You bring up a couple of things.
First of all, the changes in 2021 have made a sea change in family law. If people are bringing examples to this committee of things that happened in court prior to 2021, yes, I concur that our bench was not terribly well educated on the issue of family violence. The changes in 2021 demanded the legal profession and the courts to become far more familiar with the dynamics of family violence. That's the first thing I'll say.
The second thing is that you bring up a very good point: Every situation is different, and the dynamics are complex. Sometimes you have both parents using different forms, I'll call it, of family violence in an effort to control a situation. Sometimes it's litigation abuse. Sometimes it's physical abuse. Sometimes it's enlisting the children into their fight. It can happen on either side, or both sides at the same time.
I'll give you an example. Early in my career, I had a case in which the father had beaten the wife with his prosthetic leg. This is absolutely true. The reason he had prosthetic legs was that in an earlier dispute, the wife had driven the family vehicle into him and severed his legs. She pinned him up against a wall. They had three children together.
Think about this legislation. What would you do? The proposed bill is built in a binary way—a good person, a bad person. What happens if they're both bad people? What are you supposed to do as an arbitrator or a judge? It means that really, literally, either of them could pick up the child and run away to P.E.I. or somewhere else, and it would be justified. That makes no sense. It's illogical.
