Going by the RCMP's experience in 2002-03, there would have been some false passports that weren't investigated, some tobacco-type and alcohol smuggling offences that weren't properly investigated, and some counterfeit documents that weren't properly investigated. Given the limited recourse that has been made to these provisions, at least by the RCMP, it's difficult in my view to see the pressing need these provisions were meant to fill.
Campbell and Shirose, the Supreme Court of Canada decision, presented a very narrow problem for the police in relation to reverse sting operations in drug cases. In part, it turns upon the very expansive definition in the Controlled Drugs and Substances Act of the offence of trafficking, because it's an offence not simply to sell drugs but to offer to sell drugs. Before these provisions were introduced into the Criminal Code, that's a problem that had been rectified by regulations under the Controlled Drugs and Substances Act.
It appears that, at least from the RCMP's conduct, the types of investigations justification is relied upon for are those where there really are victimless crimes, where it's a question of possessing contraband or a question of creating false documentation that's being uttered to the government, rather than crimes that generally have an effect upon third parties, like most of the other offences under the Criminal Code.
So I question the pressing need for these provisions. Given the manner in which they've been resorted to, it's difficult to see that they are a necessity at this time.
