Evidence of meeting #49 for Natural Resources in the 45th Parliament, 1st session. (The original version is on Parliament’s site, as are the minutes.) The winning word was electricity.

A recording is available from Parliament.

On the agenda

Members speaking

Before the committee

Pineau  Professor, Chair in Energy Sector Management, HEC Montréal, As an Individual
Christidis  President and Chief Executive Officer, Canadian Nuclear Association
McGoey  Vice-President, Corporate Affairs, Canadian Nuclear Laboratories
Colin Judge  Deputy Vice-President, Science and Technology, Canadian Nuclear Laboratories
Karin Stephenson  Director, Nuclear Research and Education Support, McMaster University, As an Individual
Pieries  Global Director, Nuclear, Hatch Ltd.

11:35 a.m.

Professor, Chair in Energy Sector Management, HEC Montréal, As an Individual

Pierre-Olivier Pineau

Thank you, Mr. Simard.

Obviously, a comparison of the various options is worthwhile. That said, while not downplaying the costs I mentioned, we must also recognize the value that different technologies bring to the grid. It's certainly true that nuclear technologies, which provide stable generation 24 hours a day, offer different value to the grid compared to wind or solar farms, which provide intermittent generation.

Therefore, energy costs must not simply be measured in dollars per megawatt-hour. The value to the grid and the need for balancing must also be taken into account. In this respect, nuclear power has enormous advantages. However, once again, in Canada, as some provinces have large reservoirs and an electricity transmission network which, if sufficient transmission lines were built, would balance intermittent generation in different regions, and everyone could benefit from these reservoirs at a lower cost than it would cost to build many new nuclear power stations.

Second, you spoke of the advisability or merit for the government to invest in a particular technology, in this case nuclear power. Nuclear energy and research in this field are fundamental for various reasons, particularly in health care and in the fight against climate change. However, in Canada, we must be mindful of our current budgetary situation. We are running a deficit, we consume enormous amounts of electricity and energy in general, and it's widely recognized that developing energy efficiency in the long term costs less than adding extra capacity.

That is what is so unfortunate about the current energy debate: We constantly overlook the fact that Canadians are the world's biggest energy and electricity consumers, and that there are opportunities for energy efficiency that would make us stronger, more efficient and more resilient in the face of future climate change. It's extremely problematic to invest further in tax credits to subsidize new construction instead of putting more focus on energy efficiency.

Therefore, until we have sound economic foundations, I would be wary of subsidizing new construction. Research ought to be subsidized, yes, but new construction should not be subsidized as part of new projects until sound economic foundations that enable consumers to be aware of the true costs and to pay the true price for their energy consumption are in place.

Mario Simard Bloc Jonquière—Hébertville—Pays-des-Bleuets, QC

Briefly, what I take from your comments is that, if there were one thing to prioritize, it would be to focus on energy efficiency. If you have any documents to submit in relation to this to assist the analysts in their work, that would be appreciated.

There is one other thing. I understand that you are saying people should not get caught up in a race to offer ever-higher tax credits to build new infrastructure, but there are bound to be some opportunities that are more promising than others. I see storage technologies becoming increasingly efficient, which can certainly help to harness intermittent energy sources. I also see new technologies for advanced management, particularly in Quebec, where this is a key issue.

Wouldn't it be better to focus the government's efforts on this type of technology, rather than relying on nuclear energy, which, in the long term, will still prove very costly?

11:35 a.m.

Professor, Chair in Energy Sector Management, HEC Montréal, As an Individual

Pierre-Olivier Pineau

We need to do several things simultaneously.

There are significant gains to be made by giving consumers greater flexibility in their energy use. Before storing energy, we need to be able to shift certain uses. Electric vehicles will be very useful in this regard, shifting energy use and storing energy. However, there are ways of shifting demand—I'm thinking of water heaters and household appliances, for example—to better reflect intermittent generation and makes better use of what intermittent energy sources can offer at a lower cost.

The Chair Liberal Terry Duguid

Colleagues, we'll move on to our second round. We're going to start with Mr. Patzer.

You have five minutes.

11:35 a.m.

Conservative

Jeremy Patzer Conservative Swift Current—Grasslands—Kindersley, SK

Thank you very much, Mr. Chair.

Thank you to the witnesses for being here.

I would like to expand on some of the questions that have already been asked.

I will direct this question to the Canadian Nuclear Association.

You brought up the issue of needing to de-risk projects. What is the biggest risk that these projects need to be de-risked from?

11:40 a.m.

President and Chief Executive Officer, Canadian Nuclear Association

George Christidis

When we talk about de-risking, we're talking about having certainty in the investment environment. We're also looking at certainty in the context of the federal government's role in that process. We're looking at investment tax credits, for example, and making sure they're extended to meet the timelines of the nuclear industry's build-out, which are plans driven by provincial governments. We're looking at the inclusion of unions, because unions are partners in Bruce Power's ownership structure, as well as first nations consultation and the like.

In terms of federal programs, you would identify the portion of the risk to the private sector, the investment community, the utilities and the government. These come together to de-risk critical infrastructure projects—the story goes beyond just nuclear—in order to enable this investment to occur in Canada.

Our concern is about how these different groups and programs come together to support and de-risk our projects as they proceed.

Jeremy Patzer Conservative Swift Current—Grasslands—Kindersley, SK

There's a lot of government in there. That's what I'm hearing.

What is the number one regulatory risk that you see that needs to be changed or eliminated today?

11:40 a.m.

President and Chief Executive Officer, Canadian Nuclear Association

George Christidis

As per your colleague's questions earlier, the regulatory environment is about implementing the direction of Bill C-39. We feel it's trending in the right way, but we want to make sure there are certain components, such as one regulator, one project, and certain implementation questions in terms of ensuring that efficiency.

It's about reducing duplication, recognizing provincial and other departmental information and the regulatory process, looking at brownfield industrial processes, for example, and accepting some of the information there. That is an example where we could reduce any duplication or inefficiency. It's really about reducing inefficiency.

11:40 a.m.

Conservative

Jeremy Patzer Conservative Swift Current—Grasslands—Kindersley, SK

You could jump through all the hoops and spend millions and millions of dollars. Then, at the end of the day, the minister could just say no.

Are you concerned about that?

11:40 a.m.

President and Chief Executive Officer, Canadian Nuclear Association

George Christidis

From the perspective of national projects, we feel the government right now has made a determination that the country needs to have some sort of mechanism by which cabinet can determine whether a project is on a national basis.

I can't speak to the political conversation in that space, but given where Canada is—

11:40 a.m.

Conservative

Jeremy Patzer Conservative Swift Current—Grasslands—Kindersley, SK

It's not a political problem.

11:40 a.m.

President and Chief Executive Officer, Canadian Nuclear Association

George Christidis

—I think there's a need for accelerated economic activity and for energy and economic sovereignty.

These are questions that you, as members, and the government will have to discuss.

11:40 a.m.

Conservative

Jeremy Patzer Conservative Swift Current—Grasslands—Kindersley, SK

Sure. However, the point I'm trying to make is that a company can spend tens of millions of dollars on this. I've even heard of companies walking away from over $1 billion spent on projects because a minister either wasn't going to give their approval or was delaying on purpose. Like you said, Bill C-39 is going to try to address some of that, but it doesn't change the fact that a minister could still play that game with a project and not provide that certainty.

Is that a concern?

11:40 a.m.

President and Chief Executive Officer, Canadian Nuclear Association

George Christidis

Right now, seeing the direction of the national projects list, nuclear is included, so I don't have concerns I could table here today.

11:40 a.m.

Conservative

Jeremy Patzer Conservative Swift Current—Grasslands—Kindersley, SK

Okay. That's interesting.

An issue was brought up in one of your opening remarks. I'm sorry, but I forget which group said this. You were talking about provincial interties. This committee did a report back in 2017 specifically addressing the need for provincial interties. In the last parliament, we talked about interties, and we had witnesses come in and say that nothing's been done.

My province of Saskatchewan has a lot of uranium. That will probably be the next major nuclear project built in Saskatchewan. What are we going to do with it? Where are we going to send this power, and how are we going to send this power? What's the end objective here?

Could somebody address that?

11:40 a.m.

President and Chief Executive Officer, Canadian Nuclear Association

George Christidis

Well, being from Saskatchewan, you would know that the Government of Saskatchewan has made a series of announcements of the upgrading of the intertie system. They're taking a regional lens in terms of their energy strategy, including nuclear large and small. That speaks to the regional nature of our country. Having a national grid is not feasible. Having strong interconnections regionally is what is most practical.

In terms of Saskatchewan, for example, the connections between Saskatchewan, Manitoba, Northwest Territories, Alberta and the northern states are where the Saskatchewan government is looking at enhancing its system. Nuclear there—small reactors, but large reactors as well—is being contemplated to shore up the process to be able to export and achieve their goals as well.

The Chair Liberal Terry Duguid

That's your time, gents. Thanks to both of you.

Mr. Hogan, you have five minutes.

Corey Hogan Liberal Calgary Confederation, AB

Thanks, Chair.

Thanks to our witnesses.

This is an important study at an important moment. We are trying to hit that three-legged stool of affordability, reliability and low emitting. I think that where Canada is generally is not bad. We're at about 15% nuclear generation, and that mix is serving us well. We have some of the lowest electricity prices in the OECD, but there are many challenges that need to be tackled and many opportunities that need to be seized. We need to think about that whole system and the federal government's role in fostering and facilitating electricity generation, but also economic opportunity. That's where I want to put my questions in this round.

We can't ignore the economic opportunity that being an energy leader has provided. We can think of the billions of dollars and the tens of thousands of jobs exporting nuclear technology has given Canada.

Mr. Christidis, you talked about creating opportunities in Europe, Asia and beyond. I want to piggyback on that to ask a broader question about how we quantify the value of a robust nuclear industry. Tell us more about the jobs and economic opportunities that nuclear creates.

11:45 a.m.

President and Chief Executive Officer, Canadian Nuclear Association

George Christidis

Thank you for that.

Yes, the nuclear industry is a significant employer right now. In the energy sector, we are a significant labour-intensive industry in everything from skilled labour such as plumbers and welders to the steel industry, for example, along with the nuclear experts and nuclear engineers and the like.

We really speak to a growth of the labour side of our industry. That is also why the key groups, including unions and other organizations, support the growth of the nuclear industry. That is a fundamental benefit to investing in nuclear. It's not only the electricity generation. It's not only the low emissions to reduce emissions. It's also the creation of significant jobs.

Now, I do need to table one thing from a perspective of the cost question, just to address that fully. The cost question is quite clear that you need all technologies on the table for each provincial government to identify what's best for its own needs. Unless folks in Quebec are advocating for a national grid—I'm not familiar with that—it's very important that each province and each region has the ability to look at all technologies—renewable, hydro, nuclear, gas and whatever it might be—to assemble the best economic portfolio to generate electricity, particularly at this time. On our side, we create a lot of jobs and benefits in innovation, universities, polytechnics, research labs and the like, which we see as fundamentally a core of Canada moving forward.

Corey Hogan Liberal Calgary Confederation, AB

Thank you.

Obviously, these are long-lived assets, so some of those capital costs up front can create maybe a shadow that's not going to be there in the long term. You've opened up other markets and opportunities in them, other than Ontario and existing nuclear provinces, I should say.

I want to ask you about Alberta and the energy-only market that exists in Alberta. What do we need to be thinking about as a federal government as we start thinking about how we foster nuclear sectors in provinces that have not historically been nuclear provinces and, in particular, in ones that might have very different systems, like Alberta?

11:45 a.m.

President and Chief Executive Officer, Canadian Nuclear Association

George Christidis

It goes back to the fact that each province will make the decision that's right for them, quite frankly.

Alberta is a free market and it needs to take a look at what is the price of reliability of that market, and that's to say sustainable, reliable power that can't go down. We are seeing a conversation in Alberta, whether it's a large reactor project or a potential small reactor project, where Albertans are raising the question: Do they have the right system in place that would generate reliable power and that would complement their economic and energy needs?

Really, it's for Albertans to have this conversation, but the question becomes how the Canadian government can enable Alberta and others to consider this technology to meet national goals of reducing emissions, creating jobs and enhancing energy security. That entails, again, the proper regulatory environment; the nuclear financial models that could help Alberta and other provinces consider how this technology fits their needs; and workforce development. Again, our sector creates significant jobs, and developing a workforce, for example, will take a federal-provincial lens, along with the industry.

Those are the kinds of questions that need to be discussed by Albertans in Alberta.

Corey Hogan Liberal Calgary Confederation, AB

What are the opportunities that might exist with interties to pair with hydro or other assets?

11:45 a.m.

President and Chief Executive Officer, Canadian Nuclear Association

George Christidis

I can't speak to the intertie question directly because we're not in that space. However, it is very true that, on a regional basis, many of the nuclear projects are part of provincial and regional interconnection systems. For example, Ontario and Quebec do exchange electricity. What I understand, in Ontario, is that Quebec will have less available power in the future and needs to consider its future needs. I understand that Quebec tabled an energy strategy of its own that identified that it needs to consider other sources in the future, but I can't speak to that.

It's very true that our country has regional interconnections that will enable each province to consider how nuclear, hydro, renewables and natural gas come together.

I would also like to suggest, if there's interest in exploring how politicized decisions could impact decisions on energy, I would encourage you to take a look at the European Union and Germany specifically.

The Chair Liberal Terry Duguid

Thank you, both.

Mr. Simard, you have the floor for two and a half minutes.

Mario Simard Bloc Jonquière—Hébertville—Pays-des-Bleuets, QC

Thank you, Mr. Chair.

Mr. Pineau, I'd like to follow on from what Mr. Christidis has just said. In your remarks, you spoke of 10 different electricity systems in Canada and the possible need to further develop the integration of these electricity systems. I can't recall whether I've already had this discussion with you, but it seems to me that areas where it would be easier to integrate systems, such as Quebec, Ontario or the Maritimes, had already been identified. I can't remember, so I would like you to talk about the areas that should be prioritized.

I'll first ask you another quick question, after which I'll give you the floor.

I fully understand the principle you're advocating regarding energy efficiency, but to electrify heavy industrial processes, wouldn't that still require new sources of power generation? I don't think that energy efficiency alone will enable us to electrify many heavy industrial processes that are highly energy-intensive.

I'd like to hear your views on these two points.