We go back to the fact that the police still have to do work behind the information, even if it's basic, to be able to prove to a justice that they have enough to get more information. From the example you're giving....
I appreciate what you're trying to say. You're saying a subjective decision and a whole net of information could be gathered based on one factor. What I'm saying is that I don't think that would be reality from a policing perspective, because I have to go before a justice with an affidavit that lays out the facts that say why I believe I should be entitled to this charter-compliant information.
There are guardrails, checks and balances in the way that we get that narrow bit of information at the very beginning, at the very outset of a criminal investigation. In your example, I couldn't say what an investigator could build around one attribute.
