Evidence of meeting #45 for Veterans Affairs in the 45th Parliament, 1st session. (The original version is on Parliament’s site, as are the minutes.) The winning word was education.

A recording is available from Parliament.

On the agenda

Members speaking

Before the committee

Robert Luke  Chief Executive Officer, eCampus Ontario
Booth  Chief Executive Officer, True Patriot Love Foundation
Lowther  Chief Executive Officer and Co-Founder, Veterans Emergency Transition Services
Larochelle  Advisor, Recognition of Acquired Competencies (RAC), Cégep Marie-Victorin
Blanchard  Founder and Chief Executive Officer, Veterans Entrepreneurship Hub (Vet-Hub), VeCATS Inc.
Thorne  Chief Executive Officer, Veterans Transition Network

Sophie Chatel Liberal Pontiac—Kitigan Zibi, QC

I have one minute left, so I'll go right to Mr. Booth.

8:50 a.m.

Chief Executive Officer, True Patriot Love Foundation

Nick Booth

I'll be very brief. I have two points.

First, the honourable member mentioned Ukraine. I had the privilege of meeting the new Minister for Veterans Affairs of Ukraine during his recent visit to Canada. We went in thinking we would be sharing things with them, and I think we'll be learning from them very quickly. They have two million veterans whom they're trying to place into the workforce now, in real time, whilst also fighting a war.

The point the honourable member made about veterans not looking the same as they used to.... Their veterans are young and digitally enabled, but they're also carrying trauma. If you don't find those people employment, purpose and meaning, then downstream you'll have significant health and, indeed, civil society challenges from people who have those fractured identities, perhaps, post service.

The second point I would make is around purpose. There have been some very good studies done—mainly in the United States but also in the U.K. and then, last year, we did the first-ever Canadian study—on the importance of purpose in transition and well-being—so, on really understanding the individual's motivation and their opportunity to continue to serve in both their employment work and in volunteering roles in the community.

The Chair Liberal Marie-France Lalonde

Thank you very much.

We will now go to Madame DeBellefeuille,

You have the floor for six minutes.

Claude DeBellefeuille Bloc Vallée-du-Haut-Saint-Laurent, QC

Thank you, Madam Chair.

Thank you to the witnesses for being with us so early this morning.

Ms. Lowther, I really appreciated what you said in your presentation. I'm new to the Standing Committee on Veterans Affairs, and I've found that witnesses seem a bit reluctant to criticize a situation that makes no sense to me.

I'm a hard-working newbie, so I've read the reports from 2015, 2017, 2023, 2024 and 2026. I've noticed that the same concern keeps coming up. As you said, a lot of proposals and recommendations have been put forward. In light of all those recommendations, it's time to take stock of the situation. This study might have been even more useful had we looked at the recommendations in all those reports to see what has worked, what has been implemented and where we should focus our efforts now. That was my first impression after hearing what you had to say. I share your frustration, because I'm a woman of action. This is all well and good because I like talking, but eventually we have to take action. There's no shortage of good ideas that haven't been implemented, and I think you've made that point very clearly this morning.

I appreciate your candour and your sincerity. It's not always easy to be authentic, so I commend you for that. That takes a certain kind of courage.

I have a question for you, Mr. Booth. I did a little research on your foundation, and I saw that it received $910,000 for two projects in 2026. That funding was intended to help you create a network of civilian employers. Can you tell us if this initiative is working and whether it is achieving the desired results?

8:55 a.m.

Chief Executive Officer, True Patriot Love Foundation

Nick Booth

We are working with Veterans Affairs Canada on that grant, building a veteran-friendly Canada. The key initiatives we've undertaken so far, for example, have been mobilizing the private sector, helping them understand the talent leaving our armed forces, with those ecosystem connect events I referenced, which we've already done in four provinces. We're coming to Montreal next year, which we're looking forward to very much.

We've been moving that. We often find—and we may hear it from a witness in the next session—that the small and medium-sized enterprises don't necessarily have the big HR teams that some of the larger employers have. We've been focusing quite a lot on building portable skill recognition tools and translation tools for small and medium-sized enterprises. That has been one of our key learnings.

I agree with the point you made about getting those reports out, tracking what was recommended and whether that's been done, and then working out where the outstanding pieces are. So much has been done over the last.... I've been in Canada for seven and a half years, and it's changed even in that time.

For a veteran—this is the point Mr. Luke made—navigating that as an individual can be challenging, particularly if you're also dealing with finding somewhere to live. There are other elements of leaving the forces: worrying about the health and well-being of your family, moving away from your community, etc. That whole-system approach is very important.

Claude DeBellefeuille Bloc Vallée-du-Haut-Saint-Laurent, QC

As I work through the material and try to develop a better understanding of veterans' issues, I see what amounts to a patchwork of services. There are all kinds of initiatives, activities and organizations across Quebec and Canada. One witness told us that a single window might make things simpler.

When members of the armed forces start thinking about retiring from the military, they look into getting some education or training so they can leave the armed forces with knowledge or a specialized skill set. After retiring, they should have access to a single window in each province for support in all psychosocial spheres, including, as you said, housing, employment, family matters, health care and assistance with the transition to civilian employment.

That seems like a simple solution, but I think it's a very good one. Right now, several different organizations or activities serve essentially the same purpose. It seems to me that veterans might find that difficult to access and navigate.

What do you think of that recommendation?

9 a.m.

Chief Executive Officer, True Patriot Love Foundation

Nick Booth

Your analysis is a very good one. There are many organizations out there doing good work, although it's not clear, sometimes, how they evaluate that work. We often hear from veterans who engage with True Patriot Love that, irrespective of which province they live in, they don't know where the services or jobs are. They don't know whether these are applicable to them and their families or if they're culturally appropriate and safe for them. We at True Patriot Love now have a portal that has over 400 community programs on it, but even we couldn't honestly say that we know all of them are operating at the same standard.

I recently returned from a six-month secondment in Australia, where they're building something similar to what you're saying. We need a national overarching approach to service quality and evaluation so that a veteran can walk in—in Montreal, Vancouver or somewhere in the middle—and say, “These are the services I think I need or that I've been diagnosed as needing. They'd meet my needs and I'd know how to access them in a language, culture and geography appropriate to me.”

9 a.m.

Liberal

The Chair Liberal Marie-France Lalonde

Thank you very much.

We will now start our second round, with Mr. Tolmie for five minutes.

9 a.m.

Conservative

Fraser Tolmie Conservative Moose Jaw—Lake Centre—Lanigan, SK

Thank you, Chair.

Thank you to the witnesses for coming. I appreciate that two of them are returning.

Mr. Booth, it's good to see you again. I didn't get to say hi earlier on.

Ms. Lowther and Mr. Luke, I appreciate your attendance and your testimonies.

I have a few questions. I'm going to try to run through these as quickly as I can.

This is going to be for Mr. Luke and Mr. Booth.

From where you sit, who in government is responsible for making sure a releasing member knows where to get their skills recognized?

9 a.m.

Chief Executive Officer, eCampus Ontario

Dr. Robert Luke

I can start.

It starts with Veterans Affairs Canada. They seem to be the most likely candidate for providing that.

As for the point made earlier by Madame DeBellefeuille, there's a mishmash of services available. It is very easy today to bring those together. I suggest that Veterans Affairs put two very simple links on their website. One should say, “Here's what you know, so use this service.” An AI agent could do it. “You were in this occupation so you have these skills; here's how they are relevant to the civilian economy.” The next one should be a connection either to further education or an employer. I think that's a very simple thing to do.

The one thing I would suggest, though.... You asked whether there should be one place to go. Absolutely. There should be a link on the Veterans Affairs' website. We should have an approach to helping people exit the military that is equal to our induction process. Our induction process is quite detailed. The exiting process should be too. It's simple to do, by convening....

However, in addition to one portal, we should have no wrong door. We should have multiple routes in to help all veterans.

9 a.m.

Conservative

Fraser Tolmie Conservative Moose Jaw—Lake Centre—Lanigan, SK

I'm sorry, Mr. Booth. I will get to you.

When a veteran is injured, VAC assigns a case manager. When a veteran needs a job, they fill out an application and get referred to the career-transition service.

What are your thoughts on that process, Mr. Booth? Are veterans made aware? Some veterans, when they release, don't even know where to go and what to do.

Then, Ms. Lowther, I'll have a question for you.

9 a.m.

Chief Executive Officer, True Patriot Love Foundation

Nick Booth

I would agree with the other witness that it is hard for people to navigate a complicated system, particularly if they may have health and well-being challenges. As I said, I think it's better than it was. Certainly the other key responsibility lies with the Canadian Armed Forces transition group and the transition centres.

I repeat the point I made earlier about the connections between CAF TG and Veterans Affairs employment unit. With those two, the private sector partners and the voluntary sector partners, exploring how those things work better would be a good area of focus.

I think there's always been a concern that, the more you prepare people for release, the more you speed up the osmosis of people leaving, and we're trying to strengthen our retention right now. I don't believe that's true. I think the more you say to a military member that they will get vital skills through their career that will help them post military service, the more you strengthen retention. In terms of the point that was made earlier, there are some narrative challenges around this that we can also work on.

Fraser Tolmie Conservative Moose Jaw—Lake Centre—Lanigan, SK

Ms. Lowther, you've mentioned a bit of frustration about returning here and about our seeming to be changing the titles of our studies and doing the same thing, and I would agree with you.

We hear about veterans who are on the streets, veterans who are couch surfing and veterans who are living in their cars. We want our veterans to be recognized, cared for and integrated into society, giving them meaningful employment.

What are your thoughts? I know I've asked you questions in previous rounds when you were here before. What are your thoughts when you see veterans who need meaningful employment? What do you see as the solution?

9:05 a.m.

Chief Executive Officer and Co-Founder, Veterans Emergency Transition Services

Debbie Lowther

We need to start looking at it pre release. When veterans end up at the transition unit, that's a great opportunity to do an evaluation of their skills and competencies to give them an idea of the trades or the jobs that might be appropriate for them. We need to start before they leave the military.

The Chair Liberal Marie-France Lalonde

Thank you very much.

Ms. Royer is online, and she will be addressing us for five minutes.

Zoe Royer Liberal Port Moody—Coquitlam, BC

Thank you, Madam Chair.

Thank you, Dr. Luke, Ms. Lowther and Mr. Booth. I really appreciate the testimony that we're hearing today, and it really gives a very full picture. I'd like to begin my questions with Mr. Booth.

First of all, thank you for your incredible service. Of course, you've been appointed to the Royal Victorian Order. You're a recipient of the King Charles III's Coronation Medal. Thank you as well for your support of members of the CFB Wainwright community during this very difficult time.

I'm very interested in some of the things that you mentioned and, in particular, your work with Australia and with the U.K. You talked about 35,000 businesses in the U.K. that have made pledges to, I believe, hire veterans. There are hundreds that have made a veteran employment commitment in Australia. How did they get there?

9:05 a.m.

Chief Executive Officer, True Patriot Love Foundation

Nick Booth

Thank you, Ms. Royer.

Thank you for the very kind personal comments. They're not necessary but are much appreciated.

One interesting thing the British have done is to initiate a piece of statutory legislation, which I think Canada could consider, in which you're not allowed to be disadvantaged through your service. It's now in regulation through the Valour initiative. It started off in employment, but it now covers across housing, health and education that someone cannot be disadvantaged by their service. It's a requirement on each of those statutory functions to consider the experience of veterans and how, when they're looking for a house when they leave, they don't go back down the queue, or if they're looking for an operation, they don't go back down the queue.

I think that's something that Canada could consider. It became a benchmark legislation, and they've now undertaken quite a significant initiative called “Operation Valour” to execute that at scale. They're taking it very seriously.

As some of the members may know, the Australians have just done probably the largest analysis of the causes and consequences of veteran suicide ever done by one of the allied nations—a royal commission—and again, I would hope that something the Canadian government would maintain a strong focus on is suicide prevention.

Too often, we hear from our members that we've lost someone else. When you get those very sad stories and we ask what may have happened, it's often—to my earlier point—that loss of identity. People lose who they were. They lose those connections. Equally, I don't wish to reinforce the stigma, as only one in four of our veterans medically releases and transitions out. Three-quarters of them are well. They've had great careers and they just need to make that connection into the civilian world better.

We need to fix those two things at the same time, and that's where the communication challenge and the stigma can pull against each other. We must help those who need targeted support, but we mustn't see veterans as a homogeneous group. They're not. That goes to the point Mr. Luke made about—I'm using jargon, forgive me—segments of one: How does one person navigate their way through that system? That's the challenge at the system level, but if we work out how the bits fit together, that'll be easier for people.

Zoe Royer Liberal Port Moody—Coquitlam, BC

Thank you for that, Dr. Booth.

My next question is for Dr. Luke.

Dr. Luke, you've done a lot of work with veterans, and one of the things in education that strikes me is that we're always thinking about future-ready skills. The military is really built on being future-ready: being ready for the big event that is going to shake our nation or for going into a conflicted country and being ready and managing many things simultaneously.

How can we equip veterans to be future-ready early on? When should that start?

9:10 a.m.

Chief Executive Officer, eCampus Ontario

Dr. Robert Luke

Thank you very much for the question. It's a very important concept that you're putting on the table—

Zoe Royer Liberal Port Moody—Coquitlam, BC

My apologies: It's not future-ready for the next big event. They are, but it's future-ready for that career transition. Pardon me.

9:10 a.m.

Chief Executive Officer, eCampus Ontario

Dr. Robert Luke

It's important. A career transition is just another mission in many respects, and Mr. Booth just made the point that retention in the military will likely be enhanced if we help veterans understand that there will be supports for them.

I made the point earlier that the military does a very good job of helping serving members understand what skills they have as they progress through the ranks. That needs to be translated into effective knowledge for the serving members of what skills they have and then how those can get translated into the civilian employment market.

Zoe Royer Liberal Port Moody—Coquitlam, BC

That's amazing. Thank you.

The Chair Liberal Marie-France Lalonde

Mrs. DeBellefeuille, you have two and a half minutes.

Claude DeBellefeuille Bloc Vallée-du-Haut-Saint-Laurent, QC

Thank you, Madam Chair.

Mr. Booth, you said the United Kingdom's policy is worth looking to for inspiration. Canada is often compared to Australia or the United Kingdom. However, the reality is that Canada is a federation. The Canadian Constitution assigns very specific areas of jurisdiction, including education, to the provinces and territories, so when you talk about a national framework, you're talking about a Canadian framework. Basically, discussions and consultations must take place. There must be political will for all the provinces and territories to agree on the issue and work collaboratively. To achieve that, consultations and a very clear action plan must be undertaken by a province or by the federal government.

Right now, I see an obstacle in the fact that each province is responsible for its own curriculum and its own decisions relating to education. National Defence and Veterans Affairs Canada are somewhat constrained by that reality. In my opinion, the way forward is always through teamwork, carried out with respect for everyone's jurisdiction and through consultation. That has to lead to specific decisions and actions.

You talked about a national framework. I imagine that, in your work, you also try to lobby the provinces, education ministers and ministers' offices. I imagine that your work must also involve the provinces because, ultimately, they are the ones who decide whether or not to get on board with efforts to facilitate the transition from military to civilian life.

Do you see your work that way as well?

The Chair Liberal Marie-France Lalonde

You have 30 seconds left.