House of Commons photo

Crucial Fact

  • His favourite word was children.

Last in Parliament October 2000, as Reform MP for Calgary Centre (Alberta)

Won his last election, in 1997, with 40% of the vote.

Statements in the House

Child Pornography February 2nd, 1999

Mr. Speaker, the justice minister tells us that the child protection pornography law is working for the rest of Canada.

What about the children of B.C.? Are they not Canadians too?

This judge's ruling was out of bounds and we can do something about it in this House today. I do not want to hear more legalise from legal experts. I want to know today from the Prime Minister if he will call off his whips and allow his caucus a free vote on this issue today in this House.

Supply February 2nd, 1999

Mr. Speaker, it is a pleasure to speak to this motion.

It is a painful issue for many Canadians across the country as we have seen expressed from coast to coast.

Interestingly the crux of this argument seems to be the defence of some sort of freedom, yet at the same time we are talking about a failure of our system to protect the most vulnerable. In the cause of freedom and the championing of rights we have crossed over the line of rational thought when we can no longer protect the most vulnerable in our society. As we charge down the highway of rights and freedoms, we have made a grave error today if we let this stand the way it is.

I applaud the members of the House in my party and every party. There are some on the other side who are determined to put a quick end to this grave mistake.

We have had supreme court rulings in the past. They have had more wisdom on this issue than the current one. I am sure it has been referenced in the debates today. In the Butler case it was ruled that the access to pornographic material is not in the public interest. It is demonstrably harmful to society. For that very reason section 1 of the charter was called into effect and it was deemed to be illegal. There was no outcry there. In fact, Canadians were pleased to see that ruling. That is not the one we are faced with today. We are seeing just the opposite.

What concerns me is must we have more victims before we can determine if there is harm? We talked about the determination of harm being the criteria before we will decide whether it is reasonable to shut this kind of thing down. How much harm must we endure before we can say there has been enough? How many more children, victims, need to be involved in this kind of sick thing before we can say there has been enough?

Maybe we should not go overboard in determining harm but ask if there is any redeeming attribute of this material that would legitimize it. I would suggest there is absolutely not. Put the onus on the other side. Where is the redeeming attribute in this kind of material? How does it add to the health and safety of our children, our families and our community? It is not there.

In a charter world we seem to stop using our heads and we rely on legal arguments and highly articulated legalese. Somewhere we have lost sight that there is a victim at the end of all this and it is a child. It is tragic.

I have read material that talks about the impacts of pornography. Oftentimes those that are caught up in this cannot tell the difference between fantasy and reality after a while and sooner or later they act out.

I know there are all kinds of studies and debates and people that articulate the different sides of this. However, if we asked 100 Canadians that very question whether they think that looking at this is going to distort our perception of reality, that we start to look at individual children as objects rather than individuals, of those 100 Canadians far and away the majority will say yes, it does distort reality. It is not an accurate picture of a child.

Interestingly, a paroled sexual offender was released in my riding not long ago. One of the conditions of the individual's parole was that he not avail himself, look at or expose himself to pornographic material. That was a condition of his parole. Here we have the court system and a judge saying that this would not work. This would not be good for this individual. This would distort his sense of reality again.

One court is saying do not touch it and another court is saying it is quite all right for people to avail themselves of this material and legitimize this market. It is wrong and we have an opportunity here today to fix it.

I know that many members in this House want to shut this down now which is what the Canadian people want to have happen. We can shut this down now and put an end to the continued victimization of children, the victims depicted in these horrible things. It is not a case of freedoms and rights. It is a case of children who are victims. It is a case of the children not only who are victims today in this material but the ones who will be impacted tomorrow if we allow this to continue and we allow the legitimization of this market to carry on.

I suggest that all Canadians are victims. If we allow a law like this one to stand, every Canadian is tarnished. The pride in our country and who we are as Canadians is diminished when we say to people from other countries that in Canada we think it is quite all right for people to look at and study this kind of pornographic material that depicts children. It diminishes all of us as Canadians. We are all victimized by this. It is just not acceptable.

To defend freedoms that fail to protect the most innocent is crossing over the line. Many of us here know it. We know it in our hearts. Today we have an opportunity to show the Canadian people that being a Canadian means something. We stand for something but we are not going to stand for this. Let us do it today.

Questions On The Order Paper February 1st, 1999

With reference to the Criminal Records Act provisions enabling the Solicitor General of Canada to grant approval for the disclosure of any record of a conviction in respect of which a pardon has been issued or granted (section 6 of the Act): how many times has the Solicitor General of Canada given approval for such disclosure from November 1993 to the present?

Justice November 30th, 1998

Mr. Speaker, last week I asked the newly appointed solicitor general what possible explanation he could have for pardoning 700 sex offenders who went on to have other sexual offences on new victims. His answer was that 700 was a relatively small number. Tragic. What a callous answer to these victims.

He has had a weekend to think about it. When will he stop pardoning known sex offenders and allow Canadian parents to protect their children?

National Parole Board November 27th, 1998

Mr. Speaker, the National Parole Board is out of control. Since the Prime Minister took office it has handed out thousands and thousands of pardons to convicted criminals.

Through access to information the solicitor general's department shows that 700 sex offenders who were pardoned later had their pardons revoked because they had committed new sex crimes. More victims.

What possible excuse could the solicitor general have for pardoning so many sex offenders who go on to abuse, rape and molest our children and families again?

Health November 18th, 1998

Mr. Speaker, Canadians have heard a lot lately about the climate of fear in the health protection branch. Scientists are supposed to be independent. They are supposed to be protectors of the health of Canadians.

These same scientists have testified about intimidation tactics in the department. The deputy minister himself has said there are problems that must not be swept under the rug. An internal investigation has been promised. Will the minister commit today in this House that he will make that report public?

Canada Small Business Financing Act November 17th, 1998

Mr. Speaker, I am so pleased to follow my colleague now that he has the attention of some of the members opposite. Hopefully they will listen to the continuation of the well reasoned arguments that our party has put forward.

I am troubled by this motion as I know many constituents are. It is such a sad reflection on the lack of leadership on the other side. The best the government can do is to put forward a bill that puts the struggling small businesses further in debt and offers them no possible relief or hope. This is not the way to increase the viability of small businesses in Canada. If they were more viable, lenders would be lining up to make sure money was available to them. This kind of motion makes it all that much more difficult.

Why are small businesses having such a hard time? A number of small businesses in Calgary Centre have spoken to me over the past year and they have listed their concerns. Never have they come to me to say that they need more access to loans to get them further in debt. Every priority they have presented to me has related to taxes, taxes and taxes. They listed the property tax they pay and how high it is. They listed the provincial taxes and the income taxes. The most painful of all is the payroll taxes. It is particularly painful when they see, hear and read about a surplus they and their employees have paid into but they will not be given any relief in that arena by the finance minister.

Particularly troubling to me was one small business owner, an elderly fellow. He and his wife ran an electronic shop. He showed me on paper that he could actually make a profit but after paying taxes, he was in a losing position. He lost money because of his taxes. It is tragic especially when we sing the praises of small businesses being the engine of our economy and then we tax them into bankruptcy. It is tragic.

We have heard previously from members today about the rate of bankruptcy in this country. Is this the best solution we can come up with for businesses that are going bankrupt? We are going to make the availability of more financing that they would not otherwise have access to drive these businesses that are carrying the tax burden further into debt through government loans. Is that the best we can do?

Certainly that seems to be the best members on the other side can do, but that is not why we are here. We are here to see that these small businesses become successful and to give them some tax relief. This component of our business community should be the first to receive tax relief.

The president of the Restaurant and Food Services Association in my riding has come to me more than once. He has written to me. He has never asked for access to more financing. Each time what he has asked for is relief from taxes. He has pointed out to me that the restaurant business is where many young people in our country get a start. They learn how to work within a company, serve and build their job skills. Yet restaurateurs are so burdened by payroll taxes that many of them are limiting the number of young people they hire and this is where our young people get a start.

At the other end of the spectrum, many professionals and people trained in our universities who venture out in small entrepreneurial enterprises carry the weight of a mountain of bureaucratic red tape and the tax burden. That is one of the factors why this country is faced with a brain drain. Educated professionals look at the options and ask do they stay in Canada or do they go somewhere where their efforts are going to pay a dividend. It is not here that they choose to stay.

We are asking that we get serious about some real solutions for small business. It comes from a climate that allows small businesses to succeed, not to get further into debt, a climate that allows them to make a profit. Some members in the House do not like to hear the word profit. Allow small businesses to make a profit, to reinvest it back into their companies, to expand, to employ more Canadians. Keep more Canadians here, young Canadians, instead of driving them across the border because of the heavy burden of taxes and government red tape.

No, that is not the answer. We need to show leadership in that area and it is leadership that is sorely lacking. That is why we are so concerned about this particular motion today and this bill. It so typifies that lack of leadership.

Let me also point out that our country has the highest tax rate in the G-8, which is something we have mentioned before in the House. Canadians are starting to hear it. We hear the finance minister talking about surpluses, yet he is refusing to give Canadians the tax relief they deserve.

We have seen the vibrancy in Alberta. Why? Because Alberta has one of the most positive climates in Canada for entrepreneurs and business people to succeed. People are moving to Alberta and they are succeeding in Alberta. But the Liberal government refuses to take that as a lesson and allow for that kind of an environment to flourish in the rest of the country.

I refuse to accept the statement some would make that the success of entrepreneurs and businesses somehow means that those who are underprivileged or who are in need would be left out. My very own riding of Calgary Centre, the vibrant community of Calgary, in some ways is becoming the new business capital of Canada. I would say that the charities, the concern and the caring in that community is second to none in Canada.

It does not follow that just because there is business success somehow that means the underprivileged are forgotten. I put forward the strong example of Calgary Centre, my own riding where just the opposite is true. When there is success in business and the economy is strong, the needs of the underprivileged are cared for that much better than when business is struggling and under a heavy burden of tax.

We are so concerned about the lack of leadership on this issue shown by the government. It is so important. That is why we have made mention of this. We are making a point to bring this to the attention of the people in the gallery, those watching and hopefully the few members opposite who are listening.

My closing appeal for the young people of the country, the families that want to have a future, stay in Canada and have an opportunity to grow, raise a family and be strong contributing Canadians is that on their behalf instead of a weak approach of putting businesses further in debt that the government, parliament and all of us be committed to strengthening the economy through lower taxes, less government regulation and let the Canadian people flourish and build a stronger country.

Charitable Contributions November 16th, 1998

Madam Speaker, I appreciate the opportunity to speak to Motion No. M-318.

I will add a few contextual comments and note that we live in a time that is unparalleled in human history. Information is flooding our senses. New developments occur monthly that in the past took decades, if not longer.

I remember the comments of a leading social scientists who put it somewhat in perspective. He said that a 70 year old person living today has seen more technological and related social change in his or her lifetime than occurred in the entire human history prior to his or her birth.

Business communities and social communities form, thrive, mature and decline in much shorter cycles than ever before. Boom and bust cycles are shorter. We live in a time of dynamic and exciting change all around us. To attempt to hold to the old paradigm of a top down, centralist approach that says we will meet all needs just cannot do the optimal job in a dynamically changing nation made up of the communities in which we live.

Reform has long recognized this point. It is one of the reasons we advocate that the first order of government should be that which is closest to the people: municipal government first and then provincial government. The federal government should only address key national issues. Government close to the people will serve them best.

I appreciate Motion No. M-318 because it parallels this philosophy. The motion provides an opportunity to empower local communities to best tailor solutions which meet the needs within their communities. The motion reads:

That, in the opinion of this House, the government should bring in legislation making the tax deduction for contributions to charitable organizations no less than the tax deduction for contributions to political parties.

If we can provide a strong funding incentive to political parties through the tax act, why not charitable organizations that work for the good in our communities? Charitable organizations usually combine volunteer or contributed service with the dollars they receive, thereby increasing the contribution of each dollar in the community.

Charities usually manage their money carefully as it is dependent upon charitable giving. It is not a limitless supply. They must demonstrate effective management and results if contributions are to continue. The needs of the community vary. Individuals giving to the charities of their choice express the needs within the community. Their choices allow for the matching of givings to the preferences of the givers and the priorized needs of the community.

Large scale government programs funded by tax dollars do not allow the giver to choose and do not allow for variations in community needs. They are more likely to cost more and deliver less. In short the community approach hits the mark. The government approach is less than the best and often misses the mark.

In light of the efficient way in which charities contribute to the quality of life in our communities, especially considering the dynamics of the times we live in and the need to improve the effectiveness of government social programs, it is time consider changing the tax act to address the inequitable tax treatment of charities versus political parties.

We can pose this question in our ridings “Do you think a dollar given to a charity does at least as much if not more for the quality of life in your community than a dollar given to a political party?” I know what the answer would be in my riding. I think we all do. It is time to support the motion.

Calgary Centre is a thriving entrepreneurial business capital with more than 103 corporate head offices. Calgary is second only to Toronto in the number of head offices. Yet contrary to the heartless image of the entrepreneurial profit making business people, which is a picture some in the House like to paint, Calgary thrives with volunteers and charities that make for a rich quality of life in a very caring community.

Calgary's rate of volunteerism is one of the highest in Canada. Charities such as CUPS work with street people in the inner city, drug addicts and prostitutes. They train, coach, counsel and care for people effectively. Through the efforts of this charity Calgarians have seen many gain victory over their past and find joyful purpose again through the work of the dedicated volunteers in that charity.

We could take the example of the Calgary street teens program run by a retired vice-squad Detective Ross McInnis who together with his volunteers give many hours and often risk their personal safety to save the lives of young teenagers who have become enticed and trapped in the drug and prostitution activities that sometimes occur in the inner city. Families have been restored through this program. Some of the troubled youth who have been helped now work to help others ensnared in teen prostitution.

The Youth Immigration Support Society of Calgary is run by a Calgary doctor. The purpose of this charity is to help integrate immigrant second language youth in a healthy way into our Calgary community. I met many of these teens and saw their joyful faces. This is work that no other group could do in the same way.

For close to 15 years now Jubilee Christian Centre has provided a Christmas banquet for the homeless and disadvantaged in Calgary. Over the years, thanks to donations of many corporate and private sponsors, this event has grown. Hundreds of volunteers now provide an all you can eat five course meal, clothing and gifts for 1,500 people at a massive Christmas party. The volunteers have as much fun as the guests.

These and hundreds more that I could list are examples of the vibrant contributions to the quality of life that charities provide to the Calgary community. Government programs cannot duplicate the sense of community, caring and joy giving that charity work brings. If giving to a political party has benefit, giving to a charity has no less benefit. Some would reasonably argue that giving to a charity adds far more to the quality of life in our communities.

I also note that this idea is not foreign to the House. It was a suggestion made by the finance committee in 1996 which recommended:

—that the government consider enhancing the charitable tax credit for donations to charities currently funded by governments to make it as generous as the current political tax credit for small donations to political parties.

Two years ago the finance committee recommended the change we are debating in the motion today. I hope now is the time to move ahead.

For sake of time I move to my summary and note that change is everywhere. Let us empower the charities on the frontline in Canada and in Canadian communities to meet the needs of those communities. They are closer to the community. They add value to the dollars they are given through flexible volunteerism. They have heart and caring that government programs can never match.

The finance committee recommended it two years ago. In a post-deficit world it is right to give these charities that are giving time and effort to Canadians fair treatment. Let us give this process fair consideration and unanimously support Motion No. M-318.

Calgary Declaration November 2nd, 1998

Mr. Speaker, I appreciate the wisdom you have given me. What I am seeking is simply the unanimous consent of the House to consider a motion. I am not at this point putting forward the motion, I am just asking the House to consider an amendment to the motion.

Calgary Declaration November 2nd, 1998

Mr. Speaker, I rise on a point of order. I seek the unanimous consent of the House to consider an amendment to this motion which would specifically address some of the concerns that were voiced by the member.