Evidence of meeting #52 for Industry and Technology in the 45th Parliament, 1st session. (The original version is on Parliament’s site, as are the minutes.) The winning word was framework.

A recording is available from Parliament.

On the agenda

Members speaking

Before the committee

Plourde  Lawyer and Analyst, Option consommateurs
D. Rosborough  President, Canadian Repair Coalition (CanRepair)
Willshire  Regional Vice-President, Canada, LKQ Corporation
Threadgill  Vice-President, Head of North American Government Affairs, LKQ Corporation
Moreau  Managing Director, Association of Home Appliance Manufacturers
Dorais  Co-Executive Director, Union des consommateurs
Courchesne  Lawyer, Analyst, Consumer Protection Policy and Regulation, Union des consommateurs
Centivany  Associate Professor, Faculty of Information and Media Studies, Western University, As an Individual

4:10 p.m.

Lawyer and Analyst, Option consommateurs

Alexandre Plourde

If this bill is adopted in its current form, it will not change a single thing for the time being, because all the bill says is that a consumer protection framework to promote repairability and durability will be adopted at some point. As such, it depends on what measures the government will determine and include in the framework after the bill is adopted. That is when we will see if it makes a big difference for consumers in Quebec or not. We're still in the dark on this.

4:10 p.m.

Conservative

Harb Gill Conservative Windsor West, ON

What I'm hearing is that it doesn't have any teeth. What type of enforcement action would you recommend as an amendment to this bill?

4:10 p.m.

Lawyer and Analyst, Option consommateurs

Alexandre Plourde

I think that any framework that is adopted or any measure that is selected for inclusion in this bill needs to come with significant penalties. There has been a lot of discussion about the standards adopted in Quebec in recent years. One thing that has flown a little under the radar is that the Consumer Protection Act, which sets out all these new durability standards, has been strengthened with penalties. Now, failure to comply with the Consumer Protection Act is very expensive: up to 5% of worldwide turnover. As such, if this act or the repair and durability framework is to apply to large multinational corporations that import products to Canada, whether electronic devices, household appliances or cars, it must be able to deter and force them to comply with this framework, and there needs to be significant penalties.

4:15 p.m.

Conservative

Harb Gill Conservative Windsor West, ON

Thank you for being candid with me.

Mr. Threadgill, I have a question for you.

Modern vehicles are increasingly computers on wheels, yet they have been left out of this bill. Vehicles depend on electronic components, specialized diagnostic tools and software. Why shouldn't the same principles of durability, repairability and access to replacement parts apply to automobiles as they do to household appliances?

The second question I have for you is with respect to the issue of sovereignty and security. You brought that up. If you're going to allow Chinese EVs into the country, which have been referred to as spies on wheels by other western countries.... I'm glad to see that you're seeking amendments to this legislation that demand access to operating software for such vehicles. What Canadians need to know is whether they are being spied on. It shouldn't be a case of “trust us.” We need to verify.

Can you also talk a little bit about the cost for consumers if a qualified mechanic is not able to access such tools and software?

I know it's a long question.

Are you with us, Mr. Threadgill?

October 22nd, 2026 / 4:15 p.m.

Vice-President, Head of North American Government Affairs, LKQ Corporation

Tyler Threadgill

Yes. I'm sorry about that.

It kicked me out and I just returned, so I didn't get your question.

4:15 p.m.

Conservative

Harb Gill Conservative Windsor West, ON

Shall I start from the beginning, sir?

4:15 p.m.

Vice-President, Head of North American Government Affairs, LKQ Corporation

Tyler Threadgill

Yes, please. I apologize.

The Chair Liberal Ben Carr

Go ahead, Mr. Gill.

4:15 p.m.

Conservative

Harb Gill Conservative Windsor West, ON

Thank you, sir.

Mr. Threadgill, modern vehicles are increasingly computers on wheels, yet they have been left out of this bill. Vehicles depend on electronic components, specialized tools and software. The same principles of durability, repairability and access to replacement parts should apply to automobiles as they do to the household appliances in this bill.

With respect to the issue of sovereignty and security, if you're going to allow Chinese EVs into the country, which have been referred to as spies on wheels by other western nations, should we be seeking amendments in this legislation that demand access to that operating software on these vehicles? Canadians need to know they're not being spied on. It shouldn't be a case of “trust us.” We need to verify it.

Can you also talk about the cost of repairs if an independent mechanic is not able to access such software and the consumer is forced to go to a dealership?

4:15 p.m.

Vice-President, Head of North American Government Affairs, LKQ Corporation

Tyler Threadgill

Absolutely. Thank you for the question.

You are exactly correct. Cars are becoming increasingly smarter. They are tracking more and more of what you do, how fast you go, where you go and how much you weigh. All of this information is being stored [Technical difficulty—Editor] some in the cloud.

We believe [Technical difficulty—Editor] and what we've been [Technical difficulty—Editor] independent repair shops across the country is access to just the repair and maintenance data. For decades—more like a century—car companies have provided access to the information that is needed just for repair, maintenance and calibration, those simple things, and they have walled off all of the other information.

For years, if you go back to when CASIS was created, and you think of plugging in your old iPhone to download music or upload your pictures, it functioned the same way in the car. Now that is done telematically. That is where we need legislation to keep up with the current state of cars, because unfortunately, they are able to lock out the mechanics.

To the end part of your question, what happens is that if you only have the choice of going back to the manufacturer service location, the price goes up, as with anything. As you have less choice, the price goes up. We have seen, in some cases, increases ranging from 20% to 40%, depending on the study and whether that is just access to parts or whether it's access to data as well.

Think of things as simple as replacing tires. It's mandated in many provinces that you change your tires to winter tires. Those tires have sensors. It may be simple for a mechanic to take off the tires, change them and replace them, but if those sensors aren't calibrated, the car won't work. That takes what should be a very quick, affordable repair and turns it into something that takes an exceptional amount of time and requires a far greater cost.

The Chair Liberal Ben Carr

Thank you, Mr. Gill.

Colleagues, I have a quick note that we're tracking about eight or nine minutes late here as a result of some of these technical difficulties.

I'm going to give the floor to Mr. Ntumba for his regularly scheduled five minutes, but then I'm going to cut down the time on the remaining three. I will let you folks know what that will look like.

Mr. Ntumba, you have the floor for five minutes.

Bienvenu-Olivier Ntumba Liberal Mont-Saint-Bruno—L’Acadie, QC

Thank you, Mr. Chair.

Mr. Plourde. How are you?

4:20 p.m.

Lawyer and Analyst, Option consommateurs

Alexandre Plourde

I'm doing well.

Bienvenu-Olivier Ntumba Liberal Mont-Saint-Bruno—L’Acadie, QC

I listened to your opening remarks. I understand your interest in adding the automotive sector. One of your colleagues has defended the bill as announced and said that it was really a baseline that would leave it up to the provinces to ensure the rest. Some of the work has been done by Quebec, which has made some strides on this. What do you think of an approach where a baseline is set and the provinces are left to do the rest?

4:20 p.m.

Lawyer and Analyst, Option consommateurs

Alexandre Plourde

We think that that can be quite a positive approach. It is somewhat what we are proposing, that is, the federal government may have a role to play in terms of repairability and durability by setting minimum standards. If the provinces can improve on this framework, that's perfect for us.

There are all kinds of federal jurisdictions that may be relevant to the right to repair. I spoke about criminal law. For example, one might want to criminalize planned obsolescence. It could be a criminal act. Interprovincial trade, copyright, and product health and safety often fall under federal jurisdiction, or, at least, they have a dual aspect.

Thus, the federal government may have a role to play. The federal government can also have a kind of coordinating role. Many of the products we buy, such as electronics, household appliances or cars, are imported, or the same products are sold across Canada. As such, it can be helpful to have a certain standardized framework across all the provinces. This can be quite a relevant approach.

Bienvenu-Olivier Ntumba Liberal Mont-Saint-Bruno—L’Acadie, QC

In your answer, I've heard a sub-question that brings me to Canada's approach to interprovincial trade. It will take me a bit off topic. You're telling me that we should really accelerate and harmonize this trade and lift interprovincial trade barriers. Is that right?

4:20 p.m.

Lawyer and Analyst, Option consommateurs

Alexandre Plourde

No.

What I'm saying is that the federal government—I don't want to get into constitutional law—has jurisdiction over interprovincial trade. As such, that can be part of the jurisdictions that are used in establishing a right to repair.

Bienvenu-Olivier Ntumba Liberal Mont-Saint-Bruno—L’Acadie, QC

Families complain a lot about household products that need to be repaired, such as washers, dryers, irons, phone chargers and computer screens. These products, which are easily accessible, can be purchased by young and old. Do you think people believe that it is absolutely necessary to have their vehicle repaired before having their computer or dryer at home repaired by a local repairer, if they break?

4:20 p.m.

Lawyer and Analyst, Option consommateurs

Alexandre Plourde

I think we need to develop a repair reflex in consumers. There's an aspect of consumer accountability or awareness in all this. We talk to a lot of consumers. I can tell you that the most common problem we see is people who have a broken washer or car. Often, people don't always have the reflex to have their device or appliance repaired. They want a new one. They don't necessarily trust a repaired item. Therefore, awareness-raising work needs to be done on that front.

Before placing the responsibility on consumers, before encouraging them to have their item repaired, they need to have repair options. For example, if I want to have my broken washer repaired, it can be very difficult to find a repair person in a timely manner or to find the parts and all that. Therefore, a framework needs to be created to give consumers who choose to repair access to this option before looking to raise awareness. Currently, it can be quite a challenge to have one's devices or appliances repaired.

Bienvenu-Olivier Ntumba Liberal Mont-Saint-Bruno—L’Acadie, QC

Is this framework in the bill? It's a baseline, and it's up to the provinces to do the rest.

4:20 p.m.

Lawyer and Analyst, Option consommateurs

Alexandre Plourde

As I was saying, the issue at the moment is that we don't yet know what is in it. Maybe we're going to have a very interesting framework that's going to come out of this whole legislative and regulatory process, or maybe we're going to be disappointed in the end.

Unfortunately, we would have liked the bill to be more concrete. This would have given us the opportunity to comment on how it will concretely change things for consumers.

Bienvenu-Olivier Ntumba Liberal Mont-Saint-Bruno—L’Acadie, QC

What would you add to this bill, concretely?

4:20 p.m.

Lawyer and Analyst, Option consommateurs

Alexandre Plourde

As I was saying, there is a matter of the availability of parts. In Quebec, there's a law about the availability of parts and all that, but it's optional. For example, if you buy something in a store in Montreal, there's often a sign at the entrance, near the checkout, that says that they don't supply spare parts or a repair service. Once a store puts up that sign in Quebec, it no longer needs to supply spare parts. We would like this to be mandatory, and we believe that the federal government could impose this requirement on manufacturers.

There is also the availability of updates. People may have devices that are connected to the Internet in their homes that stop working overnight. Physically, the device works, but, since the onboard software is no longer updated, the item can no longer be used. It's a matter of obsolescence that could be resolved within the federal framework.

Finally, as I mentioned, there is the design of devices. Take the example of a battery in a cellphone or other purchased product, which can only be replaced by removing it with special tools. The design of the devices should make them more easily repairable and interoperable.

These are the kind of standards that we would have liked to see concretely in the bill today.

Bienvenu-Olivier Ntumba Liberal Mont-Saint-Bruno—L’Acadie, QC

Thank you, Mr. Plourde.

4:25 p.m.

Lawyer and Analyst, Option consommateurs

Alexandre Plourde

My pleasure.