Evidence of meeting #22 for Health in the 45th Parliament, 1st session. (The original version is on Parliament’s site, as are the minutes.) The winning word was point.

A video is available from Parliament.

On the agenda

Members speaking

Before the committee

Jacques  Interim Parliamentary Budget Officer, Office of the Parliamentary Budget Officer
Nicol  Advisor-Analyst, Office of the Parliamentary Budget Officer
Perrault  Director of Policy (Costing), Office of the Parliamentary Budget Officer
Stanton  Advisor-Analyst, Office of the Parliamentary Budget Officer

Helena Jaczek Liberal Markham—Stouffville, ON

Yes. In essence, I'm speaking against the motion in this committee.

The Chair Liberal Hedy Fry

I go to Ms. Konanz.

5:55 p.m.

Conservative

Helena Konanz Conservative Similkameen—South Okanagan—West Kootenay, BC

Thank you.

First of all, these professionals took time and energy to put together a very professional report.

Chair, we sat here as every single one of these Liberal representatives or MPs talked about how they needed to further this report—that it needed to be continued. Every single one of them said that there wasn't enough information and that they needed more in order to get the proper numbers. Some of them were questioning the numbers. Each one of them said how important it was that we continue a study to look into this more.

I know that $1.5 billion out of our budget toward health is important, whether it's health for people who are new to our country.... We're questioning possibly some of the $1.5 billion going to people who are maybe not actually deserving of that support, which would be those who have been convicted of a crime or have not passed the asylum and refugee system.

Every single one of these Liberal members who has spoken today has said that we need to continue this report. That is on record. Thank you.

The Chair Liberal Hedy Fry

Thank you, Ms. Konanz.

I go to Mr. Bailey.

5:55 p.m.

Conservative

Burton Bailey Conservative Red Deer, AB

Thank you, Madam Chair.

I apologize to you and to the members here for losing my cool.

I take this study very seriously. When we talk about our doctor shortage, from what I've learned about this study, $1.5 billion would give us 1,500 more specialists in this country.

When programs like this are being abused, it puts a strain on our health care. We are the health committee. These types of things are very important. I'm not talking about the immigration aspects. I'm not talking about the housing. I am talking about the strain on health care, the doctor shortage and the five times the billing.

This study is important. These people need to complete what they have been doing. We rushed them in the first place—even yourselves in the beginning. I am not going to waste the committee's time reading this motion again, but I ask you all to reconsider and look at the $1.5 billion of health care money being wasted.

The Chair Liberal Hedy Fry

Thank you, Mr. Bailey.

I now go to Mr. Eyolfson.

Doug Eyolfson Liberal Winnipeg West, MB

Thank you, Chair.

We need to keep in mind that there are a number of studies that are very worthwhile studies. I think we have had some very worthwhile information from this study, but there have been nine meetings so far on this study. For meetings for other topics, we've had six. We have given more than enough goodwill to keep entertaining extensions of this. Every time it appears to be done, there's one more motion to extend this.

We have a number of very important studies. It's one thing to want to take a topic and study it to its conclusion. It's another matter to keep adding on more motions, adding on more reasons to extend it and putting other studies on the back burner, particularly when we're talking about issues that are the responsibility of other departments. Quite frankly, this is a waste of parliamentary resources and a waste of taxpayers' money.

The Chair Liberal Hedy Fry

Are you finished, Mr. Eyolfson?

Doug Eyolfson Liberal Winnipeg West, MB

Yes, thank you.

The Chair Liberal Hedy Fry

Go ahead, Mr. Mazier.

5:55 p.m.

Conservative

Dan Mazier Conservative Riding Mountain, MB

I can't believe I just heard that $1.5 billion.... We've heard that five times the charging rate is coming out of these provinces. Quebec is paying through the nose on this. I can't believe that it's a waste of time to look at the spending that's going on here.

An hon. member

It's not a health issue.

5:55 p.m.

Conservative

Dan Mazier Conservative Riding Mountain, MB

It's out of control, and it's not a health issue.

Maggie Chi Liberal Don Valley North, ON

I have a point of order—

The Chair Liberal Hedy Fry

I'm sorry. You do not engage in debates across the floor. You go through the chair. You have a responsibility, Mr. Mazier, to speak to the motion. That's what you're speaking to.

Maggie Chi Liberal Don Valley North, ON

I have a point of order.

The Chair Liberal Hedy Fry

Yes, go ahead.

6 p.m.

Liberal

Maggie Chi Liberal Don Valley North, ON

I hope I can sound like a doctor, but I'm not there.

The point of order is with regard to Mr. Mazier's characterization of my colleague's comment. That's not what he said at all—

6 p.m.

Conservative

Dan Mazier Conservative Riding Mountain, MB

That's not a point of order.

6 p.m.

Liberal

Maggie Chi Liberal Don Valley North, ON

—and I think it's irresponsible to characterize my colleague's comments like that—

6 p.m.

Conservative

Dan Mazier Conservative Riding Mountain, MB

Is $1.5 billion not irresponsible?

6 p.m.

Liberal

The Chair Liberal Hedy Fry

When a person is speaking on the floor, I would like to ask this committee to please refrain from speaking over them. Allow them to finish. You can disagree with them. When you have your turn, you can say what you want.

You had your turn, Mr. Mazier. Ms. Chi is now commenting.

Ms. Chi, that is not a point of order. I'm so sorry.

Let us move on.

Mr. Mazier, continue.

6 p.m.

Conservative

Dan Mazier Conservative Riding Mountain, MB

Thank you, Chair.

This is not continuing on with the study. This is asking the PBO to do a report on a $1.5-billion boondoggle cover-up of the interim federal health program. That is what this is about.

I do not know why the Liberals are so in objection to this. They spent the first hour saying we need more details. My gosh, you haven't included everything—

6 p.m.

Liberal

Maggie Chi Liberal Don Valley North, ON

On a point of order—

The Chair Liberal Hedy Fry

Go ahead, Ms. Chi.