Evidence of meeting #49 for Natural Resources in the 45th Parliament, 1st session. (The original version is on Parliament’s site, as are the minutes.) The winning word was electricity.

A recording is available from Parliament.

On the agenda

Members speaking

Before the committee

Pineau  Professor, Chair in Energy Sector Management, HEC Montréal, As an Individual
Christidis  President and Chief Executive Officer, Canadian Nuclear Association
McGoey  Vice-President, Corporate Affairs, Canadian Nuclear Laboratories
Colin Judge  Deputy Vice-President, Science and Technology, Canadian Nuclear Laboratories
Karin Stephenson  Director, Nuclear Research and Education Support, McMaster University, As an Individual
Pieries  Global Director, Nuclear, Hatch Ltd.

11:50 a.m.

Professor, Chair in Energy Sector Management, HEC Montréal, As an Individual

Pierre-Olivier Pineau

It's clear that I'm not advocating a single pan-Canadian electricity system and that more work is needed to align different sub-regions, with the Atlantic provinces being a priority. The federal government has been working hard on this for the past 20 years or so, with little success, unfortunately.

In my view, Quebec, Ontario and the Atlantic provinces should also collaborate more closely to better identify the best projects for everyone. However, this doesn't prevent Alberta, British Columbia, Saskatchewan and Manitoba from also collaborating and trying to further align their electricity systems. Some work therefore needs to be done at the regional level. This would increase transparency, efficiency and the visibility of fair prices.

Now, as for your second question, there is enormous potential for progress in the area of energy efficiency, but we must be realistic: Canadians are extremely reluctant to make an effort in this regard. I think they'll do more, but they won't go to extremes. As such, we will indeed need new energy sources, and this is where nuclear energy can offer major advantages, because it generates heat and electricity without emitting greenhouse gases. In some cases, it may be worthwhile to make use of the heat and electricity that nuclear power can provide. In that case, we really need to take an integrated view of both aspects—

The Chair Liberal Terry Duguid

Thank you so much.

Next is Ms. Kronis followed by Mr. Saini.

11:50 a.m.

Conservative

Tamara Kronis Conservative Nanaimo—Ladysmith, BC

Thank you so much.

Professor Pineau, I want to ask you a few questions.

You've laid out some pretty powerful challenges in terms of workforce staffing, interprovincial trade barriers and some financing concerns around the de-risking side.

On the federal government's strategy, the target for 2035 is to have at least one deployment outside of Ontario operational or under construction. How realistic do you think that is?

11:50 a.m.

Professor, Chair in Energy Sector Management, HEC Montréal, As an Individual

Pierre-Olivier Pineau

Having it for 2035 is pretty quick. That's in nine years. I don't think it is entirely realistic to have a new nuclear power plant somewhere. We've failed at reaching many goals along our history in terms of the deployment of environmental and energy goals, so I don't think failing at that goal would be particularly problematic.

It is quick. I would not like to rush a new nuclear power plant unless a strong economic case is made that it would be cost-competitive against alternatives based on a regional analysis, where we compare different options and what's best in terms of reliability for everyone and costs. This is key for taxpayers. We all say taxpayers should be considered. I'm calling for us to consider taxpayers and realize that there's a cost.

Nuclear is providing some benefits, but we have to study these benefits against alternatives. We need to see these studies.

11:55 a.m.

Conservative

Tamara Kronis Conservative Nanaimo—Ladysmith, BC

In addition to calling for at least one deployment outside of Ontario to be operational or under construction by 2035, there's an additional target of two large nuclear reactors under construction by 2035.

If one is difficult, how realistic do you think it's going to be to have three?

11:55 a.m.

Professor, Chair in Energy Sector Management, HEC Montréal, As an Individual

Pierre-Olivier Pineau

It's definitely going to be very difficult, especially since we haven't made the case that they are absolutely needed and they haven't been assessed compared to alternatives. We need to assess these alternatives. We need to look at what's best for the country.

I value the nuclear industry and Canadian knowledge in nuclear energy. I think we should be careful about growing our knowledge and our capacity. It should not be done at any cost. We should establish and analyze these different costs, and we shouldn't set targets on these terms.

11:55 a.m.

Conservative

Tamara Kronis Conservative Nanaimo—Ladysmith, BC

You brought up the costs. The language that's been used here.... A lot of people have talked about de-risking. De-risking usually involves providing investment certainty to the large corporations and the large entities that are involved.

In the context of projects that, in your words, feel a bit rushed, what do you think the risks are to the Canadian taxpayer of cost overruns if this is rushed forward in an unrealistic way?

11:55 a.m.

Professor, Chair in Energy Sector Management, HEC Montréal, As an Individual

Pierre-Olivier Pineau

They might be significant. We have had some successes in the past, but if we look at New Brunswick, the Point Lepreau power plant was not on cost or on target when it was refurbished.

There are risks, and we should be careful. These risks exist in any kind of energy project. Some hydro projects in Newfoundland and Labrador went over cost, so we should be careful. That's why I agree that we should not rush. We should look at energy efficiency so we make sure that we don't overbuild, because we can consume less. We should be concerned about that.

In the nuclear sector, costs are significant, so we should be extremely cautious about trying to invest too quickly.

11:55 a.m.

Conservative

Tamara Kronis Conservative Nanaimo—Ladysmith, BC

We've talked about some of the challenges of building the actual reactors. There's an additional supply chain component in needing to build the transmission lines out of them to deliver the energy.

Can you comment on the difficulties we're going to have there with these timelines?

The Chair Liberal Terry Duguid

You have 20 seconds, Mr. Pineau.

11:55 a.m.

Professor, Chair in Energy Sector Management, HEC Montréal, As an Individual

Pierre-Olivier Pineau

There are new technologies for transmission lines that can increase the capacity of existing lines without having to build new corridors. It's not easy to build transmission lines, but they can be built. There are not many risks. They are projects to be accepted by the population, but they are not very risky in terms of technology.

The Chair Liberal Terry Duguid

Thank you, both.

Mr. Saini, you have five minutes.

Gurbux Saini Liberal Fleetwood—Port Kells, BC

Thank you, Mr. Chair.

Thank you to the witnesses.

My question is for George.

While nuclear energy is an important non-emitting energy source in Canada, there are environmental considerations surrounding the management of the nuclear waste released into water sources and the decommissioning of sites.

What is Canada's track record regarding the production of nuclear energy and environmental protection? Outside of the emissions and land footprint, has there been any assessment of the cumulative environmental impact of nuclear energy production in Canada?

11:55 a.m.

President and Chief Executive Officer, Canadian Nuclear Association

George Christidis

From a Canadian nuclear perspective and how we're seen in the world, Canada is seen as a leader in nuclear energy, including in how nuclear waste is managed. That includes the near surface projects, which my colleagues here could speak to, but also the deep geologic repository that is proceeding in Ignace, which has local support and has been a world-acknowledged process for consultation and discussion with communities and first nations. Therefore, Canada is a leader across the way from its nuclear technologies and its supply chain to the way nuclear waste is managed, as well as the regulatory process itself.

Having said that, there are always going to be opportunities for improvement for any technology. The nuclear industry very much looks at these projects as moving forward and really reinforcing Canada's leadership in that space.

In terms of the environmental footprint, the amount of nuclear waste that's generated by the industry in comparison to other energy sources is very small. The example often referred to is that the amount of energy that's created for the lifetime of an individual by the nuclear industry would fit in a soda can. That's nuclear's contribution to that energy use.

The impact of nuclear energy on the environment is very managed and regulated. I'd offer up that our industry is the most thoroughly regulated, not only domestically but also internationally, as well. From the perspective of the environment, we are a contributor to a clean and sustainable environment.

Noon

Liberal

Gurbux Saini Liberal Fleetwood—Port Kells, BC

Mr. Judge, Canada is internationally recognized in the nuclear field for domestically developing CANDU technology. There are 17 CANDU reactors operating in Canada and nine operating outside of the country.

What is the level of awareness among the public of Canada's homegrown CANDU technology?

What feedback do your members hear from countries around the world regarding the potential purchase of the Canadian nuclear technology known as CANDU?

Noon

Deputy Vice-President, Science and Technology, Canadian Nuclear Laboratories

Dr. Colin Judge

We are working very hard to increase the level of awareness through our STEM programs and education programs. The CNL is a part of and very closely connected with many university networks, but it's also working very closely with a lot of high school students, as well, to build awareness of what nuclear technology is and what we've done in Canada with CANDU.

I believe CANDU is a recognized household name, especially within the markets where they exist. In Ontario, those in and around Toronto and that region very much know where their power is coming from and the connectedness to CANDUs.

How the technology works is still slightly unknown. It's something we can very much improve upon through our STEM programs.

Internationally, those countries that have CANDUs.... When I travel around and go to conferences and people hear that I'm Canadian, they bring forward the name CANDU to me, rather than the other way around. I think it has a proven track record internationally....

The Chair Liberal Terry Duguid

Do you have brain freeze?

Noon

Deputy Vice-President, Science and Technology, Canadian Nuclear Laboratories

Dr. Colin Judge

It was contemplation.

Noon

Liberal

The Chair Liberal Terry Duguid

Mr. Saini, you have the chance for a quick question.

Noon

Liberal

Gurbux Saini Liberal Fleetwood—Port Kells, BC

I'm going back to George.

As you know, in Pinawa, Manitoba, the reactor is being decommissioned. Given the need for nuclear power, do you see a future for it now?

Noon

President and Chief Executive Officer, Canadian Nuclear Association

George Christidis

I may actually defer to colleagues who run the lab in Manitoba, where the facility is being decommissioned.

From our perspective, we certainly see nuclear power being reconsidered by a number of key provinces, including Manitoba. Could that provide an opportunity to consider how small reactors are developed and/or included in Manitoba? That's an open question. It has been discussed at a certain level.

Particularly on that site, I would defer to CNL to maybe—

Noon

Liberal

The Chair Liberal Terry Duguid

Even though I'm from Manitoba, give a quick answer, please.

Noon

Vice-President, Corporate Affairs, Canadian Nuclear Laboratories

Eric McGoey

The Whiteshell nuclear laboratories site is one of the sites that CNL operates. We are decommissioning that reactor, and I think it's an amazing site. It's a really impressive resource that we have for Canadians.

When you look at the size of the hot cells there and you look at the potential economic future of that site, there are a lot of possibilities for the site for the benefit of Canadians. Fundamental to realizing those opportunities is that we have to clean it up. We have to do the the decommissioning and the restoration to prepare that site for a new future use, and that's what we're focused on.

Noon

Liberal

The Chair Liberal Terry Duguid

Thank you so much. I really appreciated that.

Colleagues, we usually don't do a third round, but I see we have some suggested speakers.

Mr. Bélanger, I'll give you three minutes, if that's okay, and then we'll give equal time to the other side. We'll then take a break to set up for our new witnesses. We have only two witnesses, so we'll make up a little time in the next round.

Please go ahead.

12:05 p.m.

Conservative

Jim Belanger Conservative Sudbury East—Manitoulin—Nickel Belt, ON

Thank you, Mr. Chair.

I'm going to address my question to Mr. Judge.

In your commentary, I found something very interesting. You were talking about nuclear energy that is mostly done with fission and the opportunity to go to fusion. That really interests me. I'd like to know why. I guess it creates a lot more energy.

Tell me why it's so much better, what the current risks are and why it's more difficult to use that process.