey share and respect certain values, and then naming them. I don't believe the Erdogan regime lives up to those values. We also recently welcomed, with considerable fanfare, the Crown Prince of Abu Dhabi, MBZ, or Khaled bin Mohamed bin Zayed Al Nahyan, who isn't exactly known to be a strong defender of human rights. These examples are beginning to add up. The Davos speech contained many fine words. There is, of course, the summit with the European Union, but there have also been some troubling developments recently. What do these actions mean for Canada's credibility within international institutions?

The final point I wanted to raise concerns the United States. It may be that the United States has stepped back, but my impression is that it's the current administration, rather than the country itself, that has done so. Democratic institutions in the United States seem sufficiently strong that the country could eventually return to the role it played previously. Those are two separate questions.

6:15 p.m.

Full Professor and Research Chair on Sustainable, Responsible, and Inclusive Trade Law, Faculty of Law, University of Ottawa, As an Individual

Geneviève Dufour

There are several ways to answer those questions. Given the current stance of the United States, Canada has little choice but to engage with the rest of the world and seek agreements wherever it can. However, as you rightly pointed out, we mustn't lose sight of the fact that Canada stands for certain values and cannot act in ways that undermine them. That doesn't mean we can't build partnerships with countries that do not fully share those values, provided that appropriate safeguards are put in place. Whether those safeguards are in fact being put in place is another question. Canada must be a bridge builder. It must try to attract as many countries as possible.

The pragmatic foreign policy that Mélanie Joly was promoting—

Alexis Brunelle-Duceppe Bloc Lac-Saint-Jean, QC

Perhaps “advancing” rather than “promoting”.

6:15 p.m.

Full Professor and Research Chair on Sustainable, Responsible, and Inclusive Trade Law, Faculty of Law, University of Ottawa, As an Individual

Geneviève Dufour

Yes, the policy she was advancing made that point clearly. We need to remain engaged with countries that do not necessarily share our values. However, when we enter into partnerships and conclude agreements with such countries, I wonder whether this forms part of a genuine long-term strategy. Certainly, Canada is reacting to developments in the United States. Canada already has 17 free trade agreements. We have even more agreements relating to foreign direct investment. We know that Canadian businesses don't take full advantage of all the free trade agreements already in place. Why, then, do we need more? We need investment, but we mustn't sell our soul to the devil.

Alexis Brunelle-Duceppe Bloc Lac-Saint-Jean, QC

Has the tariff war with the United States become a justification for virtually everything these days? That's certainly the impression I get. I don't want to drift into extreme partisanship. Far from it. Some people may not believe me.

We nevertheless have a joint declaration with Mr. Erdogan stating that Canada and Turkey share and respect common values like democracy, the rule of law and freedom of expression, even though we know full well that members of LGBTQ+ communities are persecuted there and that opponents of the regime and journalists, among others, have been imprisoned.

6:15 p.m.

Full Professor and Research Chair on Sustainable, Responsible, and Inclusive Trade Law, Faculty of Law, University of Ottawa, As an Individual

Geneviève Dufour

University professors as well.

Alexis Brunelle-Duceppe Bloc Lac-Saint-Jean, QC

Yes, university professors as well.

We can engage in trade, but at some point there's a line that shouldn't be crossed. When I speak about credibility, I'm entirely serious. If Canada then appears before major international organizations, what's the significance of the joint declaration signed by Mr. Erdogan and Mr. Carney?

6:15 p.m.

Full Professor and Research Chair on Sustainable, Responsible, and Inclusive Trade Law, Faculty of Law, University of Ottawa, As an Individual

Geneviève Dufour

Canada is in a trade war. Regardless, it remains a form of conflict and a state of shock. Historically, it is during times of conflict that countries tend to set aside their values, human rights, environmental protection and, sometimes, even most of the time, the rule of law itself.

People often think it's an exaggeration to describe the situation as a trade war, but that's truly what it is. We're living through a trade war that seems to justify almost anything at the moment and that could ultimately prove damaging in the long run. The strategy needs to be much clearer, in my view.

The Chair Liberal Ahmed Hussen

Thank you.

MP Duncan, you have five minutes.

6:15 p.m.

Conservative

Eric Duncan Conservative Stormont—Dundas—Glengarry, ON

Thank you, Mr. Chair, and thank you to our witnesses for joining us this hour.

Mr. Robertson, I have a few questions I want to ask you, if I could.

You highlighted that several recommendations from the Colonna report remain outstanding. Which outstanding reforms should Canada treat as essential conditions for continued funding, rather than as commitments to be fulfilled eventually?

6:15 p.m.

Director, Research and Advocacy, B'nai Brith Canada

Richard Robertson

That's an excellent question that I actually had anticipated. I have a few of them open in front of me.

Recommendation 34 says, “Review the content of all textbooks and supplements with host countries”.

Recommendation 35 says, “Ban any hate speech, incitation to violence and/or anti-Semitic references from host-country textbooks and locally produced supplements”.

These are, in my opinion, some of the most simple things that UNRWA can do. The UNRWA textbook issue is not a new issue. It is an issue that has been raised for decades, yet UNRWA continues to allow these problematic materials to be utilized in the host nation's schools. This is something that is so simple. Remove the textbooks; utilize new textbooks.

How can we trust this organization with hundreds of millions of dollars in Canadian funds if they are incapable of removing hateful materials from the schools under their jurisdiction?

6:15 p.m.

Conservative

Eric Duncan Conservative Stormont—Dundas—Glengarry, ON

I appreciate that.

What information should Global Affairs Canada be required to publish annually about UNRWA funding, including amounts committed and disbursed, audit findings, identified risks and corrective measures?

6:20 p.m.

Director, Research and Advocacy, B'nai Brith Canada

Richard Robertson

This is an excellent question.

I think it's not so much about what Global Affairs Canada should be producing in terms of the funding it gives to UNRWA. It's what Global Affairs Canada should be requiring UNRWA to produce. UNRWA claims to have satisfied many of the 50 recommendations from the Colonna report, yet the evidence seems to indicate the contrary. What UNRWA appears to have done is simply lowered the threshold for being able to consider a recommendation completed, without actually taking meaningful steps to satisfy the recommendation.

We, as a nation, with Global Affairs being responsible for that, need to hold the entities that we give funds to accountable. For me, it's not so much a question of what Global Affairs Canada should be responsible for producing. It's what we should require UNRWA to produce in order to continue to receive our financial support.

6:20 p.m.

Conservative

Eric Duncan Conservative Stormont—Dundas—Glengarry, ON

Those are good points. Thank you.

Your organization has argued that Canada should not use UNRWA as its vehicle for delivering aid to Palestinians. Which alternative organizations or delivery mechanisms could provide food, medical care and other essential services, while reducing the risk of diversion to Hamas?

October 28th, 2026 / 6:20 p.m.

Director, Research and Advocacy, B'nai Brith Canada

Richard Robertson

I don't think there's a perfect solution for that, but Canada could deliver the aid itself. Canada could deliver the aid in concert with other allies.

Right now, we're putting our funds and our trust, and actually the fate of those who are relying on the humanitarian aid, in an organization that has demonstrated repeatedly that it is ripe for mismanagement, and that it doesn't value the humanitarian principle of neutrality, which is central to its mandate. Once again the question is, why do we continue to trust UNRWA? Why do we continue to invest hundreds of millions of dollars in this UN agency when we could use that money to more effectively deliver humanitarian aid, whether we do it on our own or with other capable partners?

6:20 p.m.

Conservative

Eric Duncan Conservative Stormont—Dundas—Glengarry, ON

My last question is this. What independent monitoring mechanism should Canada require to ensure the textbooks and classroom instruction materials in UNRWA schools meet UNESCO standards and do not promote anti-Semitism or glorify terrorism?

We talked about whether it's them proving it themselves, another international organization or a specific organization that should be doing the independent audit. What does that look like to make sure they're in compliance?

6:20 p.m.

Director, Research and Advocacy, B'nai Brith Canada

Richard Robertson

The UN brought in an independent review group to produce the Colonna report to make these recommendations, but it hasn't brought in an independent third party review group to ensure whether or not UNRWA has met all of those recommendations. We need an independent third party.

The organization I referenced in my opening remarks, IMPACT-se, is known around the world for its auditing of these textbooks. That is an organization I would highly recommend be involved in working with UNRWA to refine its textbooks. They've already done a comprehensive audit of the textbooks. They've identified the problems in the textbooks.

I really want to bring this point home: When it comes to UNRWA, this is a body that has, through the Colonna report, demonstrable issues with its oversight. Allowing them to be the judge of whether they have successfully met the recommendations in that independent review is, quite frankly, illogical.

The Chair Liberal Ahmed Hussen

Thank you very much.

We'll go next to MP Vandenbeld.

You have five minutes.

Anita Vandenbeld Liberal Ottawa West—Nepean, ON

Thank you, Mr. Chair.

I'd like to pose my questions to Dr. Dufour.

We've been talking in this committee quite a bit about Canada's state-to-state relationships within intergovernmental organizations like the UN, our diplomatic relationships and the funding that we do. You raised something really important that is a little under the radar when you said that to anticipate vacancies, be strategic and support the placement of Canadian candidates in key positions within these institutions.

I know that, for instance, in the United Nations, NATO and others like that, Canada will wait until a candidate is shortlisted, and then we will start our engagement to try to push for that candidate, but other countries start as soon as something is announced when it's a strategic, key leadership position in a geopolitically sensitive area. Countries like the U.S., China and middle powers, as you mentioned, will target that position, try to get strong candidates and start lobbying right at the outset. What happens is that Canadians are not shortlisted because of all the politics that go on, even before that point.

The other one I wanted to ask you about is OSCE, the Organization for Security and Co-operation in Europe. We had a previous study in this committee on the Balkans, and we heard from witnesses who were working inside OSCE that since 2008, Canada has not paid one salary for one Canadian to be placed in any position within OSCE. The way they work is the country has to pay the salary. They second somebody—either from within or outside of Foreign Affairs, but usually outside—and then the organization will pay the expenses. The only people we have within OSCE, to my knowledge, are young interns who don't expect a salary. They'll work just for a per diem, $2,000 a month. This means all of the key positions in this geopolitically strategic part of the world, in Europe where we want to engage more, are not held by Canadians. We don't have presence in these institutions at that level.

I want to ask you this, because you're the first one who has brought that up: How could Canada engage differently by really targeting and strategically trying to put Canadians into these important positions within multilateral organizations?

6:25 p.m.

Full Professor and Research Chair on Sustainable, Responsible, and Inclusive Trade Law, Faculty of Law, University of Ottawa, As an Individual

Geneviève Dufour

That's an excellent question.

It requires a strong political commitment. It requires political will, it requires a political strategy and it requires funding. I don't want to criticize anyone, but when appointing ambassadors to international organizations, we need people who are already familiar with the system, who know the network and who come from within it. We cannot expect to secure a seat on the Security Council without doing the necessary behind-the-scenes work. Yes, we must be able to promote values in line with the United Nations Charter, but it's a game of backroom diplomacy. Canada's ambassador to the United Nations must be someone who has been working there for years or decades and who is part of the UN system. The same applies to the World Trade Organisation and other international organizations. So, we need to identify young people early on and promote them. We also need to seek out experienced people within the foreign service and make arrangements to promote them.

We were talking earlier about Canadian values. If we want to promote Canadian values, we need Canadians. These people are independent. A judge at the International Court is independent. Any legal expert within an organization will be independent. Nevertheless, we believe that these people will share certain values with us, or at least have values in common with us. So, values are essential. A strategy is also required.

Anita Vandenbeld Liberal Ottawa West—Nepean, ON

Thank you very much. I think we could take some of those recommendations.

You also talked about entry points for young Canadians. I recall, in the same Balkans study, we heard about the international youth internship program where young Canadians could be placed within these organizations funded by Canada through, say, World University Service of Canada, or something like that. I was one of those interns almost 30 years ago. It launches the career, and it gets young people experience. It also allows them to move up in those organizations.

Could you elaborate a bit on what you meant by that?