Evidence of meeting #46 for Natural Resources in the 45th Parliament, 1st session. (The original version is on Parliament’s site, as are the minutes.) The winning word was gas.

A recording is available from Parliament.

On the agenda

Members speaking

Before the committee

Carter  Committee Researcher
Baiton  President and Chief Executive Officer, Canadian Association of Petroleum Producers
Jenkins  Executive Director, Indigenous Clean Energy
Bowen  Vice-President, Asset Planning and Delivery, Manitoba Hydro
Walker  Director, Institute for Sustainable Finance, Queen’s University, and Professor of Finance, Concordia University, As an Individual
Belliveau  Program Manager, Energy Transition, Environmental Defence Canada
Stirling  Communications Manager, Friends of Science Society
Levin  Associate Director, National Climate, Environmental Defence Canada

The Chair Liberal Terry Duguid

Thank you. I'll have to stop you there, Mr. Walker. We're at the six-minute mark and we're going to go on to Monsieur Simard.

You have six minutes.

Mario Simard Bloc Jonquière—Hébertville—Pays-des-Bleuets, QC

Ms. Stirling, I am a strong believer in the exchange of views and ideas. It is through that process that our thinking sometimes evolves. Listening to you earlier certainly gave me food for thought, and it has left me with a few questions.

Before getting into the substance of the matter, I would like to clarify one point. Your presentation appears to run somewhat counter to the scientific consensus on energy that has been presented to this committee, and I have two or three quick questions for you.

Do you believe that fossil fuels produce greenhouse gas emissions and are, at least in part, responsible for climate change?

12:45 p.m.

Communications Manager, Friends of Science Society

Michelle Stirling

Yes, they are partly responsible for global warming, and you can see a presentation by Professor William van Wijngaarden, who will demonstrate that it does not create a crisis.

Mario Simard Bloc Jonquière—Hébertville—Pays-des-Bleuets, QC

So you do not believe that fossil fuels are responsible for climate change. Forgive me, I just want to be sure I understand your position correctly.

12:45 p.m.

Communications Manager, Friends of Science Society

Michelle Stirling

No, I said that they're partly responsible, but there are also other things that humans do, such as land diversion and water diversion—the James Bay dam, for instance.

Mario Simard Bloc Jonquière—Hébertville—Pays-des-Bleuets, QC

All right.

I'm curious: Who funds your organization? How do you establish the data that you presented to us earlier? Do you have a scientific director? Do you have staff responsible for conducting this type of analysis?

12:45 p.m.

Communications Manager, Friends of Science Society

Michelle Stirling

We're funded by our members. We are funded by individual members. We're not funded by industry. In fact, in 2015 Ecojustice and several high-profile climate activists tried to have the Competition Bureau investigate us as an industry proxy. They did not find such evidence.

We do have a scientific director. Ken Gregory is our research director. He's a retired professional engineer. He has done a detailed analysis of decarbonization for the United States that is on our website. I can send you a link.

I also consult with Randy Stubbings, who's a retired professional engineer with 45 years of experience on the Alberta power grid, and with Professor Samuele Furfari, who was a former EU director and part of the directorate on energy for the EU for 26 years.

Mario Simard Bloc Jonquière—Hébertville—Pays-des-Bleuets, QC

Thank you.

I wouldn't say that you have necessarily taken shortcuts, but if I understood your testimony correctly, you stated earlier that equipment associated with intermittent energy sources, whether wind power or others, must be replaced every 20 years. That does not align with the testimony we've heard from experts in the field. I am thinking in particular of Professor Mousseau, academic director of the Trottier Energy Institute, a recognized authority on energy issues.

I find that somewhat surprising. I find it all the more surprising given that countries across the western world are moving at a rapid pace toward greater electrification. If your assessment is correct, then all of those countries are heading in the wrong direction and are committing themselves to an economic quagmire that will cost them a fortune. Either you are bringing forward good news that no one else has seen, or the position you are advancing runs counter to the scientific consensus upheld by individuals whose credibility is well established throughout the academic community.

Let me return to a point you made earlier. I am a Quebecker. I live in a province where hydroelectricity is the primary source of energy. That is precisely what makes Quebec attractive and encourages people, as well as energy-intensive industries, to establish themselves there. Hydroelectricity is such a draw that we are now struggling to keep up with demand.

In essence, what you are suggesting is that all of those people are mistaken because electrification does not work and because the distribution grid is prohibitively expensive. The people have to pay for that. Ultimately, it's taxpayers who pay for that infrastructure. I would simply point out that two pipelines are involved here. One of them, TMX, was built at a cost of $34 billion. You and I paid for it through our taxes. The same thing is now happening with the pipeline project in Alberta. Once again, you and I will be paying for it through our taxes. Do you not see a disconnect between the argument you're making and the reality of the situation?

12:50 p.m.

Communications Manager, Friends of Science Society

Michelle Stirling

I think there are a few things. You can look at Texas. There's a huge graveyard there for wind turbines. They're actually just burying wind turbines. You can look at Africa. Solar panels are being dumped there. You can look at Germany, where the largest solar farm has just gone bankrupt. Who's going to take care of all those dead solar panels?

With regard to TMX, you can look at what PPHB energy bankers, out of Houston, said at the time that Kinder Morgan stopped work on TMX. They said that Canada has become a country “hostile” to investment ever since the National Energy Board was turned upside down by the radical campaign against it by Ecojustice. The gold standard—which is what the NEB used to be—has been destroyed.

The Chair Liberal Terry Duguid

Thank you both.

Mario Simard Bloc Jonquière—Hébertville—Pays-des-Bleuets, QC

Thank you.

12:50 p.m.

Communications Manager, Friends of Science Society

Michelle Stirling

[Inaudible—Editor] the tar sands campaign.

The Chair Liberal Terry Duguid

Okay.

Mr. Patzer, I believe you're up next for five minutes.

12:50 p.m.

Conservative

Jeremy Patzer Conservative Swift Current—Grasslands—Kindersley, SK

Thank you very much, Mr. Chair.

Yes, there's a lot of compelling conversation going on in this room today.

Unlike the majority of people who sit around this table, I actually did work for a wind company. I worked on a wind farm, and I can tell you that the companies base their life cycle on 20 years. They don't guarantee you anything beyond that. In fact, most of them shut down before that 20. Some go a bit longer. Then you have cases like those in California, where they just leave dilapidated infrastructure hanging. It's an eyesore. It's leaking all over the place and it's not producing. There are fire hazards.

There are all kinds of problems with the renewable industry as it is currently being set up. There's very little accountability. The companies themselves base their sites on 20 years—nothing more than that. They will not guarantee anything other than that.

The cost recovery on that, when I was working in the industry, was 18 years to make your first dollar back on a 20-year wind farm. Your return on investment was a minimum of 18 years. That was with building in contingencies: replacing gearboxes and blades and also replacing gensets and things like that. It all depends a bit.... There are a lot of variables that go into it, but in the average wind company, when I worked in the industry, it was for 20 years, and 18 for a return on investment.

Let's just put that to rest here.

Ms. Sterling, you referenced the polar vortex in Alberta a couple of years ago. Let's talk a little about that.

Alberta is one of the provinces in this country that actually provides minute-by-minute reporting on where the grid is getting its power from. Do you remember what happened on the night that Alberta was facing blackouts?

12:55 p.m.

Communications Manager, Friends of Science Society

Michelle Stirling

What generally happened was that we had built out about 30% of renewable power, but we had not kept up with the replacement of coal power plants or natural gas plants. Natural gas plants are not something you can turn on with a switch. It takes anywhere from two to eight hours to get a plant up and running at speed. In winter, that's further complicated by the fact that you have extreme cold outside, where the air intake is, and inside you are running at a very high temperature.

There was a combination of factors. The polar vortex moved in and parked itself over Alberta, the sun went down and the wind died off. We had about 6,000 megawatts of renewables on the grid. Suddenly, all of that vanished, and we did not have sufficient dispatchable gas power to compensate for that.

We had recognized this problem in the fall of 2022, when there were seven grid level three alerts. That's usually when either industry is going to be curtailed or consumers are going to face rolling blackouts—or, God forbid, you face a blackout. If a power grid goes down, it's very hard to get the whole thing up and running again. That's why this kind of provincial or regional attention to reliability and redundancy is so important, because it's not a situation that anyone wants to find themselves in. It's very hard. In Spain and Portugal, it took them over 12 hours to get their power grids back up. A number of people died, and the losses were massive for all industries.

12:55 p.m.

Conservative

Jeremy Patzer Conservative Swift Current—Grasslands—Kindersley, SK

I think something similar happened in Texas a few years prior in the winter as well. Did it not?

12:55 p.m.

Communications Manager, Friends of Science Society

Michelle Stirling

Yes, that's correct. Texas has very limited connection to other local grids and they had electrified a lot of homes. A similar kind of polar storm moved in. It's not that common in Texas, but it does happen. Grids have to be designed for the maximum worst-case scenario, not the average.

There was a deficiency of electrical power from wind. It dropped off completely. At the same time, there were difficulties in getting some of the gas facilities up to standard. Yes, there was an element with the gas facilities, but not because they're not reliable. It was partly due to weather and partly due to the sudden drop-off of wind. Again, many people died. I think about 600 or 700 died.

12:55 p.m.

Conservative

Jeremy Patzer Conservative Swift Current—Grasslands—Kindersley, SK

Yes, it's absolutely tragic what is happening around the world when people aren't willing to deal in reality on how we need to heat our homes in the winter and also how we need to keep them cool in the summer.

Can you tell us a little more about some of the damage that paid activists have done over the years by trying to dump all over Canadian energy producers?

12:55 p.m.

Communications Manager, Friends of Science Society

Michelle Stirling

I don't know if people are familiar with the tar sands campaign, but it started back in the 1990s. There were hundreds of international ENGOs that were activated by Corporate Ethics to block, defame and delegitimize Alberta oil. They were paid hundreds of billions of dollars.

We have five reports on our website. Four of them were done by Robert Lyman, who was a federal public servant for 27 years and a diplomat for 10 years. He showed that the top two environmental groups in Canada received more revenues between 2000 and 2018 than both of the major federal parties: the Liberals and the Conservatives.

The Chair Liberal Terry Duguid

Thank you both.

Colleagues, we are not going to get to our last two speakers. I think I have the agreement of those who are on the list.

We have Mr. Danko for five minutes and then Monsieur Simard for 2.5 minutes.

We'll go over to you, Mr. Danko.

John-Paul Danko Liberal Hamilton West—Ancaster—Dundas, ON

Thank you, Mr. Chair.

I come to this conversation with the understanding that electrification is inevitable. It's not an ideological choice. It's not a climate change issue. It's simply because electrification provides better services, is more user-friendly and is more affordable. The entire world is going in that direction, and the only question is this: Will Canada be in a leadership role, or is it going to follow, kicking and screaming?

I think it's clear that our government is investing heavily in electrification on the production side. We talked about wind west, with $75 billion of investment and more, and about Churchill Falls, the largest clean energy investment ever in North America. In Ontario specifically, we're undergoing major nuclear refurbishments and investments right now at Darlington, Pickering and Bruce. In Hamilton, in my riding in particular, we've seen 100 years of industrialization that started based on electrified industry because of access to Niagara Falls' and St. Catharines' hydroelectric energy.

Mr. Walker, I do have a couple of questions for you. You answered them largely in the answers to my colleagues, but I invite you to make sure that you submit in particular your four pillars: blended finance, securitization, grid diversification and reliable climate data. Make sure you submit those in writing to this committee.

I'm going to move on to Ms. Belliveau and Ms. Levin from Environmental Defence.

You had some really interesting comments on affordability and reliability when it comes to electrification. I want to start with affordability. If we're talking about transportation, heating and industry—electrifying those three key sectors—what role does electrification play in making things more affordable for Canadians?

1 p.m.

Program Manager, Energy Transition, Environmental Defence Canada

Emilia Belliveau

I can start us off.

Not only are electrified energy systems with a baseload from renewables the most cost-effective form of new energy generation, but also, when we're electrifying those end uses in transit, home heating and industry, we get to reap additional benefits. For example, in the vast majority of places in Canada, transitioning home heating from baseboard electric, home heating oil or other sources—natural gas included—to a heat pump will lower the cost for the consumer. We're seeing similarly that the long-term investment in electrification has payoff benefits quite early in the life cycle of those appliances. It's similar with EVs. They quickly become more affordable than gas-powered vehicles within, I think, five years off the lot.

That also means that you're not participating in the volatile price shocks that we see when you're relying on gas or natural gas for home heating. This is a way that we can see more money go back into Canadians' pockets and invest in a system that has long-term affordability in mind.

Maybe I'll pass it to Julia for the industrial side.

1 p.m.

Associate Director, National Climate, Environmental Defence Canada

Julia Levin

Just to add to that, this is how we save Canadians hundreds of dollars each month and thousands of dollars each year. We help them get heat pumps. We help them make the switch to EVs. We are saving Canadians thousands of dollars. That's a real affordability issue, and the government has taken important steps, including just last Friday's, and I'd love to see more of that.

On grid reliability, because we're hearing a lot about it in Texas and Alberta, those are issues with the gas plants. Again, circling back to fact-based conversations, there is a real issue with too much reliance on gas leading to the blackouts we saw in Texas and Alberta. That's why we need interconnected grids. We need those interties between provinces, and we need battery storage to make sure we're not leaving ourselves vulnerable to gas, both on the price element and on the reliability element.

1 p.m.

Liberal

The Chair Liberal Terry Duguid

Thank you both.

We are at time, Mr. Danko.

Mr. Simard, you have the floor for two and a half minutes.

Mario Simard Bloc Jonquière—Hébertville—Pays-des-Bleuets, QC

Thank you very much, Mr. Chair.

I would simply like to return briefly to the point that, as legislators, I believe we have a moral obligation to listen to science. Witnesses have told us at this committee that there's a scientific consensus that we need to make greater efforts toward electrification and that climate change is real.

You may recall, as I do, that in the 1980s certain scientists claimed that tobacco was not harmful to human health. We later came to understand the interests that motivated those claims. I'm not accusing anyone of anything, but I sometimes have the impression today that a similar effort is being made with respect to certain energy sources. I will leave that point aside and return to the matter before us.

Ms. Belliveau, and perhaps Mr. Walker as well, the federal government has announced its electrification plan. When we look at Quebec's energy mix, 40% of total energy consumption comes from hydroelectricity. Across Canada, electricity accounts for 17%. In China, it's 32%. The government's objective is to double that 17% share of the mix in Canada by 2050. Frankly, I don't find that particularly ambitious, since it would merely bring us to where China stands today.

I'd like to know whether you consider a doubling of that 17% share by 2050 to be an ambitious target. More importantly, I'd appreciate your views on the fact that achieving it will, in my opinion, require an effective carbon pricing policy. If you could provide the committee with your thoughts on what should be done with respect to carbon pricing, I believe that would be helpful to the committee.

Please, can you respond?