Evidence of meeting #38 for Health in the 45th Parliament, 1st session. (The original version is on Parliament’s site, as are the minutes.) The winning word was addiction.

A video is available from Parliament.

On the agenda

Members speaking

Before the committee

Azar  Physician, As an Individual
Kaiser  Deputy Medical Director, Direction régionale de santé publique de Montréal
Nickie Mathew  Addiction Psychiatrist, As an Individual
Julian M. Somers  Clinical Psychologist and Full Professor, As an Individual
Merasty  Minister of Self Determination and Self Government, Métis Nation-Saskatchewan
Fullerton-Trotchie  Minister of Health, Mental Health and Addictions, Métis Nation-Saskatchewan

Sonia Sidhu Liberal Brampton South, ON

Thank you, Chair. Thank you, Dr. Kaiser and Dr. Azar, for your work in the communities.

My question is for Dr. Kaiser.

You talked about education. What role should school, family physicians and community health organizations play in identifying substance use risk before it develops into more serious health challenges?

5:25 p.m.

Deputy Medical Director, Direction régionale de santé publique de Montréal

David Kaiser

There are many school programs that exist already that are run by schools, that are run by community organizations, that are run in conjunction with health systems. I think those can be systematized, making sure that students have access to safe and secure environments to access care, for example, if they are experimenting with drugs or having a mental health condition or substance use problem when they're in school. They need to be sure that they can access a care provider in a safe and confidential way.

Then I think there is a whole second component, around education. We need to be educating kids to navigate the environment they are going to find themselves in, in terms of being able to understand health information and being able to navigate conflict and the types of difficult conversations that are necessary in order to get through a world that is really complicated for young people and teenagers.

Yes, there's a part of education around health education and health promotion, but I think part of our education system needs to be equipping our teens and young adults to actually function in a complex world where drugs can often be a response to distress, to mental health issues and to an inability to function in that world that generates a lot of that.

Sonia Sidhu Liberal Brampton South, ON

Thank you.

My next question is, how can federal investments in community-based prevention and treatment be better aligned with the priorities identified by provincial and municipal public health authorities?

5:25 p.m.

Deputy Medical Director, Direction régionale de santé publique de Montréal

David Kaiser

I think it's just having, as I said in my opening remarks, confidence. I think it's having confidence in the people who are on the ground and doing the real work and providing them with the tools they need to do that work.

Yes, we need to be evidence-based. I think the federal government has an important role to play in translating evidence into action, and we need to be able to orient financing and evaluation as a function of what the people who are doing the real work tell us.

I just want to say that in the perspective of translating evidence into action, I think it's really important that we don't take a small component of a complex system and draw conclusions. In the study in Red Deer that was mentioned, the conclusions of the study say the following:

Short‐term effects on acute healthcare utilization and mortality appear stable but remain inconclusive due to the limited 26‐week follow‐up period and low event counts.

That is not a study that I would expect a federal government to make decisions on in isolation. What I expect is that we have confidence, that we base our decisions on what is happening on the ground, that we bring in all of the science that brings us different perspectives, and that decisions are made as a function of the whole body of evidence.

Sonia Sidhu Liberal Brampton South, ON

My next question is for Dr. Azar.

Dr. Azar, stigma plays a significant role in preventing an individual from seeking help for substance use. From your perspective, what can public health organizations do to reduce this stigma and encourage more people to access and support the treatment they need?

5:30 p.m.

Physician, As an Individual

Pouya Azar

That's an excellent question.

Traditionally, we have done prevention quite poorly. I'm looking at moralistic, fearmongering campaigns. We're familiar with the “Just Say No” and “This Is Your Brain On Drugs” campaigns. When you think about what a young person actually experiences, a young person who is at a party feeling insecure and feeling anxious, and the drugs are being passed around, they're not going to think to themselves, oh, Nancy Reagan told me to just say no.

I think we need to be more sophisticated around our prevention campaigns. One of the things my lab is working on to help reduce stigma is essentially employing strategies that have been already used by corporations: targeting young people for marketing utilizing social media and peer-to-peer messaging. We want to use that same approach, but target it towards reducing stigma associated with mental health and addiction. I feel that we know it's already effective for corporate marketing. I think we can potentially use that same strategy.

We're launching a pilot program called The Natural Stance. It's on social media right now. We are going to evaluate it and, hopefully, we'll have some data around that.

The Chair Liberal Sukh Dhaliwal

Thank you.

With that, on behalf of the committee members, I would like to thank both Dr. Kaiser and Dr. Azar for their valuable and professional input. I appreciate it.

I will briefly suspend the meeting, and then we will welcome the second panel of witnesses.

The Chair Liberal Sukh Dhaliwal

I would like to call the meeting back to order.

On behalf of the committee members, I would like to welcome the witnesses who are joining for the second hour.

Even though the regional chief was scheduled to appear in the first meeting, because of the technical difficulties, he's here now. From the Assembly of First Nations, we have Regional Chief Wendell LaBobe. Welcome.

Appearing as individuals, we have Dr. Nickie Mathew, addiction psychiatrist, and we also have Dr. Julian Somers, clinical psychologist. Welcome.

From Métis Nation-Saskatchewan, we have the Minister of Health, Mental Health and Addictions, Madam Beverly Fullerton-Trotchie. Welcome. We also have the minister of Self-Determination and Self-Government, Mr. Brennan Merasty. Welcome.

I would like to make a few comments to our witnesses.

Before speaking, please wait until either I recognize you by name or the member asks a question directly to one of you.

For those participating by video conference, click on the microphone icon to activate your mic, and please mute yourself when you are not speaking. At the bottom of your screen, you can select the appropriate channel for interpretation: floor audio, English or French.

For those in the room, you can use the earpiece and select the desired channel. Committee members may ask questions in either French or English. If you need interpretation, please take a moment now to prepare your earpiece and select the listening channel you need in advance in order to take full advantage of the time allotted for questions and answers.

This is a reminder that all comments should be addressed through the chair. Even though I give a lot of flexibility here, my particular request to the witnesses is this: If you can keep an eye on the honourable member who's asking questions, as soon as they raise their hand, I would suggest that you please stop speaking, because it is their time.

To the honourable members, if you can say the name of the witness the question is for, then it will make it much easier.

With that, each organization has five minutes for opening remarks, and then we will proceed with the round of questions. We will start with the Assembly of First Nations, Regional Chief LaBobe.

Please go ahead.

[Technical difficulty—Editor]

We can't hear you.

Okay. They're going to check. We can go to the next witness in the meantime.

I'm sorry, Chief. We'll come back to you.

We will now go to the individual witnesses. We will start with Dr. Mathew.

Dr. Mathew, you have five minutes. Please go ahead.

Dr. Nickie Mathew Addiction Psychiatrist, As an Individual

I'd like to thank the committee for inviting me to this.

I want to speak about the rise of synthetic drugs in the Canadian drug market and how this has affected the minds and safety of the Canadian population.

How did we get here? In 1958, Arthur Sackler launched the Terramycin campaign and invented direct-to-physician marketing. In 1959, Paul Janssen invented fentanyl. Arthur Sackler and his brothers made so much money from the Terramycin campaign that they bought Purdue pharmaceuticals. In 1980, Porter and Jick wrote a five-line letter to the editor that addiction was rare in people prescribed narcotics. In 1996, James Campbell, president of the American Pain Society, launched the campaign “pain as the fifth vital sign”. In that same year, Purdue pharmaceuticals released OxyContin. They used the direct-to-physician marketing that was invented by Arthur Sackler and cited the five-line letter to the editor by Porter and Jick. This laid the groundwork for a population that had a tolerance for fentanyl. OxyContin became supplanted by fentanyl in 2010.

In 2006 there was a restriction on the sale of Ephedra in Canada. The Mexican cartels responded by perfecting the phenyl-2-propanone method. When they were using the ephedrine method, they would make one molecule of l-methamphetamine and one molecule of d-methamphetamine. L-methamphetamine was a nasal decongestant and d-methamphetamine was psychoactive. With this new method, they had a very potent version of crystal meth. Both of these invaded the Canadian drug market.

When you look at these drugs, they tend to be co-ingested. When you look at the overdoses that occurred in British Columbia in 2021-22, about 70% of the folks who died of overdose that year had stimulants in their system.

By 2017, the most used drug by incarcerated individuals in British Columbia was methamphetamine. Why is this problematic? Well, there's the issue of substance-induced psychosis. Substance-induced psychosis is a neurotoxic event. It means initially people won't get psychotic when using meth. They get psychotic during intoxication, then during withdrawal and then during the sobriety phase. Every time they get psychotic, it's more likely to happen again, it's harder to treat, and it tends to be more severe.

In 2022 Premier David Eby had the Butler-LePard report done. They looked at random stranger violence. They found in that report that three of the main drivers were, one, mental illness; two, acquired brain injuries due to the toxic drug supply; and three, methamphetamine use.

This also affects recidivism. There's a term called “concurrent disorders”, which is when folks have psychiatric and substance use disorders at the same time. Of folks who were incarcerated in British Columbia, 72% who had concurrent disorders were likely to have recidivism during that time, so it was the most important risk factor.

When we look at the population of British Columbia writ large, by 2021 there were about 75,000 people with opioid use disorder. Now, 80% of them had a psychiatric disorder, so concurrent disorders in British Columbia are the rule, not the exception. When we look at folks with opioid use disorder in British Columbia, about 12,000 of them will have a psychotic disorder as well.

I'm not sure if you have been to the Downtown Eastside in Vancouver. There are about 18,000 people there. There was a study called the “The Hotel Study”, in which they found that about 95% of the people in the study had substance use disorders, about three-quarters had a mental illness, 47% had psychosis and 45% had diagnosable neurological disorders. There was a clinical triad of substance use disorders, psychiatric disorders and brain injury.

What do we do about it? Treating addictions is complicated. The opioid crisis has been approached as though there's been an opioid deficiency: If we prescribe more opioids, we'll get out of this. Almost the entire focus has been on giving people enough different kinds of opioids, assuming this will solve the crisis.

Opioid use disorder is not an opioid deficiency. Any place on earth that has treated the opioid crisis used multiple approaches where medication was just a small part. Psychological therapies are not covered. The intervention with the most evidence for amphetamine use disorder is contingency management. We need to look at a wide range of evidence and solutions. It is unlikely we'll find a home run intervention. With the varied population, we'll need input from public health, addiction medicine and addiction psychiatry, among others.

There is Canadian evidence that treating people with mental health and addiction issues concurrently will help keep this population alive. Psychosis increases the risk of violence fourfold, so treating psychosis is important in preventing violence. Early access to treatment for concurrent disorders can help change the trajectory of the illness and the associated risks. Clients, especially high-risk clients, need timely access to treatments. Along with treatments, there needs to be stable housing with appropriate supports. There needs to be vocational rehabilitation opportunities. There's the “approved home” model in British Columbia, which is a service that has two main purposes. One is to provide long-term residence, and the second is to provide secure, low-barrier treatment and recovery. They have severe—

The Chair Liberal Sukh Dhaliwal

Thank you, Dr. Mathew. That was five minutes and 30 seconds. You had five minutes to speak.

We'll go to Dr. Somers for five minutes.

Please go ahead.

Dr. Julian M. Somers Clinical Psychologist and Full Professor, As an Individual

Thank you.

I'm a clinical psychologist and a scientist. I began my career in 1986 at B.C.'s Riverview Hospital during deinstitutionalization. Since 1996, I've helped design and evaluate federal, provincial and territorial initiatives to prevent and treat addiction.

I'm today asking the Government of Canada to build on federal work that anticipated today's crisis and charted a path out of it. That includes the Senate's landmark report, “Out of the shadows at last”, federal investments in collaborative care, and drug treatment courts, as well as the “At Home/Chez Soi” trials, the world's largest randomized trials on homelessness, addiction and public safety. In the trials in Vancouver, recovery-oriented housing cut criminal convictions by 71% and halved the medical emergencies at no greater cost than leaving people homeless.

B.C. has been in a declared public health emergency over drug poisoning for a decade, and more than 18,000 British Columbians have died. There are only two ways out of any public health crisis: stop new cases and treat existing ones. B.C. should by now lead the world in both. Instead, the province adopted policies that were predicted to escalate harm, and harm to public safety, encampments, businesses, families and indigenous communities escalated.

In my view, this happened because the lessons Canadians had already paid for were set aside and because policy was made without adequate safeguards against conflicts of interest. I will offer four examples, each with a question.

First, in 2020, a year after B.C.'s provincial health officer called for decriminalization and safe supply, four of the policy's most prominent proponents announced companies in the same field: a former provincial health officer, a former executive director of the BC Centre for Disease Control, and two leaders of B.C.'s HIV/AIDS research community. The former executive director's company dispensed opioids from vending machines and received at least $4.5 million in federal funding. I am not alleging that any of this was illegal. That's the problem. What federal rules govern senior officials who shape a policy and then build businesses around it?

Second, these policies were never meaningfully evaluated. B.C.'s Auditor General found deficiencies in target setting, evaluation and public reporting on prescribed safer supply. One week after I briefed senior B.C. officials on federally funded research on recovery, the province ordered my university to destroy our entire research database, including data for an approved and funded study of drug-related deaths. Why was the evidence that could have evaluated these policies destroyed rather than used?

Third, federal granting agencies have provided millions of dollars to the BC Centre on Substance Use, the leading academic advocate of safe supply. The centre also receives pharmaceutical industry funding, and the amounts are not publicly disclosed. Should Canadians not know who funds the research that shapes their drug policy?

Fourth, researchers affiliated with that same centre designed an evaluation of the Drug User Liberation Front, the operators of which have since been found guilty of drug trafficking. On July 29, 2022, Health Canada wrote to refuse DULF's exemption request and warned that the model would violate federal law. According to the researchers' own publications, data collection began four days later. When DULF later challenged the federal government under the charter, the judge noted, “Of marked significance, the Crown called no evidence, expert or otherwise, to challenge any of the evidence called by the applicants”. What oversight applies when publicly funded research proceeds after a federal refusal, and why did the Crown call no evidence?

Ending this crisis requires a federal vision of prevention and recovery with meaningful metrics to evaluate progress. It requires mandatory disclosure of pharmaceutical payments to researchers, clinicians and patient groups; conflict of interest rules that cover the move from public office to private enterprise; federally funded research that complies with federal law; and a Crown that defends the public interest in court. It requires the community-based, recovery-oriented care that was promised as a replacement for institutions, care that serves patients and communities together rather than pitting them against one another.

Thank you.

The Chair Liberal Sukh Dhaliwal

Thank you very much. That was perfect timing.

Now we will go to the Métis Nation.

Between the two of you, you have five minutes. Please go ahead.

Brennan Merasty Minister of Self Determination and Self Government, Métis Nation-Saskatchewan

Thank you, Mr. Chair.

Good evening, ladies and gentlemen. Thank you for this opportunity to speak with all of you today.

My name is Brendan Merasty. I'm the minister responsible for self-government, self-determination and justice, as well as a regional representative for northern region 3 with the Métis Nation-Saskatchewan.

I want to start by saying that institutional concepts will not heal our people. It is discovering our spirit through identity, culture, values and language that will carry us forward. It will ground us. It will give us the balance we need in everyday life and, more importantly, a connection with purpose. Then we can say:

[Witness spoke in Michif and provided the following text:]

Kay nantaw itihta.

[English]

It means, “Don't worry.”

Over 25 years, I lived through and learned from the impacts of intergenerational trauma, addiction, abuse, bullying and disconnection. I bring my lived experience to this space and this conversation grounded in community and identity connected to culture and a responsibility to lift others as I move forward.

Métis Nation-Saskatchewan proudly represents section 35 rights-holding Métis citizens across the province, advancing our rights, strengthening our communities and preserving our culture, language and traditions for generations to come.

On August 19, 2025, our provincial Métis council declared a state of emergency on drugs, gangs and violence, and alcohol across the Métis homeland within Saskatchewan. The resolution recognizes that these interconnected issues are affecting Métis communities throughout Saskatchewan, with particularly urgent pressures identified in our northern and eastern regions.

This declaration was not symbolic. It was a recognition that what we are experiencing cannot be addressed by one ministry, one government or one intervention. Addiction, mental health, homelessness, violence, involvement with the justice system and family instability are interconnected.

We have been reaction-based to date. Our response must be deeply rooted, connected and with purpose. This is not simply an addictions emergency. It is a community safety, health, housing, justice and family emergency. It is about reshaping our future.

Part of our response is recognizing that addiction intersects with gangs, violence and community safety, which creates that chaos, so the objective is not enforcement alone. The goal is to change outcomes and empower and create a pathway where people can self-reflect to take ownership, rather than becoming another statistic.

With that, I'll hand it over to my colleague, Minister Fullerton.

Beverly Fullerton-Trotchie Minister of Health, Mental Health and Addictions, Métis Nation-Saskatchewan

Thank you, Minister Merasty, and thank you, Chair, for this opportunity.

As mentioned, my name is Beverly Fullerton. I am the Minister of Health, Mental Health and Addictions, and regional director for western region 2A.

I am a Métis woman, a mother of seven and a kokum to two grandsons. I sit before you with 14 years in recovery. Before I held this title, I lived through abuse, foster care, gangs, addiction and incarceration. Today, I carry those experiences into my responsibility to advocate for our citizens and for Canada. The woman I was then deserved safety and care just as much as the minister sitting before you today.

Saskatchewan continues to experience serious drug toxicity harms. As of October 1, the Saskatchewan coroner's service figures showed 193 confirmed and suspected drug toxicity deaths from January through December. Saskatoon has had over 2,500 emergency calls, and we know these numbers are greatly skewed towards members of our community.

Our response is grounded in full continuum prevention, intervention, treatment, recovery, housing, reintegration and community safety. Our first step is meeting people where they are.

We have programs that meet people where they are: We respond with a low-barrier response to overdose crises. Our program, Wiichihew Li Moond mobile outreach, includes 28,006 people supported, 1,500 naloxone kits distributed, 903 housing connections, 390 health care reconnections and over 12,000 transports to shelter, medical and addiction services.

The work that connects people to safety and care creates opportunities to intervene before a situation becomes an emergency room visit, an arrest or a death, but piecemeal programs that depend on short-term funding agreements cannot provide the continuity our citizens need. This is also why we are advancing a Métis-distinct, land-based recovery lodge near Batoche, in our homeland. Current planning provides for 60 spaces: 10 for medically supported withdrawal management and stabilization, and 50 for structured 90-day inpatient treatment.

The model brings together clinical and traditional land-based healing, family involvement and structured aftercare. For me, that connection matters. We are supporting a person who needs somewhere to belong, relationships they can trust and the opportunity to build a life beyond addiction.

Métis Nation-Saskatchewan's state of emergency is a call to partnership and action. Saskatchewan needs a connected response that takes someone from crisis to safety, treatment, housing and recovery and supports their connection to a family and community.

We sit before you as lived experience. We have been through the trenches.

Thank you.

6 p.m.

Liberal

The Chair Liberal Sukh Dhaliwal

Thank you very much.

We can go directly now, to save time, to Mr. Bailey.

You have six minutes. Please go ahead.

6 p.m.

Conservative

Burton Bailey Conservative Red Deer, AB

Thank you, Chair.

Dr. Somers, I'm going to ask you a couple of yes-or-no questions, because my time is so limited and you gave us such a great description to start us off. I'd like to welcome you back to committee.

Other than a hospital setting, where strict prescriptions and monitoring are present, is the personal consumption of fentanyl safe, yes or no?

6 p.m.

Clinical Psychologist and Full Professor, As an Individual

6 p.m.

Conservative

Burton Bailey Conservative Red Deer, AB

Do you think the decriminalization of hard drugs is a mistake, yes or no?

6 p.m.

Clinical Psychologist and Full Professor, As an Individual

6 p.m.

Conservative

Burton Bailey Conservative Red Deer, AB

Thank you.

You're familiar with the Alberta model. We've been setting a standard for recovery for people suffering from addiction. The first question I have for you is, if we were to bring this into other provinces, such as B.C., what number of recovery beds would be needed?

I'll help you a bit. Alberta has 10,000.

6 p.m.

Clinical Psychologist and Full Professor, As an Individual

Dr. Julian M. Somers

I've worked in Alberta on the design and implementation of the recovery model. I would estimate—I haven't calculated this—that it would be at least comparable for that one component, and you're talking about one component.

6 p.m.

Conservative

Burton Bailey Conservative Red Deer, AB

The other question I have for you is this. Beyond the study findings of no significant change in hospitalizations or toxic drug deaths, what other public health, criminal justice or social indicators changed in B.C. after decriminalization?

6 p.m.

Clinical Psychologist and Full Professor, As an Individual

Dr. Julian M. Somers

It took about a year before municipalities took the province to court, requesting that stipulations be put in place to curtail open drug use in parks, in playgrounds and on transit. Eventually, we saw drug use in hospitals. The immediate aftermath was striking, visible and alarming. The province has been determined to have been negligent in its own evaluation of those policies. This is from the B.C. auditor general.

We've been relying mostly on the evidence of our senses and the evidence we can see in our streets, and it has been terrible.

6 p.m.

Conservative

Burton Bailey Conservative Red Deer, AB

First of all, I want to thank you for your work in Alberta. I'm very proud of what our province is doing to help people recover and not enable.

I'd like to talk a bit about a study that Dr. Nathaniel Day did in the Centre of Recovery Excellence. Are you familiar with this study?

October 21st, 2026 / 6 p.m.

Clinical Psychologist and Full Professor, As an Individual