Evidence of meeting #50 for Natural Resources in the 45th Parliament, 1st session. (The original version is on Parliament’s site, as are the minutes.) The winning word was reactor.

A video is available from Parliament.

On the agenda

Members speaking

Before the committee

Mousseau  Scientific Director, Trottier Energy Institute, Polytechnique Montréal, As an Individual
Boutziouvis  Chief of Staff International—Nuclear, AtkinsRéalis
Coupland  Senior Adviser, X-energy Canada
Gitzel  Chief Executive Officer, Cameco Corporation
Cameron  Manager, Public Affairs and Communications, Canadian Nuclear Isotope Council
Gidda  Global Leader, Future Energy, GHD Limited
Varah  Nuclear Energy Leader, GHD Limited

The Chair Liberal Terry Duguid

I call this meeting to order.

Colleagues, welcome. Let me acknowledge, as we always do, that we're gathered on the unceded territory of the Algonquin Anishinabe.

Welcome to meeting number 50 of the House of Commons Standing Committee on Natural Resources. It seems like yesterday. Today's meeting is taking place in hybrid format, pursuant to the Standing Orders. Members are attending in person in the room or remotely using the Zoom application.

I would like to remind participants of the following points.

Please wait until I recognize you by name before speaking. For those participating by video conference, click on the microphone icon to activate your mic, and please mute yourself when you are not speaking. For those on Zoom, at the bottom of your screen, you can select the appropriate channel for interpretation: floor audio, English or French. For those in the room, you can use the earpiece and select the desired channel.

Speaking of interpreters, folks, I ask your indulgence: Speak at a measured pace, so the interpreters can translate your words.

I remind you that all comments should be addressed through the chair. For members in the room, if you wish to speak, please raise your hand. For members on Zoom, please use the raise hand function. The clerk and I will manage the speaking order as best as we can. We appreciate your patience and understanding in this regard.

Mr. Patzer.

4:45 p.m.

Conservative

Jeremy Patzer Conservative Swift Current—Grasslands—Kindersley, SK

Thank you.

I want to do this quickly, before we start: At the last meeting, there was one motion that we said we could defer to today. I wonder if, right off the top, we could get that business out of the way. I wonder if I could move that motion.

Do you want me to read it quickly?

The Chair Liberal Terry Duguid

Colleagues, do we need to read it? It was a procedural motion.

4:45 p.m.

Conservative

Jeremy Patzer Conservative Swift Current—Grasslands—Kindersley, SK

It was one that the parties had all agreed upon already. At the last meeting, it's one that we talked about passing, but we agreed to defer it to today.

Should we pass it quickly, before we start?

The Chair Liberal Terry Duguid

It was to give members associate membership so they can receive materials.

We're good. There's no need for a motion if we are all agreed.

Some hon. members

Agreed.

Jeremy Patzer Conservative Swift Current—Grasslands—Kindersley, SK

That's perfect.

Thank you.

The Chair Liberal Terry Duguid

Thank you, Mr. Patzer.

Pursuant to Standing Order 108(2) and the motion adopted by the committee on Wednesday, October 7, 2026, the committee resumes its study of Canada's nuclear future.

I'd like to welcome our witnesses.

As an individual, we have Normand Mousseau, scientific director, Institut de l'énergie Trottier, Polytechnique Montréal, by video conference. From AtkinsRéalis, we have Sam Boutziouvis, chief of staff international for nuclear. From X-energy, we have Steve Coupland, senior adviser.

Welcome, all.

Colleagues, as you know, all virtual witnesses have conducted a mandatory witness onboarding test.

Gentlemen, you will each have five minutes for your opening remarks, after which we will open the floor to questions.

We're going to start with you, Mr. Mousseau. You have the floor for five minutes.

Normand Mousseau Scientific Director, Trottier Energy Institute, Polytechnique Montréal, As an Individual

Mr. Chair, members of the committee, thank you for inviting me to appear.

Before I begin, allow me to briefly introduce myself. I am a professor of physics at the University of Montreal and Scientific Director of the Trottier Energy Institute at Polytechnique Montréal. Among other things, my remarks draw on the work we are conducting at the Institute on transforming Canada's energy system within a global context of energy transition based on the accelerated electrification of energy services. This work includes our flagship publication, Canadian Energy Outlook, from the Trottier Energy Institute.

The global energy crises of recent years, caused largely by Russia's war against Ukraine and the attacks by the United States and Israel against Iran, coupled with global efforts to reduce greenhouse gas emissions—which are continuing despite Canada's marked setback in this area—and the emergence of new electricity-intensive sectors, have reignited interest in nuclear power worldwide. This trend, as you know, is very positive for Canada. I'd like to raise three specific points on this matter.

First, let's consider the strengths and weaknesses of nuclear energy. The strengths of nuclear energy are significant: a small footprint, a high capacity factor, low greenhouse gas emissions and, in the case of Canadian nuclear reactor technology, or CANDU, a wholly domestic industry. However, nuclear power continues to suffer from high costs at a time when the price of renewable technologies, particularly solar and batteries, continues to fall. It also lacks the flexibility to respond swiftly to major fluctuations in demand, particularly in the context of the electrification of heating, has a long deployment time frame—often exceeding a decade—and faces uncertainties regarding related technologies, including, among others, small modular nuclear reactors.

Thus, it is important not to be blinded by the industry's sweeping promises, but to properly understand the true role of nuclear power in a rapidly electrifying world.

First, despite its costs, nuclear power ensures a basic energy supply and public safety while reducing the public's exposure to global crises. However, its lack of flexibility means it cannot directly support intermittent renewable energy sources or manage seasonal peaks in demand. Therefore, the share of nuclear power must remain relatively small within the electricity generation mix in order to keep costs down while still providing a reliable service.

Then, if Canada wishes to maintain an industrial sector, it must prioritize technologies it already owns rather than importing American technologies.

Finally, we must draw on lessons learned from the refurbishment of CANDU reactor cores when planning new builds, as this will reduce some of the risks associated with reactors during the construction of new units.

That was my first point about nuclear energy.

Second, we must not forget to support research in the nuclear sector by allocating funds to it. If Canada is serious about developing the nuclear market, both at home and internationally, we must focus on training the workforce, which requires substantial and sustained support for fundamental and applied research. But support programs come and go, which greatly complicates the recruitment of lecturers, the development of training programs and the recruitment of students.

Although it is possible, in the world of research, to receive support from non-targeted funding, it is absolutely essential that, in a context that seeks to deploy nuclear power, sustainable research and maintenance funding be established to ensure the training of staff, but also to ensure access to the high value-added knowledge that requires.

Finally, Canada cannot be content merely to support the nuclear sector in the electricity or energy fields—it must also explore and support other cutting-edge sectors. Photovoltaic solar and wind power technologies are already mature, so there is little room for further gains in those areas. However, in other sectors, such as large-scale, long-term energy storage, for example, technologies are still being developed. Canada, given its climate, has a direct interest in this area. It therefore seems urgent to me that Canada identify sectors beyond nuclear power where its contribution could also be significant, and that it make efforts similar to those that led to the creation of the CANDU reactor.

Those are my three points. I'll stop there.

Thank you very much. I'd be very pleased to answer your questions.

The Chair Liberal Terry Duguid

Thank you, Mr. Mousseau.

Mr. Boutziouvis, you have the floor for five minutes.

Sam Boutziouvis Chief of Staff International—Nuclear, AtkinsRéalis

Thank you, Mr. Chair.

Thank you for the opportunity to appear before your committee. AtkinsRéalis and the Canadian nuclear industry have long asked for the development of a Canadian nuclear energy strategy. We're pleased that through the work done by this committee, members of Parliament and broader consultations with industry, the government has developed a very strong nuclear energy strategy.

CANDU technology figures prominently throughout the strategy, which will benefit employees of some 300 to 400 suppliers, communities, and fundamentally energy users, both domestically and internationally. The world is turning to nuclear energy as a safe, reliable source of non-emitting energy. Canada is one of only six countries that export nuclear power reactor technology. CANDU is the only technology that does not require enriched fuel. It's a proven technology, as was just indicated earlier by Professor Mousseau, and we are working expeditiously through the regulatory design assessment process, getting ready to build.

There are many opportunities to export our CANDU technology—your CANDU technology. Just last week, AtkinsRéalis was very pleased and honoured to join Prime Minister Carney, Minister Hodgson, Minister Anand and several MPs highlighting the benefits of CANDU technology in Turkey. Minister Hodgson, Minister Anand and others have noted the importance of this export opportunity and others. Certainly Prime Minister Carney did at the end of his state visit.

Equally important is that there are multiple opportunities to deploy CANDU units in Canada. Ontario is looking to develop at least 12 large conventional reactors. New Brunswick, Saskatchewan and Alberta are also looking at building large conventional nuclear reactors and potentially small modular reactors and microreactors as well. CANDU is actively involved in all these opportunities and is competing for them.

AtkinsRéalis is currently offering three updated versions of the CANDU reactor. Enhanced CANDU 6 is a 750-megawatt electric unit based on the very successful reactors built around the world in the 2000s. The second offering is the Monark-D, a replication of the current Darlington four-pack design in southwestern Ontario and the Bruce Peninsula, with the same reactor core, updated for today's codes and standards, offering 950 megawatts electric. The third, to Professor Mousseau's point, is a previously approved advanced fuel CANDU reactor, which burns spent fuel from light water reactors developed in collaboration, in a very intensive joint research effort, with China National Nuclear Corporation in the 2000s. That reactor is also ready to go. We have a lot of interest in burning spent fuel.

The Monark-D design is being developed in collaboration with both Ontario utilities and represents what they consider the ideal CANDU technology to meet Ontario's growing electricity needs, with the added benefit of the production of life-saving medical isotopes.

AtkinsRéalis and its team Canada partners and utility clients have been working closely with the Canadian Nuclear Safety Commission. AtkinsRéalis and its partners have been engaged with the Canadian Nuclear Safety Commission in a preliminary regulatory design assessment process. Based on the productive dialogue we've had with CNSC, our team Canada partners, and utilities, there is a credible path for the Monark-D to meet Canadian regulatory requirements without significant design changes. Those team Canada partners include BWXT, Kinectrics, Hatch and Aecon, to name a few, in the development of the standard plant. This puts the Monark-D in a position to move forward with site-specific design ahead of any other reactor design.

As members are fully aware, Canada is currently facing a strong trade challenge from our neighbour to the south. Over the past decade plus, the Canadian nuclear industry has been involved in the refurbishment of Ontario's nuclear fleet. It's been on time and on budget. Professor Mousseau referred to it in his opening remarks. There are over 300 companies involved in the CANDU ecosystem, and over 92% of a new CANDU unit is Canadian content. Our supply chain is already fully operational, spooled up and ready to go. This is a major advantage for the CANDU technology. No other technology comes close to having such a fully developed and operationally ready Canadian supply chain.

In addition to providing energy security, a domestic Monark-D build-out would provide a major economic boost. Studies indicate that a build would provide over $90 billion of Canadian GDP across Canada over an 88-year lifespan of a four-unit project: $41 billion would be for construction and $50 billion would be for operations. In addition, 33,500 full-time equivalent jobs per year over the nine years of construction would be created.

The Chair Liberal Terry Duguid

I'll have to ask you to finish up.

4:55 p.m.

Chief of Staff International—Nuclear, AtkinsRéalis

Sam Boutziouvis

In closing, I'd like to emphasize that Atkins is proud to be the custodian of CANDU's homegrown nuclear technology and is looking forward to building new CANDU units in Canada and around the world.

Make no mistake, distinguished members and Chair: The selling of CANDU around the world must begin at home, with a strong endorsement of the homegrown, Canadian-owned CANDU technology in Ontario, New Brunswick, Alberta and Saskatchewan.

I look forward to your questions. Thanks.

The Chair Liberal Terry Duguid

Thank you so much.

We're now on to Mr. Coupland.

You have the floor for five minutes.

Steve Coupland Senior Adviser, X-energy Canada

Thank you very much for the opportunity. I'm pleased to be here.

By way of background, I spent 20 years as Bruce Power's representative here in Ottawa. For part of that time, I was seconded to the Canadian Nuclear Association, where I was the director of regulatory and environmental affairs. I raise this because during that period I was given an opportunity to participate in a number of studies and reviews of various SMR technologies. When I retired from Bruce Power at the end of 2022, I made a beeline for X-energy, because I believe its technology is a perfect fit for Canada.

As committee members know, much of our wealth and standard of living depend on our resource extraction industry and the industrial base that supports it. The world is increasingly demanding that those resources be developed with minimal emissions. X-energy's technology can be used to reduce the greenhouse gases from those facilities.

X-energy is an advanced reactor-engineering, fuel-design and manufacturing company. Our flagship products are the generation four high-temperature, gas-cooled reactor and the tristructural, isotopic advanced nuclear fuel that powers it, commonly known as Triso-X. Our 80-megawatt electric 200 thermal reactors are grouped in sets of four, totalling what we call a four-unit plant. Up to 12 units can be put together, totalling roughly one gigawatt, and they can be combined to use a single control room to operate. The versatile and scalable Xe-100 design meets a wide range of energy needs across a variety of geographic conditions and markets.

As noted in Canada's national nuclear energy strategy, generation four high-temperature reactors like the Xe-100 can play a vital role in decarbonizing heavy industry. Our ability to generate highly reliable electricity and high-temperature steam at 565°C can readily replace current fossil fuel cogeneration capacity, which is integral to reducing emissions from multiple industrial applications across Canada. These emissions are some of the most challenging to abate. The Xe-100 reactor is an excellent alternative to generate the steam required for these facilities, while simultaneously supplying excess power to the grid.

Our proprietary Triso-X fuel fabrication process encapsulates uranium kernels in high-temperature-tolerant carbon and ceramic layers and then embeds them in a graphite matrix to form our Triso-X fuel pebbles, which largely look like cue balls. Triso fuel has more than 60 years of demonstrated performance in prototype and full-scale reactors.

The U.S. DOE has invested over $500 million in developing, irradiating and testing the fuel, which has led to its strong safety and proliferation-resistant characteristics. The fuel is designed to retain all radioactive waste and fission products under all conditions. It therefore leads to an exceptional safety case. The U.S. DOE has referred to it as “the most robust...fuel on earth”.

Our Xe-100 uses a helium coolant in the reactor and requires no spent-fuel cooling ponds. It can use air-cooled condensers. This significantly reduces water consumption compared with traditional large reactors and other light water SMRs. It enables deployment in locations where traditional nuclear reactors cannot be sited due to limited water availability, such as parts of Alberta and Saskatchewan.

X-energy has a commercial pipeline of approximately 11.5 gigawatts, or 140 units. Our first 320-megawatt project is a cogeneration plant with Dow Chemical in Texas and is targeted to begin operations in the early 2030s. At that point, it will be the first SMR deployed on an industrial site in the western world. Our additional projects in the U.S. are with Energy Northwest in Washington state and American Electric Power in Indiana. These are backed by Amazon, with both projects targeted to supply nearly one gigawatt to AWS data centres. Amazon is a significant investor in X-energy and has provided early project development capital for X-energy projects that will supply power to their data centres, with a minimum target of five gigawatts by the end of the 2030s.

In the U.K., X-energy has partnered with Centrica to deploy up to six gigawatts, with Hartlepool identified as the first potential site.

Here in Canada, we've been actively involved in the nuclear and energy sector for over five years. In 2022, X-energy and OPG entered into a framework agreement to work exclusively with each other to advance nuclear power industrial applications in Ontario. We are also keenly interested in other provinces looking to deploy SMRs, particularly Saskatchewan and Alberta, where we think our technology is an excellent fit.

Additionally, we have completed phase one of two of the CNSC vendor design review program, resulting in the CNSC concluding that there are no fundamental barriers to licensing the Xe-100 in Canada.

While we don't currently have an approved Canadian project, Canada remains one of our top-priority markets. We continue to work with potential customers and explore supply chain opportunities.

Thank you. I look forward to the questions.

The Chair Liberal Terry Duguid

Thank you, Mr. Coupland.

Thank you to all of our witnesses.

We'll start our rounds of questions.

Madam Anstey, we'll start with you for six minutes.

5:05 p.m.

Conservative

Carol Anstey Conservative Long Range Mountains, NL

Thank you, Mr. Chair, and thank you to the witnesses for being here with us today.

Mr. Coupland, I'd like to start with you.

You've referenced other projects that you've been a part of. X-energy previously identified Alberta as a potential location for its first advanced small modular reactor in Canada by the early 2030s. Meanwhile, as you've mentioned, your company has been advancing reactor projects in the United States and the United Kingdom.

What are the biggest barriers preventing X-energy from moving forward with the commercial reactor project in Canada?

5:05 p.m.

Senior Adviser, X-energy Canada

Steve Coupland

I would say that there are two things.

The first is that we'd be the first of a kind in Canada. My old CEO used to have an expression that nuclear is a mad dash to go second.

Voices

Oh, oh!

5:05 p.m.

Senior Adviser, X-energy Canada

Steve Coupland

Part of the challenge, frankly, is upfront capital.

One of the reasons we've moved forward in the United States is that the Department of Energy developed something called the “advanced reactor deployment program”, which puts significant funding to first-of-a-kind programs.

In our pre-budget submission, we were asking the Government of Canada to consider doing something similar here. It doesn't need to be to the same level as the program in the United States, because by the time we put forward a first-of-a-kind project here, we will already have projects in the U.S. Some of that initial work will have already been done, but there are different projects and differences in regulatory regimes and other things here in Canada that will need to be addressed.

I think the other challenge for us is that we are in fact a technology new to Canada, and it's about getting Canadians used to it. Alberta and Saskatchewan are both quite keen on nuclear, but they are new to it—in terms of the reactor side, anyhow. Both governments have done significant work. We've had a number of conversations out there. I'm reasonably optimistic that we're moving forward with some opportunities, but it's a slow process.

5:05 p.m.

Conservative

Carol Anstey Conservative Long Range Mountains, NL

You mentioned regulatory. I'm wondering, are our regulatory timelines competitive with those of the United States?

5:05 p.m.

Senior Adviser, X-energy Canada

Steve Coupland

They are not anymore, to be blunt. It's much easier to build a reactor in the U.S. than it is in Canada right now.

I will say we're very pleased to see the government's decision to move to a single project authority. It's been our view and the view of the Canadian industry for a long time that the full life cycle regulator, the CNSC, should have been the correct place to have the regulatory process, including impact assessment. We're pleased to see that.

The CNSC itself is one of the most respected regulators in the world, but improvement could still be made to its processes. I would suggest several different things. The U.S. and the U.K. have undergone a reset of their process. There has been a consolidation of the approvals process, establishment of firm timelines and a shift toward a risk-informed framework that, frankly, has eliminated a lot of the prescriptive requirements and those not tied directly to safety outcomes. We think there's a lot the CNSC could learn from the U.K. and the U.S. in that format.

There are also several things specific to X-energy that I'd like to raise with this committee. I've raised them with CNSC and NRCan. First, as I mentioned, by the time X-energy files a licence application in Canada, we'll have a licence in the United States from the NRC, and possibly one from the U.K. as well. While the CNSC has to review the technology from a Canadian perspective, the fundamentals on nuclear physics, fuel and other nuclear components won't change. CNSC should take advantage of the work done by the NRC or the U.K. to make it a more efficient process.

Also, because the Xe standard design is less complex than larger reactors and we have a much smaller nuclear island, reviews for subsequent sites should focus on site-specific issues and any changes to standard design—most likely seismic qualifications, for example—rather than make us go through a process design for a first-of-a-kind reactor.

Last, if I might, we'd also like to see a streamlined regulatory approach for projects that are industrial brownfield sites, particularly ones that have a previous federal or provincial EA, are well-characterized, are already monitored and have significant background. Again, we don't think we need to go to square one on that.

5:10 p.m.

Conservative

Carol Anstey Conservative Long Range Mountains, NL

Based on all those things that you outlined, what specific change do you think would make the biggest impact?

5:10 p.m.

Senior Adviser, X-energy Canada

Steve Coupland

I think there are two things. You said one; I'm going to go with two.

One is putting everything under the life cycle regulator, as the government is intending to do. The other is the CNSC adapting some of the improvements that have been made by other regulators.

The Chair Liberal Terry Duguid

Thank you both.

Mr. Hogan, you have six minutes.