Yes, very much so.
I'll answer the question that was just asked: Should Bill C-8 pass in its current form? No. Should it pass in some form? Yes, potentially, if the right amendments are brought in.
It's true that our cybersecurity protections and legislation are behind those of our allies. Why are we considering legislation, then, with much weaker oversight than our allies apply? I think that's the crucial step that needs to be addressed here. The minister, alone, cannot be making these decisions. Our right to judicial review, which occurs only when we find out about the impact of a secret order that we've never seen, isn't a real right at all.
There are various bodies that could be appropriately empowered to provide oversight here. We could see NSICOP provided with much more information about what's going on in these orders so that they can judge that. However, the public needs to have a clearer view of what's going on systemically with the system as well, otherwise you could have secret orders stacked on secret orders and have a growing system that could become, really, far more about surveillance than about cybersecurity.
