Evidence of meeting #53 for Industry and Technology in the 45th Parliament, 1st session. (The original version is on Parliament’s site, as are the minutes.) The winning word was product.

A recording is available from Parliament.

On the agenda

Members speaking

Before the committee

Chung  President and Chief Executive Officer, Automotive Industries Association of Canada
Denoncourt  Analyst in source reduction, Équiterre
Hatch  Chief Executive Officer, Electronic Products Association Canada
Holtby  Vice-President, Government Relations, Automotive Industries Association of Canada
Bester  Executive Director, Canadian Anti-Monopoly Project
Abar  President, Microland
Chu Cheng  Executive Director, Repair Café Toronto

Bienvenu-Olivier Ntumba Liberal Mont-Saint-Bruno—L’Acadie, QC

Thank you, Mr. Chair.

Good morning, Ms. Chung. In your opening remarks, you explained how other countries are moving forward on this issue.

However, I'm looking at the auto industry and households. These are two different groups. The auto sector is subject to highly specific standards. By contrast, household consumers purchase irons, kettles and phones. The conditions governing the repair of these items are entirely different.

How can we include this industry in the standards on home repairs, which this bill is seeking to establish? The member who introduced the bill said that the measures would be a baseline to enable the provinces move forward in their area of jurisdiction.

11:25 a.m.

Vice-President, Government Relations, Automotive Industries Association of Canada

Emily Holtby

I think that the perfect place to point to for success in ensuring that all industries are included is the Province of Quebec.

At first, when they introduced their amendments to the Consumer Protection Act, they didn't include motor vehicles. Then when the government and opposition really listened to the industry, they understood that if the heart of a bill centred around consumer affordability and consumer accessibility didn't include the second most expensive item, next to a home, for an individual consumer, it would absolutely be a misstep. That's why Quebec did include motor vehicles in the legislation.

That's another issue if we're looking at a federal framework that is going to work with the provinces. It's actually a direct conflict with what we have in Quebec, which is inclusive of motor vehicles.

Bienvenu-Olivier Ntumba Liberal Mont-Saint-Bruno—L’Acadie, QC

I understand your answer.

You mentioned Quebec, which is where I live. Quebec is usually a frontrunner in some areas or bills within its jurisdiction.

However, there is one issue related to the skilled workforce in the auto industry that is still unclear to me. That's why I still believe that the baseline model of standards proposed by the bill would enable the provinces to exceed these requirements within their own jurisdictions.

To ensure the applicability of this bill, don't you think we should start with that before adding provisions that touch on provincial jurisdiction into the bill?

11:25 a.m.

Vice-President, Government Relations, Automotive Industries Association of Canada

Emily Holtby

I think it's important that the federal government absolutely be aligned with the implementation at the provincial level. Where the federal government has such a crucial role to play when it comes to motor vehicles is in that essential enforcement side. We have been watching the implementation of it in Quebec very closely over the last year.

The challenge for us is that these consumer protection laws within the provinces rely on the consumer having to file the complaint directly. When the consumer has already had their vehicle turned away and their services denied and is then told, “Could you also please file this complaint to help the industry?”, that's a barrier, whereas the federal government, because this also extends to competition, has a role to play from an enforcement perspective and from a business perspective, to protect those small to medium-sized businesses within the country.

That's what I would say when it comes to the alignment.

Bienvenu-Olivier Ntumba Liberal Mont-Saint-Bruno—L’Acadie, QC

Thank you very much.

Ms. Denoncourt, in your opening remarks, you spoke about a durability index and posting product characteristics. Could you please expand on that?

11:25 a.m.

Analyst in source reduction, Équiterre

Julie-Christine Denoncourt

Yes, I'd be happy to do that.

In 2021, France expanded its repairability index to nine new product categories, mainly home appliances and electronics. The index was expanded to washing machines and televisions in 2025, if I'm not mistaken. It was converted into a durability index and after some time, it will be converted into a durability index for all the other products.

The index is based on several criteria to assess repairability, including access to documentation, “disassembly”, access to tools, and availability of spare parts. The price of spare parts is also one of the criteria in the repairability index.

The durability index is based on three criteria, namely, repairability, which corresponds to the repairability index based on all the criteria I just mentioned; product reliability, which is assessed through testing; and product upgradeability, for example through software improvements or enhancements to product features.

We have said Canada can draw inspiration from the index in place in France and make certain improvements regarding the criteria that have been developed.

Bienvenu-Olivier Ntumba Liberal Mont-Saint-Bruno—L’Acadie, QC

Indeed, we can draw from that.

I think one can still take a vehicle to a neighbourhood repairer. However, when it comes to washers and driers, which are often thrown out because they can't be repaired, I believe the approach you have suggested can give us a starting point.

Do you have any specific recommendations?

11:25 a.m.

Analyst in source reduction, Équiterre

Julie-Christine Denoncourt

Yes, to include the display of a mandatory durability index for certain categories of electronic products and home appliances, which could be determined at a later stage. We could look at which appliances break down more frequently. We had some data on that in 2022. We could obtain updated data over the coming year. Alternatively, provincial consumer protection offices no doubt have data on the complaints they receive in connection with these appliances. An index could therefore be applied to these appliances as a priority.

The Chair Liberal Ben Carr

Thank you, Mr. Ntumba.

Mr. Barsalou‑Duval, you have the floor for six minutes.

Xavier Barsalou-Duval Bloc Pierre-Boucher—Les Patriotes—Verchères, QC

Thank you, Mr. Chair.

First, welcome to the witnesses joining us today, online and in person.

I would like to start by saying that it's a shame Liberal members are standing up for automakers—at least for the time being, and I'm urging them to get their act together—by opposing the addition of the auto industry to the industries covered by the proposed repairability measures.

I'm not in the habit of drawing on examples from my personal life, but in this case, I think doing so would be in the public interest.

Ms. Chung, have you ever had repairs done to a grille on a Kia EV9?

11:30 a.m.

President and Chief Executive Officer, Automotive Industries Association of Canada

Emily Chung

No, and I'm interested to know where this is going.

Xavier Barsalou-Duval Bloc Pierre-Boucher—Les Patriotes—Verchères, QC

I have a tiny crack on my grille. It's barely one or two inches, if that. I tried to find out how much it would cost to have it repaired. It would cost $10,000. Ten thousand dollars for a grille. This is not about replacing the car or even half the car. It's the grille, a piece that goes between two headlights, which has a tiny crack.

Do you think it's normal for consumers to pay such a price?

11:30 a.m.

President and Chief Executive Officer, Automotive Industries Association of Canada

Emily Chung

Go ahead.

11:30 a.m.

Vice-President, Government Relations, Automotive Industries Association of Canada

Emily Holtby

I was just going to say that if you're looking for the affordability comparison, MNP released a report earlier this year that proves, for the first time in Canada—and we have the data to show it—that you, as an individual, will save up to 30% if you visit your independent repairer versus having to go to your local dealership. That cost will only rise, depending on how complex your labour is, and then, certainly, when you introduce aftermarket parts. That just shows you how crucial and important it is to have that healthy competition.

There are 24,000 independent shops across the country, on both the collision side and the mechanical side, and there are only 3,500 dealerships. We desperately need these independent repairers in a country like Canada, where we have people living in various ridings, rural and remote, to ensure that affordability is protected for the consumer.

Xavier Barsalou-Duval Bloc Pierre-Boucher—Les Patriotes—Verchères, QC

Do you think this case is a clear illustration of the fact that when there's a monopoly and dealerships are left to control everything without government oversight to ensure independent repairers can provide service, prices for consumers skyrocket and people are outright ripped off?

I can tell you I'm not going to change my grille.

11:30 a.m.

President and Chief Executive Officer, Automotive Industries Association of Canada

Emily Chung

Exactly. Again, we're not asking for keys to the kingdom. We don't want the proprietary software. We want the information to be able to diagnose and fix these vehicles.

Again, just as a reminder, I have my Red Seal. I'm 310S. I have the same credentials as those in the dealership. Truthfully, if a dealership technician left the dealer, they would not have access to that information the next day. Are they less qualified? Do they have lesser credentials? No. It's simply by choice of where they work right now. This is why it's key for us to be included in something like this.

October 27th, 2026 / 11:30 a.m.

Vice-President, Government Relations, Automotive Industries Association of Canada

Emily Holtby

To add to the enforcement side, this is why it's crucial to have the enforcement. We are pointing to all these jurisdictions around the world that have recognized this and have advanced, like the EU, Australia and South Africa, because of that monopoly that the repairer on the OE side is trying to control.

Going back to what Emily was saying, that independent repairer can deliver the exact same type of quality repair that the dealership does. That's why it's important that we have the enforcement in place. If the manufacturers are resistant to enforcement, we would ask why. If it is working and if it is totally transparent, it should be no problem for them to participate in some sort of strong enforcement regime.

Xavier Barsalou-Duval Bloc Pierre-Boucher—Les Patriotes—Verchères, QC

Thank you.

How much time do I have left, Mr. Chair?

The Chair Liberal Ben Carr

You have two minutes.

Xavier Barsalou-Duval Bloc Pierre-Boucher—Les Patriotes—Verchères, QC

Okay.

My next question is for Ms. Julie‑Christine Denoncourt, from Équiterre.

Earlier, you said it would be important to develop a durability index. You're not the first person to say that. Other witnesses have expressed similar sentiments.

My question for you might be a trick question. Who, in government, would be responsible for establishing such an index, given that the government has decided to close the Office of Consumer Affairs? I'd like to know whether the implementation of an index should be done by this agency, and if so, shouldn't its funding be restored?

11:35 a.m.

Analyst in source reduction, Équiterre

Julie-Christine Denoncourt

I think there are other groups that specialize in developing standards. I believe Quebec has the Bureau de normalisation du Québec, and at the federal level, there is the CSA Group, if I'm not mistaken, or the Canadian Standards Association. My apologies if I have the names wrong. In short, there are bodies that could develop these standards. As I said earlier, we could also draw on what has been done in France and use that as a starting point, and this could facilitate the work of these groups.

Xavier Barsalou-Duval Bloc Pierre-Boucher—Les Patriotes—Verchères, QC

Thank you very much.

The Chair Liberal Ben Carr

Thank you, Mr. Barsalou‑Duval.

Ms. Lewis, the floor is yours for five minutes.

11:35 a.m.

Conservative

Leslyn Lewis Conservative Haldimand—Norfolk, ON

Thank you.

My question is for Ms. Denoncourt of Équiterre.

You spoke of a national framework. Since Parliament isn't specifying the framework and what it would look like, could you identify the three most important binding obligations that you expect from this framework?

11:35 a.m.

Analyst in source reduction, Équiterre

Julie-Christine Denoncourt

Yes. I touched on this briefly in my opening remarks, but first, it would involve making it mandatory to make certain items available for a reasonable period after a product has been placed on the market. This includes parts, tools and information, as well as software updates, which are sometimes essential for repairs or, quite simply, for a product to function properly.

I would add that these items must be made available at a reasonable price. We could define what constitutes a reasonable price, but we could also leave that for later. This is the approach many countries have taken. There is existing literature on this subject. In fact, several studies have found that the acceptable price of a repair for consumers lies between 18% and 40% of the price of a new product. Obviously, this probably depends on the product. I imagine that people are prepared to pay more for large household appliances than for a small electronic device.

In short, first, there is the requirement to make parts, tools, information and software updates available at a reasonable price.

We would also like to see a ban on certain design practices which, as I said, make repairs very difficult, or even impossible in some cases. Certain appliance parts are sometimes glued or welded. Europe has taken action in this regard by banning certain design practices.

Finally, there is the requirement to display a sustainability rating, as I mentioned.