I'd like to speak to my friend, Mr. Mantle's, subamendment.
The subamendment basically states the reason for the bill. The whole reason for the bill is to not consider reasonable hypotheticals, to deviate from this practice where courts do not look at the facts before them but consider a hypothetical scenario, and on the basis of that hypothetical scenario, strike down the mandatory minimum penalty as unconstitutional.
We've had some exchanges with the officials, who believe that the safety valve will now potentially end this practice, but I'm not sure that the practice will end. There's absolutely no reason for us not to be certain. I'd like to question the officials on this.
If we can please look at page 71 of the bill, proposed subsection 718.4(1), the new section, says the following:
When imposing a sentence for an offence that has a minimum punishment of a specified term of imprisonment, a court shall impose a shorter term of imprisonment than the specified term if, in the circumstances, the minimum punishment would amount to cruel and unusual punishment for that offender.
In other words, Ms. Burt or Mr. Taylor, what I understand the bill to do is basically say that when looking at that individual offender, a court may consider a lower sentence than the MMP if the court deems it to be cruel and unusual for that offender. Am I correct?
