Mr. Speaker, I am honoured to rise on behalf of the great people of Medicine Hat—Cardston—Warner to discuss the medical assistance in dying safeguards act.
Like many of my constituents, I am puzzled as to why Bill C-41 has gone so far beyond what was necessary. It should have dealt only with preventing the scheduled expansion of MAID to individuals whose sole underlying medical condition is a mental illness. Instead, the Liberals have used it to introduce an entirely separate and deeply divisive debate over advance requests.
The question of MAID for mental illness has already been thoroughly discussed and examined. The Special Joint Committee on Medical Assistance in Dying heard from dozens of witnesses, including clinicians, psychiatrists, researchers and people with lived experience. Serious concerns were raised about the ability to reliably determine whether a mental disorder is irremediable, warning that allowing MAID for mental illness could undermine suicide prevention efforts. The special joint committee's final report made one formal recommendation: that the Government of Canada amend the Criminal Code to indefinitely exclude from MAID eligibility individuals whose sole underlying medical condition is a mental illness, with which I agree.
Conservatives twice offered the Liberals a straightforward path to do exactly that. Two private members' bills in two separate Parliaments sought to prevent this expansion and ensure that mental illness is not treated as a grievous and irremediable condition for the purpose of MAID. The Liberals rejected both and have now needlessly complicated the debate by introducing a bill that raises a separate and deeply consequential question of conscience: whether to legalize advance requests for MAID. Let us examine what the government really is proposing.
An individual would be able to make an advance request based on fears about a future condition they have never experienced, yet when that condition develops, they may find that life remains meaningful and fulfilling despite declining cognitive capacity, and they may no longer wish to die. By then, however, they may be incapable of withdrawing or revoking their earlier request. There are serious questions about whether the proposed safeguards in the bill would actually protect someone who is no longer able to express or reconsider their wish for MAID.
Under Bill C-41, a person would be able to make an advance request while mentally capable, then receive MAID years or even decades later after losing the ability to consent. There would be no requirement to reaffirm or review that decision in the intervening years. The bill does not adequately account for changing circumstances, advances in medical treatment or, importantly, any changes to a person's experience of living with their illness. Individuals often continue to find happiness, comfort and meaning in life years after a concerning diagnosis, yet this bill all but ignores that reality.
One of the most difficult questions is how practitioners would determine whether someone is experiencing enduring and intolerable suffering if that person can no longer communicate their experiences. Although the legislation would require practitioners to assess the person's current medical condition and available information, it does not define “intolerable suffering”. Two practitioners would have to agree the criteria are met, but there would be no requirement for independent review or approval before MAID is administered.
For one, the bill says nothing about a requirement for practitioners to inform patients that MAID is about to be administered or to explain the procedure in words they understand. In the case of any resistance to the procedure, Bill C-41 is even more unclear. If a practitioner is uncertain whether a person's words, sounds or gestures constitute resistance, MAID would be able to proceed after a 30-day waiting period without independent review. This flies in the face of a Canadian public opinion poll conducted by Angus Reid that found that 72% of respondents favour reassessment or cancellation of MAID if the patient persists or appears distressed. In the bill, involuntary sounds or gestures in response to contact would be expressly disregarded as refusal or resistance.
The bill also would not prohibit sedation. This raises concerns about whether a person could be sedated to reduce resistance to the procedure. In addition, all possible treatment options would not have to be exhausted before an advance request could be carried out. Again, the bill largely ignores the passage of time and the significant advances that may occur in treating or alleviating the suffering.
Bill C-41 would present another curious challenge. It would leave important aspects of advance requests to provincial or territorial governments, potentially creating a patchwork of safeguards and different rules depending on where Canadians live. More concerning, it would not expressly prevent someone living in a province that prohibits advance requests from travelling to another jurisdiction where they are permitted, providing that they meet that province's eligibility. In effect, access to MAID through an advance request could depend not only on an individual's circumstances but on where they choose to seek it. On an issue involving life and death, this lack of consistency and accountability is unacceptable. Before MAID is administered, minimum safeguards and independent oversight should apply nationwide.
These are not minor technical concerns. They go to the heart of consent, personal autonomy and the protection of vulnerable people. When a decision is irreversible, Parliament must be confident that safeguards are not merely well intentioned but are exhaustive and enforceable.
I would like my colleagues to consider two recommendations from ARPA, the Association for Reformed Political Action, in its policy report entitled “Assisted Suicide and Euthanasia”. It recommends, “Parliament must not legalize” what the report describes as “nonconsensual homicide through advance requests.” Medical professionals would be asked to rely on instructions made in the past rather than on the wishes of the person currently before them. ARPA also warns that this risks creating “a culture of neglect” for people living with neurocognitive conditions. They deserve care, dignity and meaningful support, not a decision made years earlier determining whether they live or die.
Another of the recommendations calls on Parliament to examine “the vagueness and permissiveness” of the existing MAID framework and undertake a comprehensive review of its effects across Canada. The original 2016 legislation required such a review after five years, yet it has never been completed. Before even contemplating an expansion of MAID, Parliament has a responsibility to understand if the existing law's eligibility criteria are sufficient and clear, if safeguards are being consistently applied and properly enforced, if there is adequate independent oversight and accountability when concerns arise, and if vulnerable Canadians are being offered the treatment, care and support they need rather than being left to see MAID as the only alternative. These are not questions that can be brushed aside before attempting to make the regime even more permissive.
While I respect the diversity of views in the House, I am opposed to the use of advance requests within the MAID regime, because, first, greater autonomy in end-of-life decisions must never come at the expense of compassionate, affirming care. Too many Canadians in need of mental health care, disability supports or palliative care are left without adequate resources and offered death instead of the support they need to live well. Expanding MAID in these circumstances risks deepening a culture of neglect.
Second, existing proposed safeguards are not sufficient. They must be clear, enforceable and transparent. Serious concerns remain about inconsistent application, inadequate oversight and a lack of accountability. The government should not attempt to expand the MAID regime until these shortcomings have been addressed and fixed.
Third, fundamental questions remain about whether the bill would protect consent, guard against coercion, ensure independent oversight, account for changes in a person's wishes over time and respect federal and provincial responsibilities. For this reason, I urge the government to split this bill, allowing parliamentarians to examine two distinct issues on their own merits: advance requests for MAID and preventing the scheduled expansion of MAID to individuals whose sole underlying medical condition is mental illness.
Ultimately, parliamentarians' responsibility must be to ensure that no Canadian feels that death is their only realistic option because the care, treatment and supports they need are unavailable. We should be making it easier for people to live with dignity, not making it easier for them to die.
