Evidence of meeting #22 for Health in the 45th Parliament, 1st session. (The original version is on Parliament’s site, as are the minutes.) The winning word was point.

A video is available from Parliament.

On the agenda

Members speaking

Before the committee

Jacques  Interim Parliamentary Budget Officer, Office of the Parliamentary Budget Officer
Nicol  Advisor-Analyst, Office of the Parliamentary Budget Officer
Perrault  Director of Policy (Costing), Office of the Parliamentary Budget Officer
Stanton  Advisor-Analyst, Office of the Parliamentary Budget Officer

Sonia Sidhu Liberal Brampton South, ON

Thank you, Madam Chair.

I move that the motion be amended in the last paragraph by removing the words “officials from Health Canada” and after the word “separately” adding the words “for one hour each”. The last paragraph of the motion would now read, “And that, upon the completion of this report, the Parliamentary Budget Officer and officials from Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship Canada be invited to testify separately for one hour each before committee on the subject of the report.”

The Chair Liberal Hedy Fry

Good.

I just want to be very clear that we are debating the amendment to the motion.

Please put your hand up if you would like to speak to the amendment.

We have a new list.

We will start with Mr. Mazier.

Dan Mazier Conservative Riding Mountain, MB

I don't agree with removing the Health Canada officials. This is the health committee. This does impact our health system. I don't see any use in removing them. In fact, the health officials should be here to talk about the impacts this program has on our whole health care system.

I would oppose that type of amendment.

The Chair Liberal Hedy Fry

Mr. Eyolfson.

Doug Eyolfson Liberal Winnipeg West, MB

Thank you, Chair.

I agree with the honourable member that, yes, this is worth talking about at this committee. However, the program is not administered under the auspices of the health ministry. This is under the ministry of immigration. They would have the most useful information for that. It would not be fruitful to have the health minister speak on a program that is not administered by health.

The Chair Liberal Hedy Fry

Mr. Strauss.

3:45 p.m.

Conservative

Matt Strauss Conservative Kitchener South—Hespeler, ON

Thank you, Madam Chair.

I just wanted to make the point that when we originally spoke with the PBO officials, I think the other physicians on this committee were all on the Liberal side.

We're really interested in this aspect of how the same procedure costs up to five times as much on this program than it does on the provincial budget. It seems to me that this has implications on our universal health care system, which is governed by the Canada Health Act, which is administered by the Minister of Health through the health bureaucracy at Health Canada. It seems to me that the officials should be here to speak to this concern that I legitimately think we all share.

The Chair Liberal Hedy Fry

Are there any other speakers on the amendment?

Seeing no hands, I will call the vote on the amendment.

(Amendment negatived: nays, 5; yeas, 4)

We now go back to continuing the debate on the motion on the floor. It doesn't mean people cannot bring up further amendments if they wish. I'm just letting everybody know that, because we're now debating the motion that was originally put forward.

I'm going to go to Mr. Bailey.

3:45 p.m.

Conservative

Burton Bailey Conservative Red Deer, AB

I cede my time.

Thank you.

The Chair Liberal Hedy Fry

Go ahead, Mr. Mazier.

3:45 p.m.

Conservative

Dan Mazier Conservative Riding Mountain, MB

This is a great motion. If we were to pass it, that would be fantastic.

Nothing else needs to be said.

Maggie Chi Liberal Don Valley North, ON

Is this speaking to the motion?

The Chair Liberal Hedy Fry

Yes, it's speaking to the original motion.

Maggie Chi Liberal Don Valley North, ON

Is there a possibility for Health Canada and IRCC to appear together, as a small amendment to the motion? Right now, I'm not too sure about the wording.

The Chair Liberal Hedy Fry

You're saying that you agree with the completion of this report, and that the Parliamentary Budget Officer and officials from Health Canada and officials from Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship Canada be invited.

Is that what you're suggesting?

Maggie Chi Liberal Don Valley North, ON

It's just a small amendment of them appearing together.

The Chair Liberal Hedy Fry

We now have another amendment on the table, so we're going to speak to the amendment.

Go ahead, Mr. Mazier.

3:50 p.m.

Conservative

Dan Mazier Conservative Riding Mountain, MB

I would have to disagree with this.

The whole idea is more transparency with Health Canada. The motion is very well detailed out, so that the Parliamentary Budget Officer can actually seek details from whichever department is basically hiding something here. We can then get to the real details of what's going on with the interim federal health program.

I know we've been going back and forth in the House. Liberals seem to be of the opinion that there are new changes made in the budget that are going to save this program and save Canadians a bunch of money. Yet, it can be proven out by the Parliamentary Budget Officer and he can prove all that stuff out.

I don't think it needs to be changed. I don't think Health Canada should be removed from this. I would vote against this amendment.

Maggie Chi Liberal Don Valley North, ON

Just to clarify, that's not what I'm suggesting. I'm not suggesting that Health Canada be removed. I'm suggesting that Health Canada and IRCC appear together.

The Chair Liberal Hedy Fry

Maybe you could read out the amendment you're trying to put forward, so everyone is clear, Ms. Chi.

Maggie Chi Liberal Don Valley North, ON

Can we suspend for a few minutes?

The Chair Liberal Hedy Fry

Yes, absolutely.

We will suspend for a few minutes.

4 p.m.

Liberal

The Chair Liberal Hedy Fry

We're ready to resume the meeting.

Ms. Chi said she would like to withdraw the amendment.

You need unanimous consent to do that, Ms. Chi, so I will ask the committee.

Are you all in favour of removing the amendment?

Some hon. members

Agreed.

4 p.m.

Liberal

The Chair Liberal Hedy Fry

(Amendment withdrawn)

We now go back to debating the motion.

Next on my list is Mr. Blanchette-Joncas.