Evidence of meeting #53 for Status of Women in the 45th Parliament, 1st session. (The original version is on Parliament’s site, as are the minutes.) The winning word was data.

A recording is available from Parliament.

On the agenda

Members speaking

Before the committee

Emily Laidlaw  Canada Research Chair in Cybersecurity Law and Professor, Faculty of Law, University of Calgary, As an Individual
Richardson  Director, Technology, Canadian Centre for Child Protection
Lee  Director, Education and Strategy, Open Digital Literacy and Access Network
Jad Sinno  Director, Research, Community-Based Research Centre
Matyas  Vice-President, Capacity Building and Innovation, Information and Communications Technology Council
Kim  Senior Staff Lawyer, Women's Legal Education and Action Fund

11 a.m.

Conservative

The Chair Conservative Dominique Vien

I call this meeting to order.

Welcome to meeting No. 53 of the Standing Committee on the Status of Women. We are resuming our study on the impact of artificial intelligence on women, girls and 2SLGBTQIA+ people.

As usual, this meeting is taking place in a hybrid format, pursuant to the Standing Orders.

To ensure an orderly meeting, here are a few rules to follow.

I would like to remind witnesses that committee members may ask questions in either French or English. If you will need interpretation, please take a moment now to prepare your earpiece and select the listening channel required in order to take full advantage of the time allotted for questions and answers.

For those participating by videoconference, click on the microphone icon to activate your mic. Please mute yourself when you are not speaking.

For members in the room, if you wish to speak, please raise your hand. For members on Zoom, please use the “raise hand” function.

Before we welcome our witnesses, I would like to provide a trigger warning. We discuss subjects that can disturb, offend and bring back painful memories. Committee members and panellists, please let us know if you need help. The clerk will be in a position to support you.

I will now welcome our witnesses.

As an individual, we have Emily Laidlaw, Canada research chair in cybersecurity law and professor, faculty of law, University of Calgary. From the Canadian Centre for Child Protection, we have Lloyd Richardson, director, technology. From Open Digital Literacy and Access Network, we have Vivian Lee, director, education and strategy.

Welcome. We will begin with opening statements.

Dr. Laidlaw, the floor is yours for five minutes. Thank you.

Dr. Emily Laidlaw Canada Research Chair in Cybersecurity Law and Professor, Faculty of Law, University of Calgary, As an Individual

Thank you for inviting me to speak with you.

AI holds extraordinary promise, but the focus of my remarks today will be on AI safety. We are at a keen inflection point where AI is now embedded in every facet of society. However, trust in AI is low, and very little is being invested by the public and private sectors into safety. This is a problem. The buzz term is “trustworthy AI”, but this term is often used strategically. It sounds like safety, but it isn't. Thereby, it becomes a way to avoid implementing meaningful safety measures. The focus is on end-of-the-world scenarios rather than on the everyday ways that AI is already causing harm.

For the purpose of today, I want to emphasize one key message: AI does not merely reproduce existing inequality; it makes it worse. This is because AI can be used to create, scale, personalize and conceal discrimination, and it can be a tool for violence. The safety culture needs to be flipped so that AI safety, at least, is designed up front into the system, based on understanding the people and social practices at play. I do not believe this paradigm shift can be achieved through corporate governance alone, and existing laws are insufficient to meet the moment.

Let me situate this by explaining the AI harm pathway.

First is inputs and data training, and I'll offer two examples. Generative engine optimization, GEO, is the practice of creating and shaping online content so that it's attractive to generative AI systems and more likely to then inform AI outputs. It may be as simple as convincing the AI to recommend your company's mascara, to reproduce false and damaging information about a political opponent, or to reinforce negative stereotypes about women, 2SLGBTQI+ individuals and other marginalized groups.

Sometimes that discrimination in the inputs and outputs becomes the basis of decision-making harm, such as relying on AI as a recruiting tool. We all know the story of Amazon's AI tool being scrapped because it trained on old résumés, which were mostly from men, and taught itself that male candidates were preferable.

A key feature of both of these scenarios is that the bias was buried into the system.

Second is system design and operation. This is particularly acute on social media. The platforms are designed to keep users engaged in using their products and services. That's how they make their money. A few things happen here that lead to amplification of harmful content and of fuel-targeted harassment and self-harm. The platforms collect enormous amounts of information about user habits that inform the inferences made about them and that inform what algorithms and advertisers push to them. People are responsive to emotional and rage-filled content, so this pushes the most extreme content to the top of our feeds. Bad actors have figured out that they can monetize hate, and it has become a lucrative industry, fuelling discrimination and gender-based violence.

Design features make the problem worse. Children are being pushed beauty filters and are being encouraged to get plastic surgery, reinforcing unrealistic social expectations. It's an unbearable burden for children, and it's one that crosses gender lines.

Third is AI misuse. Deepfake and synthetic image abuse illustrate the problem particularly clearly. It's now easy, using AI, to create nude and nearly nude images, audio or video content. Some of this is illegal under criminal and civil law, particularly if it depicts children.

Grok is illustrative of the broader risks. It's an AI tool that was used to nudify images of mostly women, but it was also used to create other degrading images, such as women covered in bruises, tied up and gagged. Grok is integrated into X, so X's algorithm fuelled distribution of these images to wide audiences. Experiences like this send a message to women that they must be silent and invisible and that if they dare to exist in public, they will be punished and humiliated. The constant threat of sexual violence and the lack of available remedies chills meaningful participation in public life.

I'll close with the question about a federal response.

As it stands, Canadian law is fragmented and disproportionately places the burden on individuals to manage these harms. Canada does not presently have a comprehensive federal AI statute. Existing laws address parts of the problem, as will the digital safety act in Bill C-34.

A federal response should focus on shifting the burden for safety from victims to the actors in the AI supply chain: AI developers, AI platforms, and organizations that integrate AI into their products and services.

I'll close with this: The federal government should not treat innovation and safety as opposing objectives.

Thank you.

11:05 a.m.

Conservative

The Chair Conservative Dominique Vien

That was five minutes on the dot. Thank you, Ms. Laidlaw.

Mr. Richardson, you have the floor for five minutes.

Lloyd Richardson Director, Technology, Canadian Centre for Child Protection

Good morning, everyone.

My name is Lloyd Richardson. I'm the director of technology at the Canadian Centre for Child Protection. We operate Cybertip.ca, which is Canada's national tip line for reporting the online sexual exploitation of children, as well as Project Arachnid, which is a global tool designed to curb the distribution of child sexual abuse material on the Internet.

Our organization has witnessed first-hand the impact AI is having on children, particularly girls, across our country.

The development of AI has definitely delivered some societal benefits, but it has also exposed some significant safety, regulatory and ethical gaps that disproportionately affect women and girls. I think everyone here is aware of the existence of deepfake apps and websites that market the ability to nudify—creating non-consensual intimate images of people—in exchange for money or tokens. These websites offer nudification services advertised with gendered language in the interface for their customers. For example, one particular website has an action button in the interface labelled “reveal her”. This leaves very little doubt as to who this targets and what the intent is.

Additionally, all of the sample imagery on these websites features women as models for the deepfake features. While the language on these sites speaks of women, we know it's not just adult women. It's also adolescent and younger girls, based on the images we have reported to us by victims and what we encounter online.

While interventions such as removal notices can be made with websites and apps that offer deepfake or nudification services, a more challenging issue is the open-weight AI models that we see that can be freely downloaded from the Internet. On their own, some of these AI models have safeguards to prevent the creation of sexualized material. However, they can be paired with low-rank adaptations, often referred to in short as LoRAs. These LoRAs are essentially plug-ins for AI models that add new features or allow the model to create content related to a specific individual, an object or an artistic style.

Within communities of individuals with a sexual interest in children, we see requests made for the creation of these LoRAs for specific victims or survivors of child sexual abuse. This horrific use of the technology allows offenders to generate new abuse imagery depicting previously identified and rescued victims. The same technology allows someone to create child sexual abuse material of any child they're able to download, capture a picture of or take a picture of in public.

We've catalogued and issued removal notices on 100 of these unique LoRAs, and I can tell you that the overwhelming majority of the individuals represented in them are prepubescent girls.

The harms associated with these services and offender communities are reflected in what we see reported to us through the tip line or what we've detected through the tip line. Back in 2023, we assessed about 4,000 deepfake images. In 2024, it was 9,000. In 2025, we went up to 61,000. This year, we're on track for about 100,000 that we've tagged. This only represents the imagery we're able to label, and as you can see, the problem is only getting worse.

Lastly, we also see harm in the datasets used to train some of these large models. Back in 2023, we assisted Stanford research in identifying over 1,000 known child sexual abuse images in the public LAION-5B dataset. This dataset has been used to train popular models for most image generation tools out there as it's one of the largest. Once again, the overwhelming majority of these victims were girls.

In conclusion, whether it's a commercial deepfake service, freely available AI models or the datasets used to train them, we're seeing a consistent lack of guardrails in the development and deployment of generative AI. Across each of these examples, the impact falls disproportionately on women and girls.

Thank you.

11:10 a.m.

Conservative

The Chair Conservative Dominique Vien

Thank you, Mr. Richardson.

Madam Lee, the floor is yours for five minutes.

Vivian Lee Director, Education and Strategy, Open Digital Literacy and Access Network

Good morning.

I am appearing today on behalf of the Open Digital Literacy and Access Network, or ODLAN, in my role as director of education and strategy. Our non-profit's vision is to help Canadian 2SLGBTQIA+ communities grow and thrive in the digital age through safe, accessible and inclusive digital spaces. ODLAN creates resources, hosts training sessions and conducts research to work towards a more equitable online experience for 2SLGBTQIA+ people. We collaborate with dozens of grassroots organizations that serve community groups from large-scale systems like Fierté Canada Pride to kitchen table-size organizations that provide space in rural and remote communities. Essentially, we help queer and trans folks stay safe on the Internet.

Professionally, I am positioned to speak to the impact of artificial intelligence on underserved communities because I've been building curricula on generative artificial intelligence, large-scale data infrastructure, data privacy and sovereignty, and open source intelligence systems for over 10 years, with over a dozen published courses for post-secondary education institutions. My doctoral research on digital citizenship education policy has allowed me to publish on the relationship between policy and the practical implementation of technical literacy in the classroom.

I also teach an original curriculum on digital citizenship education at York. This was designed to reflect digital literacy standards in alignment with the Council of Europe and was published through their databases as an example of Canadian parallels to their digital citizenship education standards. This background has given me the opportunity to see the impact of AI at both the macro international scale and the micro classroom scale.

With my academic and educational hat on, I can confidently tell you that the majority of first-year university students are using AI multiple times a day, every day. They've been doing it since the pandemic. LLMs like ChatGPT, Gemini and Claude have been adopted by youth with the same velocity that we adopted the Internet in the 1990s—with great enthusiasm and minimal instruction, to the detriment of their mental health and critical thinking skills, atrophying their neurological pathways. This has been the equivalent of giving a toddler the keys to a Ferrari and letting them figure out how to drive it on their own. Most students know how to use AI, but very few have any technical knowledge of how it works, how the output is built on datasets heavily biased towards straight white men and how their personal data is being bought and sold on a secondary market for profit.

In my work with ODLAN, I see the implementation of AI at an organizational level. There is the same lack of foundational knowledge among its users of how data is collected, analyzed and regurgitated by these AI systems they have to adopt. Many organizations serving communities like these have no choice but to work with Google G Suite or Microsoft Office 365 licences, both of which come with mandatory artificial intelligence embedded. There's no opt-out feature, yet these two American tech giants provide the only free licence options—a necessity for a non-profit's tight budget. Queer and trans folks organizations are very concerned about their data privacy and data retention. There is no affordable, Canadian-owned and -operated alternative to cloud-based systems such as G Suite and Microsoft 365.

Google and Microsoft require consent to collect and track all user data associated with your email, cloud drives, desktop hard drives and bio data surrounding those datasets. They then sell this data on the resellers market to third party companies, beyond the user's control and knowledge, as much as they want to and for as long as they want to. These two companies also require consent to have access to all organizational data uploaded to their clouds, including the ability to review and delete anything they want, whenever they want, without prior notice to the organization. An example of this happened in October to JusticeTrans, which had their entire archival database erased by Microsoft without warning. Microsoft deleted over a decade of carefully collected primary health research.

Google and Microsoft have been quietly surveilling and erasing queer and trans datasets from non-profits globally over the past few years, without options for recovery or recourse. Why are companies like Google, Microsoft and Meta able to have absolute control over Canadian, government-funded, non-profit research and 2SLGBTQIA+ community work? We know their artificial intelligence systems screen for risky or inappropriate content and consider queer and trans people and their identities as inherently sexualized. This means that trans-inclusive mental health groups that are regularly censored or filtered as inappropriate for the general public are quietly being deleted from Facebook and Instagram.

What's the solution? How can we move towards rebalancing women and gender equity with artificial intelligence and other digital infrastructure systems? The answer lies in consent-first, self-sovereign data systems that are hosted locally in Canada. People need to be able to retain ownership of their personal identities and should have to give explicit consent for what and with whom they are sharing their personal information.

This concept already exists in our federal and provincial systems of data collection for medical health data. We could extend it to include our personal data. Canada could also implement policies similar to the European GDPR, which has the right to be forgotten. This would allow Canadians to revoke their consent of data sharing with these tech giants at any time. This premise also needs to be applied to the generative AI companies.

11:15 a.m.

Conservative

The Chair Conservative Dominique Vien

Thank you, Ms. Lee. That's all the time you had for your opening remarks. You will certainly have a chance to come back to what you said.

I would like to inform my colleagues that Ms. Laidlaw has to leave us at 11:50 a.m. If you have any questions for her, please keep that in mind.

Ms. DeRidder, you have the floor for six minutes.

11:15 a.m.

Conservative

Kelly DeRidder Conservative Kitchener Centre, ON

Thank you, Madam Chair.

I'm going to ask each of our guests a question today.

Thank you for joining us. This is a really important topic.

Through you, Chair, Dr. Laidlaw, you mentioned that tech companies need to be held accountable. I completely agree. I think that, if tech companies can design into their software algorithms things for people to stay online and continually scroll, they also have the ability to build safety into their software. They are choosing not to do so for profitability.

What measures do you think the government needs to put in place so the tech companies are accountable for the safety of their platforms?

11:15 a.m.

Canada Research Chair in Cybersecurity Law and Professor, Faculty of Law, University of Calgary, As an Individual

Dr. Emily Laidlaw

That's a great question.

The gold standard that's emerging is the idea of safety by design. That is that the companies need to assess the risks up front, put in place risk mitigation measures and then they need to assess them on an ongoing basis. The controversy is precisely where you locate that law and responsibility. Right now, some of this will, if Bill C-34 passes, be put under the role of the digital safety commission. That only addresses, though, parts of the problem that we're talking about.

I think Vivian mentions a really key point, which is over-moderation through AI of content, in particular of 2SLGBTQI+ communities and individuals. That's often because of how these AI systems are designed and how it plays out.

What I would recommend first is that we need to get a digital safety commission off the ground that would address some parts of deepfakes, some parts of child sexual abuse material and some parts of chatbots. It is still under-inclusive for the types of harms that we're talking about here, and that's really a policy decision. Do you get going now and add more later, or are we looking for tweaks at this stage?

11:15 a.m.

Conservative

Kelly DeRidder Conservative Kitchener Centre, ON

You mentioned Bill C-34 and the commission. One thing that I personally see in Bill C-34 is that it leaves open a definition of harm and safe content. As this legislation moves to committee, how important is it that we get this right?

11:20 a.m.

Canada Research Chair in Cybersecurity Law and Professor, Faculty of Law, University of Calgary, As an Individual

Dr. Emily Laidlaw

It's incredibly important that we get it right.

There are two things. I think it's a solid piece of legislation, but there are small tweaks that could be made that are incredibly meaningful. There is a risk that, if too much is added to its plate at the beginning, it makes it difficult to get it off the ground.

I would recommend a few things. One is that there would be accountability for the companies to comply with their own terms and conditions. Most of them already have policies in place; they're just not complying with them. Europe has that legislation.

I also think companies need to, as part of what they do, assess and mitigate impacts on equality, freedom of expression and privacy. We don't have that provision in this. It is also in the European one. That would address some of the concerns that Vivian raises.

11:20 a.m.

Conservative

Kelly DeRidder Conservative Kitchener Centre, ON

Thank you very much.

Lloyd, first off, I'd like to thank you for the work you're doing to protect children. It's incredibly important. Thank you so very much.

Human trafficking in Canada is at a crisis level. How are these platforms contributing to this horrible industry? What can the government do to further protect children from trafficking in Canada with regard to online safety?

November 2nd, 2026 / 11:20 a.m.

Director, Technology, Canadian Centre for Child Protection

Lloyd Richardson

A lot of my response is going to be pretty similar to what Emily said. She was spot-on.

When we see trafficking, particularly in images related to children, it's related to a wide spectrum of actors on the Internet. We're really stumbling over how we take action in these cases.

It's not going to be one overarching set of legislation that's going to instantly solve this problem. Bill C-34 is a massive step forward. I always say that this legislation should have been around over a decade ago. The problem is that we're working backwards from a problem that has existed forever that we haven't really taken action on. Getting this into place will sort of bootstrap us into a place where we can start dealing with the wider issue here.

When I look at the Internet in general before the advent of AI, it was already very toxic to women and children. We have never solved that problem previously. We look at generative AI specifically as basically an amplifier of all of that. It's made the problem even worse. From our organization's perspective, it's getting this legislation off the ground to start and looking at how we can adapt the regulations, because that's going to be a lot of the detail as we go forward. I think you're going to see a lot of creative ways to solve some of these problems in the regulation. It really has to be flexible in what we can do going forward, because we need regulation to be able to move at close to the speed of tech. We're trying to solve the problems of 10 years ago today, and we need to adapt a process so we're able to do that quickly.

11:20 a.m.

Conservative

Kelly DeRidder Conservative Kitchener Centre, ON

Thank you so very much.

11:20 a.m.

Conservative

The Chair Conservative Dominique Vien

You still have 30 seconds.

11:20 a.m.

Conservative

Kelly DeRidder Conservative Kitchener Centre, ON

Vivian, very quickly, you mentioned that Canada doesn't have a competitive cloud. I completely agree that we absolutely need a sovereign cloud in Canada to protect our data that's Canadian owned and Canadian headquartered. Otherwise, the U.S. CLOUD Act comes into play, and I'm sure you know all these things.

Considering we're so far behind, how do you suggest the government move forward to get a cloud?

11:20 a.m.

Director, Education and Strategy, Open Digital Literacy and Access Network

Vivian Lee

I think it's important that our government invest in sovereign—

11:20 a.m.

Conservative

The Chair Conservative Dominique Vien

That's all the time. Thank you so much.

You can elaborate on that in another round.

Ms. Ménard, you have the floor.

Marie-Gabrielle Ménard Liberal Hochelaga—Rosemont-Est, QC

Witnesses, thank you for joining us today, and I appreciate the sensitivity you showed to this committee in your opening remarks. You clearly understood that this is the Standing Committee on the Status of Women, and you applied that lens.

You should know that there are currently seven committees in Ottawa looking into the development of artificial intelligence. Here, we're trying to apply that specific lens.

I'm going to try to ask all three of you a question.

First, Ms. Lee, I'd like to give you a few seconds to finish your answer, because my colleague's question was very interesting.

11:20 a.m.

Director, Education and Strategy, Open Digital Literacy and Access Network

Vivian Lee

I believe that we should follow the European example that's currently being implemented. The EU has started the implementation of LibreOffice in lieu of Microsoft products, and Canada would benefit from a similar effort. This would allow us to have regulation and storage locally and would require artificial intelligence systems to recentre Canadian sovereignty. It also is based on open source software, which provides transparency and improvements that we could make without having to consult a corporate overlord.

Marie-Gabrielle Ménard Liberal Hochelaga—Rosemont-Est, QC

Thank you.

I'll turn to you, Ms. Laidlaw.

Now that we're talking about digital sovereignty, particularly when it comes to artificial intelligence, we can be proud as Canadians to have one of the founding fathers of artificial intelligence here, researcher Yoshua Bengio. Perhaps we can hope to have safer next steps than what other nations have.

What would you like to add? We're looking for recommendations. We'll have to take them back to the government. What can you add about digital security and sovereignty?

11:25 a.m.

Canada Research Chair in Cybersecurity Law and Professor, Faculty of Law, University of Calgary, As an Individual

Dr. Emily Laidlaw

I will say that I struggle with sovereignty because we are so integrated within other jurisdictions. The questions are really what can be extracted as sovereign within Canada and where trusted partners are. We're seeing development of some of those relationships with the EU. I think that one of the key steps—I always talk about it from a legal perspective—is interoperability of laws with similar countries so that together you can find some strengths to be able to investigate the conduct of the companies.

One thing we need up front is better controls about the input that is informing the output by AI. That means you need to be able to lift the lid on what the companies are doing, and that requires researcher access and investigator access. Some of these companies are located in other jurisdictions, so we can focus on developing our own more sanitized sovereign cloud. I don't think “sanitized” is the right word, but I guess I mean better and stronger AI inputs that inform the system.

Realistically, what we might be looking at then is interoperability amongst our laws with, say, the EU, Australia and New Zealand. We could all be working together to enforce that type of accountability, better understanding and changes.

Marie-Gabrielle Ménard Liberal Hochelaga—Rosemont-Est, QC

I'm hearing that there are potential international allies and that alliances might be a good idea.

Mr. Richardson, in your opening remarks, you talked about harm to children, and you said that it particularly concerns young girls.

Does artificial intelligence put young girls' development at risk? If so, in what respect?

11:25 a.m.

Director, Technology, Canadian Centre for Child Protection

Lloyd Richardson

Yes, definitely, in many ways.

Specifically about what I was referring to, when we talk about young women, is that the deepfake side of things is absolutely huge. It's traumatic and crushing when these images are created and distributed, particularly on the same platforms used to create the material in the first place, and they're so widely distributed on social media platforms, which coincidentally are also the platforms that are using AI to feed certain things related to them to advertising and other harmful things. We're being attacked in so many different ways by the technology being leveraged against us.

Marie-Gabrielle Ménard Liberal Hochelaga—Rosemont-Est, QC

Mr. Richardson, if young girls' development is affected, is there a risk to democracy?