House of Commons photo

Crucial Fact

  • His favourite word was children.

Last in Parliament October 2000, as Reform MP for Calgary Centre (Alberta)

Won his last election, in 1997, with 40% of the vote.

Statements in the House

Supply March 4th, 1999

Mr. Speaker, there are a number of questions and I will go fairly quickly. Yes, we did vote against some of the initiatives which this member just raised. Our proposal detailed how a million low income Canadians would come off the tax roll. We are asking why those low income Canadians were ever on there in the first place.

The member has talked about the various budgets they brought forward to help low income Canadians. As far as dealing with the motion today, the inequity or the differential between single and dual income families has only been accentuated by the government opposite.

In its previous budget of 1998 it actually increased the amount of money that can be claimed for child care expenses in an institutional day care. Again it totally ignored the other arrangements of parents in the best interest of their families. It only increased the differential.

As far as the child tax benefit is concerned, one of the tragic points about it is that it is more of a bureaucracy benefit. The government takes money away from the same families it then pays the tax benefit to. They give $1 to the bureaucracy and the bureaucracy burns up 40 cents of the dollar and gives 60 cents back to Canadians. Why does it not just leave the money with families in the first place?

A lot of improvements are needed over there. It is a fundamental rework of the way they approach the whole tax structure.

Supply March 4th, 1999

Mr. Speaker, it seems what we thought might be a fairly calm debate could be a lively one.

We are debating an important motion which has been a long time coming to the floor of the House. The motion reads:

That, in the opinion of this House, the federal tax system should be reformed to end discrimination against single income families with children.

Single income families have long known that they are disadvantaged by the Liberal tax policies and it keeps getting worse. For example, a single income family earning $60,000 will pay $9,589 in taxes, but a two income family making the same $60,000 pays only $5,790 in tax.

The single income family pays 65% more taxes in this tax bracket. It is the same scenario at $50,000. The result there though is actually worse with 91% more in tax paid by the single income family. The lower we go, the worse it gets. At $45,000 the single income family pays 136% more, and so it continues.

In addition, the dual income earning family can deduct child care expenses if children are cared for in institutional day care programs which would serve to further reduce the tax paid by the dual income families compared to single income families.

Even after a decade of petitions and lobbying the Liberal government each year adds to the discrepancy between the tax paid by single income families and dual income families.

Single income families pay more in tax on the same income. They also miss out on the $7,000 allowable child care expense deduction if children are put in institutional day care programs. To add insult to injury, a parent who is at home is treated as somewhat less of a person in that he or she receives a basic spousal deduction of almost $1,100 lower than what every other working Canadian receives as their basic personal exemption.

A number of other voices are joining with Canadian families in the call for more equitable tax treatment. The Canadian Council on Social Development and the Vanier Institute in 1998 noted that average Canadian family after tax incomes have substantially fallen in recent years.

The C. D. Howe Institute, the National Foundation for Family Research and Education, and the Fraser Forum have all now reported that there currently exists unjustifiable inequities in the current tax treatment of families. For example, the C. D. Howe Institute, when referring to the child care exemption deduction, said:

—it is difficult to find a rationale for the CCED in the desire to achieve greater equity in the treatment of dual earner versus single earner couples, since families that care for their own children have lost all tax recognition for their children.

Reformers have long been aware of the need for fair family taxation in Canada, specifically in past budgets and again in this year's budget. Reform proposed an alternative budget. We detailed a fully costed out proposal that provides substantial tax relief to all families. In addition, we detailed a fully refundable tax credit for all parents regardless of how they choose to care for their children. It is not a tax deduction but a credit that would be equal in benefit to all parents whether or not they had taxable income.

We say let us leave the money and the child care choices with parents where they belong. Reform has long called for the basic spousal exemption to be equal to the basic exemption. Today the exemption for a stay at home parent is $1,100 less than for a working parent.

The financial considerations are important but also important are the social messages current tax policies send. Let us examine some of that social messaging. We know that family situations are dynamic and changing in Canada today. Parents are doing the best they can. Sometimes parents provide child care at home. Sometimes an extended family member helps with the children. Others share their responsibilities with friends or with local community groups. These and a dynamic variety of other arrangements occur.

Why does the Liberal government give a $7,000 tax expense deduction to institutional day care but there is no recognition of any other type of care? It sends the message that parental or extended family care has no value. This is wrong. A refundable child tax credit to all parents leaves the money and the child care choices with parents where they belong.

What about the message to stay at home parents when the basic spousal exemption is $1,100 less than everyone else's basic exemption? For many the message according to the Liberal tax code is that they are less than complete people, that they are second class people. This is a wrong message.

Often these same parents have chosen to devote the majority of their time to the nurturing of their children, Canada's next generation. Do members not think that is valuable work? Then why does the Liberal government continue the message to them through the tax code that what they are doing is less valuable than the work done by every other Canadian?

Reformers say that the basic exemption should be the same for all including parents at home. A recently formed national coalition called the Canadian family tax coalition called on the government to allow income splitting by families. This would allow both parents to pool their incomes and divide it equitably between spouses to reduce total taxes paid.

It would also increase the equity of dual income families. This is not a foreign or unique concept. This kind of thing has been done in many other countries including France, Germany and the United States. Reform supports the examination of joint filing or income splitting, perhaps through a parliamentary committee and some public input, to assess the impacts and to advance us toward more equitable tax treatment of single income families in line with today's motion.

The C. D. Howe Institute stated in a very recent review of the family taxation system that the take portion of Canada's tax system, the revenue raising part, assesses taxes on an individual basis but the give portion, the many spending programs, calculates benefits on a family basis. It asked the question whether this inconsistency was defensible. I suggest it is designed to raise the maximum amount of revenue and pay the minimum amount of benefit.

In the same report the C. D. Howe Institute stated that the Canadian Income Tax Act was no longer about tax policy and that social policy had become an increasingly integral part. The institute continued by indicating that, whatever the merits of that side of the act, social policy considerations had crowded out legitimate tax policy objectives.

That is our point today. We are calling on every member to use this opportunity to address the anti-family discriminatory social policies inherent in the current structure of the tax code.

With that in mind, I would like to move an amendment to strengthen the current motion on the floor:

That the motion be amended by inserting before the word “end” the word “permanently”.

Supply March 4th, 1999

Mr. Speaker, today we are debating an important motion that has been a long time in coming to the floor of the House. In fact, too long, I would suggest.

The motion is that in the opinion of this House the federal income—

The Budget February 18th, 1999

Madam Speaker, I appreciated a comment of the hon. member and I wanted to touch on a similar theme. He just alluded to the way the government announced the health care spending but did not mention very strongly that it was over five years.

I am concerned that Canadians are aware of the taxes they are paying. With GST and EI and CPP there is some way for the public to be very much aware of that. The one area I was hoping to see—and we actually discussed it in the prebudget debate in the House—was the fact that income tax brackets were not indexed to inflation.

I know the hon. member is a man of high integrity and when he speaks it is from his heart. The issue is that because they were not indexed Canadians are actually paying $10 billion more since they stopped indexing the personal income tax system or $692 per taxpayer. This is a hidden tax.

It is one thing when people know the taxes they are paying and can react, but when they are hidden and buried in bracket creep that is particularly offensive to me. It must be to Canadians when they find out about it. How could they believe anything when they find out there is a hidden tax that is not up front, that is a big revenue increase for the government which they hear nothing about?

Taxation February 16th, 1999

Mr. Speaker, it is budget day 1999.

For more than 12 years parents have called for fair treatment. Treat parents equitably and stop rewarding just institutional daycare choices, leaving parents who choose other options out in the cold. Thousands of families were represented on Parliament Hill during the prebudget debate by the newly formed Family Tax Coalition.

These families carried the message one more time but louder than ever before. They called out again to give an equitable, refundable tax credit to all parents and let them determine the arrangements which best meet the needs of their families. The Reform Party agrees.

The Liberals continue to tell parents that parental or extended family care has no value. This is wrong. Canadian families, through the Family Tax Coalition, are tired of being ignored. This time the government must respond or it will pay the price.

Families February 15th, 1999

Mr. Speaker, today is family day in Alberta and I rise to pay tribute to the over 700,000 families in my home province.

The family is important to Albertans as they recognize that it is society's fundamental social unit, the centre for social, educational, economic and spiritual life, and is the cradle of life itself, providing a safe and secure environment in which to nurture, teach and love our children.

Many Albertans are concerned about the state of the family due in part to the heavily intrusive high tax policies of the government. Families in Alberta are not alone in calling for less burdensome government. Today's Compas poll indicates that nine of ten Canadians want tax cuts and the federal debt to be paid down.

Tax and spend has to end. It is time to allow Canadian families to determine their priorities with their own money.

Criminal Code February 11th, 1999

Mr. Speaker, I appreciate the opportunity to speak to this bill.

As has been stated by a number of members, I think of how critical these kinds of issues are. It is good for us to reflect for a moment on the impacts on some of the new technologies and new developments that are almost exploding out there.

On these technologies, be it in the biotechnology area, on the Internet or in other things, this House often wrestles with key issues of what is in the public interest and how do we as custodians of the public trust serve the people who put us here effectively.

My primary and underlying concern on this bill is the requirement for us to ensure that public safety, as these new technologies come forward, has been properly addressed. I think of some of the developments in pharmaceuticals and even in food additives in the past that we were told were safe, that supposedly were tested. People took the experts at their word and either took the medication or consumed the product with very grievous results.

Sometimes we are so concerned and compassionate to quickly bring a product to market that may help those who are suffering or who are facing a very traumatic physical illness or life threatening illness. It is incumbent upon all of us to be very cautious. In our compassion to meet the short term need we may in fact cause a very serious disaster.

It is within that context that I support the bill and I support the unamended bill.

As these things come forward in the future, as they will for us to deal with, the overriding concern we must all have is what is in the public interest. Let us make sure that the controls are in place to allow the experts and those who develop these things to do all the appropriate testing, the long term testing so that we do not in our zeal to meet the needs of those who are facing life-threatening diseases actually cause more trouble than good.

We know that sometimes even those involved in research and the medical field are not always Snow White. There can be instances of abuse or exaggeration and exaggeration upon exaggeration. This is why we as custodians of the public trust must tread very carefully and slowly in this area.

I would suggest this is not just with respect to the area of human genetics and cloning but also in all kinds of biotechnology. Today some of the most grievous weapons in the world are biological weapons. When we start to manipulate the gene structures of plants and animals and other types of things, we have to be careful that the appropriate controls are in place, that if an accident or a mistake happens there are ways to shut it down quickly. We have seen what various viruses can do and what a tragedy it would be if it was a man-made problem that caused the deaths of millions.

At the same time, I am not saying that we should not explore this, but do it carefully. There may be developments that would solve the bone marrow transplant issue and many of the other tragic life-threatening things we see today. We do need to move into this arena I would say, but very cautiously and very carefully so that we can maximize the long term benefits to the people we are here to serve. We must make sure that we are not putting any of them at risk.

I commend the member for the bill. I commend all the members of the House who have spoken on this so eloquently. I think my comments have encapsulated what many of the members have said, that we do need to step carefully into this arena and make sure that we are taking every precaution. As we do in pharmaceuticals, certainly we need to do the same thing in this arena.

Supply February 11th, 1999

Madam Speaker, those were interesting comments from the member. I concur with much of what he said. One key issue of concern to me and to many members of my party is the efficient use of tax dollars. Nowhere today have we actually touched on that too much. We have talked a lot about poverty and compassion for the less fortunate which are good things for sure. I am concerned about whether we are efficiently using tax dollars to meet the needs of those who are less fortunate.

I am looking at some of the current expenditures of the Liberal government. What is the member's position on some of these expenditures? Could some of this money be better redirected to those with legitimate needs? For example, the current Liberal government has spent money on some studies. On a study of feasting and the origin of inequality $75,000 was spent. On a study of women's dress in the 19th century in Istanbul $28,000 was spent. Also there was one for $1.2 million to General Electric Canada which is a large corporation.

Why are we spending tax dollars on these kinds of things if we are here today talking about the legitimate needs of the less fortunate? What is the hon. member's opinion on that?

Supply February 11th, 1999

Mr. Speaker, it is a shame the hon. member across the way has such a gift of presentation. He is a powerful orator but he lacks so much in substance.

I follow on the comments of another hon. member. This member was telling us in the Reform Party that when it comes to social programs we are not there. Yet I remind him again about the $6 billion cut in social transfers. I was in the House when his party voted against compensating some of the hepatitis C victims. If we are talking about social conscience I would like to see him demonstrate it in a number of those areas.

In addition, I will point out some of the expenditures that party is concerned about that I would rather see go to those truly in need. For example, there was a $1.3 million study for the development of better bananas in Honduras.

Is that what he sees as a priority for the government? That is where it is spending dollars that could go to people who have legitimate needs in this country. I ask him to add a lot more substance to his comments to match his ability at presentation.

Supply February 11th, 1999

Madam Speaker, I will be sharing my time with the hon. member for Souris—Moose Mountain.

We appreciate the good intentions of the motion to address the indexing of the child tax benefit and the increase of the threshold on when people begin to pay taxes.

Part of my concern is that a motion like this couched in the terms of addressing poverty is perhaps not comprehensive enough. To take a small part of the issue, a piecemeal approach, probably does not serve all Canadians well. That is part of the reason why Reform has done such a diligent job in our budget alternative package we presented to the House, to various members and to people across the country.

It is prudent for us to pause for a moment to reflect back as we are in the throes of this debate on poverty and ask what we can do in the tax system to address it. In Canada over the last 15 or 20 years we have incurred a $600 billion debt, the highest debt ever, massive tax increases combined with that. There has been lots of money drawn from the taxpayer and also borrowed and yet we are in a country where we talk about one in every five children is supposedly in some state of poverty.

When we think about that it does not seem like getting more money both through borrowing and through taxation into the hands of government has really done much to address poverty if it is true that one in five is in a state of poverty as some would claim. We had a debate on poverty.

It is time to review quickly some of our own points that are more comprehensive. I do not have time today to go through our complete budget submission but there are some things I want to highlight to show it is more than just the components that are in this motion before us today that would address some of the challenges of the less fortunate in Canada.

Certainly our budget submission calls for very substantial tax reduction with the surpluses that are available. As well we call for a very substantial reduction of the debt which is really borrowing on the future of our youngest Canadians. The core programs that are so important to Canadians must be strengthened.

One of the speakers today quoted from the recent Vanier Institute study. The study states that in 1996 family incomes were only $600 above their 1980 level, 16 years. Family incomes on an after tax basis declined by over 5% in real terms from 1989 to 1996.

Taxing is impacting families. We are talking about poverty today and it is within that context I would like to talk on the impacts of taxation on the financial future of Canadian families. I want to quote from another study in 1998 by the National Foundation of Family Research and Education talking about bracket creep which we just heard some comments on. It says bracket creep and the clawing back of tax credits from families with incomes as low as $20,000 per year means that families earning between $20,000 and $40,000 per year are now paying the highest marginal tax rates in the country.

What we are creating with this heavy level of taxation is a type of a working poor scenario. That is of real concern to me as it is to many Canadians and I know many members House share that concern.

It is interesting also from the Vanier report that in 1980 financial stress on families was relatively low. In the 1990s this most current report states that most measures under financial stress are reaching record highs.

Families in Canada are under financial stress and I think it is incumbent on members of the House to find ways to relieve that stress and tax reduction is certainly one of the most obvious and straightforward ones that I know we could find a lot of agreement on in the House.

I want to talk a bit about some of the specific proposals in Reform's budget alternative better way budget. One of them has to do with reducing or at least considering and investigating the impacts of the current tax legislation on marriage. One submission states that single income families may pay considerably higher amounts of federal tax than two income families with the same level of family income.

Take a family earning $30,000 annually. While a dual income family splits the income 50:50, the single income family will generally pay about $4,317 a year in federal and provincial income taxes, whereas the dual income family pays a combined $3,492 a year. So it is 24% more in tax for a single income family. These are the kinds of inequities that I think should be investigated to bring some greater fairness and equity into the way families are treated and taxation is applied.

As a specific step we could take in this direction, we are suggesting that one of the easiest and most straightforward things to do is to increase the married credit by setting it equal to the basic personal credit at $1,098 from its current maximum of $915. The proposal provides for a tax reduction when coupled with the increase to the basic personal credit that we advocate of $675 for single income families across Canada. This is an important proposal for a couple of reasons. It is important because why should the spouse who is in the home and maybe not employed in the private sector have some type of exemption that is less than the basic exemption? We are advocating that it should at least be equal.

Another important point we call for to address some of the taxation impacts on family is that the current system allows for deductions of $7,000 for children under seven and $4,000 for children aged seven to sixteen. That is the current situation. We propose to replace this system with one where all families with children become eligible to receive a refundable child care expense credit of 17% of $7,000 or effectively $1,190 for all children up to seven years of age. Further, a credit of 17% on $4,000, or $680 in hard cash return, will be made available for parents of children seven to twelve years of age. The credit would be available to all families with children whether they are earning income or not and provide benefits for each child under the age of seven and for children seven to twelve.

There are costs I could provide on that. We have quantified that. We have examined the impact of that recommendation to make sure that it is consistent with our overall budget proposal.

Another area I would like to address is directly related to the impacts of capital gains taxes in Canada. Let me quickly touch on a reduction of capital gains and how that could help us strengthen opportunities for the less fortunate. The increase in economic activity which would result in a reduction of capital gains taxes would lead to greater employment and thus higher income tax revenues. In other words, the economic benefits of a reduction in the capital gains rate far outweigh the short run costs of them. There are a number of studies I could quote if I had the time to do so.

To sum up, the thrust of the motion today is to alleviate the burden of poverty and calls for two specifics on tax policy. We must meet the needs of those who are not able to help themselves and are facing harder times. However higher taxation and increasing debt are not working.