Five minutes isn't very long, but I'm going to do my best.
My name is Wayne Barkauskas. I'm a family law lawyer in Calgary. I've been practising for approximately 35 years. I'm also a mediator, an arbitrator and a parenting coordinator, and I've been doing that for between 20 and 25 years, so I'm quite often put in the position of having to make decisions about parenting for people. I've probably made hundreds of decisions, if not thousands, in my career in that role.
I represent the Alberta Family Lawyers Association, which has approximately 1,000 members practising family law in Alberta. I'm here in person because this issue and this proposed bill are of such importance. It's been explained by our members that this is a critical item that they want us to appear on.
I attempted to provide my résumé to this committee so that people could understand my perspective. It couldn't be translated in time, but I'm going to give you some highlights.
I'm a past president of the Alberta branch of the Canadian Bar Association. I am the past national chair of the CBA family law section. I was on the federal advisory committee for changes to the Divorce Act in 2021, which included all of the new revisions, including on family violence and coercive control. I was on the committee that helped create the family law tool kit for lawyers, which was approximately a two-year project. The tool kit helps lawyers identify family violence.
I've taught lawyers and judges, both within Canada and outside Canada. I've done that for years, all on the issues of family violence. I also sit on the board of Sagesse. The Sagesse organization assists victims of family violence, and I have been on that board for approximately 25 years.
That's the context that I bring to my comments this morning.
You've heard from many people who are in opposition to this bill, and rather than repeating the things they've said, I want to bring it home for you. I want you all to imagine that you are an arbitrator. You've been hired to make decisions relating to a family and what's going to happen to children. I'm going to keep the facts really simple and really straightforward, not extreme.
We have a family here. The husband and wife were married approximately 20 years ago. They had a good relationship. They had one child approximately six years ago.
Everything was fine until about two years ago. Two years ago, there was an incident because the relationship was getting rocky, and the incident involved alcohol. It escalated, and the husband hit the wife.
The police were called. There weren't any charges laid. It was a single incident. The father got anger management counselling. They went for marriage counselling. They reconciled. Now they're breaking up two years later. They have a six-year-old child.
I want to ask you, based on the bill that we have here, what would happen if the wife decided to take the child without any consent from the father and just move to the Maritimes. What would you do under this bill?
You're now the arbitrator. If you take a look at the bill, you see that it says that since there's been family violence, you can't hold it against the wife merely because she decided to abduct the child to the Maritimes. Without this bill, of course, when you look at the facts, it makes no sense that this would happen.
Now let's go back again and imagine that after separation, the wife started saying things to the child like, “Dad's bad. He's a bad person.” That's not because she's using the child as a weapon, but because she actually believes it. She's telling this to the child because she believes it's her duty to teach the child that this father is bad. This is a six-year-old child.
Under this bill, what would you do as an arbitrator? Under the provisions of the bill, you couldn't do anything, because it says that this type of conduct is not going to be held against her.
Okay, now let's go further. Let's say you now have a psychologist telling you that the damage that's been caused can be reversed, but in order to reverse it, the child needs time away from mom—a pause—and the psychologist needs some time in order to reconcile the relationship between the father and the child. According to this bill, you couldn't do it.
