House of Commons Hansard #158 of the 45th Parliament, 1st session. (The original version is on Parliament's site.) The word of the day was online.

Topics

line drawing of robot

This summary is computer-generated. Usually it’s accurate, but every now and then it’ll contain inaccuracies or total fabrications.

Alleged Premature Disclosure of Bill C-40—Speaker's Ruling Members consider the opposition’s allegation that Bill C-40 was disclosed to journalists before introduction; the Speaker finds insufficient evidence of a leak and rules there is no prima facie question of privilege. 1100 words.

Safe Social Media Act Second reading of Bill C-34. The bill would require social media platforms and AI chatbot services to reduce online harms, protect children through safer design and age-related safeguards, remove certain harmful content quickly, and disclose safety plans. It would establish a commission to oversee compliance and impose penalties. Members broadly support improving online safety but raise questions about privacy, free expression, enforcement, regulatory powers and consultation with provinces and Quebec. The House refers the bill to committee for study. 45600 words, 6 hours in 2 segments: 1 2.

Bill C-41—Proposal to Apply Standing Order 69.1 Kevin Lamoureux argues that Bill C-41 concerns only medical assistance in dying, not unrelated topics, and therefore is not an omnibus bill subject to separate votes under Standing Order 69.1. 400 words.

Statements by Members

Question Period

The Conservatives accuse the government of staging a futile EU summit, while demanding action on trade barriers and a threatened carbon tariff. They blame deficit spending for inflation and rising costs, criticize failures in anti-money-laundering oversight and bail policy, and raise concerns about immigration security screening, support for Canadian industry, and transparency around the Prime Minister’s wife’s appointment.
The Liberals emphasize diversifying trade through stronger European ties, energy cooperation, and expanding non-U.S. exports. They defend affordability supports and social programs, promote crime prevention and Indigenous policing, and highlight investment in industry, infrastructure, and ocean conservation. They also point to housing construction, high-speed rail, and efforts to cut red tape.
The Bloc warn that ending federal carbon pricing risks European tariffs on Quebec metals, while weakened pesticide rules could threaten agri-food exports. They also defend Quebec’s authority over its international relations and criticize Ottawa for disregarding Quebec’s prerogatives.
The NDP condemn Bill C-39’s environmental and Indigenous impacts amid wildfire-smoke deaths, and criticize the government for rising living costs and interest-rate hikes.

National Strategy for Soil Health Act Second reading of Bill S-230. The bill would require a national strategy to protect, conserve and improve soil health, including measures for research, information-sharing, consultation and parliamentary reporting. Supporters say it can coordinate expertise and strengthen food security and farm resilience; critics raise concerns about federal jurisdiction and argue that cuts to agricultural research undermine the bill’s goals. 8700 words, 1 hour.

Adjournment Debates

Firearms confiscation compensation Alex Ruff cites shipping problems in the firearms compensation program and asks whether owners will still be paid if administrative failures cause them to miss the deadline. Jacques Ramsay says affected owners will be accommodated and receive fair compensation. Ruff disputes the government’s description of banned firearms and asks Ramsay to define “military-style assault rifle”; Ramsay says experts identify them and points to broader gun-control measures.
Rural health care access Helena Konanz says resignations by Penticton’s neurologists and recurring emergency-room closures leave seniors in her rural riding without local care. She urges the federal government to adopt a “blue seal” program to fast-track unaccredited doctors. Kevin Lamoureux says credential recognition and residency placements are provincial responsibilities, while citing federal health funding and seniors’ dental coverage.
Spaceport contract oversight Greg McLean accuses the government of wasting defence funds on a $200-million contract with Maritime Launch Services, alleging excessive lease payments, inadequate oversight and benefits to company insiders. Mike Kelloway defends the agreement as a way to build sovereign launch capacity, citing Canadian spending requirements, project milestones and support from local and provincial partners.
Was this summary helpful and accurate?

Auditor GeneralRoutine Proceedings

10 a.m.

The Speaker Francis Scarpaleggia

It is my duty to lay before the House, pursuant to subsection 7(3) of the Auditor General Act, the 2026 reports of the Auditor General of Canada.

Pursuant to Standing Order 108(3)(g), these documents are deemed permanently referred to the Standing Committee on Public Accounts.

LiaisonCommittees of the HouseRoutine Proceedings

10 a.m.

Liberal

Judy Sgro Liberal Humber River—Black Creek, ON

Mr. Speaker, I have the honour to present, in both official languages, the fourth report of the Liaison Committee, entitled “Committee Activities and Expenditures April 1-August 31, 2026”.

Persons with DisabilitiesPetitionsRoutine Proceedings

10 a.m.

NDP

Gord Johns NDP Courtenay—Alberni, BC

Mr. Speaker, this petition is timely in that people from Disability Without Poverty are here on Parliament Hill.

The petitioners are calling on the federal government to stop the duplication of making people prove they are living with a disability after they have already been deemed living with a disability in their province or territory. They want the Government of Canada to accept provincial and territorial disability determinations as sufficient evidence of eligibility for the disability tax credit when equivalent eligibility criteria have not been met; amend the Income Tax Act and related regulations to eliminate unnecessary duplicative medical certification requirements for the disability tax credit; ensure that eligible Canadians can access the disability tax credit and the Canada disability benefit without unnecessary barriers or delays; and work with the provinces, the territories, disability organizations and health care professionals to create a streamlined disability eligibility process that reduces red tape, improves access to supports and allows family physicians to spend more time caring for patients rather than completing duplicative government paperwork.

Trans-Canada HighwayPetitionsRoutine Proceedings

10 a.m.

Conservative

Gaétan Malette Conservative Kapuskasing—Timmins—Mushkegowuk, ON

Mr. Speaker, I rise today to table a petition signed by the people of Moonbeam, Ontario.

Communities across northern Ontario are calling on this government to recognize Trans-Canada Highway 11 as a project of national interest. Every day of inaction is another day where lives are at risk on this highway, which was closed again just last week.

Moonbeam will certainly not be the last community to sign this petition. We are going door to door and village to village, and the message is the same everywhere. Northern Ontario is asking for action.

Designate Trans-Canada Highway 11 as a project of national interest.

Questions on the Order PaperRoutine Proceedings

10 a.m.

Winnipeg North Manitoba

Liberal

Kevin Lamoureux LiberalParliamentary Secretary to the Leader of the Government in the House of Commons

Mr. Speaker, I ask that all questions be allowed to stand.

Questions on the Order PaperRoutine Proceedings

10 a.m.

The Speaker Francis Scarpaleggia

Is it agreed?

Questions on the Order PaperRoutine Proceedings

10 a.m.

Some hon. members

Agreed.

Alleged Premature Disclosure of Bill C-40—Speaker's RulingPrivilegeRoutine Proceedings

10 a.m.

The Speaker Francis Scarpaleggia

I am now ready to rule on the question of privilege raised on October 6, 2026, by the House leader of the official opposition concerning the alleged premature disclosure of Bill C-40, an act respecting production, procurement and investment in relation to national defence and national security.

During his intervention, the House leader of the official opposition argued that specific details of Bill C-40 had been shared with journalists before the bill was introduced in the House. He based his assertion on two news articles published before the bill was introduced in the House, which, in his opinion, provided substantive information that could not have been gleaned from the title of the bill, nor deduced from previous government consultations and announcements. The member noted that these articles cited anonymous sources who were not authorized to discuss this information publicly. He posited that such a disclosure constituted a contempt of the House.

For his part, the Parliamentary Secretary to the Leader of the Government in the House asserted that there is no prima facie question of privilege. He assured the House that, following its own investigation, the government found no evidence that anyone leaked the contents of the bill while it was on notice. The parliamentary secretary also argued that the legislative details discussed in the news articles in question have been in the public domain as matters of government policy for some time, speaking specifically to deliberations and consultations undertaken by the government on defence procurement and other topics related to the bill. He assured the House that these conversations did not occur at a time even close to the notice of the bill. Finally, he suggested that the information cited in the news articles was at times speculative and uncertain, casting further doubt on the possibility that specific provisions of the bill were divulged.

During a second intervention, the House leader of the official opposition sought to rebut some of the parliamentary secretary's arguments. He questioned the scope and thoroughness of the government's investigation before it concluded that no internal leak had occurred. He also argued that the policy information the government claimed was already in the public domain could not account for everything revealed in the news articles.

Members are right to affirm that it is a long-standing expectation that the House must be the first to be informed of the details of specific legislative measures that will come before it. As explained by Speaker Milliken in his ruling of March 19, 2001, on page 1840 of the Debates:

The convention of the confidentiality of bills on notice is necessary, not only so that members themselves may be well informed, but also because of the pre-eminent [role] which the House plays and must play in the legislative affairs of the nation.

The Chair has on many occasions been asked to rule on matters regarding the right of the House to have first access to legislative measures, including recently in the current session. One factor to consider is whether the allegation has been met with any admission or denial of responsibility, or alternative explanations. In the case before us, the Chair is faced with two different assertions, one claiming that the rights of the House were violated, and another, from the government, denying that details of one of its bills were prematurely divulged. In other words, the facts are disputed. This is reminiscent of other situations where, taking members at their word, the Chair was reluctant to intervene.

However, it is important to note that the government's responsibility is not the only element that must be considered by the Chair. Speaker Rota stated on March 9, 2021, at page 4762 of the Debates:

While there is indeed a well-established practice that a member must be taken at their word, the fact remains that the government's stating that it is not responsible for the premature disclosure of a bill is not in itself sufficient to convince the Chair. I would add that the source of information is one factor among others and that it is important first and foremost to determine whether precise details were provided before the House was made aware of them. The Chair must thus take into consideration all the information before it and reach a conclusion based on the facts presented by the members.

With this in mind, I felt it appropriate to review the news articles in question and the text of Bill C-40 now before the House. Having done so, I find that the similarities between the text of the bill and the details in the news articles remain at a high level and do not provide sufficient grounds to conclude that a leak of the bill itself has occurred. Further to this point, while members may be correct in stating that the details published in the news articles go beyond what is revealed in the bill's long title, this cannot stand as a reliable test for judging whether the precise contents of a bill have been divulged.

The Chair also notes that the news articles do not directly address the question of whether the sources cited had access to a copy of the bill itself, or to its specific provisions, and were therefore even in a position to share it, nor has any convincing evidence been brought to the Chair's attention that would demonstrate that the sharing of information between the sources and journalists, or between the government and the sources, took place in the window between when the bill was placed on notice and when the bill was introduced.

During his intervention, the parliamentary secretary stated that related public consultations were taking place well before Bill C-40 was placed on notice. As Speaker Regan affirmed in his ruling of June 8, 2017, at page 12320 of the Debates:

The right of the House to first access to legislation is one of our oldest conventions. It does and must, however, coexist with the need of governments to consult widely, with the public and stakeholders alike, on issues and policies in the preparation of legislation.

After reviewing all the evidence provided, the Chair cannot determine with any degree of certainty that the entirety of the bill, or specific sections thereof, were divulged prior to its introduction in the House. The government's assurance that it has no knowledge of a leak, the substance of the details published in the news articles and the lack of clarity around the nature and timing of the anonymous sources' information all contribute to this conclusion. Accordingly, the Chair does not find that this case constitutes a prima facie question of privilege.

The House resumed from October 28 consideration of the motion that Bill C-34, An Act to enact the Digital Safety Act and the Digital Safety Commission of Canada Act and to make consequential amendments to other Acts, be read the second time and referred to a committee.

Bill C-34 Safe Social Media ActGovernment Orders

10:10 a.m.

Ottawa Centre Ontario

Liberal

Yasir Naqvi LiberalParliamentary Secretary to the Minister of International Trade and to the Secretary of State (International Development)

Mr. Speaker, it is a great honour for me to stand to speak to Bill C-34, the safe social media act.

In my capacity as the very proud member of Parliament for Ottawa Centre, this issue is extremely important and personal to me as a parent. I have a 14-year-old son and a 10-year-old daughter, so I am in the thick and thin of social media and smart devices like cellphones and iPads, making sure that I am continuously engaged with my children when it comes to issues around the safe use of social media. Probably one of the biggest issues that I hear from my constituents on a regular basis, especially those who are parents or grandparents, is how to ensure that we have safe access to social media. I am sure members will agree with me that AI comes up in pretty much every single conversation nowadays. People want to ensure that there are strong regulations to monitor all these things.

As a result of the many conversations I had with my constituents over several months, and I am sure all of us know of the barbecues and different events that take place, I took the liberty of sending a mailer to my constituents, a questionnaire specifically on Bill C-34, the safe social media act, asking them some really important questions so they could help guide me, and hopefully all of us, on how best to navigate this important issue and on the important features that my constituents would like to see in the legislation.

What I asked in this questionnaire, which I sent to all the residents in my riding of Ottawa Centre, were questions like, “How should the government prioritize keeping young Canadians safe online?” and “As the government implements the legislation, what should it prioritize and how?” I also asked my constituents the question, “Which online harms concern you most for the young people in your lives?” We also asked for their experience in online safety and, more specifically, questions concerning the proposed age restriction for social media accounts, which is suggested in the legislation to be 16 plus.

First of all, I want to thank all my constituents for so enthusiastically writing on this issue. Not only did they send the mailer back after filling out the questions, but they went online, because we had a Google Forms questionnaire available, and participated. They have approached me on the streets and at community events to talk about this as well.

I think a few things really came out of that. There is, as I mentioned earlier, a strong concern as to the safe use of social media. People really want government to step forward and bring in regulations, controls and monitoring so that social media is safe, especially for children, but for seniors as well. I got a very strong sense that there is support for legislation like Bill C-34 from my constituents of Ottawa Centre. One of the key reasons is that people want to protect our children and want legislation. They want Parliament and the government to take steps in that regard.

There is also support for a restriction on the use of social media until age 16. I got a very good sense, from the survey results we got back and from my conversations, that people want to make sure there is some sort of age limitation on who can use social media, and 16 seems to be the right age. I will say that if we talk to young people, there is push-back on that, including from my 14-year-old, who understands the benefits and harms around social media but has probed me as to why the age is 16. I think the most important issue that has come up in my conversations is how we are going to regulate that.

It is one thing to say we will restrict the use of or access to social media to 16-year-olds. The question then becomes how we are going to enforce that rule. There is an understanding that young people being young people, they will find ways to get around it. Of course, everybody is looking at places such as Australia in that regard. I think an important element that, as legislators, we should be focused on throughout this legislation is how best to enforce the rule, because people want a rule like that in place but also want to ensure that it is not just a rule on paper. They want effective implementation and enforcement of the rule as well.

That is why I personally like the idea that we would not just be putting a blanket ban, so to speak, in the legislation. There would be a provision that, if certain standards are met to ensure that there is safe social media, those platforms may be allowed to operate. I think there is a better path, compared to the one in jurisdictions such as Australia, embedded in this legislation, which would allow for access to social media as long as certain standards are met that would ensure that the information our kids have access to is safe.

The second point I want to raise, which is something I said at the outset, is that there is a huge concern around AI and its content, the nature of information that is available. Misinformation and disinformation continue to come up in the conversation, and we saw that in the survey documents we received. There is a very significant concern about misleading information that is AI-manipulated and about content that has been altered through AI.

I think it would be an understatement if I said that deepfake images and videos are a serious concern that people are grappling with. I heard about this through the consultation process I did in my community. People want assurances that we are taking the necessary steps to make sure that deepfake images and videos are regulated, are monitored and are not allowed, because there are some serious concerns.

There are serious concerns from seniors in this regard. I know that much of the focus of the bill is toward young people and teenagers, but there are some serious concerns in our communities on the part of seniors as well who are being exposed to information that looks awfully close to being real. They are concerned about whether information is accurate or not and whether they have been taken advantage of. There are scams being developed. We know that our seniors are quite vulnerable to those kind of scams, frauds, phishing expeditions, etc. There is a real concern from the elderly constituents in my riding of Ottawa Centre on this issue.

I think the legislation has a lot of important elements. I am supportive of the legislation and would ask my colleagues of the House to support it as well. I think it would address a very important issue. We know that social media has become ubiquitous in our lives. It is omnipresent. We all rely on it, but there is no control over the content and the algorithm, and it is having a serious impact on our children. I continue to meet a number of parents, including representatives of organizations now led by parents, who are advocating that kids should not have access to all those things. This is a valid concern. As a parent, I am concerned about it. I am really happy that, as parliamentarians, we are addressing this important issue.

I want to thank all my constituents in Ottawa Centre for taking the time to fill out the survey we circulated and for giving me this important information so I can be a strong champion for their point of view. We need to make sure the legislation not only passes but would actually be stronger and would protect our children.

Bill C-34 Safe Social Media ActGovernment Orders

10:20 a.m.

Conservative

Rachael Thomas Conservative Lethbridge, AB

Mr. Speaker, my hon. colleague outlined the concerns of his constituents. I imagine that most of them would be happy about the idea of having legislation that would protect their children online. I think the vast majority of Canadians, of course, want that.

The question with the legislation, however, is, who would kids be protected from? Which platforms would be scoped in? Would Facebook, Instagram, TikTok and Snapchat be scoped in? The legislation does not actually state that. It says that is yet to be determined in the regulations that we can expect at some date in the future. These types of decisions would be made behind closed doors rather than by elected officials in the House.

I am curious if the member could indicate how that would be determined. Which services would be scoped in, and which services would be allowed to continue to allow predatory practices with regard to our young people? Clearly, not all would be held accountable.

Bill C-34 Safe Social Media ActGovernment Orders

10:20 a.m.

Liberal

Yasir Naqvi Liberal Ottawa Centre, ON

Mr. Speaker, I thank the hon. member for her very thoughtful comment and feedback on this important issue. I will start by saying that naming specific platforms may be problematic because legislation needs to be agnostic. What we really need to focus on is the technology and the algorithms that continue to evolve. Some companies, such as Facebook and Instagram, that exist today may not exist tomorrow. We need to write a piece of legislation that passes the test of time, so to speak, so I think our focus really should be on the harms and how to reduce their impact. That is why the regulator would be really important, because it could do the analysis to ensure that the regulations would address the harms we are trying to address here.

Bill C-34 Safe Social Media ActGovernment Orders

10:20 a.m.

Bloc

Gabriel Ste-Marie Bloc Joliette—Manawan, QC

Mr. Speaker, I would like to ask my hon. colleague two quick questions.

Would it have been appropriate to extend the bill's scope to cover things like online gaming? How can we ensure that people under the age of 16 comply with the bill's provisions?

Bill C-34 Safe Social Media ActGovernment Orders

10:20 a.m.

Liberal

Yasir Naqvi Liberal Ottawa Centre, ON

Mr. Speaker, I thank my colleague for those very important questions.

The second question is the one I was trying to address. It is one thing to say that the age is 16, but the enforcement of the rule is extremely important. That is one of the conversations I have had with my constituents that came up again and again. We can set up a lot of rules, but if the rules are not followed or enforced, they become meaningless. That is a concern I bring. I want to make sure the legislation would have a meaningful way of addressing that concern. I think that ideas and suggestions from all of us would make that happen. We do not want to create a black market, so to speak, for young people to find a back door to get to these types of things.

We all have been young, and we know how creative we could be if we wanted something. However, this is not a new experience for us. There are restrictions on the use of alcohol and tobacco, on driving, and those types of things, so we know how to do this right and should think about how we can enforce the age of 16 thoroughly to get it right.

Bill C-34 Safe Social Media ActGovernment Orders

10:25 a.m.

Liberal

Marianne Dandurand Liberal Compton—Stanstead, QC

Mr. Speaker, I listened carefully to the speech by my colleague from Ottawa Centre. I really appreciated the fact that he reached out to his constituents in different ways. I have done the same thing in my riding. I talked to the youth council, for instance. Young people in my riding told me that they strongly support stricter regulations governing the use of social media. They also talked about the many benefits of not being constantly active on social media.

I would like to know whether my colleague has done similar research with young people. How do the youth in his riding feel about regulations governing social media?

Bill C-34 Safe Social Media ActGovernment Orders

10:25 a.m.

Liberal

Yasir Naqvi Liberal Ottawa Centre, ON

Mr. Speaker, I also spoke with my youth council on this important issue. What is funny is that there is a group of young people who do want strict regulations because they believe there are concerns with respect to social media. They want to be responsible users, and they want help from government regulators. Then there are other young people who want us to leave them alone. We need to find the right balance and the enforcement that would help reduce the harms regarding social media.

Bill C-34 Safe Social Media ActGovernment Orders

10:25 a.m.

Conservative

Mike Lake Conservative Leduc—Wetaskiwin, AB

Mr. Speaker, it is a pleasure to rise to speak to this piece of legislation today. I have been thinking for some time about the issues raised by the legislation, in my capacity as shadow minister for mental health and wellness and in working with many stakeholders who are very concerned about the impact of social media on our kids.

To start, I am actually going to talk about something from my own experience that I think speaks to the very things we are talking about today. A few months ago, my mom was having a fairly minor surgery. One night as I was getting ready for bed, I thought I should text my mom to find out how her surgery went. The next morning, for whatever reason, I was about to text her about something else. I opened up my phone and realized I had never texted my mom the night before to ask her about her surgery. What I had done was open my phone with the full intention of sending a text, but I saw an Instagram notification, just that little dot on the Instagram logo that we cannot ignore, and clicked on something that was not important at all.

Instagram was just getting my attention, as it does. I spent probably an hour scrolling reels on Instagram, and none of those reels was important. The types of reels that get my attention on Instagram, generally, are fantastic sports plays set to great music. Certain comedians also get my attention, so my algorithm has Nate Bargatze, Jimmy Carr and other comedians. It also has videos that explain things through AI-generated songs that are kind of funny and maybe clever, maybe not filled with really accurate information. I do not know.

The other thing, though, that I notice about my algorithm is that it is filled with some things that are not so light. Recently, oftentimes, my feed would be filled with crash videos, sometimes plane crash videos. I fly a lot, and for whatever reason, if I see a piece of video or something like that, I will linger on it maybe a little longer than I should. I have noticed recently that my feed is filled with RIP content about people who have recently passed away. In retrospect, I know why that has happened. I believe in the JFK quote “Things do not happen. Things are made to happen.”

There is a reason why I see what I see. It is that a few prominent people whom I followed have passed away in recent times, and I read the stories about them. It was enough to feed my algorithm, and now what has happened is that my algorithm has way more content related to sadness and death than it used to have. What this has done is manipulated my natural love for people, my natural empathy for people, and has replaced that with a kind of rumination on tragedy, I would say.

One other comment is that on X, there is the ability, in some cases, to say, “I am not interested in this.” I have a specific ad that keeps popping up on X, a series of ads. I have clicked “not interested in this” at least four or five times, but they just keeps coming anyway. I cannot get rid of them.

What does that look like for kids? I think that is the question we have to answer today. It is one thing as a 57-year-old to be drawn into social media. I would not phrase it as an addiction for me right now, but it definitely is something that is very compelling and takes me away from things I care about doing. What does that look like for a 13- 14- or 15-year-old? They might sit down to look something up on their phone to do some homework or study for something, or maybe there is something that would just be interesting that adds value to their life, or they are texting a friend to make plans, but they get locked into some kind of notification or addictive scrolling session that might last an hour, or two or three hours, when they were just going on their phone to make plans with their friends to do something in person.

What does the content look like for kids? Too often, we are hearing that the content that our kids are seeing on there might be related to eating disorders or to the way that someone ought to look. It might be related, in many cases now, to gambling. Maybe it is just fun games at first, but it does not take very long before the algorithm starts to feed them gambling ads. Pornography is another thing that is drawing many kids in.

There is a question that we have to ask ourselves, because some people might have a conversation. I think there are some legitimate conversations around free speech in the debate. It will be interesting to see when we go to committee and hear from experts on the impact of other parts of the bill as they relate to free speech. However I would say, for the social media part, for me personally as I am looking at this, I do not see the issue of whether a 15-year-old should have access to social media as a free speech issue. In my view, 15-year-olds are not equipped to be signing contracts with social media behemoths and signing away access to their attention, which is what is happening.

It is not a coincidence that we are all seeing what we see on our social media feeds. It is not a coincidence that kids are seeing what they are seeing on their social media feeds. People are paying for them to see what they are seeing on their social media feeds, and the more time they spend on their devices, the more money someone makes in the background. That is an issue. Again, I do not believe that 15-year-olds are equipped to be entering into contracts that they do not fully understand and that tie them into seeing things that they did not expect to see and do not understand why they are seeing them.

I have a quote from C.S. Lewis that I love, and I think it kind of highlights where we are right now. He said:

We all want progress. But progress means getting nearer to the place where you want to be. And if you have taken a wrong turning then to go forward does not get you any nearer. If you are on the wrong road progress means doing an about-turn and walking back to the right road and in that case the man who turns back soonest is the most progressive man.

I want to think about the place we want to be, which C.S. Lewis talks about. I think we all want to be in a place where our kids can thrive, where we all can thrive, where we all can flourish and where we all can live up to our potential. I like to think of a world where our kids can play like we used to play.

Jonathan Haidt's work has been raised in a lot of the conversations around social media age limits particularly, of course. He has four norms that he points to, in terms of his work. He talks not only about a social media age limit, but also about a restriction on smartphones in schools, which provinces across this country have enacted. He talks about parents deciding to delay smartphone access for their kids to 14 years old. The fourth norm is more play in the real world. There is incredible research being done on the power of play in the real world.

I think of my friend Lenore Skenazy and her work on free-range kids, and Mariana Brussoni, a Canadian who does incredible work on unstructured play and the power of risky play. If we are going to go down a road with less social media access for kids, we have to have alternatives for our kids to undertake. I would say, as a country, one thing that we have to look at is where the spaces are where our kids can get outside and play, so more green space, but more green space where kids are safe to explore like we used to explore.

I know my time is running short right now. I am very much looking forward to this bill getting to committee. I think there are some legitimate concerns that folks would have about the bill that relate to fairly undefined powers of a regulator, the impact of some of the freedom of speech provisions within the bill that are not related necessarily to a social media age limit, and others.

Right now, I look forward to questions, but I really look forward to the conversations that are going to happen at committee on the bill.

Bill C-34 Safe Social Media ActGovernment Orders

10:35 a.m.

Liberal

John-Paul Danko Liberal Hamilton West—Ancaster—Dundas, ON

Mr. Speaker, I was listening closely to the member opposite's speech, and as a parent of an 18-year-old and a 20-year-old, I really agree with pretty much everything that he had to say here. That is a rare occurrence in this House. One of the things that I think about quite often is that my kids grew up with social media from day one, so the amount of data and information that has been collected from their lives when they are posting and when they are contributing on those platforms is really concerning. We see dystopian movies where targeted ads follow people around. I think some of the members' comments about unstructured play, getting outside and touching grass are also really important for youth.

I would like to know his comments on what he is hearing from other parents.

Bill C-34 Safe Social Media ActGovernment Orders

10:35 a.m.

Conservative

Mike Lake Conservative Leduc—Wetaskiwin, AB

Mr. Speaker, that is a great question. Of course, I assume we have all been lobbied by the unplugged folks who are so passionate about this issue on behalf of their kids, which I think is more than 10,000 strong in terms of the impact. We have all gone back to our constituencies and talked to people.

In relation to the privacy issues the member raises, I want to give kudos to the member for Lethbridge who has consistently, as we have been having this conversation, been raising those issues. I expect they will be significantly raised in the committee as well.

Again, I come back to my focus and the work I have been doing and intend to be doing. There is a real power to play, and in order to make room for play, getting off or reducing time on our devices is going to be critical.

Bill C-34 Safe Social Media ActGovernment Orders

10:35 a.m.

Bloc

Mario Simard Bloc Jonquière—Hébertville—Pays-des-Bleuets, QC

Mr. Speaker, when one looks at the legislation, the many implications it could have become pretty clear. If the government wants to regulate certain online platforms, for instance, it has to include some form of education for young people. It also means taking action on content that may differ depending on whether one is francophone or anglophone.

What I find especially unfortunate is that the bill does not include any obligation for the federal government to consult with the provinces or seek any kind of alignment, particularly with Quebec, which is a distinct society and has a different culture.

Would my colleague agree that the government has missed the mark a bit with the one-size-fits-all measures set out in the bill? That said, I completely agree on the importance of the bill.

Bill C-34 Safe Social Media ActGovernment Orders

10:35 a.m.

Conservative

Mike Lake Conservative Leduc—Wetaskiwin, AB

Mr. Speaker, as a member of Parliament from Alberta, I would share those thoughts. Obviously, if the committee is given a strong enough mandate and enough time to study this piece of legislation, provinces will have a chance to weigh in, either at committee or by sending comments to the committee, and I think that would be really important.

It is important to me, more than almost any other piece of legislation I have seen, that Parliament, through the committee process right now, take the time to get this right. There are many legitimate concerns that have been raised, and it is very important that the committee that undertakes this study take the time to really hear those concerns and get it right.

Bill C-34 Safe Social Media ActGovernment Orders

October 29th, 2026 / 10:40 a.m.

Conservative

Rachael Thomas Conservative Lethbridge, AB

Mr. Speaker, I thank my colleague for his passionate speech and the incredible work he has done on this file over years, if not a decade, as a member of Parliament.

Bill C-34 does not outline the types of design features that should be put in place by platforms in order to keep kids safe. That is going to be determined later on. Given the member's tremendous amount of research and expertise in this area, I wonder if there are two or three design features he would hope to see come out of the regulatory framework that would be created.

Bill C-34 Safe Social Media ActGovernment Orders

10:40 a.m.

Conservative

Mike Lake Conservative Leduc—Wetaskiwin, AB

Mr. Speaker, when we take a look at the different design features, such as infinite scroll, one of the conversations we need to have, and this is broader than just children, is on some transparency around why we see what we see. I think, for all of us, that is a huge issue. We just take what is given to us and go on to the next thing, and we do not know why we are seeing what we see. Some transparency around that is tremendously important. Again, this will probably be one of the key things that the committee looks at from witnesses who—

Bill C-34 Safe Social Media ActGovernment Orders

10:40 a.m.

The Deputy Speaker Tom Kmiec

We will have to hear the rest at another time.

Resuming debate, the hon. Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister of Public Safety.

Bill C-34 Safe Social Media ActGovernment Orders

10:40 a.m.

La Prairie—Atateken Québec

Liberal

Jacques Ramsay LiberalParliamentary Secretary to the Minister of Public Safety

Mr. Speaker, I am pleased to rise to speak to the safe social media act. This topic holds considerable interest for many people in my riding of La Prairie—Atateken. I sincerely thank everyone who shared their views with me.

I want to start by addressing a reality that is quite familiar to families in my riding. In Candiac, Saint‑Constant, Kahnawake and other communities across the country, the first thing that many young people see on a screen in the morning and the last thing they see at night is an app. These services have real and undeniable benefits. They provide information, bring people closer together, and offer an outlet for creativity. However, they also expose our children to risks that we would never tolerate in other circumstances. The numbers are clear: One in four young people aged 12 to 17 say they have been cyber-bullied. Reports to police concerning online child sexual exploitation are increasing dramatically. In 2023‑24, the RCMP received over 100,000 reports in Canada alone in a single year.

Young people harmed in this way are much more likely to suffer from mental health issues, including suicidal ideation. Fourteen years ago, Amanda Todd took her own life because she was a victim of sextortion and cyber-bullying. Since then, two bills addressing online harm have died on the Order Paper. Victims and their families tell us that they have waited too long, and they are right. For a time, we hoped that the companies would take the necessary steps to keep our youth safe, but Canadians' trust has eroded. Their voluntary action has never kept pace with the scale, speed and severity of the harm caused. In addition to individuals' predatory behaviour, there are also design flaws, algorithmic recommendations, autoplay and infinite scroll. These are engineering choices that amplify harmful content. Worse still, today, AI chatbots are forming unhealthy, sustained relationships with young people, sometimes during the most difficult times of their lives. Tumbler Ridge is one example.

Bill C-34 is based on a simple principle: The people who design these services must be held accountable for the risks they create. The bill establishes two pieces of legislation: the digital safety act and the digital safety commission of Canada act. Allow me to outline their key provisions.

First, there is a duty to protect children. All regulated services will be required to integrate safe design features and implement age restrictions. As for social media, the government has provided that children must be at least 16 years old to have an account. However, the commission can grant exceptions to platforms that demonstrate that they have implemented and maintained sufficient protections for children. In other words, we are not closing the door. We are setting a standard.

Access to pornographic content must also be restricted using adequate age verification and age estimation measures. This responds to a call for action from our communities. In the spring, digital entrepreneurs and experts from Quebec, including some from my riding, launched an online initiative called AgeStandard, which calls for the enforcement of the 16-year-old age limit on social media. Thousands of people have signed the petition. Their message is simple: A check box has never protected a child. They are right.

Second, there is a duty to remove two types of content that do not belong anywhere: child sex abuse material and intimate images shared without consent, including sexual deepfakes. Social media platforms will be required to make such content inaccessible within 24 hours of it being flagged or reported, through a notice and appeal process. For a victim, every hour counts.

Third, there is a duty to act responsibly. Platforms will have to mitigate the risk of exposure to seven categories of harmful content, including content that induces a child to harm themselves, content used to bully a child, content that foments hatred, content that incites violence, and violent extremism content. They will have to provide simple tools for blocking, reporting and labelling synthetic content, and a readily available resource person.

Fourth, the bill establishes rules governing AI chatbots. If I am not mistaken, this is a world first. As soon as a user expresses suicidal thoughts or the intention to self-harm or hurt others, the service must immediately interrupt its interaction with the user and direct the user toward crisis intervention services that permit the user to interact with a human being. The chatbot may not pose as a human being or a professional, nor use manipulative engagement techniques to maintain an emotional attachment that causes the user to withdraw socially.

Fifth, the bill provides for greater transparency. Each regulated service must submit a digital safety plan containing information on the risks, the measures implemented and their effectiveness. Accredited researchers will be able to access the data. The days when platforms had to be taken at their word are over.

Lastly, the digital safety commission of Canada will be created and equipped with real technical expertise to develop standards, conduct audits, receive public complaints and impose penalties. Penalties for violations could be up to 3% of gross global revenue or $10 million. Convictions on indictment could lead to fines of up to 5% or $20 million, whichever is greater. For companies of this size, this is what sets a recommendation apart from a requirement.

Colleagues in this House, experts and citizens have raised serious concerns that deserve to be examined. First, there is a concern about freedom of expression. In my opinion, freedom of speech is not affected. For example, this bill does not apply to private messaging. It does not require platforms to proactively monitor everything that is being posted. It concerns these services' design and risk management. That is a fundamental difference.

We have also heard concerns about privacy and age verification. I share those concerns. Nobody here wants Canadians to have to hand over a piece of ID to watch a video. Where necessary, this verification should be done automatically. It will need to be properly regulated. This is something the committee will need to look at closely, particularly with the Privacy Commissioner of Canada.

I also want to acknowledge the sustained effort put in by Senator Julie Miville-Dechêne, whose bill, Bill S-209, has passed in the Senate and is now before the House. It aims to restrict young people's access to online pornography. Both bills have the same goal, and I hope the work done in committee will result in a consistent set of clear rules on age verification, rather than trying to impose two parallel systems on the same platforms. There is a way to do just that.

Some have said that too many details are being left to the regulations. That is a valid criticism, but as we know, technology evolves faster than we legislate. That is why it makes sense to enshrine the principles, obligations and penalties in law and to entrust the technical details to an expert body that can adapt as needed. There will be an opportunity at the committee stage to clarify what needs to be in the legislation itself.

Lastly, efforts are also under way elsewhere. The National Assembly of Quebec examined the effects of screen time on young people and focused on the role of schools and on support for families. Our bill addresses this issue by seeking to regulate global platforms. This is where the federal Parliament has a role to play. Platforms have a duty toward the children who use them, and that duty must be enshrined in law. I sincerely believe that the safety of our children is non-negotiable, as the minister said earlier.

The survivors have issued a call to us: If this bill is intended to build a safer digital future, then let it be built together with them. I urge all my colleagues to heed this call.