Evidence of meeting #53 for Industry and Technology in the 45th Parliament, 1st session. (The original version is on Parliament’s site, as are the minutes.) The winning word was product.

A recording is available from Parliament.

On the agenda

Members speaking

Before the committee

Chung  President and Chief Executive Officer, Automotive Industries Association of Canada
Denoncourt  Analyst in source reduction, Équiterre
Hatch  Chief Executive Officer, Electronic Products Association Canada
Holtby  Vice-President, Government Relations, Automotive Industries Association of Canada
Bester  Executive Director, Canadian Anti-Monopoly Project
Abar  President, Microland
Chu Cheng  Executive Director, Repair Café Toronto

11:35 a.m.

Conservative

Leslyn Lewis Conservative Haldimand—Norfolk, ON

Thank you.

I'm going to follow up on a question that Mr. Barsalou-Duval mentioned about durability standards, and you also spoke about the mandatory display of the sustainability index. How would this display be implemented? Is it on a product sticker? What is the ultimate purpose? Is the information so that penalties could be imposed on manufacturers? For example, if a manufacturer has a sustainability index indicator that is wrong, what is the outcome? Is there a penalty?

Also, how does it impact consumers? Will consumers be prevented from repurchasing an item if the durability, for example, is a date in the future? Will they be prevented from purchasing that item before the expiration? Can you explain that and the intention behind that?

11:35 a.m.

Analyst in source reduction, Équiterre

Julie-Christine Denoncourt

The intention behind this rating is really to provide consumers with more information when purchasing an appliance.

As for the first part of your question on how to implement it, in France it is displayed at the point of purchase online and in-store. Next to the price, there is a fairly prominent and large rating, or a score from 1 to 10 with a colour-coded scale from red to green. It's quite easy to understand at a glance. If you see a three in red, you know the product may not be of the highest quality. The score is also quite visible online and is displayed next to the price and the product specifications. So we could easily do the same thing here and display it online or on a label in-store.

Would it be a score from 1 to 10 or from A to E? It doesn't matter. We could see what resonates most with consumers here, but the literature shows that a colour-coded system and a score of this kind is easy to understand.

As for penalties, I would say that it is more a case of penalties being imposed if a retailer or manufacturer fails to display the rating, because this display is mandatory. There are penalties for failure to meet this requirement.

Furthermore, what we have seen in France is that this has had very tangible results in terms of product repairability and the availability of more repairable products. It has also created competition among manufacturers. Indeed, some have even changed their practices to achieve a better rating and to achieve a change in colour—for example, moving from yellow to green to make their products more appealing to consumers.

I don't want to spend too much time on this, but some great reports on this subject are available and demonstrate the tangible effects of the index for manufacturers and product design and for consumers.

The Chair Liberal Ben Carr

Unfortunately, Ms. Lewis, that's all the time we have. Thanks very much.

Ms. O'Rourke, floor is yours for five minutes.

Dominique O'Rourke Liberal Guelph, ON

Thank you, Chair.

I'd like to start by drawing a distinction between the legislation in Quebec, which was a government bill presented, I'm assuming, after robust consultation with manufacturers and les parties prenantes, as it were, whereas this is a private member's bill, where the proponent of the bill, the mover of the bill, specified both in the bill itself and here at committee that this really is for electronic products and essential home and office appliances. I think there's value in respecting the scope of that and also in being aware that a lot of the consultation that would otherwise take place on a government bill has not taken place for this PMB.

I'd like to ask Ms. Hatch this. You're the second witness who talked about consulting the manufacturing sector in the development of the framework. No one is opposing the development of a framework.

Ms. Hatch, I'm just wondering, I'm very willing to include a broader consultation to include manufacturers and repair shops. Who else do you think needs to be consulted?

11:40 a.m.

Chief Executive Officer, Electronic Products Association Canada

Meagan Hatch

It's the technical experts—the engineers who are the experts and know the international standards on these issues.

Dominique O'Rourke Liberal Guelph, ON

Okay.

We also had a representative who was telling us about some of the safety challenges. Is that why it would be important to include those technical experts?

11:40 a.m.

Chief Executive Officer, Electronic Products Association Canada

Meagan Hatch

It's for safety, cybersecurity and privacy. If you're dealing with a cellphone or a computer, there's a lot of personal information on there, and we need to make sure that we're talking to the right experts.

I also think that we need to have some look at the actual economic impacts of some of these decisions. Quebec's prescribed warranty periods ranged from three to six years, depending on the product. For our sector, this included cellphones, computers and televisions. We recommend assessing the actual effects of the prices, the product availability and the repair outcomes that come from these measures that were just implemented earlier this month.

The EU established a minimum only two-year legal guarantee, and coverage differs in terms of remedies. You can't just compare one jurisdiction to the other, so I think a little bit more research here is necessary.

Dominique O'Rourke Liberal Guelph, ON

Switching gears, I do think we're in a “both and” situation. I think we can move forward on a framework for home and office appliances and electronics, and also look separately at addressing some of the very valid concerns that have been raised by the independent repair shops.

I chair the auto caucus, care a lot about auto parts and know a lot about the sector. I would like to see strong independent repair shops, access to information, the tools and all of that, both for the viability of the ecosystem and also for affordability for our consumers. The Canadian Automobile Dealers Association has pegged that shortage of technicians at 3,000 available jobs in Ontario alone. This is a really critical issue. The Canadian Automobile Dealers Association is actually asking the government to allow temporary foreign workers to fill those positions, at least while they train up domestically. It would be helpful to have some support across the aisle on that as well, which has not been given to date.

I'm curious. You've mentioned that CASIS is not working. What would a better framework look like?

11:45 a.m.

President and Chief Executive Officer, Automotive Industries Association of Canada

Emily Chung

A voluntary framework, in essence, does not work. As I mentioned, it is an MOU at best. If you want to have a voluntary framework working better, to me that means more accountability and very real consequences for those who choose to continue not to comply. There are many who do comply and it's voluntary. To have some accountability in a voluntary framework, to me, would be legislation, at the end of the day.

It is really about setting the standard across the board as to what the expectation is for the information that we are given, and then also to have some serious consequences for those who continue to ignore it or don't participate. We have new entrants coming into the market, potentially. They are not covered by the voluntary framework either. That's what we are looking for in terms of bolstering.... When we talk about strengthening CASIS, it is really legislation we're talking about.

Dominique O'Rourke Liberal Guelph, ON

I appreciate that.

I would just close out with a quick comment around the reference to a John Deere tractor. That would require consultation with the equipment manufacturers. There's a lot of intellectual property there. There's a lot of data there. I think we're asking this private member's bill to do a lot of heavy lifting without the appropriate broader consultation with the manufacturers.

It's a great initiative. I think definitely we want affordability, repairability and durability for consumers in their homes and offices. The broader stuff was absolutely worth taking a look at and strengthening for consumers, but I think we need to do it properly.

The Chair Liberal Ben Carr

Thank you very much, Ms. O'Rourke.

Mr. Barsalou‑Duval, you have the floor for two and a half minutes.

Xavier Barsalou-Duval Bloc Pierre-Boucher—Les Patriotes—Verchères, QC

Thank you, Mr. Chair.

Once again, I have to disagree with my colleague's remarks. She said that further consultations would be needed, but, to my knowledge, the very purpose of this bill is to consult with industry to establish a framework.

Perhaps you could explain something to me, Ms. Chung. As it stands, the bill lacks teeth. If it were passed tomorrow morning, it would make no difference to the lives of just about anyone. It would simply mean that the government would consult with industry to arrive at a regulatory—and potentially legislative—framework that would enforce better repairability. However, it doesn't impose any standard or decisions.

So why shouldn't the auto industry be included in consultations to develop this framework?

11:45 a.m.

Vice-President, Government Relations, Automotive Industries Association of Canada

Emily Holtby

That is the challenge with the bill. Going back to our primary amendment, if you really want to look at the content of this bill and the heart of it, which is around consumer affordability, it has to be more inclusive of other industries. It can't just be narrow toward consumer electronics and home appliances, especially when something like a vehicle is the most expensive thing next to your house, like I've said on record. That's why we see this opportunity as the pathway and another building block connecting to eventual right to repair principles in action at both the federal and provincial levels.

Xavier Barsalou-Duval Bloc Pierre-Boucher—Les Patriotes—Verchères, QC

Along the same lines, some colleagues have mentioned that the federal government should not interfere in provincial matters. I, for one, would probably be the last person to say that the federal government should intervene in our affairs.

Nevertheless, the federal government can also intervene in its own affairs. However, to my knowledge, the Copyright Act is not a federal law. To my knowledge, the patent system is not a federal matter either.

Would it not therefore be appropriate for the federal government to take an interest in all matters relating to patents and copyright to regulate them in a way that addresses what the provinces are currently unable to regulate?

11:45 a.m.

Vice-President, Government Relations, Automotive Industries Association of Canada

Emily Holtby

That's exactly right.

The federal government has a crucial role to play. It's what we've seen in all the jurisdictions around the world that have been successful in achieving this type of legislation, which ultimately serves the consumer. The federal government has such a crucial part when it comes to competition and business support.

Going back to the affordability angle, we find ourselves in such a vulnerable economic state right now with our trade negotiations. Vehicles are going to cost between $1,000 and $8,000 more because of tariffs alone. We need to extend the life cycle of these vehicles. We need our independent repairs to have that fair access—the same access that the dealers currently have—to ensure that the consumer is served. That's where you can see first-hand why the federal government's involvement is so crucial and important. With the consumers, of course, being protected at the provincial level, working together is really a great solution.

Xavier Barsalou-Duval Bloc Pierre-Boucher—Les Patriotes—Verchères, QC

Ms. Denoncourt, do you have anything to say on these points?

The Chair Liberal Ben Carr

Thank you.

Please answer the question briefly.

She might not have heard you, and we're out of time, Monsieur Barsalou-Duval, so I think we might leave that for now.

Ms. Denoncourt, please reply briefly if you've heard the question.

11:50 a.m.

Analyst in source reduction, Équiterre

Julie-Christine Denoncourt

I don't think I heard my name mentioned at the beginning of the question.

What I would say is that it's rather difficult to comment on Bill C‑39. As the standards are not yet known, it would be better, in our view, as I said in my opening remarks, to establish precise and concrete standards straight away and incorporate them into this bill, rather than defer them to a second stage. Several countries have already done so, as I mentioned. Why can't Canada do that right now?

I don't see why we should not do it right now.

The Chair Liberal Ben Carr

Thank you very much.

Colleagues, that's going to bring us to the end of the first panel.

Thank you very much to the witnesses for availing yourselves here today. We appreciate the insight.

Ms. Chung, you may choose to leave your business card with Monsieur Barsalou-Duval to talk more about the Kia and its challenges.

This is exactly the type of conversation that is useful and meaningful for us as parliamentarians under the review of the piece of legislation before us.

Thank you for your time.

I would like to extend my sincere thanks to the witnesses with us online today.

Colleagues, I'm going to suspend briefly.

We're going to come back in seven minutes to start the second round.

The meeting is suspended.

Noon

Liberal

The Chair Liberal Ben Carr

I'll ask everyone to take their seats, please. We're going to continue with our second panel.

I can confirm that all the audiovisual tests have been completed and that everything is in order.

We have new witnesses joining us here in the room, as well as online.

We have with us Keldon Bester, from the Canadian Anti-Monopoly Project. He is the executive officer. We have Wai Chu Cheng, the executive director of Repair Café Toronto. She is joining us online. We also have Matthew Abar from Microland. He is the president and is here in person.

You will each have up to five minutes for your introductory remarks, followed by lines of questioning from the political parties represented here at the table today.

Mr. Bester, we will start with you. You have five minutes.

Keldon Bester Executive Director, Canadian Anti-Monopoly Project

Thank you, Chair, and thank you to the members of the committee for inviting me to speak with you today.

My name is Keldon Bester. I'm the executive director of the Canadian Anti-Monopoly Project. We're a think tank focused on working to build an economy in which markets work for the people who depend on them.

Being able to fix things is a big part of what it means to own something. That's why we support the framework proposed in Bill C-267 as a positive step for repairability in Canada.

Whether we can repair the things we own is not an inevitable or organic outcome. It's the result of business models, design choices and policies that set the guardrails around them. Without strong protection, Canadians can watch their ability to maintain and repair their own products slip away.

That's a problem, because Canadians depend on repair in a number of ways.

It matters to us as consumers in determining whether we get value for money on purchases big and small. It matters to folks like farmers and small business owners, who need control over the tools that they make their livings with. It matters to competition as well: When a manufacturer controls who can fix its products, it holds power over its customers and can shut out independent repair markets that could better serve Canadians.

We're glad to see that Bill C-267 recognizes the value of repair and the need for collaboration across governments to protect it. Provinces have played and continue to play an important role, but the markets we import from and interact with are global in nature. A national framework will help to avoid a patchwork that leaves some Canadians better protected than others.

As you study this bill, we ask you to consider three ways to broaden its scope and move faster to deliver for Canadians.

First, we suggest expanding the bill beyond electronic products and home appliances. Repair matters for products outside the walls of our homes and for people who rely on them for more than just personal use. Vehicles, farm equipment and medical devices all benefit from a strong focus on repairability. For businesses that depend on these devices, a timely repair at a critical moment can determine the fate of an otherwise healthy business.

Second, we encourage you to consider the businesses and organizations that make repair possible across this country. Most of us, resourceful as we are, rely on someone else to fix something when it breaks. Entire markets exist to meet that demand. The bill's mention of consumer advocacy groups is welcome, but any consultation should include independent repair businesses and regulators that have studied repair policy, such as the Competition Bureau.

Third, we suggest that the framework move quickly to enforceable measures to support repairability in Canada. The initial report of the framework should identify potential legislative or regulatory options, proposed obligations and responsible bodies. We also suggest earlier progress reports to make the process more transparent and accountable to Canadians.

While progress has been made on repair in Canada, more work remains to be done. As one example, there have been recent amendments to the Competition Act, which now addresses refusals to supply parts and to supply the information to diagnose and repair a product. That's an important improvement, but it addresses just one of the barriers to repair in Canada today. What Canada still lacks is a national framework that brings provincial and federal efforts together into a coherent program.

With the right ambition, the national framework of Bill C-267 would be an important step toward a future in which Canadians have more control over the products they rely on. Who gets to fix what, and on what terms, sits at the centre of protecting consumers and guarding against monopoly in our economy.

A national repairability framework built on federal and provincial co-operation is the right approach. Its scope and ambition should match what it could accomplish, which is to give Canadians a say over the products that make their lives easier and support their livelihoods.

Thank you for your time. I look forward to your questions.

The Chair Liberal Ben Carr

Thank you very much.

Mr. Abar, I'll turn to you for five minutes.

Matthew Abar President, Microland

Mr. Chair and members of the committee, thank you for the opportunity to appear on Bill C-267. My name is Matthew Abar. I'm the president of Microland Technical Services.

Microland is an electronics repair depot in Markham, Ontario, and has been repairing electronics since 1994. We're an authorized service partner for dozens of consumer and commercial electronics brands, handling both in-warranty and out-of-warranty repairs.

I feel this puts us in a unique position. We serve Canadian consumers and businesses on behalf of the manufacturers, so we work closely with both and have every reason to keep both satisfied. Microland supports Bill C-267, particularly in its focus on transparency and on access to parts, tools and information. Our hope is that this framework will help to build a strong repair industry and repair culture in Canada by lowering the barriers to repair, not by raising the cost of products.

However, the bill doesn't address where parts and repair services are located, and for electronics, that often decides whether a product gets repaired at all.

On cost, we agree with other witnesses that Canada is an importing market and should avoid product requirements unique to Canada. We wouldn't support measures that raise prices to the point that lower-priced products, which many households depend on, are no longer viable to sell here. Our recommendations are about how products are serviced, not how they're designed or built.

A refrigerator is repaired in a home and a car is repaired at a local garage, but a laptop or cellphone or speaker can be boxed and shipped anywhere. Many brands selling in Canada send Canadian repairs out of the country and ship replacement parts from outside the country as well, usually because they already have a service network elsewhere. The customer waits longer, often pays shipping and brokerage costs, and in many cases decides the repair isn't worth it.

This bill addresses how long parts must be available, but not where.

Canadian repair volumes are also relatively small. For most manufacturers, it isn't economical to have more than one authorized service partner in Canada, so they consolidate into one. That's why a harmonized federal-provincial framework matters so much. There isn't enough volume to justify a different repair and service program in each province, and if the rules diverge, the simplest response for a manufacturer is to centralize service further, often outside Canada. One national standard, developed with the provinces, would give manufacturers a reason to invest in service here.

We recommend three amendments.

First, add a subparagraph to paragraph 3(2)(c) to require manufacturers above a minimum level of Canadian sales to distribute replacement parts and perform warranty repairs within Canada. This isn't a product requirement. Manufacturers can set up their own operation or work with parts distributors and repair depots operating here already.

Second, the “parts, tools and information” in subparagraph 3(2)(c)(ii) should be available to consumers and independent repair businesses on fair and reasonable terms. Manufacturers wouldn't have to share anything beyond what they already provide to their own service partners.

Third, subclause 3(1) should name repair businesses as well as manufacturers among the parties the minister must consult, as other witnesses have requested.

A stronger domestic repair industry means faster, less expensive repairs for Canadians.

Thank you. I look forward to your questions.

The Chair Liberal Ben Carr

Thank you very much, Mr. Abar.

Ms. Cheng, we'll go to you for five minutes.

Wai Chu Cheng Executive Director, Repair Café Toronto

Chair, members of the committee, thank you for inviting me to appear on behalf of Repair Café Toronto.

We are a grassroots community organization made up of volunteers. Since 2013, we have been organizing community events called repair cafés in different neighbourhoods across the city of Toronto. At a repair café, our fixers help community members get their broken household items fixed and show them how to do the repairs themselves for free. We fix what people can carry to our events, so there are no big appliances but, rather, small appliances and home electronics, computers, clothing and textiles, jewellery, bikes and more. In our first 10 years, we diverted over 10,000 items from landfills.

We support Bill C-267. We think it is a good start. We would like to recommend that it go further.

Let me share a few observations that we have made at our events and in our work.

First, at a repair café, we see visitors bring in a variety of appliances and electronic items, and one common reason for the failure of many of these products is that they are made at a low cost with cheaper materials.

Second, our visitors face some common barriers to repair. Many of them lack the confidence to make repairs. Also, repair services are not accessible or affordable. There are relatively few shops around the city. They also find that it's cheaper to buy new items than to get old ones fixed at their local shops. As well, the design of some products is poor, such as those that are impossible to open without breaking them. Our fixers help them learn to repair by explaining how to troubleshoot the problem step by step and do it safely. The goal is to help them develop a fixer mindset.

Third, it is our observation that our community members have a strong desire for repair. At one of the events held last week, we had over 20 fixers, and 150 items were brought in by the visitors. Most of them were fixed.

Repair stimulates in us a sense of curiosity, creativity, collaboration and hope. For the fixer, it's gratifying to overcome a fixing challenge, and it's rewarding to give a new life to an item, especially when it has sentimental value to its owner. We also see more and more young people interested in volunteering as apprentice fixers to learn how to repair. We see an increasing demand for repair cafés in different neighbourhoods. This year, together with our community partners, we are offering a total of 170 events in Toronto. A lot of items have been fixed at our events.

Based on these experiences from our work, we have three recommendations for the bill, as follows.

One, this bill needs to include common small appliances and home electronics, and it should require the manufacturers to provide the product's lifetime and make the parts and repair information available to customers.

Two, we should require manufacturers to provide a repairability score for their products. This would provide helpful information to inform consumers' purchase decisions.

Three, we encourage the promotion of repair education and repair businesses by providing concrete support and incentives, such as tax exemptions, rebates and grants.

I would like to finish by emphasizing the significance of this bill. It's about not only consumer protection but also creating the conditions that foster repair values, behaviour and culture. By promoting repair education, this bill will empower Canadians to take effective action—that is, repairing—to reduce waste and emissions, save money, share skills and build a circular economy. Durable and repairable household items can last for multiple generations. A strong bill can save our planet for future generations to come.

Thank you for your time. I look forward to your questions.