Thank you very much.
Colleagues, we're going to turn to our first round of questioning.
Mr. Chambers, floor is yours for six minutes.
Evidence of meeting #53 for Industry and Technology in the 45th Parliament, 1st session. (The original version is on Parliament’s site, as are the minutes.) The winning word was product.
A recording is available from Parliament.
Liberal
The Chair Liberal Ben Carr
Thank you very much.
Colleagues, we're going to turn to our first round of questioning.
Mr. Chambers, floor is yours for six minutes.
Conservative
Adam Chambers Conservative Simcoe North, ON
Thank you, Mr. Chair.
Mr. Abar, thank you for your testimony here today. I wanted to follow up on a couple of points you made with respect to making sure that low-cost products would still be available to consumers and ensuring that this bill would not affect the availability of products.
Can you expand on that?
President, Microland
I was referring specifically to items that would require design changes specific to Canada. The amendments we proposed are about how service is offered.
I know that there are items in this bill that talk about the length of warranty periods. Manufacturers and our partners in general can adapt to those.
In some ways, it's more of a process change than a design change in products that would make them unaffordable. If, for example, you needed to make certain products repairable that are currently not repairable—let's say in a cheaper Bluetooth speaker—those products are generally not even openable. They're exchanged by the manufacturer when they're in warranty. These are generally at the more affordable end. They are things you can pick up even at a drugstore, not necessarily an electronics centre. Those would be the most affected, because to design those cheaper, lower-end products to be openable and repairable when they're not in other markets would basically push them to a higher category and make them not affordable.
Conservative
Adam Chambers Conservative Simcoe North, ON
Some of those products, you would guess, might not be available to consumers if the manufacturer said they're not even going to bother selling their stuff in Canada. Is that one option?
President, Microland
There's a certain subset of products that we call “exchange only”. If somebody contacts us in our role as the manufacturer's representative and has this product under warranty and has the receipt, we'll send it in. It goes straight to exchange. There are no parts even made for those products.
I basically doubt that a manufacturer would build a parts supply chain just for Canada. We would likely see the lower-end products become unavailable if there was a requirement to make them repairable.
Conservative
Adam Chambers Conservative Simcoe North, ON
Consumer choice and affordability should still be an expectation that Canadians should have, and all governments, provincial and federal, should keep that as an underlying principle in their discussions. Is that correct?
President, Microland
Affordability is important. That's why most of the positions we have are to make repair more affordable.
Obviously, repairing a product economically is a more affordable option than replacing it, so our focus is on making repair cheaper and more affordable, and on removing barriers so that we and other service partners have access to parts and information and all the tools we need to be able to provide repair services cheaply to Canadians.
Conservative
Adam Chambers Conservative Simcoe North, ON
Thank you very much.
Mr. Bester, thank you for coming.
Help me understand your organization's position with respect to.... I think you acknowledge that there's a federal government role through competition, and there's obviously a provincial government role in contract law, as an example.
How should the federal government create a national framework on areas that are outside its jurisdiction?
Executive Director, Canadian Anti-Monopoly Project
The federal government, beyond those policy areas that are more squarely in its domain, can have more of a coordinating or collaborative function in building a floor instead of, again, a patchwork.
It's true that these things are in provincial jurisdiction. It's going to be provincial work, but tying in to the earlier comments, if we know we don't want to take the Canadian market and slice it up into more and more pieces while increasing durability and increasing repairability, the federal government has a strong role to play in coordinating and collaborating and making that a smoother process.
Conservative
Adam Chambers Conservative Simcoe North, ON
Thank you very much. I happen to share some of that belief.
However, there may be a circumstance in which a province wishes not to adopt or buy in to the federal floor, if you will. In that circumstance, what should happen?
Executive Director, Canadian Anti-Monopoly Project
That's where the limit of my understanding of federal and provincial interaction goes. I think the case is to be made to Canadians as to why this is better for you, whether it's home electronics, appliances or, as we suggest, a broader set of categories.
I think the work to be done is to bring provinces along by showing the value to their constituents of either meeting or exceeding this floor.
Conservative
Adam Chambers Conservative Simcoe North, ON
Thank you very much.
I'll offer just a suggestion as the way that I might think about it.
The only way it can work, in my view, would be to set it up like the national building code. The challenge with the building code, though, is that a lot of these changes are made by the federal government to the national building code without proper consultation with industry or provinces. What started as, I think, a valuable or a laudable goal has now turned into the federal government making changes without considering things like cost and affordability, which then are automatically, in some cases, adopted by provinces. That would be a risk. It's a model, but it's a risk.
Mr. Chair, how am I doing for time here?
Conservative
Adam Chambers Conservative Simcoe North, ON
Thank you very much. I appreciate it.
I'd love to continue the conversation.
Liberal
Liberal
Karim Bardeesy Liberal Taiaiako'n—Parkdale—High Park, ON
Thank you very much.
Mr. Bester, we've seen frameworks in the past. We've also seen other forms of policy direction that have the effect of causing change at the manufacturer level. I'm wondering if you can speak to the kinds of changes you might see from manufacturers just from the mere presence of a framework or a consultation towards the presence of a framework.
Executive Director, Canadian Anti-Monopoly Project
If we zoom out and ask where this is heading in provinces, at the national level and at the international level, I'm thinking about the EU this week. The more constituencies and markets are moving towards establishing floors and establishing frameworks, the more it makes business sense for folks to just adopt that into their own practices.
In the U.S., in Canada, in Europe, there is a vibrant right to repair movement. In state or federal action, the same thing could be replicated here. My optimistic point is that in moving in that direction, it just becomes the standard way of doing business, as opposed to being an anomaly.
Liberal
Karim Bardeesy Liberal Taiaiako'n—Parkdale—High Park, ON
An example that sometimes comes up of multinational pressure resulting in real change is in the adoption of USB-C as a common standard. What other kinds of things might we be able to expect?
October 27th, 2026 / 12:20 p.m.
Executive Director, Canadian Anti-Monopoly Project
You're referencing the EU's ecodesign, I believe it's called, related to phones and tablets. It's focused more on e-waste than on interoperability and repairability.
The other big lever of their right to repair approach is the right to repair directives. Across quite a number of sizable product categories, they link market access to the provision of repair information and parts at a fair price and at a fair time, among other things.
While the market access piece may not be where our minds are at, aligning with that other half—that right to repair directive—would be a way to increase the potential market that we're talking about here.
Liberal
Karim Bardeesy Liberal Taiaiako'n—Parkdale—High Park, ON
I see that the bill includes references to both labelling and the availability of parts. Thank you for that.
You referred to the role of the Competition Bureau and its possible inclusion in the bill. It's not there now, but could you speak briefly to the role of the Competition Bureau and the Competition Tribunal with respect to these issues?
Executive Director, Canadian Anti-Monopoly Project
That's a good question. Thank you for it.
There are a couple of dimensions to it. In particular, the Competition Bureau, in its advocacy and policy function, has been a pretty consistent champion of the right to repair and has fed into a number of consultations provincially, but with the Bill C-59 amendments in 2024, there's also this refusal-to-deal provision related to repair and diagnosis, parts and information. That's an important tool, as I mentioned.
The thing about the Competition Bureau and the Competition Tribunal is that they're best focused on systemic issues that require engaging in the investigative and adjudicative process. Competition Bureau investigation and litigation can take years. If that's pointed at a major issue—let's say a dominant manufacturer has taken over the market for aftermarket repairs—that's very helpful, but as a day-to-day person, I can't go to the Competition Bureau and say, “I need this repair manual.” We need to match that with either a legislative or framework approach.
Liberal
Karim Bardeesy Liberal Taiaiako'n—Parkdale—High Park, ON
Thank you. That's very helpful.
Ms. Cheng, I have a couple of questions for you.
Thank you for the work you do with so many volunteers. We visited you at Swansea Town Hall in Taiaiako'n—Parkdale—High Park a few months ago and saw the thriving community that you described.
Could you talk to us a bit about the kinds of people who come as volunteers? Are these professional repair people? Do they run businesses that actually provide them with income from doing repair work?
Executive Director, Repair Café Toronto
Yes, we have a lot of volunteers—we call them “fixers”—who help visitors repair their broken things. Most of them are hobbyists. They just love fixing. They love helping others fix their broken things and showing them how to do it.
Many of them have been volunteering with us for a long time. They enjoy doing what they do. They love to share their skills with others.
Liberal
Karim Bardeesy Liberal Taiaiako'n—Parkdale—High Park, ON
At the end of a meeting with a fixer, what kind of reaction do you get from the people who bring in these goods?
Executive Director, Repair Café Toronto
When their things get fixed, visitors and fixers are very happy. We celebrate by getting the visitor to ring the bells, and there's a round of applause from the people in the room.
Sometimes something is not fixable, or we just don't have the tool to open it. Other times, things need to go back and the owner will need to come back with the parts, or the thing basically can't be fixed, which is the end of its life. Visitors are still very happy. They really appreciate that they have been shown the process to look into the items, and they learn. They appreciate the people who try their best to help them.
Often fixers like to consult each other as well. It is a collaborative environment, so sometimes you can see multiple fixers working on one item to help a visitor get things fixed. This is an environment that really has a sense of life that people can feel when they walk into the room.