Good morning.
Ladies and gentlemen of the committee, thank you for welcoming us here today.
Allow me to introduce myself. I am Marcel‑Olivier Nadeau, president of the Barreau du Québec. I am accompanied by Ms. Valérie Laberge, a member of our Family Law Expert Group, and by Mr. Nicolas Le Grand Alary, a solicitor in the Secretariat of the Order and Legal Affairs Department of the Barreau du Québec.
The Barreau du Québec would like to thank you for inviting it to take part in the consultations on Bill C‑223, an act to amend the Divorce Act, which aims to better protect children.
It is important to recall that the mission of the Barreau du Québec is to ensure the protection of the public, to promote accessible justice and to uphold the rule of law. It is in this capacity that we present to you the main recommendations from our submission on this bill.
To begin with, I would say that the Barreau du Québec supports the objective of better protecting children and victims of domestic violence. Violence and coercive control must be fully taken into account in decisions affecting families.
To better protect families, clear and enforceable rules are needed. These rules must also comply with Quebec civil law, the rules of evidence and the ethical obligations of lawyers.
Our reservations therefore concern the proposed measures. Several provisions primarily set out principles, without guaranteeing concrete protection. Others raise difficulties in terms of implementation. Our proposals aim to strengthen the protection of children. They also allow for each family situation to be taken into account and ensure the fairness of the proceedings.
I shall focus on four main themes of our submission.
The first theme concerns the role of lawyers. The bill would require them to assess the risk of domestic violence. Where a risk is identified, they would be required to implement an appropriate plan and ensure that the family has a safety plan.
Recognizing the signs of violence is part of the vigilance expected of lawyers. However, risk assessment and the development of a safety plan require specialized psychosocial skills. Entrusting these responsibilities to lawyers risks leading to errors and creating a false sense of security.
We recommend instead that lawyers be required to refer the parties, where necessary, to specialized and competent resources. Everyone must be able to contribute to the protection of families in accordance with their expertise.
We recommend removing all references to marital reconciliation from the Divorce Act. Indeed, simply specifying exceptions to this obligation is not sufficient. This obligation no longer corresponds to the current conception of family law, which is based on individuals' autonomy, dignity, and physical and psychological safety.
The second issue concerns the assessment of evidence. We, too, wish to prevent the misuse of parental alienation against victims of violence. However, the proposed restrictions risk preventing the court from considering evidence relevant to determining the child's best interests.
We favour specialized training, independent expert assessments and the judge's ability to assess each situation on its merits. If the legislature adopts a definition of parental alienation, the criteria must be strict: numerous, systematic and persistent behaviours aimed, without justifiable cause, at severing the child's relationship with the other parent. The presence of domestic violence should not be a prerequisite.
We also welcome the ban on the use of myths and stereotypes in family law. We do, however, have one reservation: the provision on incompatible statements and adversarial evidence should be removed from this list and instead be subject to separate rules on admissibility. The court must be able to consider relevant evidence if it is sufficiently reliable and if its use serves a legitimate purpose of justice. Stereotypes can be combatted while preserving the fairness of the proceedings.
I now turn to the third theme: the best interests of the child. We welcome the intention to clarify that there is no presumption of equal sharing of parental time. Some litigants still believe the opposite. Yet the decision must be guided solely by the best interests of the child. We therefore propose retaining the current rule: The child should spend as much time with each parent as is compatible with their best interests. It would suffice to clarify that this rule does not create any presumption of equal sharing.
The child must also be allowed to have their say. We support this objective, but we oppose the proposed written statement. Such a statement may be subject to a parent's influence, which raises questions of reliability. Challenging it also risks placing the child at the centre of a conflict between their parents.
Finally, the fourth issue concerns significant relocations. The current rules are based on a long history of case law and a 2019 reform. We recommend that they be retained and that the proposed amendments to clause 7 of the bill be withdrawn. If these rules are nevertheless amended, those relating to shared parental time must be preserved.
It is up to the parent wishing to move with the child to demonstrate that the move is in the child's best interest.
Thank you. We are ready to take questions.
