Evidence of meeting #53 for Industry and Technology in the 45th Parliament, 1st session. (The original version is on Parliament’s site, as are the minutes.) The winning word was product.

A recording is available from Parliament.

On the agenda

Members speaking

Before the committee

Chung  President and Chief Executive Officer, Automotive Industries Association of Canada
Denoncourt  Analyst in source reduction, Équiterre
Hatch  Chief Executive Officer, Electronic Products Association Canada
Holtby  Vice-President, Government Relations, Automotive Industries Association of Canada
Bester  Executive Director, Canadian Anti-Monopoly Project
Abar  President, Microland
Chu Cheng  Executive Director, Repair Café Toronto

The Chair Liberal Ben Carr

I call the meeting to order.

Good morning, everyone. I hope you had a good weekend. Unfortunately, the match between the Jets and the Habs didn't go as I expected. They missed by a goal, but we'll not say more about that, Mr. Groleau.

It was a very cool cultural event, I will say, and a nice opportunity in Winnipeg. I'm referring to the Heritage Classic. I suggested that the tone of this committee would be dictated by the result of that game. Unfortunately, the Habs won 2-1. Nonetheless, it was something for the country to celebrate, which is great.

Colleagues, we are continuing our conversation on Bill C-267. I have a couple of things just right off the top.

I am going to ask for consent from the committee to extend the amendment deadline, which had been set for today at four o'clock, and move it to Thursday at four o'clock. We are going to hold a subcommittee meeting in lieu of a full committee meeting on Thursday. If you are not Monsieur Barsalou-Duval, Monsieur Bardeesy, me or Mr. Chambers, there will be no meeting on Thursday.

Gentlemen, I will find some time for us to get together and have a discussion about some subcommittee business.

Effectively, where we're going with all of this, colleagues, is that we will not have a meeting next Thursday either as a result of the budget. That's standard. This Thursday, because there's some more time necessary for amendments to be considered before they make their way here, with no other business on our agenda, we're simply going to use that for the subcommittee meeting.

The first thing I need is consent from the committee to alter the deadline for amendments from today at 4 p.m. to Thursday at 4 p.m.

Seeing no opposition to that, we'll consider that to be the direction from the committee.

Colleagues, you can plan your travel schedules for this Thursday as though there will be no meeting.

With that, we are here today to continue the conversation with witness testimony.

I can confirm that all audiovisual tests have been completed and that everything is in order. We have two witnesses joining us online.

I would like to welcome Mr. Weiler to the Standing Committee on Industry and Technology, who is replacing Mr. Bains today.

Colleagues, joining us from Équiterre is Julie-Christine Denoncourt, analyst in source reduction, who is joining us by video conference. We have here with us, from Automotive Industries Association of Canada, Emily Chung, the president and chief executive officer, and Emily Holtby, who is the vice-president of government relations. Also joining us online, from Electronic Products Association Canada, is Meagan Hatch, who is the chief executive officer.

Witnesses, you will have up to five minutes each. I understand, Ms. Chung, that you'll be speaking on behalf of your organization.

Following that, there will be a line of questioning from members represented by the parties here at the table today.

With that, Ms. Chung, I'm going to turn the floor to you for up to five minutes.

Emily Chung President and Chief Executive Officer, Automotive Industries Association of Canada

Thank you, Mr. Chair.

My name is Emily Chung, and I am the president and CEO of the Automotive Industries Association of Canada. Prior to joining the association, I owned an independent automotive repair shop in Markham for over 16 years, and I am a Red Seal automotive service technician as well.

I am joined today by Emily Holtby, our VP of government relations.

MPs have an opportunity today to amend Bill C-267 to support the automotive repair industry and the millions of Canadians looking for affordable choices and repair options for their vehicles. Amending this bill to add vehicles to its scope is an important step towards more consumer choice and competition in the automotive repair sector.

The spirit of the bill's application, as outlined last week by MP Sari, is to avoid planned obsolescence and make it easier to repair expensive consumer goods. This is no different for a vehicle than it is for your refrigerator, dryer or cellphone. Vehicles are essentially computers on wheels. Modern vehicles use the same chips, touch screens, Bluetooth, Wi-Fi and cellular modems as consumer devices.

If members feel we should have a national framework to promote the durability of electronics and home appliances, why exclude one of the most important and the most expensive consumer products from the bill?

Including vehicles in this bill is a win for affordability and consumer choice. A study by MNP found that drivers save up to 30%, or about $500, on common repairs at independent repair shops. That's money that can be put toward groceries and other household essentials during a cost of living crisis.

Keeping car repair costs low is arguably more important than ever in the face of auto tariffs. Tariffs have added $1,000 to $8,000 to the price of a new vehicle, making it more important to extend the life of vehicles currently on the road. Voluntary frameworks, such as the Canadian Automotive Service Information Standard or CASIS, do not help Canadians with improved durability and repairability and fall short of creating more competition in our economy. I have lived experience as an automotive service technician and shop owner amongst many of my peers in the industry. CASIS has proven over 16 years that a voluntary agreement is essentially an MOU, which is an IOU to the technician and shop owner.

Fixing electronic obsolescence also keeps cars out of scrapyards and landfills, as Bill C-267 aims to do for the consumer goods it applies to. Just as MP Sari described the lack of access to information that appliance repairers face, the same is true for vehicle technicians. These repairs don't require access to secure or sensitive data. They require diagnostic and servicing information, so that we can do our jobs for our customers.

Unfortunately, we have numerous examples of a shop's inability to finish a repair because the information required from manufacturers wasn't provided to them. While Bill C-267 establishes a framework for obtaining this information, it is not sufficient in levelling enforcement or consequences for OEMs that refuse to provide access to repair and servicing data.

As stated in previous testimonies, other provinces and countries have already taken action. If you want to improve Canadians' right to repair electronics and home appliances, then we have to follow the example of other provinces and countries. We must include vehicles in the national legislation.

During the question period, we can explain how other provinces and countries are moving forward while Canada continues to lag behind.

As you have heard from other like-minded groups committed to improving competition, affordability and jobs for Canadians, strong and comprehensive national right to repair legislation must be implemented now. It's time for Canada to join the rest of the world in establishing the right to repair for consumers, businesses and drivers.

Bill C-267 is a step forward and vehicles must be included with enforcement measures implemented to be truly effective. Please amend this bill for more consumer choice, competition and affordability for Canadians.

Thank you. I'm happy to take your questions.

The Chair Liberal Ben Carr

Thank you very much, Ms. Chung.

Ms. Denoncourt, you have the floor for five minutes.

Julie-Christine Denoncourt Analyst in source reduction, Équiterre

Good morning, Mr. Chair and members of the committee. Thank you for giving me this opportunity to appear today.

My name is Julie‑Christine Denoncourt and I'm an analyst in source reduction at Équiterre.

Équiterre is a Quebec-based environmental organization that has been active for over 30 years and has just over 22,000 members. One of our priorities is to accelerate the transition toward a sustainable, circular economy. That's why we have been working on access to product repair and durability for several years.

For example, in 2022, our organization published the first Canada-wide study on access to repairs for home appliances and electronics. The study revealed that appliance breakdowns are common for Canadians, and that 63% had experienced at least one appliance failure in the previous two years, and only 19% of them had their appliances and electronics repaired. The main barriers to repair cited were product design, repair costs and access to replacement parts, tools and repair information. We are therefore pleased to see that a federal bill is attempting to tackle these various barriers.

A second report published by Équiterre in 2024 shows that a durability index could be developed and rolled out in Canada, modelled on and drawing from the model adopted in France. This report included our recommendations for this index's adoption in Canada.

Finally, our latest report on this topic was published in May this year. The report revealed that the durability and repairability of electronic products and home appliances have a significant influence on Canadians' purchasing decisions. It also revealed that Canadians are interested in seeing these characteristics labelled.

Were therefore believe that it is appropriate for the government to address these issues. That is why Équiterre welcomes the overall objective of Bill C‑267 to promote the repairability and durability of electronics and home appliances. However, we would like to point out that we believe the government could, and should, go further, because the bill under consideration has not introduced any concrete measures or requirements, or a timeline for implementing such measures and requirements. In short, we fear that in its current form, Bill C‑267 does not provide a meaningful right to repair or meaningful access to durable products. That is why we recommend adding requirements regarding some of the elements set out in the bill.

First, we recommend including a requirement to make parts, tools, information and software updates available for a reasonable period of time and at a reasonable price. This reasonable period and price could be determined by looking at the practice in other parts of the world or according to the literature. A number of countries have already done so, and so have some U.S. states for certain products. Quebec has also introduced such a requirement, although it is not perfect.

We also recommend prohibiting certain design practices, as Europe has recently done. Examples including bundling parts, matching components and the common practice of welding or gluing together critical components, such as a device's battery. These practices make repairs more expensive and more difficult and, in some cases, impossible.

Finally, based on our recent work on this issue, we recommend that the bill include the mandatory display of a durability index for electronic products and home appliances. The format and criteria could be modelled on what has been developed in France, while including certain improvements. Équiterre strongly recommends an index displaying a rating or score rather than useful life, as mentioned in the bill, because displaying useful life could create more confusion with existing provincial legal warranties, or even worse, could be misunderstood as the minimum lifespan of a product.

In closing, I would note that many of the manufacturers operating in Europe, who are subject to multiple European requirements also operate here, and they are therefore accustomed to these kinds of regulations.

I would be happy to answer your questions. Thank you

The Chair Liberal Ben Carr

Thank you very much, Ms. Denoncourt.

Our final witness joining us online is Ms. Hatch.

I'll turn the floor to you for up to five minutes.

Meagan Hatch Chief Executive Officer, Electronic Products Association Canada

Thank you.

I am Meagan Hatch, chief executive officer of the Electronic Products Association of Canada. We are an industry-led association representing Canada's electronic products sector. Our members produce cellphones, televisions, computers and office equipment. Our purpose is to advocate for a full life-cycle approach to electronic products, promoting policies and regulations that balance environmental sustainability, innovation, consumer protection and manufacturing realities. Our members routinely repair, refurbish and remanufacture products.

Unlike major appliances, farm equipment or autos, smaller electronics can be brought to authorized repair shops or shipped to specialized centres. Canadians have access to independent shops, manufacturer-authorized centres, retail chains and mail-in services. Parts, tools and online guides also support many repairs.

Electronics have an extensive secondary market through hand-me-downs, resale, refurbished products and trade-in programs. Canada also has a robust IT asset disposition—or ITAD—system.

Statistics Canada's consumer price data shows a long-term decline in prices for computing and home entertainment equipment, showing that Canadians have benefited from better technology and greater capacity for their money. Manufacturers offer products at different price points to meet Canadians' needs and budgets.

I would like to highlight four priorities.

First, meaningful industry consultation must be required.

Alongside provincial governments, the bill should require consultation with manufacturers and technical experts. Engineering, safety and cybersecurity expertise is necessary to inform any framework.

Second, the framework must be supported by a cost-benefit analysis.

Canada relies mostly on imported electronics, and any unique Canadian testing, labelling, packaging or design requirements can increase costs and reduce product availability. Replacement parts obligations also carry storage and transportation costs with unused or obsolete inventories creating waste.

As you know, Quebec and Manitoba have already passed laws. These laws are very different. Quebec's new warranty law requires long warranties of up to six years. The actual impact on prices, product availability and repair outcomes in Quebec should be fully assessed and understood before recommending this model to other provinces.

Third, the framework needs a focused scope and clear definitions.

Electronics and major appliances differ in design, useful life and repair networks. Requirements suitable for one category may be impractical for another. Minimum useful life is difficult to predict, because lifespan depends on use, maintenance, misuse or abuse. Making a product easier to repair can sometimes affect its durability. For example, protecting a device from water and damage when dropped can make it harder to take apart. The framework must recognize these engineering trade-offs.

Finally, consumer safety and privacy must be protected.

Health Canada and relevant electrical safety authorities should help develop the framework. Incorrect repairs involving lithium-ion batteries can pose serious risks. Health Canada advises consumers against modifying or repairing devices with batteries unless recommended by the manufacturer. Repair requirements must account for certification, liability and incident reporting obligations. Finally, repairs must also protect a consumer's personal information and keep their devices and connected services secure from cyber-attacks.

Before closing, I want to highlight something important about electronic recycling in Canada. Since 2003, our association has worked with provincial governments to help establish electronic recycling programs across Canada. Today, programs operate in every single province and two territories, providing Canadians with responsible options for managing electronics at end of life.

In 2004, the Alberta Recycling Management Authority launched Canada's first electronics recycling program. Since then, the program has expanded to include more than 500 types of products. Similarly, the recycle my electronics program has diverted more than 1.4 million tonnes of end-of-life electronics from landfill and illegal exports. This work started in 2007 and was the first industry-led program for electronics. It now operates in nine out of 10 provinces.

These provincially regulated programs demonstrate Canada's success in responsibly managing electronics at the end of their useful lives.

Thank you.

The Chair Liberal Ben Carr

Thank you very much, witnesses, for your introductory remarks.

We'll now go to questions.

Mr. Gill, we'll begin with you. You have six minutes, sir.

11:15 a.m.

Conservative

Harb Gill Conservative Windsor West, ON

Thank you, Chair.

Ms. Chung, let me start with a real-world example. You mentioned that independent shops sometimes can't finish the repair because they can't get the information they need from a manufacturer. Can you walk us through that process?

A customer brings their car into the shop. When the repair is finally completed, who ends up paying the price in time and money?

11:15 a.m.

President and Chief Executive Officer, Automotive Industries Association of Canada

Emily Chung

We have many examples. A concrete one would be that a couple of manufacturers a few years ago separated their U.S. and Canadian operations. When that happened, we were all of a sudden unable to access the information. It was not provided to us. One of the manufacturers recently opened that up—two years later—but in terms of the other manufacturer, still to this day you cannot get the information.

What option do I have but to tell the customer, when their car is in my bay and I no longer have access to information, that I'm sorry, but I can't do the work and they need to go to the dealership? If they're in a city like Toronto, where I'm from, a dealership is relatively close by, but I think about the people who live further out. Is it reasonable and fair that now they need to spend the time and money to go to a dealership that's located further away from them?

11:15 a.m.

Conservative

Harb Gill Conservative Windsor West, ON

Let's say a farmer's tractor is stuck in a field. It's a John Deere tractor. If he's 300 miles from a dealership, how is he supposed to repair that tractor stuck in the middle of a field?

11:15 a.m.

President and Chief Executive Officer, Automotive Industries Association of Canada

Emily Chung

It's a good question. In that case, for us, we represent the automotive sector, but we have a very similar case study with somebody in Turtleford, Saskatchewan. The nearest dealership is 75 kilometres away. That's an hour's drive, one way. Is it reasonable to get them to go there for service? That would be the only option, at that point, if the independent repair shop didn't have the information.

11:15 a.m.

Conservative

Harb Gill Conservative Windsor West, ON

It would be very expensive, obviously.

11:15 a.m.

President and Chief Executive Officer, Automotive Industries Association of Canada

Emily Chung

Yes. It's one hour's time.

11:15 a.m.

Conservative

Harb Gill Conservative Windsor West, ON

As well, is the technician even available that day? He might not be available for a week or so.

11:15 a.m.

President and Chief Executive Officer, Automotive Industries Association of Canada

Emily Chung

Exactly.

11:15 a.m.

Conservative

Harb Gill Conservative Windsor West, ON

Can you speak about CASIS, from your experience or from your members' experience, in terms of where it's falling short? When a manufacturer doesn't provide the information a shop needs, what practical remedies do you have? Are there any legally enforceable issues surrounding that in terms of the right to repair?

11:20 a.m.

President and Chief Executive Officer, Automotive Industries Association of Canada

Emily Chung

Currently, the only thing we can do if we have an issue that comes up is to send it through a service information request. Where that goes, we don't know. The website currently says that it commits to a 48-hour turnaround time. As you just heard me say, that was two years in the making.

The issue with CASIS is that it was drafted back in 2009. It doesn't include a lot of the new and modern technologies we have today, such as telematics. Also, because it is voluntary, not all manufacturers are signed on. Even the ones who volunteer to be on it don't have any requirements to provide information. It is challenging because it's non-enforceable. I think the blessing has been that it's been around for 16 years. We've tried it. We know it doesn't work. Now it's time for something else.

11:20 a.m.

Conservative

Harb Gill Conservative Windsor West, ON

Have you or your organization drafted any amendments to seek the enforcement we're talking about?

Emily Holtby Vice-President, Government Relations, Automotive Industries Association of Canada

Yes. Among the amendments we are proposing today, the first one is to ensure that motor vehicles are included under the definition of “electronic products”. In the same way that Emily has said our vehicles are computers on wheels, they're absolutely electronic products now with the software and data that are necessary to repair them. It's ensuring that this is expanded. As well, it's all around guaranteeing access to information and parts and tools, and using the right language for the appropriate time we find ourselves in now with technological access.

Where the bill doesn't go far enough and what we are hoping to propose—again, because of the vague timelines that are set—is the enforcement element. For us, it's so crucial that we have some sort of independent enforcement: that a business can file a complaint directly, and that can then be mediated directly with the manufacturer. That's where the federal government absolutely has a great role to play in enforcing that.

11:20 a.m.

Conservative

Harb Gill Conservative Windsor West, ON

Could you submit to the committee those amendments and any other data or studies that you have, so we could review them before the final decision is made?

Can you speak also about the time it requires to litigate these issues from, say, a small shop owner's perspective? How long does that take? The vehicle's up on the lift. How is he supposed to fix that if he doesn't have the information?

11:20 a.m.

Vice-President, Government Relations, Automotive Industries Association of Canada

Emily Holtby

That's exactly the current problem. There is no way to manage that appropriately. On average, if a shop has to continue to turn away even just one customer a week because they can't service the vehicle, that amounts to $340 million in lost profit nationally when you look at the shops across the country. It's a massive business loss, going back to the affordability angle.

Again, on the enforcement we are proposing, Australia has a very successful law in place. It's been in place for four years. It is a motor vehicle right to repair law. They have an independent enforcement body that manages a complaint directly from the business. Their goal is to always find resolution with the manufacturer within a short time frame so that the individual who wins in the end is the consumer. They don't have to escalate any cases to their version of the Competition Bureau. It's working very well.

11:20 a.m.

Conservative

Harb Gill Conservative Windsor West, ON

Lastly, could you speak to your issues in finding technicians to come into the field, the opportunities therein and how it's impacting the overall economic picture of the country?

11:20 a.m.

President and Chief Executive Officer, Automotive Industries Association of Canada

Emily Chung

One thing I wanted to highlight is that the right to repair is also compounding the issue of the skilled labour shortage. As you can imagine, if I have technicians on staff and I don't have access to information, how do I train them and build the next generation?

The other thing is that even our colleges don't have access to information. The very institutions that are responsible for putting out the apprentices for us are limited as well. The right to repair issue really does tie into the skilled labour shortage issue.

11:20 a.m.

Conservative

Harb Gill Conservative Windsor West, ON

What's the total—

The Chair Liberal Ben Carr

Mr. Gill, unfortunately, that's all the time we have.

Thank you, sir.

Mr. Ntumba, you have the floor for six minutes.