I don't know how they can fundamentally be part of the process if they're not part of the process of selecting and coming up with the lists of judges.
You say it will increase accountability if we take this away from members of Parliament, but who is more accountable than members of Parliament? This is a responsibility of Parliament and, in particular, the Prime Minister , who is the first minister within Parliament, to appoint judges to the Supreme Court. However, if we take that ability away from members of Parliament to have a say in this—and again, this was a system that I think was widely well received among all political parties—how could it be possible that a group that does not have accountability to any of the electorate of this country would be more accountable than members of Parliament?