Evidence of meeting #18 for Public Safety and National Security in the 45th Parliament, 1st session. (The original version is on Parliament’s site, as are the minutes.) The winning word was c-8.

A recording is available from Parliament.

On the agenda

Members speaking

Before the committee

Robertson  Senior Research Associate, Citizen Lab, University of Toronto, As an Individual
de Boer  Vice-President, Government Relations, BlackBerry
Hatfield  Executive Director, OpenMedia
Warnell  Chief Information Security Officer, Bruce Power
Bradley  President and Chief Executive Officer, Electricity Canada

11:25 a.m.

Vice-President, Government Relations, BlackBerry

John de Boer

We will be concerned if that actually comes to bear, but we would like to have judicial review and the right for reasonableness.

11:25 a.m.

Conservative

Dane Lloyd Conservative Parkland, AB

Do you think the provisions in this legislation give the government the power to do that?

11:25 a.m.

Vice-President, Government Relations, BlackBerry

John de Boer

I'm not in a position to really opine on that. It's not my area of focus.

11:25 a.m.

Conservative

Dane Lloyd Conservative Parkland, AB

That's a big concern that's been raised by many stakeholders. Theoretically, if the government came to you and gave an order that your company felt would break your encryption standards, what would be the response from your company?

11:25 a.m.

Vice-President, Government Relations, BlackBerry

John de Boer

It would be problematic.

11:25 a.m.

Conservative

Dane Lloyd Conservative Parkland, AB

Would it seek a judicial review for the decision before complying with the decision or...?

11:25 a.m.

Vice-President, Government Relations, BlackBerry

John de Boer

It would be case by case. I can't comment on a fictitious scenario, but we would definitely review that.

11:25 a.m.

Conservative

Dane Lloyd Conservative Parkland, AB

Yes, it's been painted as a very real scenario by many witnesses, and it is concerning. Thank you for that.

I don't know if you could provide any briefings to this committee afterwards. If you could get that information—

11:25 a.m.

Vice-President, Government Relations, BlackBerry

John de Boer

I'm happy to do that.

11:25 a.m.

Conservative

Dane Lloyd Conservative Parkland, AB

—that would really help the committee.

Thank you.

I think that's all my time.

The Vice-Chair Bloc Claude DeBellefeuille

Thank you, Mr. Lloyd. You're making my life easy by stopping a little before your time is up.

I now give the floor to Ms. Acan for six minutes.

Sima Acan Liberal Oakville West, ON

Thank you, Madam Chair.

Mr. de Boer, I have an engineering degree in electronics engineering, and my focus was telecommunications. Throughout the years, I was in industrial automation, which you mentioned, and robotics, where communication and cybersecurity were at the core. That's why my questions will be for you.

You previously testified in support of the objectives of the predecessor to this bill, Bill C-26. Given the scale of cyber-threats to essential services, can you elaborate on why a legislative framework like Bill C-8 is necessary for Canada's cybersecurity posture, particularly within the federally regulated telecommunications sector?

December 4th, 2025 / 11:30 a.m.

Vice-President, Government Relations, BlackBerry

John de Boer

You know, as I stated in my testimony, Canada's the only G7 country without a mandatory cyber-incident reporting bill or a cybersecurity program for critical infrastructure. This has been a long time coming. The threat landscape has evolved significantly, so in order to actually protect critical services, it is absolutely essential.

This is a start. We're focusing on four federally regulated sectors here, but we know that similar approaches need to be taken in other critical sectors as well.

The reality is that Canada works closely with its allies. We have Five Eyes allies and others. If they see us out of step, if they see that our critical infrastructure is not adequately protected, then that could also erode trust in our systems. So, I think it's very important.

Sima Acan Liberal Oakville West, ON

Thank you very much.

You actually lead into my second question.

You have advocated for harmonizing Canada's cybersecurity framework with Five Eyes partners. Beyond just compliance and incident reporting, what specific mechanisms adopted by other jurisdictions—like the U.K., Australia or the U.S.—that are related to balancing operational security needs with transparency should Canada adopt to strengthen Bill C-8?

11:30 a.m.

Vice-President, Government Relations, BlackBerry

John de Boer

One area that may be of interest would be, first of all, ensuring liability protection for good-faith reporting. That needs to be strengthened within this bill to align with, for instance, the United States and also the EU and Australia.

With regard to other incidents, things we could clarify would be what kind of cyber-incident would qualify under the reporting. Currently, as it's defined in this bill, it's any incident that affects the continuity or security of a vital system. In the United States, in Europe and in Australia, they've added “significant” to it. I think there needs to be further.... I know this will be outlined in regulations, but it's important that we make certain distinctions.

Sima Acan Liberal Oakville West, ON

Thank you.

From the perspective of a technology company serving both government and the private sector, how do you perceive the necessity of expanded government regulation and security-critical infrastructure, and how does this duty balance with the responsibilities borne by private, designated operators under the proposed critical cyber-systems protection act?

11:30 a.m.

Vice-President, Government Relations, BlackBerry

John de Boer

In order to respond effectively, and I think the Canadian government has made some strides here, it needs to be a public-private partnership. There is an onus also on the private sector to ensure that their products are secure and meet a standard that is acceptable for critical infrastructure in particular. Notions like “secure by design” are really important in understanding third party supply chain security risks. For BlackBerry, this is why we take certifications of our products very seriously. We get certifications from national authorities to ensure that our products are approved products.

I think it's really critical that the Government of Canada signal to critical infrastructure and the rest of Canada that it's important to use products that are secure, and that private industry also work to build secure products instead of just immediately releasing products that may have flaws contained in them. Bolting on security after the fact does not work.

Sima Acan Liberal Oakville West, ON

Thank you very much.

Do I have time, Madam Chair? Okay.

In your previous testimony on Bill C-26, you specifically recommended that Bill C-8 harmonize cyber-incident reporting requirements with Five Eyes nations, as you mentioned. One of the objectives of Bill C-8 is to modernize our cybersecurity framework with those partners. Could you speak to how this legislation aligns now with Five Eyes partners in relation to incident reporting and compliance?

11:30 a.m.

Vice-President, Government Relations, BlackBerry

John de Boer

Absolutely. With respect to incident reporting and compliance, as I mentioned in my testimony, in the United States there is mandatory cyber-incident reporting covering 16 critical infrastructure sectors. They must be reported within 24—

The Vice-Chair Bloc Claude DeBellefeuille

I'm sorry to interrupt you, Mr. de Boer, but Ms. Acan's time is up. You can finish your answer in another round.

It's now my turn to have six minutes to ask the witnesses a few questions, as agreed.

My first question is for Ms. Robertson.

We heard from the Privacy Commissioner about the principles of necessity and proportionality when it comes to collecting and sharing personal information. These are principles found in many acts, but they are not systematically included in Bill C‑8.

What do you think about systematically introducing these principles into Bill C‑8?

11:35 a.m.

Senior Research Associate, Citizen Lab, University of Toronto, As an Individual

Kate Robertson

I couldn't agree more with the Privacy Commissioner of Canada's remarks. I agree to the extent that the same suggestions are included in my brief under recommendation five.

The Vice-Chair Bloc Claude DeBellefeuille

Excuse me, Ms. Robertson, but I see that the French interpretation is not working. As chair of the meeting, I have to interrupt you to point that out.

The Clerk of the Committee Andrew Wilson

I just want to test to see if the translation is working in French.

It works. Thank you.

The Vice-Chair Bloc Claude DeBellefeuille

Thank you.

Could you repeat your answer, Ms. Robertson?

11:35 a.m.

Senior Research Associate, Citizen Lab, University of Toronto, As an Individual

Kate Robertson

My apologies for not being able to answer in French.

As I indicated, I completely agree with the Privacy Commissioner of Canada's remarks on the importance of this amendment to the legislation. It is included in one aspect but not comprehensively, as you noted. This is one of the really significant constitutional deficits I identified in relation to proposed section 15.4 of the legislation, which is the collection power.

Recommendation five in my brief also addresses precisely the same issue as the Privacy Commissioner of Canada testified to. I would link that not only to the privacy framework that the commissioner is responsible for but also to the constitutional principles that I've analyzed and that apply in this context.