Thank you for this invitation to speak with the committee.
The “Powering Canada Strong” policy paper suggests that building transmission lines between provinces will provide energy security, reliability and affordability.
Look at Europe. Belgium physicist Pierre Kunsch wrote in “Decarbonizing electricity in the European Union: A programmed failure demonstrated by the figures”:
A full-scale laboratory has existed for about twenty years. It allows you to form an unbiased opinion of what is possible and what is not.
Spain and Portugal experienced national blackouts in April 2025 due to grid instability caused by renewables. Norway no longer wants to be the hydro battery of Europe. Germany has lots of wind and solar, but powers the country on domestic coal and on nuclear generation from France. Wind, solar and transmission lines have driven up electricity costs. Due to Germany's expensive electricity and lack of domestic energy, industry is collapsing and moving to the U.S. or China. Net zero is the pursuit of the impossible.
Like Europe, Canada's net-zero emission targets cannot be met with current technologies by 2030 or 2050, as clearly stated by professor emeritus Vaclav Smil in his seminar called “Energy Revolution”. He calls it “more like a crawl”.
In our recent open letter to banking regulators, we explained that the push for net zero was based on catastrophic climate scenarios, of which the best known is RCP 8.5. These scenarios were officially retired as implausible this spring, but Environment Canada still uses them in “CCCR 2026”, misleading policy-makers. There is no climate emergency.
Likewise, there's no material supply chain or capacity to build out critical mineral mines to meet net zero, as shown by Professor Simon Michaux. At 2019 rates of production, it would take 189 years to mine sufficient copper and over 9,000 years to mine sufficient lithium. Is the solution to emissions to electrify everything?
The government's Sankey diagram shows that electricity meets only 18% of Canada's energy demand. Fossil fuels constitute 93% of domestic energy supply, and renewables only 7%. Can wind, solar and grid-scale batteries provide reliable, affordable power? At 2021 prices, the batteries needed for a reliable supply of electricity from wind and solar generators in Alberta alone would cost almost $2 trillion.
Canada's seasonal weather extremes mean that solar and wind are often dead when additional power is needed most. Wind is not always blowing somewhere.
Wind and solar devices can operate reliably for about 15 to 20 years and grid-scale batteries for about 10 years. Then they must all be replaced, at about the same cost or greater. The old devices cannot easily be recycled, creating garbage dumps. Conventional power plants can operate for about 60 years, while hydro dams and nuclear generators can operate for about 100 years.
Canada and the U.S. rely on each other for north-south exchange of electricity. This provides excellent reliability for both nations. British Columbia's drought meant it has had to import about 20% of its power from the U.S. Due to Quebec's electrification of home heating and to drought, at times Hydro-Québec has found itself unable to export to U.S. markets. The cost of net zero for Quebec would be $400,000 per citizen over the next 24 years.
Canada must build more conventional power generation. Transmission lines between provinces do not solve the problem; interties are useful for limited and specific exchanges of electrical power.
Europe is cited as a highly networked model. It is densely populated. In Canada, there's no city over one million people between Toronto and Calgary to underwrite the cost of transmission lines.
“Clean energy” is a misnomer. Wind, solar and batteries demand more energy and more critical minerals for manufacture. The emissions are in China, which runs on coal.
Hydrogen is touted as a solution, but the pitfalls, costs and dangers are many, and geothermal is limited by geology.
Thank you very much.
