Thank you very much.
If I could quote the remarks of Canada's intelligence commissioner, “The glaring absentee in [this legislation] is the Canadian public”, whose information, which is the subject of a reasonable expectation of privacy, is under threat of compromise in more ways than one in the legislation.
We would very much welcome the government taking a more proactive approach in ensuring that we have network-wide security standards that protect you, me and everyone watching this hearing, and their communications.
When we have raised the constitutional deficiencies around the privacy risks and cybersecurity risks, we note that the government has taken the position that this is a regulatory context where privacy interests are diminished. However, we know that the privacy interests of the individuals who use telecommunications are not in any way diminished. Human communication is not a regulatory matter. That's why we point out that the balancing exercise that's critical to protect privacy and security, in this case, is not meeting the mark.
You have recommendations from me—nine in total. We believe that these are entirely consistent with the government's purpose of the legislation, which actually creates a corresponding risk that, if available improvements are not taken, then the courts are that much more unable to understand why a constitutional violation is reasonably justified. That just really kicks the can down the road to entanglements in the courts when unconstitutional legislation is not appropriately amended to address those issues.
