Evidence of meeting #50 for Natural Resources in the 45th Parliament, 1st session. (The original version is on Parliament’s site, as are the minutes.) The winning word was reactor.

A video is available from Parliament.

On the agenda

Members speaking

Before the committee

Mousseau  Scientific Director, Trottier Energy Institute, Polytechnique Montréal, As an Individual
Boutziouvis  Chief of Staff International—Nuclear, AtkinsRéalis
Coupland  Senior Adviser, X-energy Canada
Gitzel  Chief Executive Officer, Cameco Corporation
Cameron  Manager, Public Affairs and Communications, Canadian Nuclear Isotope Council
Gidda  Global Leader, Future Energy, GHD Limited
Varah  Nuclear Energy Leader, GHD Limited

5:25 p.m.

Conservative

Jeremy Patzer Conservative Swift Current—Grasslands—Kindersley, SK

Yes, absolutely. Go for it.

The Chair Liberal Terry Duguid

Yes, please.

5:25 p.m.

Chief of Staff International—Nuclear, AtkinsRéalis

Sam Boutziouvis

Not to compete with Mr. Coupland for “isms”, but we tend to say inside our company, “Big or small, we need them all.” Because there is so much electricity demand for clean—or that should be clean—we feel very strongly that eventually there will be SMRs and microreactors developed, per Mr. Simard's point, once they become more economical in terms of electricity price and once they start getting built. This is what's happening in southwestern Ontario with DNNP, in the U.K. with respect to Rolls-Royce SMR, and in the United States in Texas and in the Pacific northwest, where we're helping out.

To your point, sir, about the current government's position, my perspective is that there have been tremendous investments made in SMR technologies, the first of a kind. There's been a tremendous weeding-out period, especially with those first-of-a-kind technologies. Some have gone on, and some have gone away, because they just have not been economical.

The Chair Liberal Terry Duguid

Thank you, all.

Mr. Saini, you have five minutes.

Gurbux Saini Liberal Fleetwood—Port Kells, BC

Thank you, Mr. Chair.

Thank you to the witnesses for this important work that you are doing.

I'm going to go to Sam.

The nuclear energy strategy identified CANDU exports as an important opportunity for Canada. What would close coordination among the federal government, province, utility and industry help achieve in securing new international markets?

5:30 p.m.

Chief of Staff International—Nuclear, AtkinsRéalis

Sam Boutziouvis

From my perspective, especially for large conventional nuclear but also for SMRs, governments need to be hand in glove with the private sector in the world. That's simply because we're not just competing technology to technology; we're actually competing against other governments and their ecosystems.

We greatly appreciate that the Government of Canada has recognized that. We're joining forces around the world in order to develop not just the technical expertise in order to sell the Canadian expertise, but also the financial, regulatory and other aspects related to the Canadian nuclear ecosystem being accepted abroad as viable in terms of a 100-year partnership with those countries.

I raise a very important point about regulatory, and it's been raised before. The Canadian Nuclear Safety Commission, yes, of course, needs to make constant improvements, but it is a world-class regulatory agency. It is in high demand around the world, and that's because it does its job really well. We find that, in particular, countries new to nuclear are very interested to learn from the CNSC with the Government of Canada and the entire ecosystem.

The provinces are a very important point. The ministers of energy for Ontario, Saskatchewan.... The premier of Saskatchewan has been abroad, promoting nuclear from a Canadian standpoint, and this is really welcome. The same goes for other provinces that already have nuclear, such as New Brunswick.

There is a drought of capacity building. Professor Mousseau did raise it very much. We see the expertise of existing utilities as part and parcel of selling CANDU abroad as folded into a total package to sell capacity building abroad as well. There are discussions under way now with various provinces and their utilities in order to take the expertise they have in terms of operating CANDU plants and export it abroad. It is very much a federal-provincial major agency effort in the Canadian ecosystem.

Thank you.

Gurbux Saini Liberal Fleetwood—Port Kells, BC

Thank you.

My next question will be for Steve Coupland.

The federal government is investing in Canada's nuclear innovation ecosystem, including $2.2 billion over 10 years for Chalk River Laboratories, with an initial $40 million in 2026-27 to assess Canadian-controlled microreactors for potential use at remote and northern defence facilities.

How can federal research infrastructure and early development opportunities help Canadian companies develop the expertise and supply chains needed to compete in the advanced reactor market?

5:30 p.m.

Senior Adviser, X-energy Canada

Steve Coupland

There are two parts to that. We're not a microreactor. We are developing a microreactor, but we don't have one that's operational right now. We're a little bit larger than microreactors. They're generally considered to be 10 megawatts and under. We're not in that field.

Ours is a little larger and costs a bit more, but advanced reactors cost a lot of money to develop. There is a reason the leading advanced reactor companies, including mine, are based in the U.S. It is capital. There were two companies in Canada that tried to develop reactors here—ARC and Terrestrial. Both ended up moving to the U.S. for the ability to get capital.

The Chair Liberal Terry Duguid

I'll have to stop you there, unfortunately, Mr. Coupland.

Thank you both.

Mr. Simard, you have the floor for two and a half minutes.

Mario Simard Bloc Jonquière—Hébertville—Pays-des-Bleuets, QC

Thank you very much, Mr. Chair.

I'm going to address all three of you.

I've been here since 2019, I've been hearing about small modular reactors since 2019—and not one has been built yet. If I understand correctly, one is being built in Ontario. So I have questions about Canada's capacity to carry out this type of project.

First, do we have the required workforce and expertise?

Second, if they try to build a new CANDU reactor, how long might it take?

I suppose they can't carry out two projects concurrently, so there must be considerable logistical problems and challenges. So how long does it take to build a small modular reactor? Can two or three be built simultaneously, and is it the same for CANDU technology? How long does it take?

Is it possible to envision building two or three projects at the same time, or is that unthinkable?

5:35 p.m.

Chief of Staff International—Nuclear, AtkinsRéalis

Sam Boutziouvis

It's a great question.

The shortest time in which a CANDU reactor has been built was four years and 11 months. That's really incredible. We hope to achieve similar construction times, should CANDU be chosen in Ontario, around the world or in other provinces. That does not include site development and final engineering, which could take one, two or three years. Overall, therefore, from start to finish, from final engineering of the site to nuclear concrete, where you turn on the reactor, is between eight and nine years, as long as the construction is approximately five years in length, based on the very quick construction time I indicated.

In the 1970s and 1980s, the Government of Canada, with AECL and the province, was building reactors two at a time. They built 22 reactors in approximately 20 years, if memory serves.

The Chair Liberal Terry Duguid

Thank you both.

Mr. Kelly, you have five minutes.

5:35 p.m.

Conservative

Pat Kelly Conservative Calgary Crowfoot, AB

I misunderstood you, Mr. Chair. I thought we were wrapping up.

The Chair Liberal Terry Duguid

Ms. Romanado is chomping at the bit. We're doing five and five.

5:35 p.m.

Conservative

Pat Kelly Conservative Calgary Crowfoot, AB

I'd like to pick up on the same line of questioning that Mr. Patzer had about—if I remember correctly—what the regulatory bottlenecks are that might exist in the current regulations for your industry and solutions that you might want to propose to this committee, if you have any.

Go ahead. Each of you can take a turn on that one.

5:35 p.m.

Senior Adviser, X-energy Canada

Steve Coupland

I'll jump in to start.

I did try to touch on a couple of things. Taking some of the lessons from the U.S. and the U.K., in particular the shift, they've moved towards a risk-informed framework and the elimination of what we would call “overly prescriptive” requirements that are not tied directly to safety benefits.

There is the Canadian Nuclear Safety Commission. As Sam said, they are one of the best in the world, but safety starts with the operators and with the developers. The job of the regulator is to oversee that and to ensure that we don't slip up on any of that. They do a great job of it. We've never had problems in this country. We have a very good track record. However, I do think they could benefit by putting in a more risk-informed approach. I don't think that treating a small modular reactor with a very safe fuel is the same as a multi-station, multisized 4,000-megawatt unit. I think things could be looked at based on being risk-informed and based on, frankly, operating records in other countries.

5:40 p.m.

Conservative

Pat Kelly Conservative Calgary Crowfoot, AB

It would require regulatory change in Canada to remove some of the barriers, notwithstanding which technology....

5:40 p.m.

Senior Adviser, X-energy Canada

Steve Coupland

Yes, a change in.... I would suggest there are some changes in the legislation and, frankly, some in regulations, a lot in regulatory documents and in how the CNSC looks at things. They include an awful lot of “shall” and “will” statements in their regulatory documents, which don't allow the flexibility. One thing we based our regulatory system on was the flexibility to prove your safety case. When you start putting “shall” and “will” in regulatory documents, that takes away the flexibility.

5:40 p.m.

Conservative

Pat Kelly Conservative Calgary Crowfoot, AB

Okay. Do you have any really narrow, specific ones that you could...? We're going to table a report in Parliament, and this is your chance to get evidence in for recommendations.

5:40 p.m.

Senior Adviser, X-energy Canada

Steve Coupland

I don't have it off the top of my head, but I could come back with a few or submit some.

5:40 p.m.

Conservative

Pat Kelly Conservative Calgary Crowfoot, AB

Okay, you can table them later if you'd like.

5:40 p.m.

Senior Adviser, X-energy Canada

Steve Coupland

Absolutely.

Pat Kelly Conservative Calgary Crowfoot, AB

I'll maybe give whatever time we have left to Mr. Boutziouvis to add to that.

5:40 p.m.

Chief of Staff International—Nuclear, AtkinsRéalis

Sam Boutziouvis

Sure.

First of all, the legislation currently before you for voting is extremely strong and broadly supported by the Canadian Chamber of Commerce, the Canadian Nuclear Association, other associations and various actors in the private sector, including us, broadly. It brings greater certainty and faster project approvals. There are benefits for major energy and nuclear projects. There's increased investment attractiveness, because there are clearer timelines and coordinated reviews. It helps with respect to our export ambitions because of that clarity. There is a one project, one review model, which is extremely important for the Canadian private sector, speaking broadly beyond AtkinsRéalis.

There is a Groundhog Day problem or challenge, which could encourage refinement, and it is this: When the one-year clock begins, you could repeatedly request additional information once the one-year clock starts, and then what? When you request information, does it restart the clock? I think clarity with respect to starting the clock and ending it on a timely basis is a relevant refinement that could be considered.

Really clarifying regulator accountability, I think, would be welcomed among the CNSC, the Impact Assessment Agency and the Canadian Energy Regulator. I realize you need to get this bill passed as soon as you possibly can. However, very importantly, you need to ensure that the agencies have capacity. If there's one thing I would advocate, it's to increase the dollars and the number of people associated with the regulator, so they can do their jobs. More—

The Chair Liberal Terry Duguid

Thank you. It's a good way to end.

Ms. Romanado, you have the floor for five minutes.