Evidence of meeting #46 for Natural Resources in the 45th Parliament, 1st session. (The original version is on Parliament’s site, as are the minutes.) The winning word was gas.

A recording is available from Parliament.

On the agenda

Members speaking

Before the committee

Carter  Committee Researcher
Baiton  President and Chief Executive Officer, Canadian Association of Petroleum Producers
Jenkins  Executive Director, Indigenous Clean Energy
Bowen  Vice-President, Asset Planning and Delivery, Manitoba Hydro
Walker  Director, Institute for Sustainable Finance, Queen’s University, and Professor of Finance, Concordia University, As an Individual
Belliveau  Program Manager, Energy Transition, Environmental Defence Canada
Stirling  Communications Manager, Friends of Science Society
Levin  Associate Director, National Climate, Environmental Defence Canada

Michelle Stirling Communications Manager, Friends of Science Society

Thank you for this invitation to speak with the committee.

The “Powering Canada Strong” policy paper suggests that building transmission lines between provinces will provide energy security, reliability and affordability.

Look at Europe. Belgium physicist Pierre Kunsch wrote in “Decarbonizing electricity in the European Union: A programmed failure demonstrated by the figures”:

A full-scale laboratory has existed for about twenty years. It allows you to form an unbiased opinion of what is possible and what is not.

Spain and Portugal experienced national blackouts in April 2025 due to grid instability caused by renewables. Norway no longer wants to be the hydro battery of Europe. Germany has lots of wind and solar, but powers the country on domestic coal and on nuclear generation from France. Wind, solar and transmission lines have driven up electricity costs. Due to Germany's expensive electricity and lack of domestic energy, industry is collapsing and moving to the U.S. or China. Net zero is the pursuit of the impossible.

Like Europe, Canada's net-zero emission targets cannot be met with current technologies by 2030 or 2050, as clearly stated by professor emeritus Vaclav Smil in his seminar called “Energy Revolution”. He calls it “more like a crawl”.

In our recent open letter to banking regulators, we explained that the push for net zero was based on catastrophic climate scenarios, of which the best known is RCP 8.5. These scenarios were officially retired as implausible this spring, but Environment Canada still uses them in “CCCR 2026”, misleading policy-makers. There is no climate emergency.

Likewise, there's no material supply chain or capacity to build out critical mineral mines to meet net zero, as shown by Professor Simon Michaux. At 2019 rates of production, it would take 189 years to mine sufficient copper and over 9,000 years to mine sufficient lithium. Is the solution to emissions to electrify everything?

The government's Sankey diagram shows that electricity meets only 18% of Canada's energy demand. Fossil fuels constitute 93% of domestic energy supply, and renewables only 7%. Can wind, solar and grid-scale batteries provide reliable, affordable power? At 2021 prices, the batteries needed for a reliable supply of electricity from wind and solar generators in Alberta alone would cost almost $2 trillion.

Canada's seasonal weather extremes mean that solar and wind are often dead when additional power is needed most. Wind is not always blowing somewhere.

Wind and solar devices can operate reliably for about 15 to 20 years and grid-scale batteries for about 10 years. Then they must all be replaced, at about the same cost or greater. The old devices cannot easily be recycled, creating garbage dumps. Conventional power plants can operate for about 60 years, while hydro dams and nuclear generators can operate for about 100 years.

Canada and the U.S. rely on each other for north-south exchange of electricity. This provides excellent reliability for both nations. British Columbia's drought meant it has had to import about 20% of its power from the U.S. Due to Quebec's electrification of home heating and to drought, at times Hydro-Québec has found itself unable to export to U.S. markets. The cost of net zero for Quebec would be $400,000 per citizen over the next 24 years.

Canada must build more conventional power generation. Transmission lines between provinces do not solve the problem; interties are useful for limited and specific exchanges of electrical power.

Europe is cited as a highly networked model. It is densely populated. In Canada, there's no city over one million people between Toronto and Calgary to underwrite the cost of transmission lines.

“Clean energy” is a misnomer. Wind, solar and batteries demand more energy and more critical minerals for manufacture. The emissions are in China, which runs on coal.

Hydrogen is touted as a solution, but the pitfalls, costs and dangers are many, and geothermal is limited by geology.

Thank you very much.

The Chair Liberal Terry Duguid

Thank you to all of our witnesses.

We're now going to go on to questions and comments. We're going to start with Ms. Anstey for six minutes.

12:30 p.m.

Conservative

Carol Anstey Conservative Long Range Mountains, NL

Thank you, Chair.

I'd like to start with Ms. Stirling. Thank you for your opening comments.

Ms. Stirling, wind and solar may be relatively quick to build, but the grid still has to provide electricity when the wind isn't blowing and the sun isn't shining.

I'm curious about your comments around who pays for the generation, storage and grid infrastructure needed to provide that reliability. Also, should those costs be included when governments tell Canadians what wind and solar actually cost?

12:30 p.m.

Communications Manager, Friends of Science Society

Michelle Stirling

A lot of the renewable subsidies, of course, come from taxpayers. It looks like we're building out batteries, wind and solar, but that's actually being heavily subsidized in the background. Also, things like the ITCs are draws from the Canadian tax pool, so the full cost of wind and solar is almost never presented to the public.

Also, when you have a lot of wind and solar on the grid, you basically have to have equivalent conventional, reliable, dispatchable power. “Dispatchable” means you can turn it up and down. You can control it. There has to be a parallel system, and that adds a great deal of cost.

Also, the transmission lines for wind and solar are not used to their maximum potential. Wind has a capacity of about 30% and solar varies quite radically, but let's say it's around 15%.

12:30 p.m.

Conservative

Carol Anstey Conservative Long Range Mountains, NL

You've also raised the difference in lifespan between wind and solar infrastructure and longer-lived assets such as hydro and conventional generation. Can something really be called a cheaper option if it has to be replaced multiple times over its life as the alternative?

12:30 p.m.

Communications Manager, Friends of Science Society

Michelle Stirling

I don't think so, and I think most taxpayers would agree. If you can buy a refrigerator, for instance, that will run reliably for 20 years, rather than one that will run for three years, which is the preferential investment?

Look at it. If you put up a lot of wind and solar generation and then you have to replace it in 10 or 15 years, that's a huge sum of money, and it's also a big garbage dump. What are you going to do with all those unrecyclable things?

Carol Anstey Conservative Long Range Mountains, NL

There's something else that you touched on, and I want to give you an opportunity to expand on it.

Government is putting major emphasis on building new transmission lines between provinces, but transmission lines only move electricity. They don't generate it. If electricity demand is expected to grow significantly, is there a risk in spending billions of dollars to expand transmission without first making sure there is enough dependable generation available to supply that grid?

12:35 p.m.

Communications Manager, Friends of Science Society

Michelle Stirling

That's correct. If you look at most provinces and most regions, you see that the province takes care of its own first.

Just imagine if we had a national transmission line from Quebec and Ontario, where there's nuclear and generally lots of hydro, and then you have one of those big winter storms in Quebec and Ontario and the other provinces had not built additional capacity. As Manitoba Hydro mentioned, they're kind of up to here. Would we have a national blackout, as Spain and Portugal did?

If you have redundancy and power generation within your own region and you also have sufficient interties to local neighbours, you can draw or contribute small portions. For instance, when we had the big polar vortex in Alberta in January a couple of years ago, we almost went to blackout, but Manitoba supplied a bit of power to Saskatchewan and Saskatchewan supplied a bit of power to Alberta, and that saved us from that cliff.

When you're transporting a lot of electricity, there are huge line losses. If you're transporting on an ultra-high-voltage DC line, which is what's used for wind and solar, you lose power at either end in the inverter in converting it to AC—alternating current—which is what the regular grid runs on. When you have long AC high-voltage lines, you lose transmission because of line losses from the resistance factor, which is an element of physics.

People have said that if we build wind west and have 66 gigawatts from offshore wind, we can supply 20% of the power to Canada. Well, you might only ever get 33 gigawatts of power out of it, with great difficulty, and with great difficulty for the power grid, because what are you going to do if there's a hurricane? What are you going to do if all that wind drops off? Where is the reliable backup to fill that gap?

12:35 p.m.

Conservative

Carol Anstey Conservative Long Range Mountains, NL

Thank you so much.

I'd like to cede the rest of my time to my colleague, MP Ellis Ross.

The Chair Liberal Terry Duguid

That's 30 seconds.

12:35 p.m.

Conservative

Ellis Ross Conservative Skeena—Bulkley Valley, BC

Thank you.

Ms. Stirling, with the 30 seconds, I have the one issue that nobody wants to talk about when we're talking about electrification, including solar and batteries, which need minerals, which need mines, which leave massive tailing ponds that can't be remediated. If they are remediated, it takes a long time and costs a lot of money, which most likely will end up leaving the onus on taxpayers.

Have there been any studies on how much it costs and what damage is going to be done, not only just in Canada but globally in terms of what tailing ponds do to our environment?

The Chair Liberal Terry Duguid

Thank you.

Ms. Stirling, I'll give you 30 seconds to answer that.

12:35 p.m.

Communications Manager, Friends of Science Society

Michelle Stirling

You can just look at the community of Baotou in China. They live in a toxic dump where all of the rare mineral processing has basically killed the landscape and is killing the people. Most of the “clean” materials that we get come from China.

The Chair Liberal Terry Duguid

Thank you.

We're moving on to Mr. St-Pierre, who's going to be sharing his time with Mr. Saini.

Is that correct? Will it be three minutes and three minutes?

Eric St-Pierre Liberal Honoré-Mercier, QC

Yes, that's right. I'll be sharing my time with my fine colleague from British Columbia.

I'd also like to take this opportunity to thank the translators for their hard work. They've been working really hard, and I know there have been some issues. They're often working in the shadows, and I just want to thank them for their hard work.

Ms. Levin, thanks for joining us today. You just heard the testimony from the Friends of Science Society. I'm curious to know Environmental Defence Canada's perspective on what you've heard from the Friends of Science Society.

Julia Levin Associate Director, National Climate, Environmental Defence Canada

Thank you for the question. I'll take a few seconds and then I'll pass it over to my colleague.

I think it's very important that we have a fact-based conversation around the pace of the energy transition and the costs, as well as the realities of the benefits that the energy transition is bringing to our peer countries around the world and the risks that Canada faces if we slow down on this energy transition.

The costs include the cost of fossil fuel infrastructure and the cost of the climate crisis. I think we can agree that we are in a climate crisis. As my colleague spoke to, we are seeing that the costs of solar and wind energy—paired with energy storage, paired with flexible grids and paired with the demand side—are vastly more affordable for Canadians. The industrial demand for clean energy is growing, to the point where you can attract foreign investment dollars only if you are supplying clean energy. Canada had a lead there, but with more natural gas on the grid, we are starting to go backwards and that's actually scaring away the foreign investment dollars that this government is keen to attract.

I'm glad we are worried about tailings, because the fossil fuel industry is the largest source of dangerous tailings. If we're worried about communities, there are health studies for that. For example, for the Athabasca Chipewyan First Nation, there's currently a cancer study because of the impacts of the oil sands tailings on their communities, so let's have a holistic conversation about how fossil fuel infrastructure is harming communities across this country and is leading to the climate crisis. “Canada's Changing Climate Report” serves as a stark warning of the future that awaits us if we don't rapidly decarbonize.

Also, just because it was touched on, let's have a conversation about the scale of the subsidies to the fossil fuel industry. Over $85 billion of federal money has gone to the fossil fuel industries in recent years. That number is set to increase with alarming new projects of national interest, but the renewable energy industry has received only a fraction of that support. We suggest strengthening the ITCs and the important measures that have been developed in budget 2026 to deliver those.

Eric St-Pierre Liberal Honoré-Mercier, QC

Thank you.

I have three minutes left, so I'll pass the floor to my colleague to ask his questions.

Gurbux Saini Liberal Fleetwood—Port Kells, BC

I'm going to ask Mr. Thompson this question.

I was in Vancouver when the Prime Minister announced LNG phase two. A $38-billion foreign investment came into Canada. It was a historic moment. Can you guide us on what else we can do to bring that type of investment into Canada?

12:40 p.m.

Director, Institute for Sustainable Finance, Queen’s University, and Professor of Finance, Concordia University, As an Individual

Thomas Walker

You said, “Mr. Thompson”. Was that question directed to me?

Gurbux Saini Liberal Fleetwood—Port Kells, BC

Yes.

12:40 p.m.

Director, Institute for Sustainable Finance, Queen’s University, and Professor of Finance, Concordia University, As an Individual

Thomas Walker

Thank you, Mr. Chair.

Let me stick to the line of argument we just had.

On the investment side, as was just said by Ms. Levin, there's a lot of pressure in the financial world for investors internationally and for pension funds to invest sustainably. I don't think we can ignore that. On the exporting side, it's similar. Let me also go to that side. If we want to export to Europe, for example—and I don't mean energy but products—the European Union will levy a tax on imported products that are not sustainably produced, so I think it is very important that we do look at clean energy.

How do we attract additional investors? We need data. That's one thing I mentioned earlier. We need reliable data and data disclosures. We also need a low cost of capital so that investors are attracted and companies want to invest in things. Finally, we need low risk, meaning government guarantees for specific projects as well as guarantees against future regulatory risks—for example, future carbon prices. We don't know what future governments will decide, but if future carbon prices change, then companies face large risks. That can be handled through so-called forward contracts or carbon contracts for difference, as we call them, that can lock in carbon prices. A plethora of tools are available.

I probably can't answer in a few seconds, but I hope that's at least started the conversation.

Gurbux Saini Liberal Fleetwood—Port Kells, BC

On the same theme, we had a major economic summit in Toronto. The world came to it because they see Canada as a reliable partner to work with, and they're willing to invest half a trillion dollars.

Is that happening because of the government's great policy of being open for business?

12:45 p.m.

Director, Institute for Sustainable Finance, Queen’s University, and Professor of Finance, Concordia University, As an Individual

Thomas Walker

Is the question directed at me, Mr. Chair?

The Chair Liberal Terry Duguid

Yes, it is. Go ahead, Mr. Walker.

12:45 p.m.

Director, Institute for Sustainable Finance, Queen’s University, and Professor of Finance, Concordia University, As an Individual

Thomas Walker

Do we see this coming? Yes, I think there is a lot of demand.

In terms of the geopolitical things—events and policies we've seen south of the border, and the current trade war—Canada has come more to the attention of Europe in terms of building our trade ties and investing, and also in diversifying from the energy crisis in Europe, which was mentioned earlier.