If I may, Mr. Taylor, this is the most important moment of everything that's happened on this bill. The bill was brought in order to eliminate the practice of reasonable hypotheticals. We just heard from Mr. Taylor that even though you're supposed to avail yourself of the safety valve as it pertains to the individual offender, nothing precludes the court from looking at the constitutionality of an MMP. You can still come back and say this MMP is cruel and unusual on the basis of this reasonable hypothetical. Therefore, the entire clause would be struck down, therefore defeating the entire purpose of this bill. This amendment is very clear-cut. It says a court shall not consider a reasonable hypothetical. That's why we're here.
Why not pass this basic, very clean language?
This is tantamount to performing surgery on a patient and removing the cancer, but not stitching up the patient after surgery. If the Liberals are really serious about preserving mandatory minimum penalties while avoiding cruel and unusual scenarios for individual offenders, they got it done, but they have neglected to impose a mechanism where reasonable hypotheticals would still not be considered. This amendment does that.
Let's think about this a little more. I'm glad that now everybody understands the legal landscape that I've been talking about for days. Let's actually accomplish what Bill C-16 sets out to accomplish.
Thank you.
