Under the Constitution, the courts will look for a meaningful system of accountability. If you have an absence of transparency, a notice to individuals, including potentially the need for strict gag orders that would prevent individuals from knowing that their privacy, or other interests, have been impacted, then that thwarts their ability to meaningfully access review mechanisms. In that regard, the judicial review is inadequate from a constitutional perspective.
I'd also note that there is a reasonable best standard, and there's deference applied, which is why I recommended that we have a specific clause clarifying that this is essentially not for surveillance purposes but is about cybersecurity, because that as well would be, in the absence of such an interpretive clause, assessed on a different standard in the judicial review process.
