That is indeed what we propose in our brief.
It is important to look at the decisions that have been handed down by the Supreme Court of Canada. It began in 1990 with the Keegstra ruling, which is a criminal law ruling, where hatred is defined as “emotion of an intense and extreme nature that is clearly associated with vilification and detestation”. However, the new definition proposed in the bill refers instead to an “emotion that involves detestation or vilification and that is stronger than disdain or dislike”.
The reason why the Supreme Court expressed itself in this way in the Keegstra ruling and requested that hatred be defined as an “emotion of an intense and extreme nature” is because the offences under the Criminal Code are reserved for the most harmful behaviours in our society. Of course, hatred can be defined in other ways, as we saw in the Supreme Court case Saskatchewan (Human Rights Commission) v. Whatcott, where hatred is defined somewhat differently. However, when we talk about criminal offences, we must be referring to the most reprehensible acts, because they have significant consequences in terms of individual rights. For example, a prison sentence may be imposed after a person has been found guilty.
