I have a point of order.
Evidence of meeting #22 for Health in the 45th Parliament, 1st session. (The original version is on Parliament’s site, as are the minutes.) The winning word was point.
A video is available from Parliament.
Evidence of meeting #22 for Health in the 45th Parliament, 1st session. (The original version is on Parliament’s site, as are the minutes.) The winning word was point.
A video is available from Parliament.
Conservative
Conservative
Liberal
The Chair Liberal Hedy Fry
Mr. Mazier, I decide. In debate, a person is allowed to say what they wish as long as they stick to the topic.
Ms. Chi is not out of order. She's reading the motion.
Liberal
Maggie Chi Liberal Don Valley North, ON
I'm literally reading your motion.
I'm going to start again from paragraph (b). It reads:
(b) a detailed breakdown of supplemental health benefits by category, province, utilization and contribution to overall program growth, including utilization rates; (c) cost implications across different asylum claim pathways and outcomes broken, down by province; (d) the financial sensitivity of the program to changes in IRB processing times; (e) the relationship between intake levels, backlogs and projected IFHP expenditures;—
Conservative
Liberal
Maggie Chi Liberal Don Valley North, ON
I'll continue:
(f) risks that could materially impact long-term program costs beyond current projections; (g) an analysis on the distribution of IFHP usage and costs across provinces, highlighting impact of the program on specific hospitals/regions; (h) an analysis of changes in the average cost per beneficiary and its contribution to the overall growth of the program; (i) an analysis of alternative scenarios taking into account variations in intake volumes and processing times; and (j) any other elements deemed relevant by the Parliamentary Budget Officer to ensure a comprehensive analysis of the factors influencing the program's fiscal trajectory.
Chair, I need to reiterate that I really agree with my colleagues' assessment and their point about whether this is the appropriate committee to study this motion. We really spent a long time and had countless witnesses. We have a lot of testimony on studying the impact of immigration on health care.
I do empathize with the office of the PBO that they didn't have sufficient time to analyze the report.
I do remind the committee that it was a Conservative motion to call the office of the PBO in such a short timeline that they couldn't take into account the changes, which does mean that some of the numbers really are not representative—
Liberal
Maggie Chi Liberal Don Valley North, ON
—and some of the projections are not representative.
Excuse me. I'm sorry.
I'm speaking here, Mr. Mazier. Do you have a point of order, or do you want to interrupt me?
Liberal
The Chair Liberal Hedy Fry
I'm the chair. I will decide.
Mr. Mazier, can you refrain from editing aloud when she's to speak?
Liberal
Maggie Chi Liberal Don Valley North, ON
Yes, I give you the time of day, and I expect the same thing.
Liberal
Maggie Chi Liberal Don Valley North, ON
In the estimates here, in the first page of the highlights of the report, it literally says, “Budget 2025 indicated that a 'modest co-payment model' will be introduced to the Interim Federal Health Program for supplemental health products or services. This change to the program is not reflected in our projection. Including this new measure would reduce our estimate”. I repeat that the change is “not reflected”.
I really want to remind committee colleagues here that when they keep on repeating or quoting a number that didn't even account for these measures, it is really not an accurate representation of the projection.
Conservative
Dan Mazier Conservative Riding Mountain, MB
I think it's just a point of clarification for Ms. Chi and all the committee here. That's exactly why we introduced this motion.
Liberal
The Chair Liberal Hedy Fry
Mr. Mazier, that's not a point of order or a point of clarification. You're just debating your motion, and you had your time to do that already.
Liberal
Maggie Chi Liberal Don Valley North, ON
I was just trying to make a point that whenever members quote reports, I really hope people understand the context behind a number, because that matters.
When you are quoting something to the public, it's so important to take into account the context, because that matters. When you repeat a figure that hasn't really taken into account the projections with accurate information, I think that's really harmful to the dialogue. This is why I really want to emphasize to the PBO that I think that's a really responsible thing you did on the first page to account for the missing components and context in the report. I thank you for highlighting that.
I want to remind folks about quoting a number that really didn't have the most accurate projection. That's no fault of anybody, because we called you in too early. That's a Conservative motion. They really didn't have the consideration for some of the changes that we are seeing.
There's a lot of noise in the committee right now. I really would like to focus on making my point.
Back to the motion itself, when you look at some of the pieces here in the relationship between intake levels, backlogs and projected IFHP expenditures—I'm speaking to the motion. This is actually in the motion. It's line (e). This is an IRCC issue. This is an immigration issue. They have the numbers. They have the expertise. They are accounting for the numbers and expertise. This is why I think our committee may not be the most appropriate—this motion is not the most appropriate for the Standing Committee on Health, and I would really encourage folks to think about that.
When we are looking at studies and motions—
Liberal
Conservative
Dan Mazier Conservative Riding Mountain, MB
That was already debated and lost. We decided as a committee that wasn't relevant.
Liberal
The Chair Liberal Hedy Fry
We're debating the motion on the table, Ms. Chi, and not whether it should or should not be here. We already decided that. Let us discuss the motion.
Liberal
Maggie Chi Liberal Don Valley North, ON
Okay.
I do have another point to make, especially when the report itself referenced that it really didn't take into account the recent changes. As of January 27, 2026, this is on the Government of Canada website right now. It's titled “Changes to the Interim Federal Health Program”. If you search it, you will find it, and it gives more detail about the program.
Can I please outline what is in the program without being interrupted? I would really like the indulgence of the committee for that:
As announced in Budget 2025, Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship Canada will introduce co-payments—
—which was mentioned in the report—
—for supplemental health products and services for eligible people (beneficiaries) covered under the Interim Federal Health Program....
The IFHP is the subject of the discussion here.
The [Interim Federal Health Program] provides limited and temporary coverage for urgent and essential health products and services for eligible beneficiaries until they transition to provincial or territorial health care programs.
It gives an outline and it's also outlined in the report.
A co-payment is the portion of the cost that a beneficiary pays directly to their health care provider, with the remaining cost covered by the IFHP. Introducing co-payments—
—which was outlined in budget 2025—
—will help keep supplemental health care accessible for eligible beneficiaries while responsibly managing growing demand.
I think we recognize there is a growing demand, and this really helps manage that piece.
This change supports the long-term sustainability of the IFHP so it can continue providing essential support to current and future beneficiaries.
The part that is changing is in the next section, where it says, “What is changing”.
As of May 1, 2026, IFHP—