I submit that, for Naud, who was the other applicant in the Senneville case, who was holding 250 videos of children being raped, we should approach that case with the expectation that courts will not depart from the mandatory minimum penalties, just like we do with treason and murder. By the way, I can see everyone's brains moving when it comes to murder and treason, but it might not be as cut and dried as people think here.
Think about Edward Snowden, an example that I often use when I instruct on the charter or civics. Edward Snowden blew the whistle on national security, on Homeland Security, on the NSA and on the CIA as collecting metadata—something that is proposed in Bill C-22—indiscriminately, on everybody.
I ask an ordinary civics class, or a grade 12 law class, or a grade 11 law class or even first-year law students this question: Would you convict Mr. Snowden for treason, for coming out, leaving for Hong Kong and saying the United States administration and the security apparatus are violating search and seizure? Would you convict? Nine out of 10 say they would not convict.
It's a very interesting proposition that I'm advancing here. None of this is certain. What needs to be certain is sentencing. The Criminal Code says that this is the minimum for this evil of the possession of child pornography. That should be the sentence as opposed to weakening the mandatory minimum sentences, which is what this bill is, unfortunately, doing.
Thank you.
