House of Commons Hansard #163 of the 45th Parliament, 1st session. (The original version is on Parliament's site.) The word of the day was s-5.

Topics

line drawing of robot

This summary is computer-generated. Usually it’s accurate, but every now and then it’ll contain inaccuracies or total fabrications.

Connected Care for Canadians Act Second reading of Bill S-5. The bill requires health information technology vendors to adopt common standards and prohibits data blocking, aiming to let patients and authorized providers securely share medical records, improve care coordination and support research. Members broadly endorse interoperability but raise questions about privacy, cybersecurity, implementation costs, vendor oversight, innovation and provincial jurisdiction, particularly Quebec’s. Conservatives support the goal while calling for scrutiny of implementation and accountability; the Bloc opposes the bill without stronger protections for provincial authority. 36300 words, 4 hours in 2 segments: 1 2.

Statements by Members

Question Period

The Conservatives criticize the government’s taxes and spending, warning of food affordability problems and rising debt. They challenge immigration levels and accounting, and repeatedly question the Prime Minister over a Telesat contract and potential conflicts of interest. They also raise concerns about government transparency, public safety and bail reform.
The Liberals promote Budget 2026 as a plan for affordability and investment, fiscal strength, housing and support for families. They defend immigration reforms, highlight clean-energy projects and Canadian sovereignty, and back major-project development, jobs and business productivity. They also defend the Prime Minister’s ethics and deny his involvement in Telesat decisions.
The Bloc opposes Bill C-39 over Indigenous rights, environmental protections and limits on striking. It also condemns oil companies’ record profits and government support for the fossil fuel industry, including a proposed pipeline and oil-and-gas tax deductions. (/debates/2026/11/5/mario-simard-10/)
The NDP call for affordability measures, including non-market housing, affordable groceries and better health care, and warn that AI data centres could raise electricity costs for families.

Financial Statement of Minister of Finance Members debate Budget 2026, which the Liberal government presents as a plan for economic growth, affordability, housing, sovereignty and cultural investment. Conservatives criticize its deficits, borrowing and accounting framework, while the Bloc raises concerns about Quebec’s health transfers, asylum costs and jurisdiction. The NDP questions spending priorities, and the Green Party and Bloc criticize climate measures. 13200 words, 2 hours.

Was this summary helpful and accurate?

Bill S-5 Connected Care for Canadians ActGovernment Orders

1:45 p.m.

Bloc

Mario Simard Bloc Jonquière—Hébertville—Pays-des-Bleuets, QC

Mr. Speaker, the member for Winnipeg North has often oversimplified things in the past, but I found it especially interesting today when he said that people should care more about patients than about jurisdictions.

If my colleague were consistent and really cared about patients, he would not accept that his party is making cuts to health transfers, and he would not accept this disgraceful situation where, year after year, the federal government underfunds health care. Right now, the federal government is barely covering 22% of health care costs. If the member really cares about patients, then he should try to convince his government to be less stingy when it comes to health care funding.

Bill S-5 Connected Care for Canadians ActGovernment Orders

1:50 p.m.

Liberal

Kevin Lamoureux Liberal Winnipeg North, MB

Mr. Speaker, there is a long story with respect to health care transfers. We could go back many decades to when the provinces and the federal government made the decision that they wanted some change in tax points to the provinces in favour of having direct cash going to them. I was never a big fan of that. I believe that the federal government needs to not only have a strong, healthy Canada Health Act but also to maintain a basic level of health transfers. That is something the government, under the Prime Minister, has committed to do.

In addition to that, I would recognize that the Prime Minister came up with a $5-billion fund to build Canada's capital health infrastructure. I look forward to those health care dollars' being spent across the country.

Bill S-5 Connected Care for Canadians ActGovernment Orders

November 5th, 2026 / 1:50 p.m.

Liberal

Eric St-Pierre Liberal Honoré-Mercier, QC

Mr. Speaker, I just learned that the member for Winnipeg North is a former Manitoba health critic. His comments on a stronger collaboration are well noted. However, I wonder if my colleague can elaborate a bit more on data blocking and vested interests. Why is data blocking important?

Bill S-5 Connected Care for Canadians ActGovernment Orders

1:50 p.m.

Liberal

Kevin Lamoureux Liberal Winnipeg North, MB

Mr. Speaker, the simple reason is that often data blocking is not done in the interests of the patient but in the interests of some vendor that has a vested interest, and often that vested interest is driven by money. Whether it is the Prime Minister or any member of the Liberal caucus, what we are saying is that we need to put the patient first. If we put the patient first, we will have a better, stronger and healthier health care system.

Bill S-5 Connected Care for Canadians ActGovernment Orders

1:50 p.m.

Conservative

Kelly DeRidder Conservative Kitchener Centre, ON

Mr. Speaker, it is an honour to rise on behalf of Kitchener Centre to speak to this really important issue.

I think we can all agree that every Canadian should be able to access quality health care when they need it, without waiting and regardless of where they live and what they earn. Unfortunately, that is not the reality of our current health care system. Canadians are struggling to find a family doctor. They are waiting months if not years to see specialists. They join long wait lists for surgeries and imaging. Emergency rooms are overcrowded, and patients spend hours waiting even to be assessed. For too many Canadians, the challenge is simply accessing health care. While we can all agree that our health care system is worth protecting, it cannot mean defending something that is failing too many Canadians.

Canadian taxpayers spend an enormous amount of money on their own health care. Taxpayers will spend $57 billion in 2026-27, and Canadians are still left waiting for proper care for their investment. Do members know that Canada ranks last among 10 similar countries with respect to timely access to health care? Only one in four Canadians gets an appointment with a doctor or nurse the day they need it. Most Canadians wait two months or longer to see a specialist.

We have to ask ourselves how we can make our system work better. It is not just about how much money we put into health care. It is about its effectiveness. How do we support health care professionals, and how do we improve the outcomes for all Canadians?

Let us imagine that somebody from Kitchener decides to travel across this beautiful country to Alberta. Maybe they are visiting family, enjoying a family vacation or travelling for work. Then, unexpectedly, they have a heart attack. They are taken to the ER, and the doctors treating them need to know their medical history, such as what medications they are taking, if they have any allergies, if they have had any previous surgeries or if there are any underlying issues or conditions that could affect their treatment. The patient is lucky enough to have a family doctor in Ontario, but their medical records are not in the same system as Alberta's, and the hospital cannot access them.

What happens now? The patient literally cannot provide their health information if they have had a heart attack. They cannot give their history. They cannot give their allergies or the pertinent information the doctors may need in that exact moment. The doctors now are spending time trying to access the patient's information instead of immediately caring for them. Tests may be needed or repeated, and information is not available. All this is happening while the individual is not getting the care they need. Would it not make more sense if the patient's medical information could just follow them so surgeons would immediately be able to operate on them, potentially saving lives?

A colleague just shared a story with me. A man and his wife were travelling across the country, and they got in a car accident. Because of that car accident, the gentleman needed immediate surgery, and his wife was unconscious. Right on the roadside, penicillin was administered to the man during the operation, but unfortunately he was allergic to the penicillin and passed away. Data transfer can literally save lives in this country.

We have already invested in medical records across this country. More than 95% of physicians use electronic medical records today, but that is not the same as having a connected system. A doctor might have a patient's entire medical history on their computer, but if the doctor treating them next door does not have that same information, we have a problem. Only 29% of primary care providers make patient information available outside their own practice. Only a quarter of practitioners make that information available outside that practice. This leaves 75% of the population without records that can be immediately accessed so patients can get immediate care in the times they need it.

This costs Canadian taxpayers an extra $9.4 billion a year. Let us think about that. Billions of dollars are being lost because the information that already exists on a system somewhere is not being accessed by someone right next door. Patients are undergoing repeat tests. Health care professionals are spending extra time tracking down records. Important information is being missed when patients move between providers.

Doctors, nurses, pharmacists and other health care professionals should be spending their time caring for patients, and that is it. They should not be spending their time trying to access information that already exists on another system. It is a complete waste of, first, the physician's time and, second, the immediate access to care for patients who immediately need it. Not having to chase down medical records or repeat work that has already been done would only help the care of patients here in Canada. We should be giving physicians the tools they need to do their jobs, not making their jobs more difficult by repeatedly investigating the care that a particular person may need.

There is a tremendous opportunity with the bill, but there are a lot of questions behind the scenes. We do need to make sure that the details are right with this piece of legislation, because Canadians need to be able to access their own data, and we do need actual improvements for Canadians. This cannot just be another measure where we are saying that we are going to be doing something in Parliament but not actually working with the provinces and territories to make sure that it is implemented across Canada.

We have questions that we need to ask, and as we move forward, we will ensure that we ask these questions in committee.

Provinces and territories are responsible for their own health care systems. As the federal government, we need to respect the role of the provinces. We should be working with them to make sure that health information can be shared across provinces in a way that all provinces agree with. We have to ensure that we are not going to be encroaching on provincial territory when we are trying to implement a system to access care across systems. This is a key important piece of this legislation that we need to look at.

We need to understand how the bill would work with the systems that are already in place and make sure provinces still have a say in how these changes are made. We know that different practitioners use different systems, so what does that mean for the current systems that practitioners are already using? Are they going to be able to keep these systems or are they going to need to move to a different system? None of these questions have any answers to them yet, and these are the things we are going to look at.

Aerospace IndustryStatements by Members

2 p.m.

Liberal

Doug Eyolfson Liberal Winnipeg West, MB

Mr. Speaker, I rise today to recognize the 55th anniversary of Boeing Winnipeg, located in my riding of Winnipeg West.

Established in 1971 with just 57 employees building Boeing 747 components, Boeing Winnipeg has grown through five major expansions into Canada's largest aerospace composite manufacturing facility. Today, nearly 1,500 skilled workers operate across its 700,000 square foot facility, producing critical components for Boeing commercial aircraft, including the 787 Dreamliner, as well as the P-8 Poseidon, Canada's next multi-mission aircraft.

With an extensive local supplier network and a recent $36-million investment supporting research, development and robotics, alongside its contributions to STEM education and veterans' opportunities, Boeing Winnipeg remains an important anchor of Manitoba's aerospace sector.

Please join me in congratulating Boeing Winnipeg and, most importantly, its dedicated workforce, on 55 years of innovation, excellence and contributions to our community and economy.

The EconomyStatements by Members

2 p.m.

Conservative

Clifford Small Conservative Coast of Bays—Central—Notre Dame, NL

Mr. Speaker, families and seniors across Coast of Bays—Central—Notre Dame are working hard and doing their best to live within their means, yet they are struggling to make ends meet.

The Liberal Prime Minister promised Canadians affordability, but the reality is that we have higher costs and growing financial pressure on households. In Newfoundland and Labrador, food security affects more than one in four residents. Food bank usage across our province has increased by 44% since 2019. These are not just statistics. These numbers represent real people making impossible choices between groceries, heating their homes and putting fuel in their vehicles.

As Liberals prepare to table their budget, Canadians deserve action, not more spending and debt. The government needs to cut waste and restore fiscal responsibility, instead of spending and making more debt. The government needs to eliminate all taxes on gas and diesel. It is high time that the Prime Minister lives up to the expectations of those who voted for him—

The EconomyStatements by Members

2 p.m.

The Speaker Francis Scarpaleggia

The hon. member for Hochelaga—Rosemont-Est.

BPW MontréalStatements by Members

2 p.m.

Liberal

Marie-Gabrielle Ménard Liberal Hochelaga—Rosemont-Est, QC

Mr. Speaker, I want to take members on a trip down memory lane.

In 1926, seven visionary and determined women founded BPW Montréal, a business and professional women's network. For the past 100 years, BPW Montréal has played an important role in advancing gender equality and promoting women's professional development.

To the many CEOs and dedicated board members who have served the organization over the past century, congratulations on this remarkable milestone. While some are no longer with us and are watching over us today, I am certain they would be immensely proud of all that has been accomplished.

To the tireless, the passionate, the go-getters: Your contributions have left an indelible mark on the organization as we celebrate it today.

My colleagues and I have great admiration for all that has been achieved, and we fully appreciate the strength and collective power of women.

I wish BPW Montréal a very happy centenary.

Royal Canadian Air Force FoundationStatements by Members

2 p.m.

Conservative

Blake Richards Conservative Airdrie—Cochrane, AB

Mr. Speaker, as we begin Veterans' Week and we approach Remembrance Day, I had the privilege of co-hosting a reception this afternoon for the Royal Canadian Air Force Foundation under the leadership of Jeremy Diamond.

When Canadians think of veterans, minds can often drift to historical black and white photos. We remain deeply appreciative of the freedoms that they fought for, but there are also heroes who walk among us today. They are our neighbours, parents of young children and colleagues that we work with, and they bore heavy burdens in modern conflicts like Afghanistan, the Gulf, and many other missions.

By supporting modern veterans and inspiring tomorrow's aviation leaders, the Royal Canadian Air Force Foundation bridges our history with our future through STEM scholarships, with recipients joining us today, including Anjana Ramaswamy, Clare Balkissoon, Arabella Allen, Nehsy Poinen, Declan McCloskey, Virajdeep Rattan, Lucy Levy and Vincent Bujold-Roux.

Let us stand united behind our veterans, past and present, and remember that a life of service is the only life worth living.

Eric BauzaStatements by Members

2:05 p.m.

Liberal

Doly Begum Liberal Scarborough Southwest, ON

Mr. Speaker, I rise to mourn Eric Bauza, Scarborough's very own Emmy Award-winning voice actor.

Eric attended St. John Henry Newman Catholic High School in my riding of Scarborough Southwest, and from those hallways he went on to become the voice of Bugs Bunny, Daffy Duck and many other beloved characters. A proud Filipino Canadian, Eric broke barriers in an industry where very few look like him, inspiring young people across our communities. During the pandemic, he joined our virtual New Year's celebration, bringing laughter and joy when we needed it the most.

I want to quote Eric's parting message from his high school yearbook: “Well, b4 I go, I'd like 2 say thanx 2 every1 who thought I was funny, & if I ever do b-come famous, party at my house!”

I call on the members of the House to join me in offering our deepest condolences to Eric's family and loved ones. Eric's legacy lives on through the laughter that he gave to this world.

Margaret HeinmillerStatements by Members

2:05 p.m.

Conservative

John Nater Conservative Perth—Wellington, ON

Mr. Speaker, as we begin Veterans' Week, I rise to pay tribute to World War II veteran Margaret Heinmiller.

Marg passed away this week at the age of 101. Born in Berkshire, England, she came to Canada at the age of four, and when World War II broke out, she was determined to serve. She joined the Royal Canadian Navy, the senior service, as she was quick to tell us, and almost joined the air force. Like so many of her great generation, when Marg's service in uniform ended, her service to the community continued. She was the first woman to join the Listowel Legion in 1947 and was the first woman president of the Palmerston Legion.

Even at 101 years old, Marg was quick with a witty joke, often delivered while on one of her daily walks down Main Street in Palmerston. Our hearts are with Marg's family and loved ones.

On behalf of a grateful nation, Bravo Zulu, Marg. I thank you for your service.

Service de police de la Ville de MontréalStatements by Members

2:05 p.m.

Liberal

Abdelhaq Sari Liberal Bourassa, QC

Mr. Speaker, since June, certain facts have been coming to light about the Service de police de la Ville de Montréal. A team at station 39 was disbanded, allegations of racist acts were made, and evidence of domestic violence provided by a victim was allegedly destroyed.

On Monday, we learned that the police force had fired seven police officers. That response was necessary. However, for the riding of Bourassa, it is neither a finish line nor the end of the matter.

I am telling the police force that it needs to meet the moment. Montrealers are entitled to transparency and public accountability. I am thinking about the people who were affected, the families who were afraid and the police officers who had the integrity to break the silence.

I want to remind all of those people that they are not alone. In Canada, safety is not a privilege, dignity is not negotiable, and a person's background should not determine how they are treated.

Automotive IndustryStatements by Members

2:05 p.m.

Conservative

Chris Lewis Conservative Essex, ON

Mr. Speaker, I rise on behalf of the 6,000 auto workers in Windsor-Essex at the Windsor assembly plant. Next week, these workers will be laid off by Stellantis, marking the fourth shutdown before Christmas.

The Liberal government has handed more than $6 billion to Stellantis, yet these workers are still without work. The government is also spending billions in foreign aid abroad and opening our market to state-subsidized Chinese EVs that compete with our own vehicles.

The Prime Minister promised a deal with the U.S. by 2025. Instead, families in Essex are losing faith because they are losing their jobs. No deal means no jobs. These workers are not asking for government handouts. They are asking to work and provide for their families.

The Liberal budget should put Canadian workers first, reduce foreign aid spending, stop opening our market to state-subsidized Chinese vehicles and take action to prevent Canada's auto industry from being hollowed out. Essex workers have paid the price for the government's failures for far too long.

Canadian Armed Forces LegendStatements by Members

2:05 p.m.

Bloc

Mario Simard Bloc Jonquière—Hébertville—Pays-des-Bleuets, QC

Mr. Speaker, today I want to talk about a strong, larger-than-life man who has become a legend in the Canadian Armed Forces: Chief Warrant Officer Marco Côté.

This guy from back home began his military career in 1988 with Le Régiment du Saguenay. In 1999, he was selected to join Canada's elite special operations unit, where he served for more than 20 years.

Following the events of September 11, 2001, he was deployed to Afghanistan and was awarded the highest U.S. military honour, the Presidential Unit Citation. In 2003, he completed sniper training, and in 2010, he became the warrant officer in charge of the sniper team. In 2017, he was promoted to chief warrant officer and became the regimental sergeant major of the Canadian Special Operations Regiment.

It would take too long to list all the awards he has earned, but I can say that Marco Côté is an exceptional leader, capable of the greatest sacrifices and endowed with a talent and courage that would put Rambo and Chuck Norris to shame.

Mr. Côté, we are all very proud of you.

Patricia May MartynStatements by Members

2:10 p.m.

Liberal

Peter Fragiskatos Liberal London Centre, ON

Mr. Speaker, it is a great honour to rise to honour the life of Patricia May Martyn, who passed away recently at the age of 86.

Married for 66 years to her best friend, Harold, together they raised four children, Paul, Linda, Anne and Karen. Karen, of course, is our former colleague, Karen Vecchio, who served the House so ably and with such great talent and dedication from 2015 through 2025.

Adored by her children, of course, her grandchildren and many great-grandchildren, Patricia May Martyn was an outstanding Canadian, someone who loved her community and her family. She is someone who will be deeply missed.

Our country is a great place, a great country for so many reasons, but it is unsung heroes like Patricia May who made it so. It is an honour to speak about her today. May she rest in peace.

The EconomyStatements by Members

2:10 p.m.

Conservative

John Williamson Conservative New Brunswick Southwest, NB

Mr. Speaker, lobster season opens November 10 in southwest New Brunswick. Fishing families along the Bay of Fundy are ready to work, but many are worried about making ends meet. Before setting day, diesel is already up 50% in a year. It is made worse by the Liberals' clean fuel tax that adds 19¢ a litre to diesel and 15¢ a litre to gasoline. Every boat carries hundreds of lobster traps; they have now been hit with a Canadian tariff.

Our fishermen are literally paying their own government in Ottawa just to go to work. These men and women work hard, follow the rules and pay their taxes. They are the backbone of coastal communities. They work as hard as ever, pay more and fall further behind.

This is a story across Canada, worsened by 11 years of massive deficit spending. It is a government that spends well beyond its means and passes the costs to Canadians. The budget must cut taxes, stop inflationary money printing and end its wasteful spending. Canadians deserve nothing less.

Hamilton CardinalsStatements by Members

2:10 p.m.

Liberal

Lisa Hepfner Liberal Hamilton Mountain, ON

Mr. Speaker, it is official. The Canadian Baseball League's top executive in 2026 is Hamilton's Eric Spearin. Fans packed into Bernie Arbour Stadium in Hamilton Mountain all season long to watch the Hamilton Cardinals play with a talent-packed roster. The Cardinals are among the city's oldest sports teams, but their last championship game was in 1978. For a long stretch, the team struggled until Eric Spearin became owner in 2022. His vision brought the team a real winning culture and, for the first time, the Cardinals were on top heading into the championship series.

The team's impact goes much deeper than winning ball games in Hamilton. When 80 children were suddenly left without a way to get to the Salvation Army summer camp, Eric Spearin dispatched the Cardinals team bus to make sure no one missed out. We are grateful and proud.

Congratulations to the Cardinals.

The EconomyStatements by Members

2:10 p.m.

Conservative

Kelly Block Conservative Carlton Trail—Eagle Creek, SK

Mr. Speaker, after more than a decade of inflationary Liberal policies, Canadians are concerned with the direction our country is going. News of Canada's inflation rate rising is sad confirmation they have every reason to be. While the Prime Minister promised affordability, Canadians are watching the cost of housing, groceries, fuel, insurance, utilities and everyday living rise to increasingly unsustainable levels. Even though they are working full time at good-paying jobs, they are still struggling to afford necessities. Recent reports of increased food bank usage and people skipping meals because they cannot afford groceries are further confirmation of this sad reality.

The Prime Minister is out of touch, his spending is out of control and Canadians are out of money. In today's budget, Conservatives are calling on the Liberals to cut wasteful inflationary spending, keep their promised debt anchors and save Canadians money by reducing the cost of gas, groceries—

The EconomyStatements by Members

2:15 p.m.

The Speaker Francis Scarpaleggia

The hon. member for Vaudreuil.

Mille et une huîtres EventStatements by Members

2:15 p.m.

Liberal

Peter Schiefke Liberal Vaudreuil, QC

Mr. Speaker, this Saturday, I will have the pleasure of marking the 10th anniversary of Mille et une huîtres, an oyster dinner fundraiser organized by the Fondation Paul-Leboeuf.

For 10 years now, this event has been bringing our community together to give children and adults with special needs a chance to enjoy adapted and inclusive camp experiences at the Centre Notre-Dame-de-Fatima. Thanks to the generosity of the attendees over the past decade, more than 20,000 camp days have been offered, supporting 1,398 campers with special needs and their families.

I would like to thank Steven Grenier, Guillaume Roberge, France Pomminville, and the entire team and board of directors for their hard work year after year, not to mention all the donors whose generous contributions continue to support this important work in our community of Vaudreuil.

May this extraordinary camp continue to thrive for years and decades to come.

The EconomyStatements by Members

2:15 p.m.

Conservative

Gérard Deltell Conservative Louis-Saint-Laurent—Akiawenhrahk, QC

Mr. Speaker, the budget will be tabled in less than two hours, and we, the Conservatives, want Canadians to have more money in their pockets. That is why we are proposing to eliminate gas taxes, which have a real impact on the cost of food and other goods, to reduce wasteful and inflationary spending and to save Canadians money at the pumps, at the grocery store and everywhere else.

For businesses, we want what they want: less bureaucracy. Incidentally, I commend the representative of the Association hôtelière de la région de Québec who came to Ottawa to highlight the hotel industry's contribution to Quebec's economic growth. Six hundred million dollars in spinoffs is good, but too much bureaucracy is not.

Although the Prime Minister, the prominent banker, promised affordability, everything has become more expensive since he took over. For the sake of all Canadians, we are hoping for a responsible budget.

Ordine al Merito AwardStatements by Members

2:15 p.m.

Liberal

Judy Sgro Liberal Humber River—Black Creek, ON

Mr. Speaker, I rise today to recognize an extraordinary member of our community, Danny Montesano, who will soon be honoured with the Ordine al Merito award by the National Congress of Italian-Canadians.

I have known Danny for decades and have seen first-hand his kindness, generosity and dedication to helping those around him. A respected business leader and successful entrepreneur, he has never lost sight of the importance of giving back. Through his long-standing record of charitable donations, including generous support for local hospitals and many other causes, Danny has made a meaningful difference in the lives of countless families across the community.

This recognition by the national congress is a testament to a lifetime of hard work, leadership and service. I extend my heartfelt congratulations from my family to his. To Danny, on this well-deserved honour, bravo.

I thank him for all that he does for our community.

TaxationOral Questions

2:15 p.m.

Battle River—Crowfoot Alberta

Conservative

Pierre Poilievre ConservativeLeader of the Opposition

Mr. Speaker, one in three Canadians are skipping meals because groceries are too expensive. The number one job of the budget is to save Canadians money.

Will this Prime Minister get rid of all of his 20¢-per-litre taxes on diesel and gasoline to help Canadians save money at the pump and at the grocery store?

With one in three Canadians skipping meals because they cannot afford groceries under this Prime Minister, job one for the budget is to save Canadians money.

Will he get rid of his 20¢-a-litre tax on gas, to save Canadians at the pump and at the grocery store?

TaxationOral Questions

2:15 p.m.

Nepean Ontario

Liberal

Mark Carney LiberalPrime Minister

Mr. Speaker, in a few hours, we will unveil the budget so that Canadians can become masters of our destiny, and therefore masters of their own destiny, through affordability, opportunities and, above all, sovereignty, so that we can live our lives as we choose.